Buffy's Blackmailing Little Sister Ch. 05

Buffy whimpers and slowly turns her attention back down to Dawn's pussy.

Dawn closes her eyes able to feel herself ready to cum and she allows herself to focus her attention on the pleasure as her first orgasm of the day hits.

Buffy's eyes bulge in shock as she feels Dawn's cunt clamp down around her three fingers like nothing she has ever felt before and she feels her little sister start to cum hard all over her fingers which despite shocking her inside it also makes her happy to know she has been able to make her little sister cum. Buffy slowly turns her attention from Dawn's pussy to her face and as she does so she see's Dawn has her eyes closed and is focusing on the orgasm she is evidently in the throws of which only makes Buffy feel even prouder of herself although she is doing her best to deny that she feels this as she feels Dawn's pussy slowly releases her fingers from it's vice like death grip and she slowly removes them from her sister's pussy completely. Dawn slowly opens her eyes to see her older sister looking at her pussy in shock and disbelief.

"Clean your fingers Buffy." Dawn says causing Buffy to lift her head and look at her. Buffy seems hesitant so Dawn repeats herself, this time more firmly, "Clean them."

Buffy looks at Dawn feeling tempted to refuse her command and yet knowing what will happen if she does and so she slowly raises her right hand up to her mouth and starting with her first finger starts to clean each finger that was just in her little sisters pussy with her mouth.

Dawn moans as she watches Buffy suck her cum off of each of her three fingers.

"I bet my cum tastes good." Dawn says watching Buffy for any sign that she is enjoying the taste of her little sister's pussy juice.

Once Buffy has finished licking her fingers clean doing her best to hide any sign that she is enjoying the taste of her little sister's pussy juice she slowly lowers her hand back down to her side and looks down at Dawn waiting to see what she wants them to do next.

"Why don't you lay back down here?" Dawn asks patting the side of the bed next to her that Buffy was laying down on a short time a go.

Buffy slowly does as Dawn tells her while Dawn climbs off of the bed grabbing her strap on as she does so. While keeping her back to Buffy she puts the strap on back on herself having feeling tempted to make Buffy put the strap on back on her however deciding to leave that for another time. Once the strap on is securely back in place Dawn slowly turns around and looks at Buffy who is once again laying down where she was on her back looking over at her.

"Ready for me to butt fuck you again?" Dawn asks looking at Buffy with an ear to ear smile.

Buffy nods her head doing her best to hide her excitement at having her little sister butt fuck her again.

"I can't hear you." Dawn snaps.

"Yes Dawn." Buffy says a small part of her still hating her little sister for forcing her to verbally answer questions like this.

"Yes what?" Dawn asks determined to break Buffy of her embarrassment at verbally answering her.

"Yes, I'm ready for you to butt fuck me." Buffy says despite being angry at her younger sibling she can't help but also like the fact that she is being forced to verbally respond.

Buffy watches as Dawn climbs back onto the bed.

"Roll over and get on your hands and knees." Dawn orders, looking at Buffy with a grin, "I loved fucking your ass in that position last night, but I want you bent over in front of me so I can spank your ass while I'm fucking it."

Buffy blushes as she slowly rolls over onto her stomach and get's up onto all fours, doing her best to mentally deny the fact that she is actually looking forward to getting butt fucked by her baby sister. Because she is to busy focusing on this denial Buffy doesn't see Dawn move from the side of her to behind her until she is able to feel Dawn's hands on both of her buttocks.

"That slayer healing is absolutely amazing." Dawn says looking at Buffy's ass as she runs her hands up and down and all over her sister's ass cheeks which doesn't have any signs of what it went through the night before. Then Dawn spread the cheeks wider, her mouth falling open as her eyes finally focused on Buffy's completely healed ass hole, "Oh my God... I can't believe it. Your ass hole... it looks virgin again."

Dawn immediately thrust a finger into her big sister's butt hole, crying out in pure joy as Buffy yelped in surprise.

"Definitely virgin." Dawn says lustfully as she gently fingers her sister's ass, "And now, it's all mine. All mine. God, I'm so glad I now own my big sister's butt. It really would have been such a waste if I hadn't butt fucked my big sister into giving me ownership of her hot slayer ass."

Buffy blushes and does her best to try and keep her focus on the headboard in front of her as well as the wall behind it and ignore what Dawn is saying as well as how much she is enjoying feeling her sister's fingers sliding in and out of her ass. Unfortunately for Buffy her little sister knows a lot about fingering ass hole and remembers exactly what to do with Buffy's butt, the slayer fighting back the urge to moan for as long as she could but inevitably a soft one escaped her lips which was quickly joined by others as Dawn's finger continued pumping in and out of her pooper.

"Does my big sister like the feel of my finger stretching out her hot slayer ass?" Dawn asks.

Buffy doesn't answer.

"It certainly sounds like you do." Dawn says, "I bet you can't wait for me to fuck your hot slayer ass can you? I bet you can't wait for me to slide my big cock into your hot slayer ass, fuck it hard and deep, make you cum like the little anal slut you are. Well... you're going to have to wait a little longer for it."

Buffy whines in disappointment as Dawn slowly slides her finger out of her ass, the slayer then blushing at her initial reaction.

"First, it's time for your spanking." Dawn says with an ear to ear smile on her face.

Buffy looks at Dawn hating the fact that she has to be spanked every day by her little sister until their time together is up and yet knowing that she can't argue with Dawn. So rather than try and argue with her baby sister Buffy simply lowers her head and raises her ass, presenting it to her little sister for her spanking.

Dawn is surprised by Buffy's response to what she has just told her however she can't help but smile due to this letting her know that even though Buffy may not be enjoying what they are doing together at least not yet she has accepted Dawn's rule over her at least for this week. Now all she has to do is make Buffy enjoy it and try and get Buffy to want her rule to last a lot longer than just this week.

Buffy knows what's coming Dawn smiles as she looks down at Buffy's well rounded behind and she runs her hand over both cheeks gently loving the feel of them underneath her hand.

Buffy closes her eyes doing her best not to let Dawn's gentle touch fool her due to the fact she is sure that any minute now Dawn is going to start to give her a really hard spanking just like she did last night and she does her best to mentally and physically prepare herself for what she is sure is about to come. Despite being a little bit nervous Buffy can't help but also be turned on and want to get spanked by Dawn and the longer she wait's the more Buffy's desire to have Dawn spank her outweighs her nervousness.

Dawn suddenly removes her hand from Buffy's ass causing Buffy to think that the spanking is about to begin and so she does her best to really make sure she is both mentally and physically ready.

"Because you have been a good girl and done everything I have asked you without question or argument this morning's spanking is going to be nice and gentle." Dawn tells her older sister, "However I want you to know if from this point on you ever question or argue with me or do something I don't like or didn't tell you to do then your spanking will be just like it was last night or worse."

Although she can hear sincerity in Dawn's voice Buffy does her best not to allow herself to be lulled into a false sense of security by it. Despite mentally and physically preparing herself for a hard spanking much to her surprise the first hit from Dawn's hand isn't hard at all in fact it is very gentle and almost playful as is the second one and the third and the fourth and the fifth. With each strike that Dawn gives her Buffy can't help but slowly start to relax and enjoy the 'spanking'.

"Good girls should get soft spankings. Bad girls should get hard spankings." Dawn says as she continues to gently tap Buffy's ass, "Don't you agree Buffy?"

When Buffy doesn't answer right away Dawn gives her big sister a hard slap on the butt in order to get an answer out of her and not have her nod or shake her head.

"Yes." Buffy snaps in response to the hard slap she has just received.

"Yes what?" Dawn asks as she starts to give Buffy's ass a gentle slap and then a hard slap.

"I agree with what you said." Buffy says doing her best to hide the fact that she is actually starting to like Dawn's technique.

"Which is?" Dawn asks her.

"Good girls should get soft spankings." Buffy says unable to believe her little sister is actually making her say this, "Bad girls should get hard spankings."

"So if your good you'll get what?" Dawn asks.

"A soft spanking." Buffy responds.

"And if you're bad you'll get." Dawn says leaving the question in the air for Buffy to answer.

"A hard spanking." Buffy says.

"That's right." Dawn says having never liked or seen the point in hurting a lover in anyway shape or form unless in the case of a spanking they deserved it.

Of course Dawn loves giving her lovers a spanking, she just likes the light gentle type of spanking she is currently giving Buffy and will continue to give Buffy these sorts of spankings unless Buffy gives her a good reason to give her a hard spanking like she did last night.

That is another thing Dawn has never understood why some people will use or try and find any excuse to beat a person's backside until its black and blue to Dawn it seems very counter-productive to slave training or laying the foundation of a Dom/Sub relationship. As far as Dawn is concerned when a slave had been good that slave should be treated well. If the slave misbehaves then you spanked her really hard. This way you are showing the slave her behaviour is unacceptable. This gives the slave the motivation they need to be good. Finding any excuse to brutally bruise a slave's ass just undermines spanking as a punishment as well as the mistress/slave relationship.

Having said that however Dawn does like to cause a little bit of pain on occasion and Buffy's ass has certainly proven it can handle a beating not to mention the fact that Buffy has the type of butt that was made to be spanked. It's round and fleshy not fat but big enough so that when Dawn hits it Buffy's ass cheeks ripple a little for about a second or two, as if someone has just thrown a stone into a pond.

It's almost hypnotic and very, very hot. Not to mention the fact that Buffy's soft yet firm cheeks are making a lot of noise and Dawn notices the harder and harder she spanks Buffy the louder and louder the smacking sound get's. And Dawn can't deny Buffy's ass looks just as good pink which is the colour it's starting to turn as it does it's normal colour.

As Dawn's strikes are slowly starting to get harder and harder Buffy is finding it increasingly difficult to stop herself from crying out. Not in pain, she has been doing that for quite awhile, but in pleasure.

It has always deeply shamed her but getting spanked turns Buffy on, and Dawn's firm and confident strikes really get Buffy's submissive juices flowing even more than they were before.

Of course as an humiliating turn on as being on all fours receiving a spanking from her little sister is it's made worse from the fact that Buffy knows that as soon as the spanking stops her ass hole will be taking a large strap on inside it, Dawn seemingly determined to butt fuck her again, and even though Buffy knows it's wrong she wants it. She wants to be butt fucked by her baby sister again. To be Dawn's anal slut. To be an anal slut and take it up the butt again like Buffy has secretly wanted to ever since Faith had last taken her tushy.

The fact only increases Buffy's desire to cry out in pleasure, however despite this the Slayer manages to retain her focus on not doing so, even though there is a big part of Buffy that desperately wants to give in as well as wanting Dawn to really lay into her just like she did last night.

Dawn continues to spank Buffy making sure she hits her hard enough that when her hand comes into contact with her ass it makes a really loud sound but not so hard that it really hurts Buffy however as soon as she see's Buffy's ass start to turn red Dawn iminidiatly stops.

"Ok that's enough." Dawn says as she starts to run her hands all over Buffy's backside in an attempt to try and cool her ass cheeks down and make her backside go back to its regular colour again.

Buffy lays where she is loving the feel of her little sister's hands on her ass and able to feel her ass cheeks starting to cool down.

After massaging Buffy's ass with the palm of her hands for quite a while Dawn begins groping her big sister's butt cheeks more firmly before spreading them part to spit on the Slayer's extremely fuck-able looking ass hole. She then quickly pushes her finger inside, Dawn licking her lips at the tightness of Buffy's back passage clamping down on her finger as she slid in and out of her, her older sibling unable to stop herself from moaning as Dawn stretches out her shit hole for the much bigger object to come.

"You ready Buffy?" Dawn asks lustfully as she continues to stretch out Buffy's ass until she is happy that she has loosened her big sister's ass enough. When she has she slowly slides her finger out of Buffy's ass, "You ready for your butt fucking? My cock is ready and so is your ass. Are you ready for me to fuck you just like I did last night? Ready for me to fuck your hot slayer ass with my big cock?"

Buffy doesn't respond due to the fact she is too busy trying to mentally and physically prepare herself for what she is about to experience.

Dawn simply smiles knowing that while Buffy maybe acting as defiant as their first night together deep down she really isn't feeling as defiant as she was their first night and that bit by bit she is slowly breaking her sister and if she hasn't completely broken her yet she will have by the time their time together is up of that she is sure. Dawn then refocus's her attention on her older sibling's ass taking a deep breath as she positions her fake cock at the entrance to Buffy's ass feeling just as excited as she did when she first fucked Buffy's ass the day before as she slowly starts to push the head of her cock into her big sister's ass again.

Once the head is inside Buffy's ass Dawn waits to let Buffy's ass get used to the feeling of having it there again.

"You ok Buffy?" Dawn asks.

Buffy slowly nods her head doing her best to deny the fact that she is actually enjoying the feel of Dawn's strap on back inside of her as she feels Dawn slowly push a little bit more of it into her ass and stops again so that she can get used to the amount she already has in her ass. Despite Buffy is grateful to her sister for doing she can't help but also hate due to there being a big part of her that wants her little sister to fuck her the way she did last night.

"How does it feel Buffy?" Dawn asks as she slowly pushes more of her fake cock into Buffy's ass, "How does it feel having my cock up your ass?"

"Good." Buffy whimpers after a hard slap on her behind tells her she had to answer, and answer correctly.

"Do you want more?" Dawn asks.

"Yes, I want all of it." Buffy says, not wanting to have to constantly beg Dawn for more.

Dawn decides to see if her big sister is telling the truth and so with one powerful thrust she forces the rest of the strap on inside of her big sister's ass.

"I'm all the way inside you now Buffy." Dawn says, impressed with Buffy's ability to take the whole thing in in such a quickly space of time.

Buffy whimpers in responds.

"Ready for me to fuck your ass now?" Dawn asks.

Buffy nods her head.

"That's not a good enough answer Buffy." Dawn says in her own way letting Buffy know what type of answer she is looking for.

"Yes Dawn..." Buffy says, "I'm ready for you to fuck my ass."

With that Buffy feels Dawn's hands take a hold of her hips, the younger sibling slowly starting to slide her fake cock all the way out of the older sibling's ass until Buffy can only feel the head remains and then the fake cock starts to move back in, going in and out of her butt, causing the slayer to whimper in a little pain but mostly pleasure, Buffy hating herself for loving the feel of Dawn's cock inside of her again and yet unable to stop herself.

Buffy's whimpers of pain and pleasure slowly turn to moans of pure pleasure as her virgin tight ass adjusts to stretching obscenely wide for that big fake dick, the hole the slayer pooped from becoming an orifice for her little sister's pleasure.

Dawn certainly seemed to be enjoying Buffy's poop hole, slamming her strap on into the deepest depths of her big sister's bowels with thrusts which gradually increased in speed and ferocity shortly after Buffy started obviously moaning in pleasure, the action of course making Buffy moan even louder.

The Slayer blushed shamefully, wishing she could control herself, but the feelings raging through her were just too amazing. Besides, what was the point? She was getting her ass fucked whether she pretended she didn't enjoy it for as long as she could or simply relax and surrender her ass to her little sister and that big dildo, so why fight it?

Of course, Buffy's ass was no longer hers to give away. Her ass was Dawn's now. Her little sister owned her ass. Last night Buffy the Vampire Slayer, the chosen one, the supernatural warrior who had defeated all kinds of evil, had surrendered her ass to her little sister, had given her ownership of it, and in the process she, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, the chosen one, the supernatural warrior who had defeated all kinds of evil, had forever become her little sister's anal slut.

Buffy trembles with a mixture of shame and lust, not just from the thought of what had happened to her but because the little stud that she called her baby sister is beginning to give her the same type of butt pounding that had made Buffy surrender her ass last night, and despite any apprehension she may have Buffy can't deny she is loving every minute of it.

As she continues to slowly fuck her big sister's butt Dawn can't get over how tight it is again loving the fact that it is due to the fact that she now knows no matter how bad she fucks Buffy's ass each time she does it will be just as tight as the first time she did it.

Buffy's moans Dawn can tell are no longer strained or trying to be restrained they are now sounds of pure pleasure not only that but Dawn can feel Buffy has started to thrust her ass back against the strap on.

Taking this as a sign Dawn starts to really give Buffy an ass fucking as she takes a firm hold of her sister the Slayer's hips and starts to increase the pace of the ass fucking going deeper and harder with each and every stroke.

Both girls become completely and totally lost in the ass fucking she is giving/receiving.

Despite knowing that it is actually happening and that she is actually fucking her older sister's ass for the second time Dawn still finds it hard to believe having always known that if she ever got the chance to butt fuck Buffy it would be fantastic but she honestly didn't think it could be this good.