All Comments on 'Haemon and Antigone'

by WilliamButlerYeats

Sort by:
  • 5 Comments
twelveoonetwelveooneabout 13 years ago
A bit

of a walk through? I don't think "billow" does it for lead in to concluding line.

"we sullenly met the serene;"

this is a nice trick, however, you might be better served by not relying on directly stating so. i.e. a lit fleshing out, instead of just the hollow bones of sound.

for the sound, and the nice tricks, score 5.

P. S. title seems to be reeking of pretension.

WilliamButlerYeatsWilliamButlerYeatsabout 13 years agoAuthor
the title is mostly pretentious

It assumes the reader has read a few differing translations of Antigone's defense. Thank you for commenting on the content too.

twelveoonetwelveooneabout 13 years ago
For one so astute

in the ways, consider the risk to reward ratio. i.e. how good was it, how involved will the reader be, to justify. Poem stands on it's on (although it could have been longer), would have done better with a different title, "Haemon and Antigone" would have functioned better a subtitle. Just my opinion, I admit I'm wrong about half the time. You can always delete comments, and keep the score.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 13 years ago
In my advanced old age

I've found myself to be merely a garlander or garlandier(?) A writer of simple garlandy, garden variety poetry. Often I've debated with myself whether a title can subtract anything from a poem. I think it can, but not to the degree that a title can add to the quality. When Alexander Pope and Robert Browning tagged Greek names onto poems their readers would be familiar with the stories. Tagging a Greek name(s) onto an already existent poem or town or city can still add a magical quality to a poem or place of reference, in my elderly estimation. Whether it was appropriate in the case of this poem, I can't say. -WBY

twelveoonetwelveooneabout 13 years ago
True

true, that was then. Regardless of the argument regarding the title, your poetry is some of the best crafted I've seen, here.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous