All Comments on 'A Cloak'

by BlackShanglan

Sort by:
  • 14 Comments
twelveoonetwelveooneabout 19 years ago
*

strangely affecting, almost like an exploded haiku, three levels of awareness

sacksackabout 19 years ago
very effective....

I wonder though, there are five it/it's Can you rewrite this to eliminate some of them?

foehnfoehnabout 19 years ago
A cloak, a life, a love...

Very tight and powerful. The instances of "it" just seem like good pronoun usage to me, making more room for the metaphor. Kudos!

minsueminsueabout 19 years ago
Strangely affecting, indeed

It's a testament to your talent that you can move so many with your words even as they all interpret them differently, as you well know. Or at least you should, by now.

impressiveimpressiveabout 19 years ago
A thing worth having ...

In spite of its flaws. The ache we all feel to be wanted. I watched this develop in the Poetry forum. Lovely! ~Imp

carsonshepherdcarsonshepherdabout 19 years ago
~

Yeowch. Vivid, impressive and raw. Made me cringe.

LadyJeanneLadyJeanneabout 19 years ago
With such few words,

you had me feeling angry, wistful, disappointed, defiant, and ultimately resigned. Bravo, dearest! Thank you.

herecomestherainherecomestherainabout 19 years ago
Wonderful writing

And I thought it a thing worth having...

The bittersweet,defiant, matter of fact sense of this line brought the prickle of tears to my eyes. Beautiful writing, I look forward to more.

The_FoolThe_Foolabout 19 years ago
Requires a close read

I like the symbolism expressed in this one. The twists in thought made me back up once or twice, which is good, because that way I had to read it that much closer. One of those poems that make me say "Good idea, I wish I'd thought of it."

Harry LegHarry Legover 18 years ago
Wow

This affected me although I'm not entirely sure why. Absolutely love it.

LeBrozLeBrozover 17 years ago
~~

A metaphor can mean so many things

But second-hand clothes

Like second-hand love

Holds little appeal beyond crass functionality...

duddle146duddle146over 17 years ago
Cloaks

Second hand clothes like second hand love can sometimes be disappointing.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 17 years ago
Well Done!

Resounds of truth.. and we all know how bittersweet that can be.

tazz317tazz317almost 12 years ago
BEGGARS CAN NOT BE CHOOSERS

but have gratitude and taste. TK U MLJ LV NV

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous