Another Night on the Hill

This time I heard movement to my side and something bumped my feet. I sensed movement on either side of me, like the sound of steps on the blanket, going past my head. Next, I felt hands again clamping down on my wrists, but no feel of skin against my shoulders as I was expecting. I was confused, but then felt skin against my chest and soft flesh moving against my neck and chin. 'What was this?' I thought. I was still really confused, then the thought hit me – she was crab-walking her crotch up into my face. I lifted my head with my mouth open and felt the folds of her pussy. As I did, she rotated her hips up and down just a little while wiggling her bum in sort of a gyration. With this enticement, I pressed on with my tongue deeply into her folds for a juicy taste. She was also pleasantly moist and aromatic. Again, I thought this tasted like Angie, but I still wasn't sure. Could this be Lynn?

As I tongued and mouthed her, she shifted forward, pressing down on my wrists harder as she unexpectedly slid her open butt cheeks onto my face. I couldn't help but dive in. I probed with my tongue and found the pungent taste of her anus. I moaned with delight and pushed in as deep as I could. I savored the moment and the taste but had no idea which girl it was. Then she shifted back toward my chest and moved her butt away from my face. I could feel her weight on my chest and her hands remained on my wrists. Then she was still, basically sitting on my chest. That was it. Now I had to make my guess. I was trying to convince myself it was Angie, not Lynn. In my mind, Lynn would not have been so bold her first time with me, even in a game.

I was confused and still in a buzz from being so aroused. I really did want to get this right. Concentrate! I knew I had a 50-50 chance and just had to outsmart them. The first girl really did taste like Angie, but then they both tasted so good it was hard to tell. The second girl's action of letting me taste her asshole was puzzling me. There she sat on me, but I wasn't sure who it was. The girls were of similar weight and build. I was guessing that it was Angie, because I assumed Lynn would not be into getting her butthole licked, at least not just yet. And that, I decided, was the girls' strategy – make me think it was Angie when it was really Lynn. With that thought, my cock got even harder – I had just licked Lynn's asshole! And if I guessed right, I was going to lick it some more.

"You girls really tried to confuse me, but I think I have it right. It was Angie first and Lynn second. This is Lynn on me right now."

There was a pause. Oh no, I got it wrong, I thought. I was trying to imagine what they would ask me to do. But then I felt hands on my head, pulling the blindfold off.

I looked up and there was Lynn, smiling at me. It was her!

"Ron, you must have cheated somehow," said Angie. "How did you know?"

Lynn had loosened her grip on my wrists, and I moved my hands to feel her butt cheeks and hips. She started to move.

"No, don't get up yet. I won, didn't I? Let's just keep going with what you were doing. We don't have much time before we need to head home."

Then I added, "Angie, I really thought it was you, but I guessed the other way figuring you were trying to trick me. I'm so glad Lynn is here and this is what I want. I want to kiss and lick both of you. We can do that for a while to warm up. Then we'll finish with you two girls in a sixty-nine position. OK?"

Lynn didn't wait. She got up on her knees and straddled my head as she spread her ass cheeks with her hands. I guided her in with my hands on her hips. She let out a little moan as I started kissing her asshole again.

"That sounds so sexy, Ron, but that has to remain our little secret," said Angie. "The part about us licking each other. I'm not saying we've never done that, but I don't want anyone else to know."

By then, my mouth was fully occupied and my tongue was probing Lynn's ass. She was hairless there too, so she must have shaved all over. "Oh, that feels good," said Lynn. She was gyrating her hips again, like she did earlier. With my long arms I reached my hands around her hips, finding her smooth mound. I stroked her mound and outer lips as I licked and tongued her bum hole. I was in heaven.

"Mmm..." was all I could say. After a while, with a smacking sound I pulled my mouth from her. "Angie's turn now." Lynn was still in sort of the crab-walk position. She pushed her butt into my face again and I took a last taste as she raised herself off of me. 'What a view,' I thought. By now, the overcast sky had started to open up, and there was some light from the moon behind the thin clouds. The sheen on her skin and aroma of her pussy and ass were wonderful. She hadn't cum yet but was very juicy and excited. She lifted herself off me and stood up. She looked so desirable and my cock ached for her, but now I turned to Angie.

"Well, we have done this before, Ron. How do you want me this time?" asked Angie.

"Let's try this. Lie down here next to me with your ass in my face. That way, you can relax while I do you. I'll move over and make more room on the blanket so Lynn can lie down next to you."

I rolled on my side to make more room as Angie lay next to me, and stuck her butt out in a lewd way. She was on her left side facing Lynn, who at the moment just stood watching. Angie used her hand to lift up her bum cheek and expose her beautiful asshole. I held her around her hips as I pulled my face into the crevice between her cheeks. She was obviously also very excited. I lifted her thigh to open her even more as I tongued her asshole. 'Unreal,' I thought and even better than the last time. She was completely smooth and hairless. I couldn't get enough.

"That looks so sexy; I can't believe I am watching you two do this," said Lynn. I was still probing Angie's ass with my tongue as I pushed my lips in. I rested her knee back on the blanket and moved my free hand to her pussy. She was slick with juice as I rubbed her clit and gently probed her pussy with a finger. She was close to cumming, but I wanted to see her do that with Lynn.

"Lynn, you come in now. Time for some sixty-nine," I said as I got up on my knees. Angie rolled onto her back, and her breasts looked succulent in the partial moonlight. Lynn moved over Angie and stood with one foot on either side of her head. I didn't know if they had ever done this before. I moved myself on my knees behind Angie's head as Lynn bent down to get on her hands and knees.

This was beyond belief to see two cute girls doing it. They seemed tentative, like maybe this was new to them. I watched with my cock sticking straight out, harder than ever, as Lynn lowered her crotch onto Angie's face. Angie used her hands to guide and support Lynn's ass as Lynn leaned forward. "Ahh..."she started moaning as Angie licked her pussy. Lynn then started moving her knees back, stretched her arms forward and legs back as she lowered herself out flat on top of Angie. Angie opened her legs and lifted her knees as Lynn lowered her face into Angie's crotch and used her arms to spread Angie's thighs even wider.

The view of Lynn's back and butt lying on top of Angie and the sounds they were making got me almost to the point of cumming without even touching myself. "You girls look so sexy doing that. Unbelievable." I moved closer on my knees from the side, until my cock was in contact with Lynn's ass. She was dewy with sweat and I slid my cock over her cheek as I stroked myself. I could see the top of Angie's head underneath Lynn and hear the girls making soft moans as they licked each other. Angie and I made eye contact. I couldn't wait any longer.

"I'm going to cum on your ass!"

"Do it, Ron, do it! It's OK!" said Lynn.

I squirted on Lynn's butt in 3 or 4 jets of cum. Then, I smeared my cum over Lynn's cheeks, into her ass crack, and gently probed her asshole with a finger. This set Lynn over the edge and soon she was cumming, followed shortly by Angie, who moaned loudly as she saw what I was doing to Lynn.

They lay there a few moments as I caressed Lynn's ass and thighs. As much as I hated to spoil the moment, I was about to speak, when Lynn rolled off of Angie and stood up. Angie sat up and said, "That was amazing – I wish we could do more." She also stood, and then moved to their pile of clothes. I was left kneeling there on the blanket, taking in one last long look of these two adorable girls in the nude. We were all sweaty and the smell of sex was still in the calm night air.

I reluctantly stood and thought about what we had just done. Did I make them do something they didn't want to do? Maybe. They seemed so enthusiastic. The game was fun, and it could not have turned out better for me. Or could it?

As the girls got dressed, I folded up my blanket, and then asked, "What would you have made me do if you had won the guess?"

"We weren't sure. I think we might have made you lick us both to orgasm, and after that make you jerk off and squirt into your own mouth," said Angie with that impish smile.

But that wasn't all. They said, no matter what, I had to agree to do this again, another night with their friend Sue. That sounded interesting. Sue was a bigger girl, chubby without being obese, definitely not the same build as Angie or Lynn.

I said, "Well, we're running out of time." None of us had a watch to check the time, and I was worried about getting caught if it started getting light as I made my way home. "We'd better get going. Do you know the way now? It'll be easier going back because it's mostly downhill."

"Sure, we can do it on our own now, Ron. Thanks for coming down to meet us, I don't think we could have made it up here without you," said Angie. She walked up to me, now dressed, and kissed me on the lips as she gave my cock a caress. I was in a semi-soft state but quickly my erection started to return.

Lynn moved over behind me as I stood there with Angie, put her arms around me and gave me a big hug. "That really makes my sleepover with Angie memorable – I hope we can do this another time, but I have to go home to California." She gave my cock a quick squeeze, and now it really was hard again. "I won't forget the feel of your tongue!" With that she kissed me and turned to go. We said our goodbyes and went our separate ways.

The walk home went quickly. I was still wound up from reliving what had just happened. It seemed unreal and my surroundings in the dark were surreal and dreamlike. All was quiet, and no houses had on any lights. I got to my window, climbed in, and then put the screen back in place. Finally, I started to relax as I lay on the bed, still nude, and drifted off to sleep.