Buffy's Blackmailing Little Sister Ch. 03

"He won't be able to do it." Buffy says defiantly.

"I just told you he's already doing it." Dawn snaps starting to feel as though she is talking to a brick wall

"No I mean... if what you say where true he won't be able to continue doing it after the wedding I'll be in Sunnydale and he'll be off in some dark jungle hunting Big Bad's." Buffy says doing her best to convince her sister that she is wrong in what she says.

Dawn sniggers at Buffy's logic.

"I just told you he's changing you bit by bit. Whenever he get's the chance to visit he'll continue to change you subtly so subtly you won't even realise it until it is too late by the time he leaves the army he'll have you exacterly how he wants you." Dawn says really believing what she is telling her older sibling.

Buffy looks at her sister unable to believe what she is hearing or what her sister is saying and yet she can tell from the tone of her voice and the look in her eyes that Dawn really does believe what she is saying and she really does feel it.

Dawn watches as Buffy once again hang her head causing Dawn to swallow hard due to her really not wanting to hurt her older sister and yet willing to do whatever it takes to make her see and realise the truth.

However right now she can tell that Buffy doesn't need to hear any more of the truth in point of fact she needs a distraction which causes Dawn to smile due to her having the perfect distraction as she does her best to hide her smile.

"I took a look at the video camera." Dawn says immediately getting Buffy's attention as she slowly lifts her head and looks at Dawn, "There was nothing on it."

Buffy swallows hard knowing where this is going.

"No footage of you doing what I had told you to do last night." Dawn continues on, "I thought we had an understanding that if you didn't do what I told you to do there would be serious consequences."

Buffy looks at Dawn terrified as to what those consequences are going to be.

"Dawn." Buffy says in a whisper, "Please."

"I'm sorry Buffy." Dawn says, "You give me no choice."

And with that Dawn turns and heads for the door.

"No wait!" Buffy snaps getting up and getting in between Dawn and the door to the bathroom, "Ok I admit it I couldn't record myself playing with myself or my ass like you told me."

"Did you play with yourself and your ass despite not filming it?" Dawn asks her already knowing the answer.

"No." Buffy says honestly, "But you can punish me another way. Please don't tell Riley about me and Faith."

Dawn smiles at Buffy as she takes a step back from both her sister and the door.

"I'm not going too." Dawn says causing Buffy to frown in confusion due to her having been sure that that was what Dawn had intended to do, "That would be too merciful, too quick, and it wouldn't really be a fitting punishment."

Buffy does her best to not show her relief even though she is relived she is also a tad worried as to what Dawn is going to have her do or how she is going to punish her instead of telling everybody her secret.

"However that doesn't mean I won't still tell them unless." Dawn says intentionally pausing.

"Unless what?" Buffy asks swallowing hard.

"Unless you agree that I can punish you later tonight when we get back to the hotel. I can come to your hotel room and punish you however I see fit." Dawn tells her.

Buffy swallows hard having hoped she could convince her younger sibling to punish her in a different way to telling Riley and the others her secret however hearing her sister say 'however I see fit' makes her nervous which she is sure is Dawn's intention.

"So do you agree to my terms or am I going to have to go downstairs and-" Dawn says.

"I agree." Buffy says interrupting Dawn before she can finish her sentence.

Dawn smiles an ear to ear smile again.

"I knew you'd see it my way... eventually." Dawn says as she begins to undo her pants.

"Wait Dawn... what are you doing?" Buffy asks nervously.

"Relax, I'm just getting something to help me with your punishment." Dawn says as she reaches into her pants, rummages around and pulls something out, "There... have you ever seen one of these before?"

"W... what are you doing caring around that?" Buffy asks in surprise.

"Well, I don't make a habit of it. I thought of this just as I was leaving and figured I'd get you alone at some point so I could teach you a lesson, which is exactly what this little thing is going to help me do." Dawn says, "Now, answer the question."

There's a pause and then Buffy admits, "Faith kept a couple in a box along with some other things but she said... they were a waste of time for me."

"Good girl." Dawn says with a smile, "Do you know what it's called?"

There's the briefest of pauses and then Buffy says, "Dawn, please... I can't..."

"You can and you will." Dawn snaps at her, before adding in a much softer tone, "Because you know what will happen if you don't. Now, what is this called?"

Buffy closes her eyes briefly, gulps and then replies, "It's called a butt plug."

"That's right, that's exactly what it's called." Dawn says, smiling widely, "And where do you think it goes? More to the point, where do you think it's going?"

Buffy blushes bright red and then in a voice barely above a whisper answers, "Up my butt."

"Right again." Dawn says, her smile becoming even wider, "Now, bend over the sink and stick your ass out."

Dawn feels a sudden urge to lick her lips as her big sister obeys her command, presenting her ass like a good little slave in training to her owner, who almost reaches out to touch what's on offer until a wicked thought crosses her mind.

"I just thought of something." Dawn announces, "I was going to just pull your skirt up and your panties down and have some fun with your hot ass... but I think it would be more fun if you were completely naked so why don't you strip for me first and then bend back over the sink."

This time Dawn does lick her lips as her older sister quickly strips in front of her and gets back in position, Buffy is obviously in a hurry to get this over with, not that Dawn can blame her considering Riley, his family and their friends are all still waiting for them downstairs.

Once her sibling is naked and bent over the sink Dawn licks her lips again as her eyes focus on Buffy's tight ass, the slayer gasps softly as Dawn reaches out to give her butt a firm squeeze followed by a shameless groping it.

After putting the plug down on the sink next to one of Buffy's hands Dawn grabs a second handful of her sister's rear and starts shamelessly groping it like she was a butcher testing out just how succulent a fresh piece of meat was. In that analogy Buffy's ass is a grade A cut of the finest pieces of ass meat Dawn has ever had the pleasure of sampling and she can't wait to savour every moment of enjoying it.

"Has anyone ever told you you have a great butt?" Dawn asks lustfully after a couple of minutes of greedy butt fondling.

"Yes." Buffy replies quietly.

"Well they were all selling your butt short, it's so beyond great, it's perfect." Dawn says, completely lost in her lust, "I used to spend hours stealing glances at it, staring at it, imagined fucking it and now it's mine, all mine."

Dawn knows she's far from objective considering she's spent all of her life lusting after her but Dawn truly means everything she just said. To her Buffy's ass is perfect, which is why she finds it understandable to spend several more minutes just enjoying filling up those tight cheeks she has fantasized about for so long, but she can tell from Buffy's whimperings that her big sister is feeling a little uncomfortable so to make sure she doesn't have an unnecessary freak out again Dawn decides to move on with her little plan.

"I used to lie awake at night wondering if you were still an anal virgin." Dawn admits softly into Buffy's ear, "It was stupid. I knew it was, but I liked to dream you still were because taking your anal virgin was pretty much my ultimate fantasy. To be the first to fuck you there, in such an intimate and forbidden place, mmmmmm, oh I came so hard every time I mentioned popping your anal cherry. In my dreams I did it in so many different way, but in my absolute favourite you would come into my room carrying a strap on, confess you were crazy about me and wanted to be mine, and then you would hand me the dildo, strip naked, get on all fours on my bed and then spread your ass cheeks wide and beg me to take your anal cherry so you could be my bitch forever."

Dawn pauses to let it sink in for a second.

"Stupid right? Yeah, it was stupid. It was stupid to think Faith wouldn't have been gaping your hot little ass the first chance she got. Hell, it was hard to believe that she wouldn't have been balls deep in your butt, but for some stupid reason I kept convincing myself you still had your back door cherry just waiting for me to take it. That was until I saw those picture of you taking Faith's big strap on up your butt like a giant anal whore or that one picture of your gaping ass hole showing off your insides like Faith had been ass fucking you with a truck." Dawn says in a weird mix of jealousy and lust, "I hated Faith more than I hated anyone when I first saw those pictures. It wasn't enough she had to be your first lesbian experience she had to take your anal cherry as well. That should have been mine. You should have been mine."

Dawn sighs, letting her pent-up anger and jealousy wash away from her, at least for the moment.

"For a while I even blamed you for not saving yourself for me, for not at the very least keeping some shred of your uptight nature by refusing to let Faith ass fuck you but then I realise it was my fault. I should have made a move on you years ago, claimed you and your ass hole long before Faith got the chance to turn it into her cock depository. Besides, it would have been a crime to let you go this long without getting your tight little ass thoroughly fucked so really I should be grateful to Faith for giving this ass what it so obviously needs and stretching you out to get nice and ready to become my little anal whore." Dawn nips at Buffy's neck, squeezing a half whimper, half moan out of her sister, "It's isn't like I could stay mad at you or Faith for long, especially not after frantically masturbating to those pictures, but now we're going to do a little rewriting of history and pretend, just for now, that you still have you back door cherry intact and waiting for me to take it."

Only letting go of one of Buffy's butt cheeks Dawn quickly brings her free hand up to her mouth and suck on one of the fingers before putting it directly in front of her sister's face.

"You see this? This isn't my finger, it's my strap on. It's that big strap on dildo you saw back in my room, and in just one moment I'm going to use it to pop your anal cherry, but first you're going to reach back, spread your ass cheeks and beg your little sister to fuck you up the butt for the very first time." Dawn says, obviously more excited than she's ever been before in her life.

Buffy's face first goes white and then red as she is filled with horror and embarrassment about what she must do and for a few seconds she just stays where she is but just before Dawn is about to warn her about disobeying her the slayer slowly pressed her face against the cold glass of the mirror in front of her, reaches back with both hands and spreads her ass wide-open, exposing her 'virgin' back hole.

"Good." Dawn says, practically drooling at the sight before her as she presses her saliva covered finger against her older sister's vulnerable little butt hole, "Now beg. I want to hear my big sister beg me, her little sister, to take her anal cherry."

Buffy closes her eyes, gulps and mumbles, "Plea... please Dawnie... fuc... fuck my ass..."

"Your virgin ass." Dawn corrects.

"My virgin ass... fuck my virgin ass... take... take my anal cherry..." Buffy whispers.

"Say it like you mean it." Dawn orders.

"Please Dawn... fuck me, fuck my virgin ass. Fuck your big sister's virgin ass." Buffy says, trying to be quiet but also trying to sound like she means it, and succeeding more than she would have liked, "Your big sister wants to be your bitch Dawnie. Butt fuck your big sister and make her your bitch. It's... it's what you've always wanted... what we've both always wanted, so please Dawnie, make me your bitch. Fuck me up the ass and turn me into your bitch. Push your big strap on cock through my tight little virgin ass hole and take my anal virginity. Pop your big sister's back door cherry Dawnie. Take my anal cherry and... oh... Dawnie..."

Buffy's begging slowly trails off into gentle whimpers as she feels the pressure against her little puckered rosebud increase until her ass hole slowly begins to open up for her little sister's finger.

During the begging Dawn had closed her eyes and imagined herself in her favourite dream scenario, her big sister face down and ass up on her bed, spreading her butt cheeks and begging for her as Dawn knelt behind her, a nice big strap on pressed against her older sister's 'virgin' butt hole.

Part of Dawn remains in the fantasy for what comes next, but she opens her eyes and tries to stay mostly in reality, not wanting to miss a moment of what is about to happen, which is something she has dreamed about for so long and is going to be such a special moment that she wants to treasure it for the rest of her life... the first time she enters her big sister's ass hole.

There will be many, many more times, Dawn will make absolutely sure of that, but she knows this moment will always be special. And it will.

Buffy gasps and then whimpers as her baby sister violates her back hole, while at the same time Dawn gasps, moans and then shoves her finger as deep into her big sister's butt as it can go, causing both sisters to gasp and whimper/moan again.

"Oh. My. God." Dawn groans lustfully into Buffy's ear, "Your so... so tight. How the hell are you this tight? I've fingered the asses of 16 year old virgin girls who never even kissed anyone before and they weren't even this tight. Seriously, how is your ass this tight? Especially after all those nasty things Faith did to it?"

Not for the first time this week, or the first time since she stepped into the bathroom, Buffy wishes she could literally die from embarrassment just to end her humiliation, but it doesn't seem the world is that merciful and, believing that Dawn will force the truth out of her anyway she tells her little sister one of her most embarrassing secrets.

"My... my slayer heeling..." Buffy says, tears of humiliation beginning to flow, "It... it heals me... back there..."

More tears flow from Buffy's eyes, which she wishes she hadn't opened again, as she sees Dawn's mouth hung open for a few seconds before her eyes seem to burn with pure lust.

"You mean... you mean your slayer heeling heals your ass hole? As in it makes your ass hole as good as new? Like virgin tight?" Dawn asks in disbelief.

Buffy's soft whimper as a response sounds deafening under the circumstances.

For a few seconds Dawn just stares at Buffy with her mouth slightly open and then Dawn briefly opens and closes her eyes, a lot of pure joy crossing her face as if she's just had an orgasm.

"Oh... oh my... you're... you're so beyond perfect..." Dawn says, struggling to find the right words to convey what she's feeling, "I mean, I've dreamed of making you mine for so long, and in all my dreams you've been perfect, but... wow..."

As her baby sister salivates over this news Buffy whimpers, not just from what Dawn is saying but from the feelings of her little sister's finger beginning to slowly slid in and out of her rectum, the mighty vampire slayer struggling to keep the pleasure from her voice as her neglected back door was pleasured for the first time in what feels like forever.

It had been so, so long... not that Buffy had missed it, or that she was enjoying it now... she is only moaning because her clit was bashing against the basin, not because she has something in her butt again, and especially not because the thing just happens to be her little sister's finger.

"I love butt fucking... I've always loved butt fucking." Dawn says, waking Buffy from her thoughts before she done quickly adds, "Giving, not receiving. I love fucking butt. And I'm good at it too. You can just ask all the blonde girls I've ass fucked, while imagining they were you are of course. All of them said I was made for butt fucking, as in I was made to fuck butt. And you, you were clearly made for butt fucking too. Differences is I was clearly made to fuck butt, you were clearly made to take it in your butt. You were clearly made to take a nice big fat dick up your butt every single moment you are not slaying... and hey, wouldn't it be funny if that was supposed to be your other job? You could be Buffy the vampire slayer by night, and Buffy the insatiable anal whore by day. Hell, you wanted to settle down right, so why don't you quit being the slayer so you can concentrate on your true calling in life, getting fucked up the ass like the insatiable anal whore you are!"

At this point Buffy has her mouth pressed against her right hand which is in turn pressed against the glass of the mirror, the humiliated slayer desperately tries to keep her whimpers and moans quiet as her own sister whispers such filth into her ears while frantically pounds her ass with her finger.

With what seems like every passing moment Dawn's finger has been moving faster through Buffy's bowels, it somehow becoming even worse when Dawn starts randomly twirling and curling her finger around inside Buffy's back passage, and when a second finger is added a tear rundown Buffy's cheek as she can no longer deny she is enjoying being anally finger fucked by her baby sister, which is sadly only the latest in a long line prevented and humiliating facts the blonde slayer has had to acknowledge so far this week.

"Are you on imagining it anal whore? Are you imagining your little sister's strap on dick pounding your ass?" Dawn asks as she starts finger fucking her sister's ass even harder, "Remember? It's my favourite fantasy. Me taking your anal cherry... and that's exactly what I've done. You came in here, into my bedroom, told me you loved me in more than just a sisterly way and you wanted to be my bitch, so you handed me a strap on, bent over, spread your ass cheeks and begged me to take your anal cherry, then I did it, strapping on the fake dick and slowly pushing it into your ass, taking your anal cherry and making you mine forever. And now I'm butt fucking you, my own sister. I started slow, stretched my sister's shit pipe for a bit, making you nice and loose so that I can give you a nice rough butt pounding, which is exactly what I'm doing now. I'm pounding your butt, pounding my big sister's butt with my strap on cock, making her my bitch, making you my bitch!"

For a few moments after she's done talking Dawn finds herself completely lost in her fantasy world in which she is butt fucking her older sister, the only difference between this time and all those other times is that now she is really butt fucking her older sister, only with her fingers which she thinks to herself sadly as she slowly comes out of her fantasy world just isn't as much fun as if she was butt fucking her big sister with her strap on, it doesn't even feel like a real butt fucking to her considering she can't go as hard or as deep into Buffy's ass like she has always dreamed, but the sensations of feeling her sister's super vicelike grip on her fingers almost makes up for that fact. Still, Dawn finds herself longing for the moment in which she will make her fantasies a reality as she stuffs a strap on deep into her sister's ass, a moment Dawn promise herself won't be far off.