Choice, Chance and Circumstance

"If you're sorry dad... oooouummph... why do you keep fucking me? You're cock is too big daddy...oooooo... it hurts me"

Her father was surprised to hear Sarah say those dirty words, but far from chastising her. Tim was getting less and less subtle about continuing to chase the pleasure his tiny daughter's quim was giving him.

"Sarah, your little pussy makes my cock feel very good... ohhh... it won't hurt as much if I just fuck you a little more honey" his hips slapped against her buttocks and Sarah could feel her father prodding her deep enough to encounter resistance inside her.

His hands started to wander around Sarah's chest. The friction his fingers were causing by rubbing his fingers over her nipple with the cotton tank-top between made her shiver involuntarily.

"But you can put your thing in mommy's pussy... ohhh shiiiit... you can't put it in mine. You could get me pregnant daddy!"

Tim stood his daughter up straight and slid his hand from her hip up to the hem of her shirt. He didn't want to ignore the pleading of his baby girl; he hadn't even dreamt of deflowering her. But now that he had, Tim couldn't help himself. He could still feel his daughter's opening leaking with desire, and it gave him hope that he might win her over.

"Your mom doesn't let me anymore honey, and you are so much more beautiful than she is..." he told her truthfully, "you can only get pregnant if I cum inside you honey... ouhhhh... I promise I won't!"

Sarah felt him shoving his big cock into her again. She'd lost count of how many times he'd plunged into her now, but between that and the sweet compliment he'd paid her, she was tingling from the inside out.

She could feel her father's hands getting bolder. One of them had found its way under her shirt and was moving its way up her flat stomach to her boobies. When he reached there, he hesitated with his thumb and forefinger making a half-circle under her breast. As Sarah held her breath she felt her father move his hand so he was cupping her tit fully and testing its weight. Finally, he took her nipple between his fingers and squeezed gently; Sarah mewwed in response.

"Oh God Daddy..." Sarah moaned as she felt her father urging his cock in and out of her.

She felt bad for him, that her mother had not allowed her wonderful father any relief for many weeks. He was desperate enough to seek it from his own daughter, though he may have only mistakenly done so at first.

As Sarah's father was fucking her as gently as he could stand from behind, she could feel the shock and pain of losing her virginity to her father begin to subside just as he had promised . It was being replaced by something she had never felt before: a building pressure each time her father sunk all the way into her.

"Mnnnhhh... what if someone sees... unnnhhh..." Sarah complained, "you should stop now, you shouldn't fuck me anymore daddy... oooumpph..." No matter what she said, Sarah's pussy was drenched and her moans indicated to her father that if he continued she was going to experience her first orgasm by penetration.

His hands were roaming around, one on her tit and the other massaging the soft flesh around her hip. Her daddy was manhandling her, much different from the way he usually held her as they fell asleep watching TV.

Twenty minutes ago, her father had crossed her mind more than once as she touched herself in the quiet darkness of her room. She had been thinking of him when she reached into the vegetable drawer at the fridge. She'd wondered what vegetable would be most similar to her father. Now that he was fucking her, she was quite sure that nothing in the fridge was large enough to match him.

Sarah knew it was wrong; she knew she should push her father off and stop the incest they were committing right away. Why did she stay? Sarah wondered what her friend Erin would say. She was always talking about how hot her daddy was and how bad she wanted him. Did Sarah want him too? Is that why she was starting to excitedly anticipate each time his cock would again be snugly thrust inside of her after withdrawal?

"Fuck daddy! You're cock is really big..." he was increasing the vigor of his thrusts, grasping her hip tightly and making sure he was all the way into her before pulling back out. "Be careful dad please... unnhhhh... it hurts more when you fuck me harder!"

"Is this okay baby?" Tim asked his daughter; he slowed down the pace but still savored the feeling of filling the tiny brunette completely again and again.

"Yes daaaad... uhhhh uhhhh... that feels much better."

He was surprised to hear his little girl finally yielding, and her wet pink pussy was still easing his repeated entry. The sounds of the house were always soothing to Tim: the drone of the fridge compressor, the click of the air conditioner turning on or the breathing of his sleeping family. But the sounds coming from his teenage daughter were more wonderful to him than anything he'd ever heard... her labored breaths... the swishing of her tight pussy as it accepted his pistoning cock and the quiet whimpering as she felt a man's cock inside her for the first time.

Tim had been there for all of Sarah's firsts: her first steps, her first words, her first day at school. He'd held her when she got hurt or when she got a bad grade or whenever he felt his wife was being too harsh with his little girl. He had been there for Sarah's first break-up, and even when she bought her first bra. Now Tim was always going to be his daughter's first time with a man, and the knowledge that he was claiming her bare, untouched pussy by reaching places with each thrust into her that no man had ever been before... the truth of it was the amazing beyond words.

For years he'd looked on as Sarah became the beautiful girl she was today. In the dressing room some time ago, she'd asked how multiple bras looked when he took her to the mall to try them on. He shouldn't have been looking at his young daughter, but with her perfect globes were nestled inside the supportive cups, even then her body was a sight to behold. The thought that she would become such a gorgeous young daughter scared him... He loved her completely, beyond compare, and only dreamed that someday a man would be deserving enough to have her.

Now as he looked down, the dimples in her back where he'd pushed up her shirt and curve of her hips... he gasped... he couldn't believe he was the man fucking his daughter.

"Ohhh fuck... Daddy keep fucking me... ohgod..." she was forgetting to resist now, "you feel so good in my pussy dad."

Tim had felt so guilty when he realized for certain that it was his daughter whom he'd buried his cock into. Even more so when he discovered that he'd taken her virginity as well. But now... now that she was asking him to continue.. she wanted him to keep fucking her...

Tim established a good rhythm and could feel his little girl leaning backward to help him. In short order he could tell that his teenage daughter was going to have an orgasm. She was breathing more heavily, crying out more needily.

"Ohh fuck... I feel strange... ouuuhhh... wait Daddy... hold on..."

But Tim knew what to do, and soon his little girl would be cumming on his cock just the way he wanted her to. He continued to push into her folds and prod her deep within.

"Ohh fuckkk... oh Daaad... "

Sarah's knees went weak. Her father supported her while continuing his unrelenting thrusts into her pussy. Her mind was suddenly white and she felt pins and needles in all of her extremities. She howled

"Ohhhhhh Daaaaaaaaddyyyy."

It was like nothing Sarah had ever felt before. Her father had shoved into her and stayed there as she rode out her newly discovered orgasm. She felt so incredibly full. Her body seemed to conduct electricity through thin wires stretching from her fingers to the tips of her toes and all leading back to the apex point of pleasure behind her eyes.

Tim's cock throbbed as his little girl curled her toes against the hardwood floor and reached back clumsily for some kind of hold on him. He loved watching his daughter climax and simply savored the sight of her quaking in front of him, not to mention the way her virgin walls were clenching him as she did. Though her father's cock fit perfectly inside Sarah, she was even wetter than before and her juices were dripping from within her.

For the first time, Tim decided to remove himself from his daughter's drenched tunnel. She stood, but only with the support her father gave her. He turned Sarah towards him, her head hung low. With a finger at her chin Tim lifted his daughter's head up to look into her eyes.

She looked so pretty, a light sheen of sweat on her brow and flushed cheeks. Sarah kept her eyes closed for a moment, but when she finally opened them they weren't angry. They weren't hurt or sad or anything he had expected. Sarah had pleaded with him to stop, but as she came back to the world from an earth-shaking orgasm, Sarah was glad her father had kept fucking her.

She only looked a little embarrassed, like she hadn't expected to see so much pleasure from having her virginity taken by her father.

"I love you baby," he told her.

Sarah looked at him closely, her big green eyes holding his gaze for long enough that he was desperate to know what she was thinking.

"I love you too dad."

He kissed her on the cheek, right next to her lips, and lingered there. Sarah felt him hesitate and brought her lips close enough to kiss him. Simultaneously they closed the gap between them and brought their mouths together. Sarah kissed her father hungrily, thanking him for the beautiful feelings he'd shown her.

Each peck, each explorative placement of his lips on hers, Sarah understood why she wasn't upset with her daddy for continuing to fuck her when he did. All of Sarah's friends seemed to love her father, and they didn't know him half as well as she did. He was the best father a girl could have, and he was handsome to boot. So many times she had thought of him, alone in her bed at night, but she didn't ever know how he could make her feel. The tingling surface of her skin and her sensitive pussy was more than she had ever dreamt of. Now that she had the chance, why shouldn't she willingly accept her father? Nobody had to know... Sarah shivered at the taboo thoughts.

Their tongues darted out to meet each other. Sarah didn't have much experience kissing boys, but she absolutely loved kissing and making out with her dad. Tim felt like a teenager again, and found his hands moving of their own volition to feel the tiny frame of the teenager in his arms. He wanted to be inside her again, but only if she chose to this time.

When her father's hands once again found her perky breasts under the shirt, Sarah knew he wanted her to take it off. She lifted her arms above her head readily, surprising her father with her willingness. He quickly obliged her, pulling the shirt off and revealing her young tits to him.

God she was so gorgeous and irresistible, and her breasts larger and shapelier than her mother's. Tim put his hands on her and Sarah watched closely as his they roamed all over her.

"You're so beautiful Sarah," he told her, "and you made me feel wonderful honey."

As Sarah was looking down she caught a glimpse of her father's cock again. It WAS large, and it was silvery with all the wetness she must have covered him in. Not only that, but it was sticking straight upward and she could feel it bobbing against her leg at a pace that must have been his heartbeat.

"Why is it still so big dad?"

"Because I am so turned on looking at you. I'm thinking about making love to you sweetheart."

Sarah shrugged with embarrassment. In doing so, she looked adorable and her teardrop breasts shook with the motion of her shoulders.

"You want to fuck me again don't you daddy?"

Tim felt guilty. Hearing the naughty words from his little girl's mouth made the deed very real. Still he shook his head 'yes.'

Sarah may have been inexperienced, but she knew how dangerous it would be for them to have sex again. In class at her high school, the book had shown her how to find out when her period would come and when she was most likely to become pregnant. If she was doing it right, she was right at the best time for her daddy's sperm to find her egg and make her pregnant. And the book had also said always to use protection, like a condom or birth control and she wasn't using either one.

"What if I just put my mouth on it?" Sarah suggested. She felt his penis throb perceptively when she did.

"You like that idea, don't you daddy?"

Sarah proceeded to get down on her knees and gingerly take her father's erection in her hand. She could feel her stickiness on him still, and she knew there was more coming from deep within her.

Sarah tested the head of his cock at her lips, looking up at him with her pretty eyes and hoping she did a good job. Slowly she opened her mouth and took in the head of her cock. She sucked on it gently, not minding at all that she could taste herself on him.

The little brunette tried to emulate what her father might have felt when he had his big penis inside of her; she encircled his shaft with both hands and moved them up and down while she lapped at his tip. Her father moaned.

"Oh honey, you're doing wonderful," he said as he tossed his head back.

Sarah sucked on him and tried her best to take more into her mouth. She knew that some girls could take the whole thing, but hard as Sarah tried she could get less than half of her father's cock in her mouth. She wondered what it would taste like if he squirted his white stuff into her mouth.

Sarah sucked and stroked and like an angel she praised her father with her mouth. He did his best to watch her, though she made him feel so wonderful that he could barely stand at a few points. When he did look at her, the image of her perched in front of him with his cock in her mouth and looking up at her with her soulful, innocent green eyes...it would be burned in his mind forever. His daughter was doing a wonderful job for her first time, he told her. But hard as she tried, and beautiful as she looked kneeling, Tim had one thing on his mind.

"Baby," he beckoned her, "stand up, let me see you again."

She obeyed him, arising so that her breasts brushed against his abdomen as she did. After admiring her for a few more seconds, Tim wasted no time lifting his daughter onto the island and she knew immediately by the proximity of his cockhead to her entrance what his intentions were.

"Daddy," she warned, "I don't think you should fuck me anymore, it's too risky."

"I promise sweetie," her father sounded desperate again, "I'll be very careful. If I'm very careful you won't get pregnant, cross my heart."

"I don't know daddy," she continued to protest, "I don't think we should, it's too dangerous right now for my fertility cycle. We'd be in so much trouble!"

"I know honey, how about I just put the tip in you, just for a minute?" Tim negotiated. He was already prodding his daughter's mound with his large head and Sarah was beginning to wish he would press harder and keep making her feel good. For a brief moment, the thought of her father's penis shooting his warm sperm into her pussy entered Sarah's conflicted brain. She knew it was even more wrong than having an orgasm or sucking her daddy's cock, but what would it feel like? Sarah loved her father more than anybody, even her mom; what if he did get her pregnant? God... she was so confused... she wasn't supposed to want it but this night was unlocking feelings she'd never conceived of before.

"Okay, but only for a minute, right?" Sarah relented. She didn't want to sound as eager as her body felt.

Tim didn't respond with words, the waiting had nearly driven him to madness. He pushed his tip against Sarah's still very wet lips. They parted and allowed his head to pop into her entry. Once again Tim had the thought that he'd never feel something so good as being inside his daughter's little pussy.

"Ouuwwh Daddy!" she cried, feeling him inside her once more. Her father's tip alone felt bigger in their new position. It hurt a little but still she watched intently as he withdrew his tip and pushed it into her again. Both gasped as he did so, listening to each other and feeling everything from their incestuous connection between them

Tim removed and replaced his tip in his teenager's pussy enough times that she lost count. He had gone on longer than he promised, but he wasn't done yet.

"Ohhh fuck Dad," she whimpered, "it feels really good now!"

Sarah's mouth had brought him close, but Tim needed to come more than he ever had before in his life. He dared push his cock a little further into his daughter. She noticed immediately, but assumed it was only an accident.

When he did it again, Sarah called him out.

"...Fuuckk," she blurted, "Daddy you promised."

"I know baby just a little more!"

Maybe Tim had intended to keep his word, but once he felt her tiny channel more deeply wrapped around his cock, his promises began to evaporate.

He pushed into his daughter again, and then deeper, and then withdrew, and then thrust back in. In a few moments he was fucking his youngest daughter along the full length of his cock. Sarah, for all her protest, could not hide how much pleasure it was giving her,

"Oooohhhh Dad... mnnnh fuck... it's so big..."

She certainly didn't sound like she wanted him to stop, and Sarah's feet were wrapped around her father's tight core. His abs rippled as he fucked her deeply and ever so gently her heels were pulling him in. She watched in wonder as the tip of her father's penis would peek out from between her lips and then the whole thing disappear entirely into her. She couldn't believe it fit. She lost track of time, but when she looked back at Tim's face, she could see him cringing and focusing hard.

"Okay daddy, shouldn't you stop now?"

Instead she felt him grab on tightly to her hips and squeeze. Sarah put her hands on his strong chest, not knowing whether she wanted to push him away or hold on tight. He was much too strong for her; she could do nothing but accept the deliberate thrusts of her father into her. Her hands felt his manly chest instead, the hair upon his pecs and the dampness of sweat from fucking her so well. Did he know how badly she wanted him to continue? Should she keep protesting?

As he held on tightly, Tim could feel his orgasm building. He watched the soft spot between her hips mounding as he buried his cock in her fully before removing it. Her melodic panting and moaning was beginning to be too much for him.

"I'm almost there sweetheart,"

"Alright dad, please... ouuumphh... it's too risky!"

Sarah felt her father pick up speed for a few more thrusts until he squeezed her hips tight and began to tense.

Then she knew what was happening.

"Daddy no!"

Tim went stiff as soon as he was buried all the way in his young daughter's pussy. He gladly released a first, powerful jet of sperm into Sarah's womb. It immediately gave his daughter a jolt. Then another, and another; his tip painted the little girl's walls, her cervix and everywhere it could with his forbidden cum. Whether he had promised to or not, the intensity with which he was filling the beautiful teenager felt unquestionably right.

Sarah tried to be mad at him, but before she could scold him or yell or even try to push him off, the hot, forbidden sensation of what she knew was her father's semen made her quake from the inside out. Like before, Sarah's body trembled, her skin crawled and her insides squeezed more cum from her father's buried cock. It was the most wonderful feeling, and her second orgasm rocked her more powerfully than the first. It was so wrong that her daddy's cum squirting into her was making her quake with so much pleasure.