Buffy's Blackmailing Little Sister Ch. 01

"I'll do it Buffy." Dawn says not wanting to embaresse or humiliate her older sister and yet determined to do so if she has to.

"Why?" Buffy snaps angrily and upset at the same time, "What have I done to make you hate me so much that you would do this?"

"I don't hate you." Dawn says honestly.

"Then why would you do this to me?" Buffy yells.

"I don't want to do this to you but I will if I have to if it saves you from a loveless marriage!" Dawn yells back, before calming herself, "There is a way in which you can stop what I'm threatening to do from happening."

"How?" Buffy asks looking at Dawn on the verge of tears.

"First I want you to tell me how long you and Faith have been together." Dawn says.

Buffy slowly nods her head figuring she has no choice but to tell her younger sister how she and her former lover got together and how they ended.

"Me and Faith's... thing... affair... whatever you want to call it started on the very first night she came to Sunnydale. Right from the start of our... relationship Faith... dominated me and when she turned evil our relationship continued only it became a lot more abusive and kinky. As horrible as it sounds I... I liked it. I loved it. I don't know if it was because it was kinky or what some would consider wrong or if it was because I was in love with Faith... which I was at the time, but whatever the reason I loved what she did to me... how she made me feel." Buffy says hanging her head due to her talking about Faith is bringing back both good and bad memories, "When she went to jail... I was devastated."

"Why didn't you tell anybody?" Dawn asks causing Buffy to lift her head and look at her, "Why didn't you tell me?"

Dawn isn't angry or hurt, just confused as to why her older sister wouldn't tell her due to them having kept all kinds of secrets before. Nothing as big as this at the time but still if Buffy had told her not to tell anybody she would have not told a soul.

"To begin with when me and Faith first started because it was new and because I was afraid you and the others wouldn't accept it. When she turned evil and things got more... abusive I was ashamed. By the time it was finally over I had become an expert at lying to everybody and acting like everything was ok. I thought I had everybody fooled including you." Buffy says honestly.

"What happened when Faith was paroled?" Dawn asks curious to find out why the relationship didn't either continue or start back up again.

"Well." Buffy says swallowing hard due to this part of the story still being a sore spot for her, "When I found out through Giles about Faith's impending release I called her up and invited her back to Sunnydale. When she got back we met in one of the crypts we used to... be together secretly and I told her I wanted her back, but this time things would be different. This time I wouldn't insist we sneak around or hide from you or the others, this time we could be open about our relationship, that I didn't care what she'd done or what we'd been through I just wanted to be with her... I just wanted to be hers... and that's when she told me that we where finished. She told me she had moved on and had found somebody new... somebody better. I asked her who it was but she told me that wasn't important the only thing I needed to know was that we were done and unless the world was ending she wasn't coming back to Sunnydale ever again. She then told me that Angel had offered her a job with him and she was going to take it... that was pretty much the end of the conversation and the last conversation we had until I saw her here at the hotel."

"Didn't you guys talk when we went to LA that time?" Dawn asks.

"We where as civil as two ex-lovers can be. But we didn't really talk not properly at least like you and me are talking now." Buffy answers.

"Cordelia?" Dawn asks.

Buffy looks at Dawn a tad confused by the question.

"The other person Faith had found and was... going to get with when she left prison. Was it Cordelia?" Dawn asks and explains at the same time feeling tempted to ask if it was Cordelia that Faith was basically dumping Buffy for however deciding against it and saying what she had just said instead.

Buffy nods her head looking at Dawn once again on the verge of tears.

"I'm sorry Buffy." Dawn says really meaning what she says and feeling what she says.

"I'm over it." Buffy says doing her best to smile, "She's moved on... and so have I."

Dawn slowly hangs her head able to see from the look in her sister's eyes that she isn't over it and hasn't totally if at all moved on.

"How long after Faith ended your relationship was it that you and Riley got back together for the second time?" Dawn asks having a gut feeling she already knows the answer to this.

"Not long." Buffy says not wanting to say how long exacterly due to her already knowing what Dawn is no doubt thinking and not wanting to confirm her suspicions.

"So was that it? Are we done?" Buffy asks, hoping to change the subject from Faith and Riley back to how she can stop Dawn from humiliating and embarrassing her in front of her friends and Riley and his family by showing them the photos of her and Faith.

Dawn takes a deep breath doing her best to refocus her attention from what she has just heard to the other thing she wants Buffy to do.

"The other thing I want you to do Buffy..." Dawn says taking a deep breath due to her knowing that this is the main thing she wants her sister to do for her, "Is I want you to spend the next week doing whatever I want."

Buffy looks at Dawn in confusion, unable to believe the way this night has turned out from being a simple dress rehearsal to her revealing to her younger sister her relationship with Faith and now having her sister blackmail her.

"What is it that you want me to do?" Buffy asks finally not saying that she will do it but willing to hear what Dawn wants her to do.

"I want the same thing you want Buffy." Dawn says with a smile confident that she is going to get what she wants and what Buffy wants deep down.

Buffy frowns in confusion.

"What are you talking about?" Buffy asks.

"Do you remember January 28th 1998?" Dawn asks back.

Buffy thinks about the date she has just been told and slowly shakes her head even more confused.

"So you don't remember that night moaning 'oh fuck me Dawnie fuck me hard'." Dawn asks impersonating the way Buffy moaned her name that night.

Buffy's eyes go wide wider than they have before as she does remember that night due to Dawn's impersonation of her.

"You remember it now don't you." Dawn says able to see the realisation all over Buffy's face.

Buffy just stares at her younger sister.

"But how..." Buffy begins.

"How do I know about that night?" Dawn says, finishing off Buffy's question for her.

Buffy nods her head.

"Well because to start off with I was in the next room listening to you moaning. I was supposed to be at a sleepover but one of the other girls got sick so we called it off and I came home. Mom was away because of the gallery and I got home before you did. I heard you come in, but by then I was in bed and I didn't let you know I was here until the morning, at which point I pretended I was just coming home. I had too after that night. I mean to begin with I thought you where just... playing with yourself but then I heard the bed springs start to move which told me you weren't playing with yourself somebody was in there with you and I couldn't resist trying to find out who. So I crept out of my bed into the hall and down to your bedroom door which was open a fair bit. Not all the way, but just enough for me to get a good view of what was going on in your bed and who was with you." Dawn says smiling an ear to ear smile at the memory of seeing Faith and Buffy together for the very first time, "I stood there shocked as Faith..."

"Don't say it Dawn." Buffy snaps interrupting her little sister which just makes Dawn smile more.

"As she made you moan I leant against the door which caused it to creak open. You where too lost in your own little world but Faith heard it and looked over and saw me. She then turned her attention to you and told you to moan 'fuck me Dawnie' you refused at first but eventually she... convinced you and that is when you moaned 'oh fuck me Dawnie fuck me hard'." Dawn says.

Buffy breaks down and cries out of shame.

"So you know it wasn't my fault." Buffy pleads looking over at Dawn as the tears roll down her cheeks, "Faith made me do it... she made me pretend she was you... I swear I don't really feel that way about you Dawnie."

Dawn looks at Buffy knowing that what she has just said is a lie.

"Well I feel that way about you." Dawn says causing Buffy to look at her, "And ever since that night I haven't been able to stop thinking about you. I can't stand to see you with Riley and I'm not going to let you marry somebody you don't love and won't give you what you need! Which is why I am doing this."

Buffy simply sits where she is having stopped crying and now simply staring at Dawn not knowing what to think or say or feel right now.

"You asked me what I wanted." Dawn says her eyes locked with Buffy's.

Buffy slowly nods her head.

"This is what I want," Dawn says, "For the next week you're going to do everything I say and you're going to help me fulfil every little sexual fantasy I have ever had about you and by the end of this week I will show you that you shouldn't be with Riley, you should be with me, or at least someone who can actually give you what you really want... what you really need."

Buffy simply sits where she is staring at her little sister her brain having stopped working due to everything that has happened thus far tonight what she has confessed to what she has talked about and what she has heard and seen.

She slowly hangs her head trying to get her brain to start working again so that she can try and figure out what she is going to do, however she is too shocked and confused to figure anything out.

"I need to think this through." Buffy says slowly lifting her head and looking at her sister unable to believe what her sister has just said as well as what she wants, "I need some time Dawn."

"You have until... 7pm tomorrow night." Dawn says tempted to give Buffy 24 hours but if she does it will be after midnight and she won't be able to do what she wants to do with her sister before they get to the good stuff, "If you really want your relationship with Faith to remain a secret come to my hotel room on the floor above at 7pm tomorrow night."

Buffy simply looks at Dawn wanting to believe that she is dreaming or rather having a nightmare and any minute now she is going to wake up and yet at the same time she knows or rather doubts that this is a dream or a nightmare as she slowly nods her head.

Dawn nods her head back and with that she turns and heads for the door stopping once she reaches it and turns to look at Buffy who has her head hung.

"And Buffy." Dawn says with an ear to ear smile on her face.

Buffy lifts her head and turns to face her sister.

"Wear something sexy." Dawn says.

***

Buffy takes a deep breath, feeling nervous about what is going to happen once she knocks on the door in front of her, unable to believe she is actually going to go through with this.

As she continues to stand where she is Buffy thinks about what happened almost 24 hours ago with Dawn and how she has been unable to think about anything else since then. She tried to put it to the back of her mind long enough for her to get to sleep but she just couldn't stop herself from thinking over and over and over again about it. It became an obsession, Buffy practically sleepwalking through the whole day as she desperately tries to think up an explanation for what is happening and how to get out of it.

Amongst the many, many different thoughts throughout her day Buffy considered breaking into Dawn's hotel room, bribing her sister and even using physical force, but Buffy would never hurt her sister, she doubts Dawn would be stupid enough to just have one copy in her room, which at least left her with bribery but there was this nagging feeling in the pit of Buffy's stomach that Dawn didn't want anything else.

Thinking back to what Dawn did and said it was so out of character for her. Dawn wouldn't do this to her, she couldn't do this to her, something has to be making her do it, something has to be manipulating her or there has to be some type of spell, whatever it is there had to be something wrong because there is no way her sweet little sister could actually want to fuck her.

But throughout the night and day a terrifying thought kept circling in Buffy's head... what if Dawn really wants her?

That thought led to other thoughts such as what if there is no spell to break? What if Dawn couldn't be bribed? What if there was nothing wrong with Dawn and this is how she really felt?

But Buffy didn't allow herself to listen because they couldn't be true. Dawn didn't want her. Dawn couldn't want her. She is her sister, and a girl and Dawn is straight so she couldn't possibly want her. Ok, so it has been awhile since Dawn had a boyfriend, but that didn't mean anything. She could have been dating secretly or maybe she is going through an incredibly long dry spell or maybe she's the only girl her age not that interested in boys... who seems to have a lot of girlfriends... friends who are girls... was Dawn gay? No, she would have said something. Buffy isn't the most open person about her sexuality but if it was something this big, Dawn would have said something. And yet, it kind of made sense, and Dawn sort of had just come out to her... but that couldn't have been the real Dawn, or at least not a Dawn who knew what she is doing.

Something or someone has to be doing this to Buffy's little sister, Buffy has to believe that, and as she is unable to think of a way out of this situation all she can do is go along with it and desperately try and find a way out before things go too far.

Unfortunately as Buffy stands in front of her younger sister's hotel room, one floor above her own hotel room, she is unable to 100% convince herself that Dawn doesn't really want this, that she isn't really here because of Dawn, standing here, forced to wear... this.

Buffy looks down at what she is wearing, hoping it is sexy enough for her younger sister and yet as she does so she can't believe she is actually hoping that she looks sexy enough for her own sister.

She raises her head and looks at the hotel room door in front of her once again.

She takes a deep breath as she quickly tries to think of another way of stopping Dawn from revealing to Riley and his family and her friends her and Faith's past without having to go through with what Dawn wants her to do, however she quickly comes to the same conclusion that she has come to all day long and that is that the only way to stop Dawn revealing what she is threatening to reveal is by doing what she wants.

So Buffy slowly raises her hand up and knocks on the hotel room door and after a few minutes of waiting the door opens to reveal her younger sister.

Dawn smiles the moment she see's her sister.

"Hi Buffy." Dawn says her happiness evident from the tone of her voice as well as the expression on her face.

"Hi Dawn." Buffy says trying to smile and yet just not feeling it.

Dawn ignores her older sister's discomfort, looks quickly left and right to make sure they're alone in the corridor and then smiles mischievously before she slowly and obviously looks her sister up and down, her eyes lingering particularly on Buffy's tits as she admires her sister's cute little outfit. It's sexy, but not blatantly so, making it perfect for tonight.

"Very nice." Dawn says, resisting the urge to lick her lips, "Turn around."

Buffy is shocked by this as she looks down either side of the corridor making sure nobody is around as she slowly gives her younger sister a twirl letting her see all of the outfit she has on.

Dawn's smile grows wider as she watches her sister, the mighty vampire slayer, do as her younger sister says, loving having this power over her as she gives Buffy another look up and down as she finishes her twirl. The twirl lasts just long enough for Dawn to check her older sister's cute butt out as she gets the full view of Buffy's outfit, a tight fitting sleeveless and backless dark brown coloured top with tight fitting light brown pants and brown shoes.

"Very, very nice." Dawn says, turning her attention from the outfit to her sister's face and smiles an ear to ear smile at her, "Is my outfit sexy enough?"

Dawn then gives Buffy a twirl to show her what she is wearing.

Buffy looks her sister up and down and can't deny even if she wanted to that what she has on is most defiantly sexy a lot sexier than what she has on as it is more in your face type of sexy as to her reserved type of sexy. Despite Dawn's outfit being in your face sexy it also looks casual so that even if you weren't trying to look sexy you would but then again Buffy is sure that if Dawn didn't want to look sexy she would have worn something else other than the tight fitting dark black leather pants, purple long sleeve top and black leather shoes that she has on right now.

Dawn smiles as she finishes her twirl able to tell from the look on Buffy's face and in her eyes that although she isn't smiling she approves of what she is wearing and pleased that she is for a number of reasons one of them being she picked this outfit out for a reason and that reason is because she wanted to make a statement with how she looks and the statement she is trying to make which she isn't 100% sure she has made is to ensure that Buffy knows this isn't going to be a friendly sister outing it's a real life proper date. However she didn't want the outfit she was going to wear out on her first date with her older sister to look too sexual.

"So?" Dawn asks finally causing Buffy to turn her attention from the outfit to her sister's face, "Do I look sexy?"

Buffy swallows hard.

"You look nice." Buffy says softly.

Dawn smiles figuring Buffy is paying her back for the comment she made about her own outfit earlier.

"So." Dawn says stepping out of her hotel room completely and shutting then locking the door behind herself once she has done that she turns back around to face Buffy, "Shall we go?"

Buffy nods her head and with that the two start walking towards the elevators.

"Where exacterly are we going?" Buffy asks feeling the need to know.

Dawn smiles at her.

"Just down to the hotel restaurant." Dawn says totally at ease.

"But what if..." Buffy starts to blurt out before Dawn cuts her off.

"I've already checked nobody we know is going to be down there. They are either ordering room service going home to eat or going out to eat." Dawn says.

Dawn knew this because she had spent the day first trying to figure out what to wear tonight and 'accidentally' bumping into Riley, Xander and Anya, Willow and Tara, and Faith and Cordelia and 'casually' chatting to them about what their plans for tonight where. Without raising any suspicions Dawn was easily able to find out that nobody was going to be eating down in the hotel restaurant, making it the perfect location for her first date with her sister.

"But what if they change their minds and decide to have dinner in the restaurant downstairs?" Buffy asks thinking quickly.

Dawn smiles.

"Well if they see us they will just think we're having a friendly sisterly dinner together." Dawn says shrugging her shoulders as she answers her sister's question.

Dawn had mainly picked the downstairs restaurant because it isn't super romantic so the setting won't freak her older sister out and most importantly of all as she has just told her sister if any of their group does come into the restaurant they will simply assume they are having a friendly sisterly dinner together.