Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Trailer Trash Ch. 03 Does rich boy finally get the Trailer Trash girl? by Slickman (09/29/06) | 4.83 (1856) |
| 2. | Goodbye, La La Land Gary and Kathleen discover 'Real Life' together. by MLyons (11/09/04) | 4.82 (2011) |
| 3. | Army Brat Ch. 06 Army base game and romance. by Slickman (10/30/08) | 4.82 (837) |
| 4. | A Blizzard & the Night of Firsts A storm forces a virgin to find warmth with 3 women. by the_last_high (02/06/05) | 4.81 (3364) |
| 5. | Tomboy Ch. 05 Tom and Jo must make an important decision. by Slickman (04/11/05) | 4.81 (1339) |
| 6. | Bosom Buddies Ch. 03 Enjoying an unforgettable after-party with big-breasted BFFs. by bosombuddies (11/25/11) | 4.81 (631) |
| 7. | Kathryn's Question Ch. 02 Their relationship continues to develop. by val wrangler (09/30/06) | 4.81 (498) |
| 8. | In Step Ch. 03 Teens get closer, while parents have their first real date. by RonCabo (03/09/10) | 4.81 (372) |
| 9. | Nothing Between Us Two friends let it happen. by M-Y-Erotica (02/15/06) | 4.80 (6938) |
| 10. | Trading Favors Ch. 02 Rachel continues Nick’s sexual education. by cliffgirl08 (09/20/11) | 4.80 (265) |
| 11. | A Lifetime in One Moment Virgin & lonely widow share love, briefly. by C.C. Rider (05/13/04) | 4.79 (2110) |
| 12. | Camera Buff - Exposed Ch. 01 High school photography session gets out of control! by cbsummers (01/18/12) | 4.79 (749) |
| 13. | Delayed Action Naive 18-year-old meets a very naughty tutor. by cbsummers (12/03/11) | 4.79 (671) |
| 14. | Herbs A love story. by Spykke (02/02/05) | 4.79 (480) |
| 15. | Suzie's Lessons Ch. 10 Suzie's Lessons are near complete. by BlewWater69 (12/27/06) | 4.79 (307) |
| 16. | The Incentive List Ch. 02 Another fantasy comes true - with a little planning. by wabbit_season (01/30/12) | 4.79 (150) |
| 17. | A Almost Perfect Awakening Ch. 19-21 Lynn makes Larry an offer she hopes he won't refuse. by Wm_Sexspear (10/21/02) | 4.78 (1089) |
| 18. | Chemistry Between Nerds and Sluts Ch. 02 Stef fulfills her side of the bargain. by BlewWater69 (05/15/07) | 4.78 (866) |
| 19. | Dawn's First & Only Ch. 03 The final day of a special weekend. by wizarddriver (02/15/05) | 4.78 (631) |
| 20. | Tracey Ch. 03 Steve & Tracey have the house to themselves. by woody_strokem (02/09/05) | 4.78 (556) |
| 21. | Berry's Second Chances Ch. 01 One girl, two loves, same family. by PacoFear (03/18/10) | 4.78 (528) |
| 22. | Kathryn's Question Ch. 05 The finale. by val wrangler (05/01/07) | 4.78 (438) |
| 23. | Living with Omega Theta Pi A purity ring can only go so far. by Charles Petersunn (11/06/09) | 4.78 (381) |
| 24. | Living with Omega Theta Pi Ch. 02 Albert and Shelley get to know each other. by Charles Petersunn (06/09/10) | 4.78 (303) |
| 25. | The Weekend Sleepover Ch. 02 The weekend heats up with Jenny and Brenda. by spaldan (02/01/12) | 4.78 (287) |
| 26. | Suzie's Lessons Ch. 08 Prom night finally arrives. by BlewWater69 (12/17/06) | 4.78 (212) |
| 27. | The Cherry Poppers Ch. 07 Jason gets number six. by BlewWater69 (01/25/08) | 4.78 (206) |
| 28. | The Cherry Poppers Ch. 27 The contest soon ends. by BlewWater69 (11/04/09) | 4.78 (179) |
| 29. | Slightly, Once Ch. 03 Dave finds the words. by Balrog (07/31/11) | 4.78 (169) |
| 30. | Kelly Ch. 02 She cooks dinner, they enjoy dessert. by Balrog (05/08/05) | 4.78 (154) |
| 31. | A Kiss is Still a Kiss School beauty is cast as Juliet against his Romeo. by MaxSebastian (08/09/04) | 4.77 (1923) |
| 32. | Sleeping Beauty Wife pays babysitter to do more than just sit. by Slickman (06/09/05) | 4.77 (1604) |
| 33. | Spring Break Guy meets his dream girl - until she takes off. by Slickman (07/21/05) | 4.77 (1596) |
| 34. | Is That Really You? Former best friends meet again in college. by Tony155 (01/08/07) | 4.77 (1394) |
| 35. | Tomboy Ch. 02 Tomboy turns into a girl - and likes it. by Slickman (02/04/05) | 4.77 (1123) |
| 36. | Things That Go Hump in the Night Peter meets a ravishing girl on Halloween. by Stefan_J (10/20/04) | 4.77 (1087) |
| 37. | Confession Of A Teenage Pussy Eater The nerds get the cheerleaders. by Stormbringer (10/27/04) | 4.77 (1084) |
| 38. | Trailer Trash Ch. 01 Rich boy meets girl of his dreams however... by Slickman (08/08/06) | 4.77 (1018) |
| 39. | Bosom Buddies Ch. 02 A private pool party with five very voluptuous friends. by bosombuddies (11/15/11) | 4.77 (863) |
| 40. | Brown's Shoe Store Ch. 04 Final chapter: negotiations turn hot at mountain lodge. by Slickman (01/31/05) | 4.77 (769) |
| 41. | Tomboy Ch. 04 Do Tom and Jo get back together? by Slickman (03/29/05) | 4.77 (746) |
| 42. | Chemistry Between Nerds and Sluts Ch. 08 After the prom at the lake, the fun continues and ends. by BlewWater69 (10/22/07) | 4.77 (652) |
| 43. | Chemistry Between Nerds and Sluts Ch. 03 The sluts plot for repeat dates with the nerds. by BlewWater69 (06/19/07) | 4.77 (648) |
| 44. | Under Mr. Nolan's Bed Ch. 05 Mr. Nolan goes on a date and Leah gets jealous. by Selena_Kitt (07/27/06) | 4.77 (613) |
| 45. | The Incomer A tale of pain and passion. by Spykke (07/13/06) | 4.77 (509) |
| 46. | Donna & Carol Ch. 01 A 1969 high school seniors long road to his first time. by Snow Snake (05/14/11) | 4.77 (470) |
| 47. | Beth & Michael The woman of his dreams finally becomes his. by LSanders (08/14/08) | 4.77 (417) |
| 48. | Slightly, Once Ch. 01 Shy Dave is smitten with Kim by Balrog (07/29/11) | 4.77 (411) |
| 49. | Dawn's First & Only Ch. 02 The sexual education of a dying 19-year-old. by wizarddriver (02/14/05) | 4.77 (371) |
| 50. | Quel age as-tu? His first love…his first time. by Dinsmore (02/20/07) | 4.77 (271) |
