A Divine Gift Ch. 02

Karen nodded and did exactly as I asked. I sat on the couch and watched her strut around the living room tidying things up. She was a bundle of nervous energy as she walked around, constantly glancing at the clock and at me when she wasn't picking something up or putting something away. I watched her perfect tits jiggle in the t-shirt and her hot little bubble butt that was barely concealed by the shorts she wore. When the doorbell finally rang, she jumped and gave a little yelp before looking at me in panicked arousal. "Go answer the door for your little sister, slut," I told her with a huge grin. She nodded and scampered to the door.

She opened the door with a friendly greeting, "Teri!" and gave her sister a hug. Her sister returned the hug and Karen grabbed her hand and practically dragged her inside. Teri is a beautiful, almost classically Irish girl. Pale skin and faint freckles. She was tall, almost 5'11, which she frequently lamented but other than that and her blue eyes, if you imagine a beautiful girl from Ireland you're pretty close.

It wasn't until Teri's eyes adjusted to the interior of the house that she got a good look at Karen. "What are you wearing?"

Karen laughed nervously and answered, "I told Danny I'd wear what he wanted me to today. This is what he wanted."

Teri laughed a little, "Typical guy, I guess... well you look great in it, I suppose. I hope I'm not interrupting sexy fun time or something," she said the last with a nervous laugh.

Something clicked in my mind just then. All she'd commented on was Karen's clothes. How had she not noticed her drastically changed appearance? I decided to try something and imagined a new tattoo right above Karen's ass. The one I'd asked her about earlier, "Danny's Property".

When Karen turned to lead her sister into the living Teri gasped, "Karen? When did you get that?"

"What?" Karen asked, unable to see what her sister was pointing to.

"That tramp stamp? Danny's property? Really?" she asked. Karen flushed and looked at me with a look.

"I just got it... I was feeling indulgent," she said nonchalantly.

"Weird," I thought to myself. She'd noticed the tattoo but nothing else. Was it because of HOW I'd imagined her changed appearance initially? I'd pictured her like that in college... could I actually change history somehow? I then imagined Karen getting a tattoo in college right above her cunt that said, "Insert here." The letters appeared before my eyes and I looked at the two girls.

Teri said, "I guess it's not nearly as bad as that other one you got in college. You always were a bit of a freak."

Karen blushed and my jaw dropped. I could fucking change history! At least when it came to Karen. Thank God! Literally.

I imagined the college tattoo gone and took a moment to revise my mental history of Karen. I imagined us still doing all the perverted things we'd done together but instead of her being open about it, she was secretive and snuck around. She'd studiously kept her "good girl" image for her parents all while slowly descending into the depths of sexual depravity with me.

Teri's face went back to being surprised by the new tramp stamp now that it, once again, had no precedent in Karen's past behavior. "Well... uhmm... what did you want to talk to me about?"

Teri walked over and started to sit down beside me. I shook my head and guided her instead to kneel on the floor. Teri looked at us with confusion as I ran my fingers through Karen's gorgeous red hair and down her spine. She shivered erotically under my touch. "What's going on guys? Why are you acting all weird, sis?"

"Karen has been desperate to tell you about... us... for a long time. Haven't you Karen?"

She shot me a look that was halfway between pleading and orgasm before turning back to her sister and nodding, "Yes. I have been hiding a side of me, Teri."

"Are you two swingers?"

"No!" Karen practically shouted, "I mean no... Danny wouldn't want that... would you, Danny?"

I looked at her and said, "Not today." Karen's eyes twinkled at me as she shuddered at the implication. Teri was still staring in utter confusion.

Karen turned her gaze back to her sister, "The Bible says, 'Wives submit to your husband' so that's what I've done. Completely. Danny can do literally whatever he wants with me and I'll be happy about it."

"Sis... Karen... I don't...," Teri stuttered unsure of exactly how to respond.

"What did you want me to do to you today in front of your sister, dear?"

"S... spank me," she managed.

"With?"

"Your belt," she said softly, not breaking eye contact with Teri.

"Okay guys... this is pretty fucked... what is going on?"

I decided to see how far I could push this history rewriting thing. I imagined Karen confessing her deepest desires to Teri when they were younger. Karen confiding in Teri her secret desires. I imagined Teri responding with enthusiasm and arousal herself and the two of them sharing these secrets.

Teri looked at Karen and I before saying, "Well... I have never understood this side of you Karen but I guess you're finally getting what you always wanted, right?"

Karen nodded, unable to talk because she was so aroused. I hadn't expected that answer from Teri. I'd expected a little more enthusiasm so I spoke up, "You're not a little bit interested?"

Teri looked at me studying me. "No. I mean I want Karen to be happy but her little... kink... never really did anything for me."

I frowned, surprised by the response. Was she that good an actress? Then I realized what had happened. I could change Karen and her history but not other people's. Karen had those conversations with her sister but I couldn't control the way Teri would react. I couldn't change Teri. Nuts.

At least Teri was a little more accepting knowing some of Karen's secret yearnings. I decided I could at least take advantage of that. "Tell your sister what you want, slut. Tell her what you need to happen and then ask if she'll help."

Teri recoiled at my use of the word "slut" but then saw that Karen didn't care. In fact, she was obviously turned on by it. Karen looked at her sister, "Please, Teri... Will you... watch him... uhmm... whip me? And then... uhhmm... will you... will you encourage him to... uhhh... Oh God... encourage him to uhmm... use me."

Teri looked at her sister, amazed at her depravity. "You guys are kinky as fuck!" she said but she didn't get up to leave. Like I said before, a beautiful wall flower. A voyeur.

Karen looked at me and I nodded. She smiled back at me and slowly slid her shorts off while I pulled out my belt. She knelt on the floor at my feet, knees spread and ass sticking high up into the air, begging for a thorough reddening. I smacked her lightly with my palm a couple times on each cheek to warm her up. "MMMmm..." she murmured happily.

Teri, remembering conversations that I'd implanted only minutes prior, scolded me. "She wants a lot harder than that, Danny. Really give it to the stupid bitch."

Karen whimpered and looked at her sister, "Please..."

"Oh... I'm sorry," Teri said apologetically, "I just thought..."

"Please don't be nice," Karen said, "I don't want nice from either of you." Her voice was practically sobbing with arousal and I could tell she was more turned on than she'd ever been. I'd kept her on edge all day, constantly imagining her being aroused and the cumulative effect was to make her absolutely desperate with lust.

I smacked her ass with my belt and she shrieked before saying, "Yess... more!"

I brought the leather strap down again and again on her ass, making little criss crosses of red along her perfect butt. For her part, Teri got into it as well. She kept saying things like, "Whip the dumb cunt harder," and, "Hurt her so good, Danny." Each time she did, Karen would wail out with desperate arousal. When Teri started reminding her about her "Useless empty cunt," it was too much for her and she started spasming and shaking with an orgasm despite the complete lack of human contact. "Pathetic," Teri said.

"No," I said, stroking Karen's red ass and long legs. "She's perfect."

Karen picked her head up and looked at me. There were tears running down her face as she smiled and whispered, "Thank you."

"Okay you guys. This has been fun but I've really got to get going," Teri said. Her skin and chest were flushed with arousal and I suspected I knew precisely what she'd be doing when she got home.

"No worries, Teri. Thanks for coming over and getting my slutty little wife all hot and bothered."

Teri blushed again and averted her eyes, "You have fun... uhmm... taking care of my sister."

Karen was just kneeling there staring up at me with complete adoration. I started pulling my zipper down and Teri hastened her steps towards the door. The door wasn't even closed before Karen plunged onto my cock, sucking me forcefully into the back of her throat with a satisfied murmur. I looked down and stroked her long, bright red hair, trailing my fingers down to caress her cheek.

"You are a little pathetic," I said with a smile.

As if to prove my point, she slowly pulled off my cock, leaving a trail of spit connecting the head to her lips. She looked up at me, saliva trailing across her cheek and down her chest as she nodded, "Yes, I am. Is that okay?"

I gripped her hair and shoved her back down onto my cock, "Yes... it's perfect." She stroked her tongue around me as she fellated me with skill that only a wish from God can grant. "Did you like having your sister watch?"

She murmured her unmitigated approval.

"Teri's pretty cute," I said. Karen didn't take my cock out but arched her head back to look up at me with wide eyes, "Do you like that?"

Karen plunged down on my cock, ignoring the question for the moment. "I wonder if I could seduce her? Is she a big cock slut like her sister, I wonder?"

Karen was now making almost manic sounding noises. Then she suddenly pulled off my cock and took a couple ragged breaths before sitting back on her heels and looking up at me. "You could fuck her right now, Danny."

"What? No I can't..." I said in confusion.

"Sure you could. You can... make me... uhmm... be her," she said.

"Do you want that?" I asked.

She paused for a moment before answering slowly, "No, I want you to fuck me... which is why it's perfect."

I smiled and closed my eyes, imagining Karen looking exactly like her little sister. Objectively, they weren't even close. Teri was cute and fit and a solid 9 on any guy's scale. But Karen's look was absolute physical perfection. But somehow opening my eyes and seeing my naked sister-in-law kneeling on the ground was way hotter than I thought it would be.

"Go look in the mirror, my little slut," I said to my wife. She scampered up and ran into the bedroom. I admired her tight little ass as I followed her.

"Oh my God," she said from the bathroom.

"I had to make some guesses about the nipples and stuff."

"And you apparently picture my sister with a smooth shaved cunt and giant clit?" My wife said as she stepped out. Sure enough, she was standing there with a gaping, dripping, smooth cunt and an obviously swollen clit.

"Is that a problem?" I said as I beckoned her closer.

"Absolutely not, stud. So what do you want to do to my sister?" she asked with a coquettish innocence.

I grabbed her and kissed her. Our lips mashed together and our tongues snaked around each other with a moist need. I grabbed her ass and squeezed it, causing her to moan into my mouth. "God I want to fuck you," I snarled before kissing her again with almost feral hunger.

When she broke our kiss, she whispered to me, "What about your wife? My sister? Is Karen okay with this?"

I grabbed her and flung her on the bed. She gasped in surprise but happily wrapped her legs around my waist as I pinned her down to the bed. "Does it matter?"

Her eyes looked at me and, for just a moment, I forgot it was Karen. She looked EXACTLY like Teri and, what's more, she sounded just like her too. "Of course it doesn't. I'm going to fuck you better than she ever could, stud."

The playfulness in her voice was the only thing that brought me back to reality. She reached down and spread her cunt lips wide, showing me the wet, pink interior that I was about to split asunder. I slid my shaft into her, marveling as the pink skin parted to accommodate my new found girth. "Oh, God... Danny... go slow... it's... it's so fucking BIG."

I slowed down and looked at her as she blinked and tried to breathe. Her hands were on my chest holding me back from ramming hard into her. I guess Teri was a little smaller on the inside than Karen... Or at least she was in my imagination. The thought made me surge inside of her, flexing involuntarily. She in turn gasped and gave me a knowing smile. "You like that, stud? You like knowing that this giant fucking meat stick is nearly splitting me open? It hurts but it hurts soooo good, Danny. I must be so much tighter than Karen. Am I, Danny? Am I tighter than that slut wife of yours?"

"Y... Yes," I managed to choke out.

She smiled another smile. This one more sinister, "MMMmm... good... I like that. I like knowing that my pussy is nice and tight around this beautiful cock. Go nice and slow, stud. Let me get used to it. Then you can fucking pound me and make me another slut like my sister."

I grinned at her and pressed her thighs wider with my hands. She obligingly unlocked her heels from behind me and held her legs out straight, toes pointed to the sky as I finished sliding the entire length of myself into her. Her little fists pounded the bed, "Jesus... Jesus... fuck me... so fucking big... How does my bitch sister take all this... fuck... fuck. Why has she been keeping this from me?"

I pulled out slowly and watched as she whimpered at the empty sensation, "Want it back, Teri?"

"Yesssss," she said. I shoved it into her, a little harder this time. A little faster. Nice and steady. It made her eyes roll and she let out a long moan that became a scream as I became fully engulfed again. We repeated that several times, each time with me giving it to her a little harder. A little faster. Her legs were now on my shoulders as I started pumping steadily into her. Before long, I was ramming her hard and fast, "Tell me... oh God... tell me how much... fuck... tell me how much better I am, Danny."

"Sooo much better," I said as I slammed into her. "Tighter than Karen. Such a nice tight young pussy, Teri."

My wife smiled up at me with Teri's face. Her red hair was cascading all around her and her tits were bouncing with each thrust. "You can fuck me anytime, Danny. Anytime you want some nice, tight young pussy. Don't ask. Just use me like this, Danny."

I couldn't hold back much longer. I leaned up and grabbed her ankles, spreading her as wide as possible as I slammed hard into her. She screamed out a joyful shout and started rubbing her clit. Suddenly, she started cumming, spasming and twitching in front of me. Her cunt gripped my cock hard and the next thrust through that velvety chasm was like heaven. I couldn't help but cum after that, filling her up with a grunt.

I collapsed down beside her still twitching body as I imagined her back to how she'd been before. She sighed and looked at me, "Did you like that, Danny?"

I nodded, still trying to catch my breath.

"Good... cause next time I'm going to help you make sure it's really Teri and not an imposter."

I looked at my wife and she smiled at me before giving me a sweet, almost chaste, kiss. What a weird world we live in.