"Arrow": Forbidden Desires

Finally, Oliver broke it off, and gently pushed her backwards off of him.

"Thea...this is wrong. Look, I love you...but not like this. We can't do this. It's forbidden. It's ince..."

"Incest?" she said suddenly, beating him to the punch. "Oh, really, Ollie? It's incest? It's wrong? It's forbidden? According to whom, exactly? According to society? Last I checked, neither of us were really the types of people who really gave a crap about what 'society' thought. According to biology nerds? Well, I don't know about you, but I ESPECIALLY don't care about what any biology nerds think about it."

"Speedy, they have valid points. There are biological repercussions, societal repercussions, it's..."

"Shut up, Ollie," she finally said as she held him tightly once again. "Just shut up."

She slowly started to cry. Then, she looked up in his eyes, and tried to reason with him.

"Ollie...I don't care what anyone thinks. I don't care about society, about what biology people think. All I know is one thing: there is a gorgeous man standing in front of me right now...a man who I know will always love me forever, unconditionally. A man who I thought I lost, who came back to me as my own personal beautiful miracle. A man I will always love...and I want to show him what true love means, in every sense of the word. Will you let me show that man how much I will always love him? And not just as a brother."

Oliver's mind was racing. He had imagined something like this happening, but thought it wouldn't. He couldn't believe Thea was romantically in love with him. He supposed it made some degree of sense...she had been through so much heartbreak and trauma. She hadn't lived a normal life, and that would screw up the emotions of any young girl.

But he had to put a stop to this.

"Thea...I...I know that both of us have been through a lot of trauma. A lot of grief, and heartbreak. But that doesn't mean we're allowed to do something like...this. We'll always love each other, to be sure...but not like this. Not in that way. I'm so sorry, Thea. I never understood how deep your hurt was, how much your losses disturbed you...but I can't do something like this with you. It's wrong. You need to see a psychiatrist to help sort out your feelings, because as of right now, you...OH, GOD, THEA!"

Oliver wanted to continue his thought decrying the notion of what she intended to do, but he couldn't. Thea wouldn't let him. Partway through his speech, Thea dropped to her knees, yanked down his boxers, started to lick him intimately.

Oliver took a moment to compose himself. His little sister was orally pleasuring him.

"Thea, what are you doing? You can't...you shouldn't...Oh, God..."

Thea continued to pleasure him as she ignored his cries. Finally, she disengaged herself from him, as her mouth left his member with a popping sound, while moving her hand towards him to stroke him.

"You can't tell me this doesn't feel good."

"Listen, Thea...oh, it does feel good. But it's forbidden. We can't..."

Thea moved her mouth towards him again, and began sucking fervently. She wasn't going to allow him to back out now. Nuh-uh. They had come too far. This was their chance at experiencing true love.

Oliver paused in fright as he considered the circumstances surrounding him at the moment. His little sister was sucking him off. A forbidden act of incest. But against his better judgment, he couldn't stop her. It felt too good. It was absolutely electric, and he felt himself getting aroused both by the forbidden nature of what they were doing as well as how much it felt like a pure expression of love.

After several more moments of her taking his erect manhood in her mouth, Thea took a step back and stood up. She slowly took off her nightgown, exposing her perky breasts. Then, she slowly slid her panties down her thighs seductively.

His little Speedy was standing in front of him, completely naked.

She eventually moved towards the bed, then leaned back and spread her legs.

"I did you a favor, Ollie. Now it's time for you to return the favor."

Naked and wanting, Thea presented her pussy towards him. She wanted him to orally pleasure her. He had so many misgivings, so much doubt about it...but he figured to himself that he should return the favor that she had provided him. It was wrong, but maybe it would be okay if they stopped at oral.

Slowly, Oliver moved his mouth towards the bed. Towards his little sister's pussy. He opened his mouth, and began to stick his tongue in her hot wetness. God, it felt so good. He moved his tongue up and down her sweetness, savoring the taste.

Even though he had not been with a woman during his five years on the island, Oliver's increased skills in strength and accuracy had so far paid off dividends in the bedroom. He knew exactly what spots to hit, and hit his targets with precise accuracy. Thea was no different. He used smooth, steady, and slowly rhythmic licks to target Thea's clitoris and G-spot immediately. He softened his tongue, slowly massaging her clitoral area, knowing not to attack her clitoris immediately. He exorcised his techniques on Thea, to great effect.

"Oh, GOD, Ollie!" she screamed. "You're so fucking good at this!! I love you so much!"

His techniques eventually proved to be too powerful. Thea came, unleashing her juices into his mouth.

"Oh, God, Oliver! I'm cumming! YOU'RE MAKING ME CUM!"

He enjoyed the experience, as her fresh juices ran into his mouth while he pleasured her.

Finally, he removed his face from her and moved upwards to meet her in the eye.

"That was amazing, Thea. I love you so much. But this is where it ends."

"What?" she cooed with disappointment. "Why?"

"We've pleasured each other orally. Sure, it was enjoyable, but it will still wrong. And now, we have to stop. Maybe in the future, we can continue something like this. Just the oral part. But we can't have full intercourse. It would be..."

Thea stopped him mid-sentence with a deep kiss on the lips. Then, she grabbed his shoulders, and slowly maneuvered them towards the bed, so that he would be lying on it, his erection facing upwards.

"Thea?" he questioned. "What are you doing?"

She slowly crawled on top of him as he lay on his back, facing him. Her legs surrounded his, and the opening to her eager pussy was held right about his erect member.

"Thea...wait, no. We can't. Oral was one thing...but this? We can't...we shouldn't...there are so many potential repercussions..."

Thea just smiled as she reached down to grab him. She slapped him against her entrance, rubbing it up and down a bit.

"I love you," she said sweetly, ignoring his protests. Then she decided it was time for the real thing. She slowly lowered herself onto him. His member slowly entered her as she lowered herself and felt the pleasure of him filling her so completely.

Oliver couldn't believe this was happening. His cock was in her. He was having full blown sex with his sister. With his Speedy. And despite his protests, he couldn't quite bring himself to stop it.

"Thea," he said suddenly, "No. No. We can't, we." Her warm wetness felt amazing as it enveloped him. "Thea...no...no...you're my sister...you can't...we can't..."

With his member inside her as she straddled him, Thea began to moan. In response to Oliver's complaints, Thea leaned towards him. She kissed him deeply on the lips, and then replied.

"I don't think you get much choice in the matter."

Oliver's eyes started to roll into the back of his head as his sister's beautiful body continued to bounce up and down on top of him.

"Oh, yes, Ollie. You feel so good. Fuck me, Ollie...I'm all yours..."

As good as it felt, he still felt guilty, and felt the need to exorcise precaution.

"Thea...oh, God, this feels so good. But we need...UGH!" he said as she bounced her delightful body on him. "But we need...a condom. We can't do this raw."

With her big brother's cock buried deep inside of her, Thea looked down upon him and smiled. "No condom necessary, Ollie. Condoms are for...OOH, RIGHT THERE! Um, condoms are for people you aren't sure about. You don't use condoms when you're with someone that you love...OH GOD, YES, OLLIE! RIGHT THERE!"

He supposed she had a point. Still, he felt unsafe.

"Thea, I...OH, FUCK! YES!....umm, I love you and everything...but we should probably be safe...we should..."

Slowly, Thea moved upwards, detaching herself from his member for the time being. Oliver's member slowly felt cold and alone.

Thea took a step back towards him, then looked at Oliver. "Well, then, Oliver, do you think we should use a rubber?"

"Well...yeah, I do. You know, just to be safe."

Thea looked back at Oliver seductively. "Well, too bad. Not a chance, mister. I want to feel you. The real you. All of you. And you don't get a say in the matter."

"I...umm..."

Thea slowly sauntered back towards the bed, then leaned against it. Her pose quite clearly displayed what she wanted. She wanted him to take her from behind.

"Now, come on over here and take me."

He had so many objections in his head. Or at least, he had many objections in the head that was on his shoulders. His "other head" pretty much had the opposite opinion and knew what it wanted.

And right now, his animalistic urges seemed to be winning out. He quickly used his mind to justify what his body wanted. He certainly wasn't taking advantage of her...he had explained himself to her plenty of times. Explained all the consequences, gave her plenty of opportunities to stop, to use precautions...she said no.

She was an adult. She was beautiful. He was crazy for her. She felt amazing. And they both would always love each other.

Time to stop objecting. Enjoy the moment. Deal with the consequences tomorrow.

He moved over towards her delightful body, taking a moment to feel her perky breasts and wonderfully toned figure. Then, he slowly moved his erect member towards her entrance.

"Make love to me, Ollie. Enter me. Take me."

He did. Grabbing both sides of her ass, he guided his cock deep within her entrance, and began to move back and forth.

"Oh, YES! Thank you Ollie! Oh, you feel so good! You're so big! MMM!"

"I...ohh...I love you, Speedy."

He moved himself back and forth inside her wetness as he took her from behind, using his accuracy skills to hit all the right places inside of her as she moaned.

He couldn't believe how unbelievable this felt. An erotic explosion of both pure love and the forbidden.

Thea was getting everything she ever wanted. She almost felt like crying, and probably would if she wasn't being filled with so many waves of pleasure. She had never felt anything like this before. She felt so much love...but was also was supremely turned on the wrongness of it all. She thought it was so immensely hot how they're telling society to get lost, and breaking all of society's rules.

She smiled to herself as he continued to enter her. So far, everything Ollie has said to her has been about the love aspect of it all. She wanted to take a moment to embrace the wicked side of it as well, and figured she would need to give him a kick start in that department.

After awhile, Thea spoke up again.

"Ollie, I...oooh...listen...I have an idea..."

"Oh yeah? And what might that be?"

He disengaged from her, in the process of shifting positions.

"Well...I love you. And I always will. In the most loving and purest possible way. And this is an expression of that love..."

Oliver smiled. "I love you too, Speedy."

She grinned and then looked up at him again. "So...I don't want to take away from the fact that this is a beautiful act of pure, unconditional love. But, still, that being said...well, we're still being really naughty."

He laughed. "Yeah, I guess you could say that.

"Well...Ollie...we both like breaking the rules of society. I can't deny...and I'm sure you can't either...the fact that despite how pure our love is...well, the fact that this is so wrong and forbidden and we're breaking society's rules...well, that really turns me on."

Oliver felt himself twitch and harden. "Obviously someone here agrees with you. So what do you want to do about it?"

"Well," Thea smiled. "I think we should...embrace it. Embrace the taboo and forbidden nature of it all...in order to help add to our own erotic pleasure. Stop talking about the love for a bit, and embrace the naughtiness. A little bit of dirty talk?"

Oliver smiled. "So, what do you suggest?"

This was unbelievable. It was like she had read his thoughts.

He picked her up by the legs and back, and he stood upright and moved against the wall. He pressed her against it, her legs wrapped around him with her back to the wall. He hovered over her entrance as they leaned in to kiss each other.

Thea slowly whispered seductively in his ear.

"I want you to fuck me...big brother."

In the moment, in the pureness of their lovemaking, it was easy to forget their relation and focus on the fact that this is a woman he loved. The mention of him being her 'big brother' caused him to shudder for a moment at the erotic and forbidden implications. Implications that drove him wild with desire.

"I want you to fuck your little sister's eager pussy. Little sis wants big brother's cock so bad."

He moved himself into her with a sudden thrust. She gasped, as he began to fuck her up against the wall. It was a little rougher and less gentle than before.

"This is wrong, Speedy. I'm supposed to protect you...I'm not not supposed to...OOH! I'm not supposed to...take advantage of you....to FUCK you...." It wasn't a real protest, but a continuation of their act.

"Well, too late," she gasped in between moans of pleasure. "You're FUCKING me, big brother. My pussy is all yours for the taking. Fuck me more. Harder!"

His left hand explored her body, slowly caressing her ass as he continued to pump furiously. He couldn't help but moan as she moved her body back and forth on him. Eventually, he moved her back towards the bed, still inside her. He lowered her on to the bed and lay on top of her as her legs locked around him.

"Oh, Ollie...please fuck me...harder!"

"You like big brother's dick?" he asked, continuing their charade.

"Oh, I LOVE big brother's big dick. Fuck me more!"

Thea was so happy he had agreed to embrace the taboo for a little bit. As he continued to move up and down inside of her, she felt her leg start to twitch as it wrapped around him. God, she couldn't believe how good he felt...for the first time ever, she was having sex with a man. It felt a thousand times better than any of the boys she had been with. It wasn't close. He was hitting every spot in her erogenous zones expertly, and soon she felt another orgasm sweeping across her body.

"Ohh...you're making me cum again, Ollie...I'm cumming all over your big cock..."

"That's it, Speedy. Let it all out. Cum for me."

As her orgasm raced over her, he eventually flipped her over so that he was lying on the bed and she was on top of him.

"I want to watch you bounce up and down on my cock while you cum. Let me feel all of it."

He grabbed the sides of her ass as she bounced up and down on him. Her eyes rolled into the back of her head as she moaned.

Waves of pleasure went through her body as she released her fluids onto him. She had never cum before from someone just being inside of her. He couldn't believe his stamina -- anyone else she's ever been with would have been done 20 minutes ago.

After she finished her orgasm, Thea looked down into her brother's loving eyes as her body continued to move up and down on him. She had a question for him. She couldn't help it.

"Ollie, I...OOH! I...have a question for you..."

"Oh yeah?" he said, hands continuing to explore her body.

"Is my pussy...your favorite pussy?"

He shuddered and was caught off guard. A sexual perversion of an innocent childhood question that they had shared in the past. It was wrong, and yet turned him on, also.

Still, he regained control. He held his composure. As she asked the question, he couldn't help but feel the deepest possible love towards her. He pulled her tightly in to himself, at first licking her perky nipples, then moving his way towards her mouth and kissing her deeply as she rode him. Finally, he detached himself, and looked into her eyes as she bounced up and down on his cock.

"Of course, Speedy," he finally answered. "Your pussy is my favorite. It's the best I've ever felt. Always....and forever."

Thea was delighted with his response. Still, she decided to push it one step further. She needed confirmation. "Oh, really?" She paused for a breath, then asked a follow up question. "Even better than Laurel's?"

Oliver smiled as the woman he loved most in the world continued to ride his member in an expression of true love and eroticism. He knew what she wanted to hear. And he was prepared to deliver it.

"Who's Laurel?"

Thea squeed in response, leaning forward to hug her big brother tighter. She furiously kissed him on the lips, on the forehead, and everywhere in between that she could find.

Oliver continued to grab her in a bear hug as she explored his body with kisses. He meant it, too. What he felt with Laurel was nothing compared to this.

Still, he knew it was soon time for it all to end. He was close to finishing.

He announced his intentions. "Thea...I'm about to finish soon. Real soon, in fact. You should probably get off of me...you should let me finish in your mouth, in your hands, whatever you prefer..."

Thea continued to ride him furiously, and gave him a smile. "I know where I want you to finish, big brother."

Thea continued to gyrate her hips as she straddled him. She didn't give a follow-up response to that comment.

Oliver continued to feel closer and closer to the point of release. Slowly, he realized what Thea was implying by her refusal to get off of him.

"Wait," he said suddenly, "Speedy, no. You have to get off me. We've been having fun, but what you're thinking is...OOOH...oh God...well, it's way too far. You have to get off of me...I can't..."

For some reason, he felt powerless. Thea knew what she wanted, and she was determined to get it.

"Ollie, listen, I know it's...OH, GOD! OOOOOH...I....oh, sorry. But, like I said, I know what I want from you...I want you feel you...the REAL you...all of you...and forget whatever society or biology thinks about it."

As she continued to ride him, Oliver thought about the implications of what she was saying. "Speedy? Surely you can't mean...you won't...you couldn't..."

"You know exactly what I mean," she smiled back at him. Once again, she leaned back into his ear seductively.

"I want you inside of me, big brother. I want to feel you. I want to feel all of you...inside me. It's okay, Ollie. I'm on the pill."

Oliver knew it was wrong, but he couldn't hold it any longer. He came. He came as his little Speedy's pussy surrounded him, and he shot load after load inside of her.

"Oh....YES! GIVE IT TO ME! FILL ME UP, BIG BROTHER! I LOVE YOU SO MUCH!"

He continued to fill her up, and her walls were completely filled with incestuous fluids.

This was by far the riskiest part of it, and the one thing he told himself wouldn't happen. But it happened anyway. As he finished unloading, he felt his slowly softening member detach itself from her.

She lay down beside him as they both gasped from their act of forbidden coitus.

Slowly, they turned to face each other. She smiled at him, and kissed him deeply.

The absolute pure waves of pleasure started to fade from Oliver as he considered the consequences of what he had just done.

"Speedy...I can't believe we did that."

He had so many misgivings. It was so wrong...but it felt so pure, so electric. So right.