And Then There Was Katie Ch. 04

With a disheartened look in her blue eyes, Katie nodded and shimmied off the table. As she gained her footing, a soft smile returned to her face and she looked up at her tall brother-in-law. "I never get tired of feeling your cum inside of me." Taking his hand in hers, she led him out of the kitchen and up the staircase.

Each dressed quickly in their respective bedrooms before reassembling in the hallway. "Come on," Mike said, sliding his left arm around the small of Katie's back. He led them back downstairs to the small living area just off the main entryway. "If they show back up," he explained, "we'll be able to see them from here."

Mike had achieved his position in life with his sharp intellect and remarkable sense of logic. He approached his current problem in the same manner as he would any other. "Okay," he began once they were seated, "let's think through the scenario of each person finding the panties and their probable thoughts, suspicions, and reactions. Start with John."

Mike and Katie thus analyzed each family member over the course of the subsequent forty minutes. Daniel and Chad were deemed to be the least problematic if one of them found the underwear in question. Conversely, Jennifer and Thomas would probably be most likely to cause trouble.

With the exception of Daniel and Chad, anyone else in possession of the panties would likely be suspicious enough either to ask about them or to secretly scrutinize the actions of Mike and Katie, looking for proof of any affair that would surely be assumed in that person's mind.

"The bottom line," Mike concluded, "is that there are too many unknowns here. I don't think we're going to have any choice but to stay away from each other until we find out who is our culprit or until we are absolutely certain that we will be one hundred percent safe. This is why we set out to be so cautious – so much for that, huh?"

Katie stared at the floor in apparent dejection. "How could we have been so stupid?" she asked. Mike heard the tell-tale sniffle signaling the start of Katie's quiet sobbing. He stepped quickly across from his sofa to hers and wrapped his arms lovingly around her. Katie leaned into his shoulder and cried.

"I love you so much," she said through her tears. "All I want is to be with you, Mike."

Mike gently lifted her head up and looked at her puffy face. "I love you too, Katie...so much that it hurts. But we can only do as much as we can do without getting caught. We both know that."

Despite the seriousness of the situation, Mike once again felt himself getting hard. The feel of Katie's body and the scent of her hair quickly returned him to that place where he didn't care about consequences or getting caught. Acting on his feelings, he lifted Katie's chin and looked into her watery eyes.

Mike used his thumb to wipe away the tears that streamed down her precious cheeks, then he kissed her. Katie kissed him back, and they embarked on one of those wonderfully soft, loving kisses, full of longing and the desire for a greater closeness that they were destined to live without.

The passion swelled inside them both like ocean waves with an approaching storm. As their lust overtook them, breathing became heavier, kisses became wetter, and hands became more familiar. Breaking their kiss, Mike looked past Katie to the clock on the wall.

"It's just now 8:50," he said, almost in a whisper. "We probably have at least an hour."

Katie nodded silently, and began to quickly undress. Mike did the same, and a few moments later their naked bodies pressed back together with a renewed infatuation.

Their tongues met again, but with greater urgency. Hands roamed and squeezed and pinched and rubbed, and the room was filled with the accompanying pleasurable gasps. Mike slid his hand down between Katie's legs and teased her outer sex. He could tell she was wet, very wet, and the intoxicating aroma hardened his cock even more.

Katie eased Mike into a lying position, never breaking their kiss. The leather of the couch groaned under the friction of her legs as she swung herself over Mike in a straddle. As she reached back between her legs, Mike took both of her breasts in his hands, kneading them firmly. Katie made quick time of lining up Mike's erection where she wanted it, then let go, allowing only the head to slide between her ready lips.

"How bad do you want me, Mike?" she teased, not moving her body one more millimeter down his pole.

"Oh baby," he moaned, "I want you bad! Please fuck me!"

"Is this what you want?" she asked, quickly plunging down on him and then right back up to where she was.

"Oh god yes! Don't stop, Katie. I need to fuck you. I need to cum inside you again," Mike pleaded. He gave her nipples a hard pinch, trying to regain some control over the situation.

Katie's head flew back as she unleashed a delicious squeal of ecstasy. "Oh Mike!" she cried out with a cracking voice. Mike pinched her again, and she once more impaled herself on his throbbing cock. Mike savored the sensations her tight, wet pussy gave him as she proceeded to ride him carefully and deliberately, like she was afraid to waste even one stroke.

Mike lay there on the couch looking up at the woman on top of him, and he felt like a peasant worshipping his goddess. The way her short hair bobbed and her breasts bounced with her every thrust onto the object inside her increased the beauty Mike saw in her ten-fold. He was lucky to have a woman like Katie love him, and he knew it. He was even luckier to have a woman like Katie fuck him and like it, and he wondered if Thomas really appreciated her like he did.

"Oh Mike, I love how you feel inside me!" she whimpered in the midst of her bouncing. "I love it! I love it!" Suddenly, Katie pressed her hands flatly into Mike's chest and leaned forward, looking intently into his eyes without breaking her rhythm. With less frenzy and more seriousness, she said, "Tell me how it feels to be inside of me, Mike."

With his hands on her hips, Mike returned her gaze. "It feels amazing, Katie. You are so tight around me. You are so wet. I love knowing how wet I make you."

"Oh god, Mike – I am so wet for you! Just thinking about you makes me wet. At work, I think about you and get wet. In the car, I think about you and get wet. In bed with my husband, I think about you and get wet."

Mike moaned, absolutely loving how vocal she was while she continued to ride him. "It feels like I'm hard around the clock, Katie. I get hard every time I see you or talk to you or smell you or even just think about you. I walk by a woman in the mall with your perfume, and I get hard. I see a picture of you on the wall, and I get hard."

"Yes! Yes, Mike, yes! I can feel you!" Her seriousness quickly melted back into an ecstatic whimper. "I can feel your hard cock touching just the right spots. I can – ooooooh Miiiiiiike – oh, I can feel it throughout my whole body!" Katie shivered in pleasure while their sexy banter continued.

"You're pussy is so perfect. It drives me so wild and makes me think of wanting nothing else. It's so hot! It's so you! You are what I want! I want to fuck you! I want to cum in you! I want to make you cum! I –"

Katie interrupted him with her moaning cries. "Oh Mike! I'm so close! I can feel you! It's so good! Oh there! There! Right there! Right there! Oh fuuuuuuck!" Her voice broke into squeals of orgasm, the pleasure exploding inside and around her quaking pussy.

Mike revered the experience of making his sister-in-law cum. The sensation of the flooding wetness of her rippling flesh was intensely hot. So was the look that spread across Katie's face whenever she climaxed. Mike loved her, and he loved giving her so much enjoyment.

Katie's orgasm raged on long enough for Mike to thoroughly enjoy it. He was so hard, but he wasn't ready to cum. As she came down from her high, she continued to ride him hard and fast. "I love you Mike!" she cried. "Fuck, you're so good! I never want to stop making love to you. I want you on top of me. I want you underneath me. I want you inside me. I want you to do things to me that have never been done before."

That last thing she said got Mike's attention. He decided to find out what she meant. "What things?"

Katie suddenly stopped her movements and looked breathlessly down into Mike's face. Panting, she just stared at him for several long seconds, long enough for Mike to wonder what was going on inside her mind.

"I want you to fuck my ass, Mike." She remained quiet as her words sank in. Mike's cock twitched inside Katie at the excitement those words produced in him. Jennifer had never been interested in anal sex, and it had always been a fantasy of Mike's. How fitting, he thought, that here was his ultimate fantasy woman asking him to fulfill his ultimate fantasy inside her tight ass.

"Are you sure?" he asked.

Katie took a few seconds to answer. "Yes, I'm sure. It's something I've been fantasizing about lately, but I wasn't sure I wanted to tell Thomas. But I know for sure I want to tell you. I want you to do it, and I want you to do it right now."

Katie dismounted from Mike's achingly hard pole and stood up next to the couch. When Mike still looked at her in disbelief, she said, "Please, Mike. Do you not want to do it?"

There was no hesitation in his answer. "Hell yes I want to do it. Do you have any lube upstairs?"

"Let's try without it," Katie replied. "Use my cum as lube; I'm so wet, it should be fine. Plus..." She looked down at the floor, blushing.

Rising up off of the couch, Mike asked, "What is it?"

"Well, I've been, you know...using things...to get myself ready for you."

Mike almost shot his load on the spot. The thought of Katie using objects to ass fuck herself was nearly too much to handle. "Okay," he said, looking her in the face, "why don't you get on your knees here and kind of lean on the couch."

Katie just nodded and followed his instructions. Mike knelt down behind her and looked eagerly at the sexy back door that awaited him. He reached between her legs and slid two fingers inside her pussy. Once they were sufficiently soaked, he pulled them out and smeared Katie's gooey cum all over her waiting hole. He repeated the lubing of his fingers, but this time he pushed one inside her ass.

Katie gasped at the intrusion. "Oh god, Mike. I want it. I want it bad." Mike slid the finger in and back out again before adding the second. She again moaned as he pushed the digits as far inside her as he could before removing them.

"Are you ready?" Mike asked, himself nearly ready to explode. He hoped he would last long enough inside her for her to enjoy it.

"Yes," was her simple reply.

Mike lined his cock up with her pussy and quickly shoved it inside, giving it a fresh coat of cum before sliding it back out again. Katie stretched out her arms on the sofa and pressed her face into the cushion, ready for him to fill her backside.

Mike placed his head against her red hole and grabbed her hips. He began applying pressure, and before long his tip slipped inside.

When Katie didn't make any sounds, Mike asked, "You okay?"

Biting her lip, Katie nodded. "Mmm hmm."

Mike continued, slowly pushing his wet cock inside her tight ass. He was thankful that she had been preparing herself for this, because it took only a minute before he was fully buried in her. "That's it, baby," he informed her. "How does it feel?"

"Fuck, you feel so big inside me," she rasped through gritted teeth. Grimacing, she whispered, "Just wait for a minute."

Mike reached deep inside himself and found the self-restraint to grant her request. There he was, on his knees, his throbbing pole swallowed up by the snugness of Katie's back door. He had arrived in the promised land and then asked to "just wait." It was easier said than done.

After what seemed like an eternity, Mike heard the words he had been waiting for. "Okay," Katie said, sounding normal. "It's much better now." Looking back over her right shoulder, she smiled mischievously at Mike and said, "Now fuck me, you sexy sexy stud!"

Mike needed no more encouragement. Using his hands on her hips for leverage, he slid most of his raging erection out of its newly discovered home before shoving it forcefully back inside. From the very first stroke, Katie's lust was on fire, evident to Mike from the sounds she produced.

"Oh god Mike! Oh fuck, that's amazing!" He continued to pound into her. "Ah! Ah! I can't tell you! Oh Jesus! Oh! Oh! Oooooohhhhh my GODDDDD!"

Katie was already so hot that her orgasm struck in less than a minute. Her ass contracted in time with her pussy, and Mike felt like she would completely pinch off his cock, which had stopped its movements.

Mike could smell the arousal emanating from between her legs. It felt like he was immersed in the smells of their love making, and he wondered if the aroma was really as strong as it seemed. He hoped not, because he planned on having his cock inside some part of Katie's body until the rest of the family pulled into the driveway.

Katie's climax was short, and as soon as Mike felt it subside, he once again began to fuck her. "Jesus Katie, this is so fuckin' hot!"

"Mike," she whimpered, "ca – can you reach my clit?"

Never stopping the thrusting of his hips, Mike leaned forward onto her back and reached around her waist with his right hand. When he felt his fingers touch her wetness, he said, "Thank god you're a size 4."

Not waiting for permission, Mike went to work on her love button. His upper body rested on Katie's lower back, which was the only thing keeping her still enough for him to continue what he was doing to her.

"Fu – uu – uu – uu – uck!" Katie cried with a shuddering voice. Her pleasure was so intense that she sounded like she was in pain, but as usual Mike knew better. The combination of his fingers on her clit and her ass being stuffed with his meat sent Katie into sexual orbit. Her cries and moans stopped, and her body just shook and shivered and twitched and jerked underneath Mike.

He knew from the massage his cock was receiving that she was once again climaxing, but he still didn't stop. He continued on for at least another minute, the only sounds coming from his heavy breathing and their body parts slapping together. With his fingers doing their thing, Katie's orgasm was unrelenting, and after another thirty seconds of silent ecstasy, her voice finally returned.

The sound welled up from inside her like it had been there the whole time and was finally able to escape. In a quick crescendo, she let loose with a string of profanities that made Mike blush inside. "Hooooolllyyyyyyyyyyy fuuuuuuck! Fuck! Fuck! Fuck! Jesus H. Fucking Christ! Oh GODDD! Mike! Mike!"

It was so raw, so animalistic, so carnal, and so time for Mike to finish. As Katie's arms flailed out and pounded the couch underneath her, Mike felt his own orgasm explode out of the excitement that had been building in him. "Katieeeeeeeeee!"

Her name was all he could manage to say before his entire body tensed with the gush of cum that shot from his buried cock. His cock jerked again, and again, and again, each time sending a rope of his thick cream flying into his sister-in-law's scalding hot ass.

Before Mike finished cumming, Katie grabbed his right hand and tore it away from her sensitive clit. "No more! No more, Mike!" she squealed. She lunged forward, pulling her deflowered ass off of his cock, which slid down through her crack, leaving a trail of cum before falling between Mike's legs.

Exhausted, Mike dropped to the floor, panting. As he lay there on his back, trying to catch his breath, Katie pounced on him, locking her lips to his. She kissed him like a woman possessed, and Mike responded to her tongue's affection.

"Oh Mike," she said, repeatedly pecking his lips and face, "that was so so SO amazing! I don't know how you do the things you do to my body, but sex with you is beyond any pleasure I've ever experienced!"

Still out of breath, Mike simply answered, "Ditto." Katie laughed at him before sliding her tongue back into his mouth. The lovers just stayed there in the floor making out for several minutes before Katie pushed herself up to a kneeling position, straddling Mike's waist.

"So," she said slyly, "what do you say to getting yourself cleaned up and letting me see if I can suck some life back into that amazing thing between your legs?"

Mike couldn't help but smile at her. Katie was so adorable, so sexy, and staring up at her stunning, oversexed body would bare any hot-blooded man's teeth. "I say, I love you," he replied. "Now let me up, little lady, and we'll see if we can't honor your request."

Looking at the clock, Katie announced, "It's 9:45. They'll probably be back soon, so let's go to the kitchen and wash off that cock of yours, get our clothes gathered up and upstairs where we can quickly get them on, then come back down here and lick and suck on each other until everybody gets back."

"I think I can live with that," he said. Holding hands, they headed off to quickly complete their plan. Within five minutes, they were back on the couch by the front door. Despite two incredible rounds of sex, seeing Katie's naked body walking in front of him already had Mike thinking about getting hard again. He knew her mouth would be able to accomplish the task in no time.

"Okay," Mike started, "we're going to have to be alert and ready to jump up and get up into our rooms. Can you handle that?"

"I can handle it, but you're going to have to watch for the others because I'm going to busy stuffing my face full of your cock. So the question is, can you handle it?"

Mike lay down on the couch and spread his legs slightly. "There's only one way to find out, love."

Smiling, Katie swung her leg over Mike's chest and rested her knees on either side of Mike's shoulders. At the same time, she lowered her mouth to Mike's crotch and her pussy to Mike's face. In unison, their mouths found their targets.

Katie sighed contentedly at the feeling of Mike's tongue pushing its way inside her residually wet hole. He loved the taste of her pussy, and he began earnestly eating her out despite his fatigue.

He felt his semi-erect cock being sucked up into Katie's talented mouth. Chills raced through his body as her tongue swirled around his sensitive head. The incredible suction her lips provided brought his erection back in full force. Her actions weren't frantic or wild. Slowly, lovingly, deliberately she made love to him with her mouth.

As his own passion rose, he returned the favor to Katie's soaked hole. Her wetness actually ran down his tongue and dripped into his mouth. Just inches from his eyes was Katie's ass, and his cock twitched inside her mouth at the sight of his cum oozing out of her.

Mike struggled to keep his eyes focused on the walls and ceiling so he could see the headlights when the family returned. As the minutes passed, things got hotter, harder, and wetter between them. Before long, Katie's body began a rocking motion on top of Mike. Rocking back forced his tongue deeper into her pussy. Rocking forward forced his cock deeper into her mouth. She was humping his face, and he loved every second of it.

Mike thought about far he and Katie had come in their relationship. They had gone from proper, standoff-ish in-laws to cautious lovers to all-out fuck buddies. Here they were, feasting on each other's genitals, waiting for their spouses to return so they could act like everything was normal and like they hadn't just spent the last three hours fucking each other senseless. Oh, how things change, Mike thought as he squeezed Katie's firm little ass with his hands.

With Katie moaning in pleasure around his cock, Mike saw the flash of lights streak across the ceiling. He quickly but reluctantly removed his tongue from inside her pussy and sounded the alert. "They're home Katie. Let's go."