90% True Ch. 03

Time absolutely crawled along that day at school. I couldn't think of anything other than what might happen that night. But finally the last class of the day ended. I was out the door of my school quicker than I'd ever been. Certainly kids rushed out, and certainly on a Friday afternoon there was a mad dash for the student parking lot, but I was even more excited then normal as I ran flat out to my car. Giving it a cursory swipe with a snow brush, I hopped in and gunned that sucker to life and half slid, half flew out of the parking lot, trying to beat the school buses out of the lot.

It seemed like I got to Jen and Nina's private catholic high school in half the time it usually took me. I pulled up out front as close to the door as I could with traffic and waited impatiently. Finally after ten long minutes my girlfriend and Nina came out the door. My heart skipped a beat as I saw them.

You know that old cliché of the dirty naughty catholic school girl? It seemed like today these two girls were going to play that image to a tee. Both of them had rolled the hem of their skirts up so that the bottom of the skirts were a good inch above their knee. At their school, that was scandalous. I could even see the top of the leggings that Jen was wearing. They came up to her mid thigh like stockings, but were thicker, and in the deep dark green of her school uniform. They looked like a vision as they half jogged towards my car, my girlfriend dark, exotic, and athletic, and Nina, curvy, blonde, and oozing sex somehow even from this distance.

They hopped into my SUV, Jen in the front seat, and Nina in the back. Jen leaned over and gave me a deep, tongue filled, long kiss. Almost immediately I could smell pussy on her lips and I could taste that tangy deliciousness as well. I had no doubt that she and Nina had made me wait out front as they had a little fling somewhere in the school.

I pulled back from her finally and said, "Well, I guess I don't have to ask why I was waiting out here so long do I?"

Jen laughed, "Sorry baby, we wanted to pre-game."

In the back seat Nina laughed loudly. I turned and said, "Do I get a kiss from you as well?" My hopes were that I'd be able to taste Jen on her lips as well."

Nina looked slightly horrified and said, "Good god no Pete. Everyone would see us."

I turned around, a little ashamed. Of course, other than the three of us, Rich, and now Lions, I guess no one knew about our twisted little affair. I also knew that if the rumor mill at a public school could be bad, it was absolutely nothing compared to the vicious grapevine of teen judgment that happened at the all girls school they went too.

Chagrined, I put my SUV into drive and began to pull out of the parking lot. "Where are we going?" I asked the car in general.

Nina replied, "The Red Roof Inn over by the I-90." I nodded but she held out a gold colored credit card to me, "Also, you're rich, ok?"

I was confused, "Nina, I can barely pay my parents rent on the apartment..."

She smacked me in the shoulder, "No Pete, you're Rich." She shoved the credit card at me again and I took it. I saw that it was embossed with "RICH" her fiancee's name. She explained, "Rich has to work until 5:30. He said to get a room and wait for him, He'd be there by six and would bring a pizza. But there's no point in waiting around for him, he gave me his card and said that you should just check in under his name."

I nodded, understanding as I pulled onto the interstate. In less than fifteen minutes, I'd be at the hotel, and then hopefully, shortly after that, I'd have a little alone time with these two beauties. I could handle that. I think Rich realized that too, and figured that I'd not only get them warmed up for him, but then also I wouldn't feel jealous about him fucking my girlfriend right in front of me.

I was very nervous as I checked into the hotel. I was worried they'd ask for ID or something. But they didn't. They really couldn't have cared less as long as the credit card payment went through, which it did. I had my pick of almost any room since a Tuesday in early January in Buffalo wasn't exactly peak season for a red roof inn. So I reserved a room, and asked for one on the end of the building, with a queen bed. I got it as a smoking room too. I was a very light social smoker, having a few when I was drinking, especially at a bar, but never smoked otherwise. But Rich was a pack a day guy, and I thought that since this was his party, he'd appreciate not having to go outside to fire one up.

Going back out to the car I grabbed the girls and their bags. We bustled up the snowy outside stairs to the room. Jen walked ahead of me, and flipped the back of her skirt up to quickly flash her ass at me. My cock throbbed as I noticed two things in that quick flash; one, she wasn't wearing any panties, two, she had her purple butt plug stuffed between her athletic ass cheeks. I groaned softly and realized that she must have put it in before even leaving her school, and had it in that whole time. I also knew that Jen would be horny as hell. She was very anally focused, loved having her ass played with and fucked, and if she'd been wearing her butt plug for any length of time, that meant she was probably already very turned on.

I opened the door for the girls, and before I went in out of the cold, was pleased to note that some drifting snow had started to dust across the outdoor balcony that wrapped around the building allowing access to the rooms. I saw no footprints and it didn't look like any of the curtains were open in any of the rooms I could see. Since the parking lot had a whopping three cars in it other then mine, and those were parked close to the office, I figured we'd have quite a bit of privacy.

I entered the room and sighed as the warm hotel room started to banish the cold from outside. Kicking off my shoes, the girls and I hung up our coats and looked around. The room wasn't very large, it was pretty standard for one of these motels. Near the door a table and two chairs, across from that a dresser with a TV. A large queen sized bed, then two comfortable looking padded chairs. Then a tiny kitchenette type sink and counter and a door that lead to what I was sure was the bathroom.

I had just finished taking it all in when my athletic girlfriend crushed me back against the door. Her firm D cup breasts pushed into my chest through my T shirt and flannel and her school uniform. The kiss was long and intense, and I could still detect the faintest smell of pussy on her, a remnant of her dalliance with Nina before they got in my car.

Finally she pulled me back to the bed and sat down on it, holding my hands as I stood in front of her. Nina had already laid out on the other part of the bed and was flipping through the channels on the TV. Jen looked up at me from her sitting position and asked me, "Baby I need to know, to really really know that you're ok with this?"

I cocked one eyebrow, "Ok with what?"

"Uh," she said looking at me like I was an idiot, "Ok with all of this. This is the first time we've really had a chance to talk about everything since new years. I need to know that you're ok with me and Nina, that you're ok with me fucking Rich, that you're ok with filming your girlfriend fucking two other people. With all of it."

I knelt down in front of the bed and pulled her face down to me. I kissed her lips softly and smiled as I told her, "baby, I couldn't dream of anything more amazing. You and Nina are both amazingly sexy women, and I love you so much for bringing this all together."

Jen's mouth quirked to the side, "Well, I know you're ok having sex with her."

Nina added from behind Jen, "Who wouldn't be?"

Jen turned long enough to stick her tongue out at Nina before turning back to me and saying, "But before new years, I was afraid I'd get jealous or angry watching you have sex with another woman. But when I saw you fucking Nina, I didn't feel jealous, I only felt more turned on. I'm just worried that you're not going to like watching me fuck Rich."

I looked Jen dead in the eyes and said to her, "Baby, I watched you and Nina have sex, and that only turned me on. Rich is a great friend, and this is the last we're going to see of him for months. I know that you love me, and that this whole thing, this whole sex thing, it's all just for fun. I promise you this, I'll be fine, and that even if I'm not, we will talk about it later and I won't ever hold this against you. Besides, I think this is going to be really fucking hot." I grinned at her.

She kissed me again and it lingered for a while. When the kiss broke up, Nina had turned to lay on her side and watch us. She spoke first, "You're going to have to get us going before Rich gets here too Pete."

Jen nodded and said, "Nina decided she's going to give up her ass to Rich tonight too."

I was a little impressed. Nina had never let Rich, or me for that matter, fuck her in the ass before. She was always too afraid it was going to hurt. But I sensed that Jen's influence on her was starting to wear off. Jen must have convinced her how good it felt or something. Hell, there were some days where I thought that Jen must have been wired wrong, because she seemed to enjoy anal sex as much or more than vaginal sex. I asked, "This is Jen's doing isn't it?"

Nina shrugged, "Partially, but I've been thinking about it for a while now anyways." She rolled over on the bed so that she was facing away from me and lifted her skirt. I saw the red rubber rectangle between her ass cheeks of Jen's 'trainer' butt plug. She continued, "But you left your sex toys at my house on Sunday so I started playing with them. I found that I really liked the way this one felt."

I couldn't help but chuckle, "You know that was the first plug Jen and I bought right? It's a 'starter' plug, much thinner than the other two we have." Mentally my brain added 'one of which is in Jen's ass right now.'

Nina flipped her skirt back down and rolled back over to look at Jen and I. She bit the bottom of her lip and said, "Yeah, but I thought maybe the two of you could work me up and we could replace this with the black one till Rich gets here?"

The black one huh? That means that Jen must have brought some of her toys, because the black one was the second plug we bought. It was a more normal sized plug, about five inches from base to tip, an inch and a half wide at the widest point, and maybe half an inch at the narrow point between the base and the flare of the cone. The red trainer in her ass now was only three quarters of an inch wide at the widest point, half of the black one she wanted to step up too. The one Jen was wearing was about the same shape as the black one, but was purple so therefore much prettier in her eyes, and also had a small removable vibrating egg.

"I'm..." I hesitated, "I'm not really sure how to start this." I said after a few moments of awkward silence. "Last time I was pretty drunk and you gals did all the work."

Jen nodded and then slid away from me to stand up and start removing her school outfit. Nina followed suit a few moments later, and Jen took the lead saying, "Why don't you get undressed and lay on the bed baby. Nina and I will get started, you can jump in whenever you want." Her school uniform quickly fell to the floor and she rolled her leggings down, stripping down nude.

As the two girls undressed, I quickly yanked the comforter and blanket off the bed. I couldn't help but think of a story I'd heard about how the blankets rarely got washed at motels, and I figured the sheets would be clean enough. Throwing the blanket and comforter in the corner padded chair, I turned to see my now nude girlfriend pulling some stuff out of her bag. On the bedside table she set out two bottles of lube, one was a 'warming kind', the black butt plug, her favorite vibrator, and a non vibrating dildo. Then she quickly pulled out a strip of condoms almost as an afterthought. She and I didn't use condoms during sex, but we had found that they were fantastic for easy cleanup, and often used them just for hygienic purposes, especially if she wanted to use any of her toys other than her plugs in her ass.

I yanked off my clothes as I watched the two women get on the bed and lay side by side. They began making out and touching each other passionately. I lay next to them, my cock quickly rising to fullness as I watched them. I felt almost like I shouldn't intrude they were so obviously into their sapphic encounter. Nina paused and rolled over towards me. She grabbed my neck and tongue kissed me deeply. I felt her mouth explore mine and I groaned as my cock twitched eagerly. Finally she broke the kiss and turning back to Jen said to me, "There's your hello kiss, hope you didn't mind waiting for it."

She began making out with Jen again and I looked at her back, with the rectangle of red rubber slightly exposed between her cheeks, and knew that I certainly didn't mind waiting one bit. I reached over and turned off the TV as I didn't want any distractions from what these two were about.

Jen had begun to roll over on top of Nina and the two were really going at it. I mean their hands were mostly on each other's breasts, back, neck, and head, but man... they were making out like two ... well... like two horny teenagers, which I guess they were. I lightly played with my cock as I watched them, not wanting to interrupt this scene. Then suddenly it occurred to me and I said, "Oh no, we don't have the camcorder!"

Nina broke the kiss and looked at me, "Rich came and picked it up from my house monday. That's when he gave me his card. He's bringing it with him when he comes." Then she turned back to Jen and asked, "69 now please?"

Jen laughed and nodded, then pushing herself away from the curvy blonde, she rotated around. Her knees came down on either side of Nina's head and the blonde woman likewise spread her legs for Jen's eager mouth. My girlfriend wasted no time lowering her face down to Nina's thick delicious slit. I heard the two of them both begin licking and sucking at each other right away and I simply lay next to them for awhile watching and enjoying the sounds they made. Gasps and moans and other small mewls of pleasure told me that they weren't doing this for my benefit, but they were really enjoying themselves.

After a while Nina began gasping and panting and moaning faster and faster. Jen redoubled her efforts and made Nina cum beneath her. Nina didn't squirt this time, but I'd learned that she only did that every so often. But still her orgasms were always quite wet and I could smell the fresh burst of her arousal in the air as she came. Jen lightly lapped at Nina's juicy slit as the blonde beneath her moaned and twisted pleasurably. Then Jen lifted her head, and her face, wet from nose to chin with Nina's juices split into a great smile. She said to me, "Baby, I want you to do something. Put on a condom and fuck my ass while Nina licks me."

Well, who was I to argue with that? I hopped off the bed and went around to the night stand. Rolling an unlubricated condom onto my rock hard shaft, I watched as the two women squirmed slightly to make room for me at the head of the bed. I drizzled a copious amount of the water based lube on my condom sheathed cock and moved to kneel on the bed, my legs outside of Jen's which were surrounding Nina's head. I could hear Nina resume her oral attentions on Jen's bald pussy as I positioned myself the best. I gripped the purple base of the butt plug in Jen's ass and slowly started teasing her with it. I began pulling it out, stretching her ass ring, then letting it go to fill her back up fully. I did this about three or four times before she finally moaned at me, "Oh for the love of fuck Pete, would you just take it out and fuck my ass already?"

I laughed and I felt a tender lick at the bottom of my ball sack as Nina must have been adding her encouragement in a non verbal way. I pulled the butt plug out of Jen's ass and very quickly lined the head of my cock up with her spread nether hole. Before I even had a chance to prepare to push into her, she shoved her hips backwards into me. The tip of my cock speared into her open ass. It never felt as good when I was wearing a condom, but I was in no place to complain as she rocked back into me, taking a fraction of an inch more with each rock. Finally with a delightful burst, the full head of my cock popped into her ass, drawing another pleasurable moan from Jen. I could feel my balls brushing against Nina's face, but I had large balls, there was really nothing I could do about it.

"Now fuck me please," Jen requested. I was only too happy to comply. I began stroking my lubed cock in and out of her ass while below I felt Nina resume licking her pussy with gusto. I wasn't even a dozen strokes into it when Jen came loudly and violently. Her orgasm must have been intense because she literally screamed out with pleasure, wordlessly and genuine. Her ass clenched down on my dick so hard I couldn't stroke in and out any more till her orgasm began to fade.

She held me like that for a moment then pulled away from me. She crawled down Nina's body and I gripped my cock as it came free from her ass. I thought it might be rude to let it smack down into Nina's face as the blonde lay below me. Jen crawled to the edge of the bed and then lay there, across it, looking at us. Nina raised her head, slightly sweaty and covered in Jen's girl jizz to look at the chocolate haired woman as she trembled and shook. Jen took a moment and then said, "well? What are you waiting for? Take off the condom and fuck her already."

I looked down at Nina and she looked back up at me, "Oh yes please?" She said with a laugh. Then scooting out from beneath me, she quickly got up on all fours in the doggystyle position. I could see the red rubber of the trainer butt plug still embedded in her cheeks. I pulled off the condom and tossed it into the trash before lining the fat head of my cock up to Nina's slippery wet cunny. I smiled at Jen as I pushed into Nina's tight wet sheath. The pleasure was heavenly and I could almost feel my copious precum mixing inside her with her own luscious juices and my girlfriend's saliva.

I began fucking Nina with slow but deep strokes. My balls slapped against her clit every time I buried myself in her. She moaned and groaned, and I think had a small orgasm almost right away. But I kept fucking, I needed my release after all.

"Nina," Jen asked the blonde as she watched us fucking, "I have a thought."

Nina simply moaned in pleasure as I fucked her deeply. So I responded, "What is it baby?"

Jen looked at me and said, "Nina loves tasting cum. I was thinking maybe you cum in me and she can get it from me instead of you?" Jen's smile was deviant and devilish and the thought of what she'd just said made my cock throb with desire, drawing another moan from Nina.

I smiled, "Ok but first, hand me the black plug." Jen hustled to sit up and reach for the night stand while I banged Nina harder and faster. Jen drizzled lube on the medium sized butt plug and handed it to me. Then I reached down to Nina's ass and said, "Ok Nina, just relax"

Nina cried out between moans, "Just go for it, I don't care, just don't stop fucking meeeeeeeeeeeee!" That last word turned into a cry of pleasure as her pussy began clenching my cock violently as she reached her peak. I wasn't sure about the first one, wasn't quite sure if she came when I first started fucking her, but there was no doubt about this one. Her cunny flooded with wetness and I could feel it soaking my shaft and balls as she slammed her hips back into me and rode the wave of her pleasure.

I kept fucking her through this, and when she seemed to come down from her orgasm, I gripped the red rubber between her ass cheeks and started teasing it out. She started crying out again as the anal stimulation along with the fucking revived her flagging orgasm back to full power. This time I did feel a hot gush of fluids hitting my balls and I knew she was squirting. The smell of her girl jizz was now overpowering in the room. But unwilling to quit my task, I eased the trainer butt plug out of her ass. I had a moment where her asshole gaped at me, clenching and releasing as she enjoyed her orgasm, but then I quickly replaced it with the rounded tip of the black butt plug. I worked it in and out of her, deeper with each thrust, until finally with a pop, it sank into her, leaving only a rectangle of black rubber between her cheeks.