Buffy's Blackmailing Little Sister Ch. 06

"Willow is my best friend." Buffy says wondering if maybe it is because she and the red head Wicca are so close that she has never seen her in that way, "And that is all I have ever seen her as... but Tara... in the beginning I didn't know her all of that well. And obviously I didn't know she was... into women."

"You mean a lesbian!" Dawn snaps causing Willow, Tara and Buffy to turn and look at her.

"Yes." Buffy says having had a feeling Dawn wouldn't let her get away with not saying the word.

"Well then say it!" Dawn snaps again hating her sister's refusal to say/use the word.

"I didn't know she was a lesbian." Buffy says turning her attention from Dawn back to Tara feeling a tad angry at her sister for insisting she use the word 'lesbian' all of the time and yet at the same time not liking or understanding why she is so against saying the word. "And I didn't know that she and Willow were together. And besides... I had Faith... and because of all of those things. I didn't see it as a bad thing for me to be attracted to her."

"You mean you didn't feel as guilty being attracted to Tara as you would have done had you been attracted to Willow?" Dawn asks looking at her sister, not buying her reasons or explanation for her attraction to Tara at all. In point of fact hearing Buffy's explanation for being attracted to Tara only confirm and reinforce her theory as to the real reason why Buffy was attracted to her best friend's girlfriend.

Buffy nods her head in answer to Dawn's question.

Dawn smiles a small smile as she remembers what Buffy had said earlier when Willow asked her if she was a lesbian.

"But I thought what you and Faith did together was just... what was the word you used... experimentation." Dawn says, looking at her big sister to see how she reacts to this. Buffy turns her head and looks at her little sister who's smile turns from a small smile into an ear to ear smile as she looks back at her, "Are you saying you wanted to... experiment with Tara?"

Buffy looks or rather stares at her little sister slowly turning her head away not looking at her or Willow or Tara but letting all three of them know the answer to Dawn's question by her actions.

Dawn turns her attention from Buffy to Tara.

"Tell me something Tara when you thought about being with Buffy." Dawn says causing Tara to turn her attention from Buffy to her, "How did you imagine it happening?"

Tara looks back at Dawn a tad surprised by this question due to the fact that the brunette now knows for sure that she is a Dom and since Buffy is a Sub she would have thought that was obvious.

"Well... being a top... I used to imagine myself... fucking Buffy." Tara says turning to look at Willow who looks back at her with a look of shock on her face.

"What else?" Dawn asks knowing or rather confident that that is not the only thing Tara imagined doing to her older sister, "What exactly do you think of when you fantasise about fucking my big sister?"

Tara turns her head and looks at Dawn who looks right back at her with a small smirk on her face.

"I've imagined fucking her pussy with my tongue. And fingers. And strap-on. I've also imagined having her eat my pussy, having her lick my ass, spanking her and fucking her ass with my strap-on." Tara says.

"And did you imagine doing the same to me?" Dawn asks a plan starting to form in her head.

"Well... sometimes I did." Tara says hanging her head briefly before lifting it to look at Dawn, "But it was only because I thought you were a bottom."

Dawn smiles an ear to ear smile as she nods her head to show Tara that she understands.

"What about you Willow?" Dawn asks turning her attention from Tara to Willow who turns her attention from Tara to her, "When you thought about being with Buffy. How did you imagine it happening?"

Willow slowly turns her attention from Dawn to Buffy who is looking back at her with a curious expression on her face.

"I imagined... basically everything Tara did." Willow says as she slowly hangs her head not ashamed of her fantasies however she is ashamed that she has just told Buffy, Dawn and Tara, "Only because I am a bottom and I thought Buffy was a top I imagined her doing those things to me."

"You mean you imagined Buffy fucking you?" Dawn asks smiling an ear to ear smile at Willow even though she has her head hung, "And you imagined her fucking your pussy with her tongue, fingers, and strap-on? And you imagined her making you eat her pussy, and making you lick her back hole, and spanking your butt, and fucking your ass with a strap-on?"

Willow keeps her head hung as she slowly nods.

"And what about me?" Dawn asks causing Willow to lift her head and look at her, "How did you imagine it happening when you thought about me?"

Willow hangs her head now feeling ashamed due to her fantasies and thoughts when it came to her best friend's sister, "I imagined you doing the same thing I imagined Buffy doing."

Dawn looks at Willow a tad surprised having expected the red headed Wicca to tell her that when she imagined them together she imagined dominating her not being dominated by her. However this information also works its way into her slowly forming plan as she slowly turns her head and looks at Tara who looks just as shocked and surprised as she herself is. As she slowly gets over her shock a rather naughty dirty and disgusting at least disgusting in some people's eyes thought or rather question pops into Dawn's head and despite how wrong it is or maybe because it is so wrong of her to ask this question she can't help but want to ask it.

"Ok, so you have both imagined being with either myself or Buffy. But... have either of you... ever imagined... me and Buffy together?" Dawn asks feeling nervous and wondering if maybe she has just gone too far with her questions and yet at the same time unable to help but wonder.

Willow and Tara both look at Dawn in shock and disbelief at what she has just asked them. Buffy is also in a state of shock at what her little sister has just asked her best friend and her best friend's girlfriend and expects to hear both the Witches to yell at her telling her how disgusting what she has just asked them is as well as how disgusting what they saw them doing is etc. However neither Willow or Tara make a noise causing Buffy to turn her attention from her sister to the two Wicca's sitting across from her. The Witches two both slowly turn their attention from Dawn to Buffy and the look on their faces although is still one of shock as well as the fact that they have both been silent for over a minute if not longer causes Buffy to start to wonder if maybe they have as she watches Willow and Tara turn their attention from herself and Dawn to each other.

Willow and Tara look into each other's eyes as they have a telepathic conversation.

"Have you?" Willow asks her girlfriend.

Tara slowly nods her head. "Have you?"

Willow unable to believe that Tara has just admitted to imagining Buffy and Dawn together slowly nods her head back unable to believe that she has just told her girlfriend the truth and Tara has just told her the truth back. How she knows that it is the truth is due to the fact she can feel it as well as see it in Tara's eyes just as she is sure Tara can see it in her own eyes. With that the two Witches turn their heads and look back at Buffy and Dawn.

Buffy stares at Tara and Willow having a feeling she knows the answer the two Wiccas are about to give her sister and yet she unable to believe it.

"Yes." Tara says.

"We have." Willow adds.

Buffy closes her eyes feeling as though this must be a dream and that it is not real and that she did not just hear her best friend of seven years almost confess to having imagined her with her sister and not only that but also heard her best friend of seven year's girlfriend admit or rather confess to the same thing.

Dawn meanwhile is looking or rather staring at both Willow and Tara feeling shocked and yet at the same time unable to stop the ear to ear smile that spreads across her face.

"Well." Dawn says feeling that taking into consideration everything they have all said as well as what they have seen tonight the two Wicca's will be or should be open to the idea she is about to suggest, "Since you have already seen me and Buffy together. How would you like to make a few other fantasies come true?"

Both Willow and Tara look at Dawn and swallow hard unable to believe what she has just said or what they both think she is suggesting.

"What do you mean?" Willow asks finally breaking the silence.

Dawn smiles even more at Willow's question.

"I mean, how would Tara like for us to swap Subs? She has mine. And I'll have her's" Dawn says turning her attention from Buffy to Willow who is looking back at her with the same expression on her face as the Slayer has before turning her attention back to Tara to see what her answer is, "Provided that she is willing to accept a few conditions."

Tara looks at Dawn unable to believe what she has just suggested and yet able to tell from looking into her eyes she means what she says and as she thinks about this Tara turns her attention from Dawn to Buffy. The Slayer is still kneeling in front of Dawn in all her glory, the sight making Tara think back to when Buffy was riding that strap on and how much she seemed to enjoy it. Which causes the Wicca to wonder how Buffy would feel if it was her that was fucking her with the strap on and liking the idea of her being able to for fill one of her all time deepest darkest fantasies.

"What would be the conditions Dawn?" Tara asks swallowing hard due to the fact that although she is willing to go through with this that doesn't stop her still being nervous.

"It's simple." Dawn says her eyes lighting up due to Tara having more or less accepted her idea or rather suggestion/offer, "One, all four of us stay in here and after one couple has finished they have to watch the other couple. And two, you can do whatever you want to Buffy, except fuck her in the ass."

Tara looks at Dawn unable to help but feel a little disappointed that she can't fuck Buffy in the ass due to that having been one of her fantasies involving the Slayer however she can tell from the look on the Slayer's little sister's face that these conditions are non-negotiable. She either accepts them or there is no deal.

"Ok, I accept your conditions." Tara says after a brief silence, "But just out of curiosity... why can't I fuck her in the ass?"

Dawn smiles an ear to ear smile at Tara's question.

"Well Tara." She starts off by saying however stops suddenly getting a much better idea than answering Tara's question herself, "Why don't you ask Buffy why you can't fuck her in the ass?"

Tara looks at Dawn with a slight frown wondering why she doesn't want or won't answer the question herself however she slowly turns her attention from Dawn to Buffy.

"Why can't I fuck you in the ass Buffy?" She asks the blonde haired Slayer feeling weird asking her this question.

Buffy hangs her head.

"You can't fuck me in the ass." Buffy starts off by saying.

"Stop!" Dawn snaps causing both Tara and Buffy to turn their attention to her while Dawn focuses her attention on Buffy, "You will look Tara in the eye as you answer this question."

Buffy looks at Dawn as she slowly turns her head and looks at Tara forcing herself to look the blonde haired Wicca in her blue eyes. "You can't fuck me in the ass... because... my sister."

"Dawn!" Buffy's sister snaps wanting her older sister to say her name.

"Dawn." Buffy says doing her best not to give her little sister an evil look as she continues to force herself to focus on keeping her eyes locked with Tara's, "Owns my ass hole."

"An how long do I own your ass hole for?" Dawn asks her.

"Forever." Buffy says.

"So your ass is my property?" Dawn asks.

"Yes." Buffy answers, "My ass is now my sister Dawn Summer's property. She owns it. And I will bend over for her whenever she wants for the rest of my life."

"So if I want your ass on your wedding night." Dawn starts off saying.

"Then I will leave Riley with blue balls so I can spread my butt cheeks for you Dawnie." Buffy says for some reason feeling the desire to turn and look at her sister as she says this however resisting this desire and doing what she has been told and that is keeping her eyes locked with Tara's, "I'll do the same on my honeymoon or any other moment of any other day that Dawn wants it after that. I'm going to give her my ass so that she can make sure it will not be wasted on Riley or worse go unused. I will let her fuck my ass every single day from now on."

Dawn smiles an ear to ear smile having both watched and listened to Buffy this whole time. After a few minutes she slowly turns her attention from her big sister to Tara who is staring back at Buffy in shock and disbelief.

"Are there any conditions that you have as far as me having Willow?" Dawn asks doing her best to try and help get Tara over her state of shock.

Tara slowly turns her head and looks from Buffy to Dawn.

"What do you mean?" Tara asks the tone of her voice letting all those around her know that she is still getting over what she has just heard the blonde haired vampire slayer declare.

"Well." Dawn says with an ear to ear smile. "Are there any parts of Willow that you own and as such are off limits to others?"

Tara for some reason can't help but smile due to what Dawn has just said or the way she has just said what she has.

"No." Tara says doing her best to try and stop herself from smiling. "You are free to do whatever you want to Willow. Use any part of her you wish. The only rule that we have is no marks."

Dawn meanwhile is busy milling over what Tara said before she turned her attention to Willow. "The only rule that you have... does that mean that this will not be the first... Sub swap you have done Tara?"

Tara looks at Dawn unable to believe how she could have let what she just has slip so easily as she turns and looks at Willow who looks back at her with an expression on her face which makes Tara think that she doesn't care that Buffy and Dawn now know their secret. A secret that they have not told anybody except for the third parties that have been involved. Slowly Tara turns her attention from Willow back to Dawn feeling as though she has no choice but to come clean as far as what she meant when she said that 'they' only have one rule.

"You remember how me and Willow first met?" Tara starts off by asking, turning her attention from Dawn to Buffy and back again letting both of the Summers sisters know that she is talking to both of them.

Both Buffy and Dawn nod their heads.

"You met at a Wicca's meeting." Dawn says.

"Right." Tara says smiling a small smile. "Well after we moved into our own place together we decided to see if we could find another group like the one that led us to finding each other. We found one. And we went to one of their meetings. However when we got their we found out that the meeting was just a cover for members of the group all of whom were witches and all of whom were of the... lesbian persuasion to partake in an all-girl orgy. After going to a few of the 'meetings'. We found out that some of the couples there invited some of the single ladies back to their houses etc for 'meetings' outside of group meeting times... Eventually me and Willow decided to do the same and ever since the first time we did it we have... occasionally invited another girl into our bed."

Dawn looks between Tara and Willow unable to believe what the two Wiccas, or rather what the Dominant Wicca, has just revealed to both her and Buffy and yet unable to help but admire and respect the two of them for being so comfortable with the way that they are and so open with one and other and willing to share themselves with each other but also with a third person.

"This other girl... or girls." Dawn says, "Where they Doms, Subs or switches?"

Tara lifts her head and looks at Dawnie, "Sometimes the other girl was a Dom, sometimes she was a Sub, and sometimes she was a switch. It depended on who we met and... who we were in the mood to play with."

Dawn slowly nods her head to show that she understands, "Is that the wildest thing you've ever done?"

Tara smiles back and nods her head, "And the wildest thing we have ever seen."

"Until we saw you two go at it." Willow says causing all eyes in the room to turn and look at her which causes her to hang her head due to the redhead not being able to believe what she has just said.

Dawn smiles an ear to ear smile deciding to let Willow off and get the rooms focus back on what she had suggested that she and Tara do.

"Alright then Tara." Dawn says causing the blonde haired Wicca to turn her attention from Willow to her. "Since you're willing to accept my conditions. Buffy is all yours."

Tara looks at Dawn still finding it hard to believe what she both has said and is doing as she slowly turns her attention from Dawn to Buffy who has her head hung. As she looks at the blonde Slayer Tara can't help but think about all the dirty little fantasies she has had that have involved the woman in front of her who has saved not just her life but the world countless times. And although she is feeling nervous about what she is about to do the blonde haired Wicca can't help but also feel excited as she tries to think which one of the naughty things she has been given permission to do to Buffy she will do to her first.

After having made up her mind what she is going to do to Buffy first Tara grabs a nearby chair and places it not too far away from the bed making it possible for everybody on the bed to see what she is about to do. Once she is happy with the position of the chair Tara sits down on the chair and turns her attention back to the bed specifically to Buffy.

"Come here Buffy." Tara tells the blonde haired slayer doing her best to sound both commanding and authoritive and hide her nervousness and excitement.

Buffy slowly turns her attention from Tara to Dawn who turns her head and looks back at her.

"You heard what she said Buffy." Dawn says emotionlessly.

Buffy slowly turns her head back around from looking at Dawn to looking at Willow who is looking back at her. Buffy secretly hopes that Willow will say something or do something to stop what is about to happen however as she looks into her best friend's eyes she sees no hint of willingness or desire to stop what is about to happen. This shocks the blonde haired Slayer however she does her best to try and convince herself the reason her friend is refusing to do anything is because she is a Sub and it is not her place to say or do anything against her Dom even if she wants too. Yet despite doing her best to convince herself that this is why Willow is going to allow this to happen she can't help but keep thinking about the fact that there was no desire to either help her or stop this and even if she was a Sub and had accepted the fact that she could not stop or it was not her place to stop what is about to happen Buffy is sure she would have at least seen the desire to want to help or want to stop this from happening.

Doing her best to not think about this Buffy moves to the end of the bed where Tara was sat a short while ago and gets up off of the bed and takes a step toward where Tara is sitting.

"What do you think you're doing?" Tara asks looking at Buffy who looks back at her.

"You told me to come to you." Buffy says a tad confused by Tara's question although doing her best to hide it.

"I didn't say you could walk." Tara says.

Dawn smiles an ear to ear smile as she watches what is going on between her sister and Tara.

"Get down on your hands and knees and crawl to me." Tara tells the Slayer.