Caitlin's Choice Ch. 04

Caitlin paced her bedroom as she glanced at the bathroom door. It had been four weeks since Mark and Sophie's wedding and she wished she could forget the disaster of the weekend. She had been told her ex boyfriend Logan was in Australia, but he had shown up anyway and instead of meeting in a respectful way, she had fallen ass over teakettle over his legs as she tried to take a nice walk on the beach. They had been assigned to share the same two-bedroom cottage and she really didn't remember the details, but she knew that in the past, when the two of them were angry and frustrated -- watch out because the sex was hot and intense. They had agreed to pretend that afternoon never happened and they had gone their separate ways. It wasn't until she got home that she realized she had forgotten to take her next set of birth control pills.

Caitlin looked at the clock and walked into the bathroom and stared at the test on the counter. She hated how cutesy those pregnancy tests looked and she sighed as she saw the 2 dark pink lines. She had known she was pregnant before she had taken the test but at least this was proof. She turned and walked to grab her cell phone, dialing his number.

"Don't hang up. It's important."

She knew that Logan was rolling his eyes as he answered his cell phone. She had no idea where in the world he was, but she needed to talk to him.

"What do you want Caitlin?"

"I was wondering if we could get together next time you're in Sandford."

Sandford was the city that Caitlin had been living in since she went off to college. The college was located in town and she loved it so much that she had stayed. Of course, not wanting to go back to her hometown and face Logan was a pretty good motivator as well.

"I'm in Sandford now."

Caitlin's blood pressure went up as Logan said that. She was trying hard not to freak out.

"Can we meet for dinner tonight. Joeys at 7pm."

"Fine."

Logan hung up and wondered what the hell was going on. He wondered if she had spoken to Stacey and found out the truth. He had wanted to tell her the whole story back at the resort, but he had chickened out. He really didn't want to relive that part of his life when he was conned out of a large sum of money from some stupid blonde. He also didn't want to tell her that he had accepted a job in Sandford and was just settling in to his new apartment.

Caitlin sat on her couch and dialed Stacey's number. She wasn't sure why she was doing this but she needed to know the whole truth from Stacey before she told Logan her news.

"Hello. Can I speak to Stacey Moore?"

Caitlin heard the phone drop and the man who answered the phone called out for Stacey to pick up the phone.

"Yah, what?"

"Stacey, I'm not sure you remember me from high school, but this is Caitlin Anderson. I know this is personal, but a month ago I met up with Logan at Mark and Sophie's wedding and he told me about you and him. I just want to know if he's taking care of you and the baby."

"What the fuck are you talking about? It wasn't Logan's baby. I just tried to milk him for some money since my fat assed boyfriend was being a dope head. He gave me $5000 and then, when Angel was born, he was smart enough to ask for a paternity test."

"Oh."

Caitlin apologized and hung up the phone. Her mind was racing as she tried to figure out what to make of this. She had been spending the last four weeks thinking that Logan was selfish and stupid and had purposely hurt her. Now she realized that he had broken up with her to shield her from his mistake and that by the time he found out it wasn't his mistake, it was too late. Caitlin knew exactly what she needed to do.

A few hours later Caitlin was seated at a table for two at Joey's, a nice seafood restaurant that she loved. She was wearing a black sweater with black pants. Her red hair was in a ponytail and she was nervously chewing her bottom lip, waiting for Logan to show up. She smiled as he entered the restaurant and made his way to the table. He was wearing gray slacks and a button up shirt.

"Hi Caitlin."

"Hi Logan. I have something to tell you. Do you want me to tell you now or wait until after dinner?"

"Tell me now."

Logan leaned back in his chair and crossed his arms over his muscular chest. Caitlin looked down at her hands and began to speak.

"I called Stacey and found out what she did to you. I feel so bad and feel like a complete bitch for thinking you were selfish and mean. I have no idea how to say sorry and I know that even at the wedding I was rude and selfish. I'm pregnant. I was on the pill, but I guess with going to the island and everything I forgot to take some of the pills. I don't expect you to do anything and considering what Stacey did to you___"

Caitlin was cut off as Logan slid his hand over her mouth.

"I never stopped loving you. You know that and I accept your apology. We're going to have a baby?"

"Yeah. Aren't you mad?"

"Let's eat dinner and let me think about it."

Caitlin and Logan ate dinner with only small chitchat about random things. She could see he was thinking and she wondered what he was going to say. After paying for dinner, they walked towards the parking lot where he had parked his silver sports car next to her red sedan. Leaning against his car he looked at Caitlin.

"I love you."

Caitlin's eyes filled with tears as the roller coaster of emotions she was feeling explode. She collapsed in his arms and sobbed. Logan wrapped his arms tight around her and held her until she had composed herself.

"You're coming home with me."

As they walked into his small apartment, he guided her to the bedroom and sat her down on the bed.

"We never made love together. It was always sex or fucking. Tonight, let me do this."

Caitlin nodded and they slowly undressed in front of each other. Once naked, he leaned her back on the bed and kissed every inch of her body. His lips brushed her collarbone and nibbled down between her breasts before capturing each nipple in his mouth and sucking softly. Caitlin moaned and whimpered, not used to this speed of seduction. Logan nestled himself between her legs and slid his tongue up and down her pussy lips. He tasted her juices and opening her wider, flicked his tongue against her clit which was hard and throbbing.

She was thrashing around, begging for him to be inside her. He continued his assault on her pussy, bringing her so close to orgasm and then slowing down. Just as she was on the peak, he stopped and sat up. Her eyes said it all. She was in love and full of complete lust, desperate for him. He guided himself inside her and held himself there.

"I love you."

"I love you more."

They kissed as he thrusted slowly, but forcefully, in and out of her pussy. Suddenly she was cumming and it was so intense that she brought him with her. Both of them were moaning and panting. Their bodies shaking as they experienced such a high, they could barely speak.

As they lay intertwined on the bed Logan looked over at Caitlin.

"So where do you want to get married?"

"What!"

Caitlin sat up and her eyes were burning with anger.

"After all that, you propose to me like that. As if!"

Caitlin sat up and started grabbing her clothes. Logan let her storm off since he knew that anything he said would make it worse and for once he did the right thing by letting her cool off.