Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 151. | The Virgin Valentine Ryan's V-Day gift from Gwen takes an unexpected turn. by Vaginalpuppetry (01/24/18) | 4.80 (738) |
| 152. | Coppernicous Pt. 04 Lynn has troubles with a boyfriend and Toomas gets shot. by SonofCallicious (11/23/15) | 4.80 (719) |
| 153. | Fluffer in Training Ch. 05 Naive Rachel encounters the new king of porn. by rmdexter (03/18/17) | 4.80 (595) |
| 154. | My Best Friend Alice With Alice, practice makes perfect. by Secretauthor2021 (09/14/23) | 4.80 (583) |
| 155. | Fluffer in Training Ch. 06 Porn star and sexy MILF make use of fluffer Rachel's talents. by rmdexter (03/24/17) | 4.80 (560) |
| 156. | Chinese Takeout Ch. 03 Love Changes Everything - Jay-Lin gets beaten up on the bus. by ChloeTzang (01/30/16) | 4.80 (552) |
| 157. | Operation Minnow First mission for him and many firsts for her. by fsqueeze (01/01/21) | 4.80 (496) |
| 158. | Camp True Touch Intimate journey of love, acceptance, and sexual awakening. by chloehunt (07/10/21) | 4.80 (490) |
| 159. | My Best Friend Alice Pt. 02 A weekend with Alice changes everything. by Secretauthor2021 (09/28/23) | 4.80 (439) |
| 160. | A Ski Adventure Chloé and Michel get together in Chamonix. by CelticLion101 (03/31/19) | 4.80 (368) |
| 161. | Broken Babysitter Injuries open up a young babysitter's world. by Chris6160 (02/06/24) | 4.80 (338) |
| 162. | Water Park Fun Ch. 04 - First Week Ryan and Amanda have fun together in person and apart. by storyteller19 (04/16/21) | 4.80 (315) |
| 163. | My Grey Summer A college students summer coworker expands his horizons. by Warkat747 (09/11/23) | 4.80 (304) |
| 164. | The Lone Ranger and the Ho Our intrepid hero rescues a woman of ill repute. by Trionyx (10/24/23) | 4.80 (253) |
| 165. | Mountains and a Coincidence Lessons in sex exchanged. by Westman99 (04/24/22) | 4.80 (167) |
| 166. | My Brother's Best Friend Ch. 04 Birthday girl and her Norse god explore even more firsts. by LV4206 (12/01/21) | 4.80 (162) |
| 167. | Becoming Who We Are Ch. 06 A dance, a brawl, a talk - and a future for Mark & Melina? by vanmyers86 (07/12/21) | 4.80 (118) |
| 168. | Becoming Who We Are Ch. 08 Melina wrecks her bike; Luke & Shelley get closer. by vanmyers86 (07/14/21) | 4.80 (115) |
| 169. | Water Park Fun Ch. 11 The summer comes to an end. by storyteller19 (12/20/23) | 4.80 (100) |
| 170. | A Lifetime in One Moment Virgin & lonely widow share love, briefly. by C.C. Rider (05/13/04) | 4.79 (4676) |
| 171. | My Irish Virgin Coed learns about sex and love. by Cat5 (03/31/05) | 4.79 (3607) |
| 172. | New Girl in Town Pt. 02 Will the arrival of a new girl at school change his luck? by AuroraIncident (11/01/17) | 4.79 (3395) |
| 173. | New Girl in Town Pt. 05 Will the arrival of a new girl at school change his luck? by AuroraIncident (12/19/17) | 4.79 (3384) |
| 174. | A Teddy Bear for Christmas A romantic little Christmas tale. by ChloeTzang (11/14/16) | 4.79 (2869) |
| 175. | Army Brat Ch. 02 Son of Army Hero copes with his new town and love. by Slickman (08/16/08) | 4.79 (2375) |
| 176. | Company Policy They find their Valentine's, snowed in at the office. by Red_Jakal (01/29/14) | 4.79 (2225) |
| 177. | Prom Night Pegging Prom date reveals how naughty she really is... by SluttyBisexualGuy (08/28/20) | 4.79 (1678) |
| 178. | A Thankful Blizzard Pt. 04 Accosted, Paul plans to get back to Kat. by rexspaulding (05/31/14) | 4.79 (1498) |
| 179. | Camel Toe This is Biology one zero seven zero, right? Biodiversity? by ChloeTzang (02/05/18) | 4.79 (1448) |
| 180. | Mutual Benefits Ch. 05 The most popular girl in school needs a study buddy. by BashfulScribe (05/07/21) | 4.79 (1349) |
| 181. | The Weekend Sleepover Ch. 02 The weekend heats up with Jenny and Brenda. by spaldan (02/02/12) | 4.79 (1334) |
| 182. | A Taste for Christmas Cake A shy guy is seduced by his older, female Japanese manager. by taiyakisoba (01/17/15) | 4.79 (1259) |
| 183. | Jerk Ch. 02 His nemesis' mom is back and he's pushing for more. by RejectReality (07/03/13) | 4.79 (1019) |
| 184. | Corpulent Carl Bullied, overweight, teen overcomes. by Callicious (07/19/14) | 4.79 (954) |
| 185. | Amnesty Program Ch. 03 High performing students tease and experiment. by Ambidentrous (11/18/12) | 4.79 (927) |
| 186. | Tomboy Titties An accidental flash of big beautiful titties leads to more! by Korinky (04/14/22) | 4.79 (869) |
| 187. | Hanky Panky You can't trust a gweilo guy with a nice Chinese Girl! by ChloeTzang (02/04/18) | 4.79 (846) |
| 188. | Amnesty Program Ch. 04 High performing students tease and experiment. by Ambidentrous (02/06/13) | 4.79 (786) |
| 189. | It All Works Out In The End A stupid accident leads to a life-altering change. by TooTallToFall (01/03/21) | 4.79 (757) |
| 190. | Lori Ch. 02 More FIRSTS for the both of us. by LoriisaDirtyGirl (01/03/13) | 4.79 (660) |
| 191. | The Cherry Poppers Ch. 28-2 Part 2 of the end of Cherry Poppers. by BlewWater69 (11/21/09) | 4.79 (625) |
| 192. | The Girl from the Ouachita Ch. 08 The Ambush, the Proposal, the Bouncer, and the Debut. by Texican1830 (04/17/22) | 4.79 (534) |
| 193. | From Charity to Chastity A teacher's concern paves the way to his future. by carrteun (02/01/20) | 4.79 (527) |
| 194. | The (un)Lucky Girl Can love bloom in the dead of winter? by Devinter (11/11/23) | 4.79 (514) |
| 195. | Sosoni Ch. 03 Bringing the wild woman home, peril looms. by fsqueeze (07/06/19) | 4.79 (492) |
| 196. | Her Last Affair She gave him the courage to take a chance on love. by regularguy13 (04/13/21) | 4.79 (376) |
| 197. | Nerd and Nerdess Two nerds are gently pushed together by friends. by RicknCenFl (12/11/22) | 4.79 (349) |
| 198. | Tutelage Sister's boyfriend teaches Tim the secret of his success. by JimBob44 (05/06/22) | 4.79 (346) |
| 199. | Summer Camp Firsts Jake and Mara reconnect at Summer Camp. by Secretauthor2021 (10/20/23) | 4.79 (330) |
| 200. | Paige Teaches Perversion Pt. 01 Austin visits a pregnant woman to learn about perversion. by IsabellaEmily (01/29/24) | 4.79 (275) |
