Choice, Chance and Circumstance

Tim shakily withdrew an inch of his embedded member from his daughter's insides and then roughly pushed it back in. His cock emitted another rope into her fertile and unprotected womb.

He had never felt so invigorated and so satisfied, and Tim was quite certain that he'd never cum so much in his life as he just had inside his daughter. Sarah wrapped her arms around his neck when her orgasm had struck her and was, willingly or not, still quivering as the last bit of her father's seed dribbled from his head and topped off her overfilled pussy.

His daughter held onto him, overwhelmed by the climax she hadn't expected and the incestuous load she now carried inside her. The sheer amount of it, and the feeling of her father's cum was unlike anything she'd ever felt and still his hard cock was filling her the rest of the way.

"Daddy...you promised," Sarah pouted as she met his eyes with hers.

"I know baby, you were just too sexy... I had to!" Her father reasoned.

She was still mad, though his tactics to win her over weren't completely lost.

"You lied to me! You said you wouldn't cum inside my pussy and then you came so much!"

Sarah was right; he could feel his semen all over his buried rod. He knew that if Sarah had been telling the truth, his little swimmers would soon make their way even deeper into his daughter and she could conceive his child. He looked down to see it.

Tim pulled his cock, still hard, from within his daughter's sensitive hole, watching her tremble as he did so. As soon as his head was revealed, white, milky cum pushed its way around him. As he fully disengaged, his load cascaded from within her deflowered pussy.

Sarah's eyes went wide.

"Oh my God Daaaad! There's sooo much!" she sounded more amazed than upset.

"Quick daddy, get it out before I get pregnant!" Sarah cried, reaching down to where his cum was dripping from within her.

Tim took his daughter's hand tenderly instead, "it's too late for that honey."

Sarah felt so conflicted. She was worried, but only because people like her mother and that awful teacher in her sex education class told her she should be. Yet her daddy didn't look worried at all. As he took her hand in his and pulled her up toward him, Sarah was already feeling much better. They kissed lovingly, neither of them fully believing the wonderful, forbidden and life-changing thing they'd just shared.

"What should we do Daddy?"

Tim looked down at his daughter's young and freshly-fucked opening. Seeing that his cum was about to flow onto the granite countertop, Tim made a quick decision. He'd only once accomplished it with his wife, but he thought his odds better with a beautiful girl whom he loved far more. Could he fuck his daughter again while his defiant member bobbed, still rock hard, tantalizingly close to Sarah's cute little slit?

Tim dared to scoop up the stream of his cum that had leaked out with his cock head and push it back into his daughter's pussy. He was too turned on to stop fucking his beautiful little girl yet. She shrieked with sensitivity.

Normally, even the faintest touch would send a shiver up Tim's spine, and it did, but he kept fucking her. Feeling the lubrication of his fresh cum easing his path into his daughter he decided to press on.

"Ohhhhh Daddy... ohhh pleaaase... it's too sensitive... fuckkkkk!" his little girl cried.

Tim had been here before, and his desire to follow through prevailed. He cringed and he bucked, but he was determined to fuck his little Sarah until he was utterly spent. It was not long until he could feel his balls, unbelievably, building toward a second consecutive orgasm.

Sarah had been so overwhelmed by her father's actions that she hadn't the chance to look, but when she finally did she could tell that her daddy was going to cum inside her again, and so soon after he just had the first time!

"Ohhhh fuck daddy... twice?" Sarah was about ready to pass out. "You can't cum in my pussy again!"

He didn't answer, with a labored series of grunts and moans, Tim once more buried his cock as deep as it would go and unloaded another sizable amount of semen into his little girl. Jet after jet, he added his cum to her already charged insides. He held her tight and Sarah watched him intently as he came. Though he was doing exactly what he'd promised not to, seeing her father so wholly give himself into his desires, and knowing that she had been his lover through it all warmed her more than the multiple loads of her father's seed she now held within her.

Before he allowed his whole body to go limp, Tim lifted his baby off of the kitchen counter and laid down on the nearby area rug with her on top of him. He didn't pull out of her, he didn't want to ever again.

Sarah and her father lay in the dark for an untold amount of time. As they drank each other in, the teen's soft breasts pressed against Tim and he felt her breathing deeply. She seemed tinier when draped over him as she was. His baby girl... completely naked and still with his softening cock inside of her... the thought was incredible to behold.

The young brunette propped her head up on her hands, the hairs on her father's chest tickling her palms. She looked up at him. She could tell he was completely drained, and she could definitely feel his cum slowly making its way out of her sore pussy.

"You're bad daddy!" Sarah said.

Tim opened his eyes and peered down at her. Expecting her to be upset, or sad or something of the like, he was surprised to see a naughty grin on his pretty daughter's face. Confused, Tim furrowed his brow and replied:

"You're not mad at me?" hoping to God she wasn't.

"Wellllllllll..." she teased him, tilting her head and making him wait for her answer "you did take my virginity daddy..."

"I know baby, I had no idea... I didn't even know it was you... I never would have..."

"Hmmmph!" Sarah interrupted "You never would have? You seemed like you really liked fucking me Dad..."

She was goading him now. That was the girl he knew: a little rambunctious, definitely with a naughty streak.

"I see the way you look at me sometimes, I'm not stupid daddy." He didn't know what to say to his little girl, she was right. "I think about you sometimes too dad..."

Time raised his eyebrows, "You do?"

"Every once in a while... when I'm in bed and I can't fall asleep. My friends talk about you all the time, I can't help it!" she told him. Knowing that his daughter thought about him that way made the fact that he'd just fucked her seem a little better. "But I never thought you would put your big thing in me when I was just looking in the refrigerator, like totally out of the blue!" she exclaimed.

"I swear it was an accident sweetheart, I didn't mean to startle you," Tim reiterated

"And what about all this cum daddy? It's dripping out 'cause you put so much in me! Was it an accident when you came in my pussy...? TWICE!?" He could tell now that she was just playing with him. She reached between them where it was seeping out of her. Tim watched, incredulous, as she took a finger and swept some of it from the stream that had made its way out from her tight little tunnel. Without hesitation she brought it up, looked at it curiously, and then popped her finger in her mouth, tasting it and swallowing his excess semen like it was no big deal.

Tim looked at her sideways, "Okay maybe that wasn't an accident..." he admitted, "but you don't look so upset baby."

Sarah smiled, licking her lips. "...maybe because I'm not."

Her father smiled too. He slid her little body up so her lips could meet his and they kissed. First Sarah just pecked at him, but shortly thereafter they were making out again and playfully dancing they're tongues about. When they broke apart, Sarah laid her head next to her father's.

"You know I'm not on birth control, right daddy?"

"Yes, I know." Tim said with an 'oops' look on his face.

Sarah giggled, "and you still squirted all that sperm in me, even when I told you how easily I could get pregnant?"

"Yeaaah... I did, didn't I?." Tim replied playfully.

"Hmmm..." his little girl sighed, "that would be soooo naughty, wouldn't it dad? You could have gotten me pregnant already!"

The possibility didn't scare him like he thought it would. An image of Sarah, his favorite daughter, with her beautiful brown hair and green eyes staring at him, the bulge of his child in her belly. She would look so beautiful with that tiny body and his baby inside of her.

"We can go to the store tomorrow if you want sweetie. We can get a pill that make's sure you don't get pregnant."

"Oh," Sarah said, sounding disappointed, "Or...?" she queried with a nervous glance.

"Or what honey?" Tim asked, totally confused.

"What if I don't take the pill?" Sarah said with an embarrassed shrug. She hoped her father wouldn't be mad at her suggestion.

He looked surprised, Sarah thought, but then his eyes were full of love. "Well...I don't know... I mean I..." Tim stuttered, feeling smitten that his daughter would suggest something he'd only fantasized.

Sarah thought it was cute that her dad was trying to pretend when she could so clearly tell that the thought appealed to him. "I guess we'd wait a little while. You'd miss your period, your belly would start to grow and then we'd know that you're carrying your daddy's baby."

Sarah's green eyes were opened wide, waiting for him to say more. The corners of her mouth turned upward and she looked adorably curious. Tim could hardly ever say no to his little girl, but this was entirely different. Thoughts were racing through his head, not least of which how wonderful it felt to have his naked little daughter draped over him as they spoke; that he'd never have another child with his wife Maggie; that he fully intended on fucking Sarah every chance she allowed him. If she was willing, she'd be perfectly fertile and healthy to make a baby with him.

"Do you think you might want that Sarah?" he paused, "I know you'd look so pretty with our baby growing in your belly."

Sarah giggled and bit the tip of her finger, "I think I might daddy, but I don't know for sure. It makes me so happy thinking about it that I'm tingling, but..." she was obviously working hard to wrap her head around it.

"You don't have to decide now honey, and nobody would know for a few month," Tim assured her.

Sarah knew that she loved her father more than life itself. For months she had been taking on the role of her mother in his life, and she did so knowingly. He had confided in her, held her like a lover when she was down, even taken her out on dates. She was now awakened to the thought that she could truly be her daddy's forever. Her mom couldn't have her father's babies anymore, but she certainly could. Sarah was starting to allow the thought that she wanted to, badly.

"I graduate soon daddy," she reasoned, "would anybody at school have to know?"

"No sweetie, it could be our secret." He couldn't believe he was really considering it.

"And then what?" Sarah continued.

"And then... well..." her father looked to be deep in thought, "I don't have it all figured out yet Sarah, but I'd do anything for you, no matter what."

Sarah felt so completely enveloped in his love that she ached for him. Her little pussy was much too sore to accept him again that night, but Sarah had never felt such desire for a man before then. It was as if their little accident had brought out a part of her she never knew existed, locked in tight by her virginity: the part that wanted her daddy to be her lover, to be his again and again, and to become pregnant with his child whether the world said she could or not.

"How about we talk about it more in the morning?" Tim suggested.

"Okay daddy, but we'll have to be extra careful." Sarah was very surprised and felt lucky that nobody had heard them making love. Most of her family were heavy sleepers, but she had certainly been making a lot of noise as her father impaled her about the kitchen. It was also funny to Sarah that she suggested being careful when so much good had come from her father not being careful, cumming in her vulnerable little pussy with no condom.

They kissed again. It was a long one, and different than before. There was an unspoken promise of more, a deeper love that they both intended to build upon. Sarah knew she wasn't supposed to feel that way about her father, and Tim about his little girl, but neither of them cared. Taking their relationship to such heights had been mostly by accident. But the sexual tension between them had been broken by the forbidden seed Sarah carried inside her and they kissed with an unhinged passion most could never know.

Tim picked up his daughter easily. She wrapped her arms and legs around him and he slowly carried the cute brunette up the stairs toward her room. They could both feel his cum seeping from Sarah, telling definitively of their act. Their naked bodies holding each other tight and the looks they exchanged would were evidence enough.

Tim set his daughter gently down on the bed, and she held on tight, not wanting him to leave her. She watched lovingly as her father pulled the covers back and slipped into bed with her.

"I love you so much daddy," she told him sincerely, "I was nervous at first, but I don't regret anything that happened."

"I love you too baby, and I want you to know that I will be here to make sure everything turns out okay."

"I know you will." Sarah said adorably, holding her father tight as she drifted off to sleep.

Not long into her slumber, she felt her father leave quietly. Feeling hurt, she reasoned that he probably needed to go back to her mother's bed so they didn't get found out. Still, she felt jealous, wanting him only to herself.

But the door to her room opened again, and back came her father.

He saw her eyes were open and hurt, "you thought I was leaving you, didn't you sweetie?"

"I know you need to, I just don't want to sleep without you tonight," she admitted.

"I had to clean up our little mess," he explained, holding up their discarded clothing. "...probably not a good thing for your mother to see our clothes all over the floor or how wet you made the kitchen table, right?"

Sarah smiled guiltily, "Definitely not! I suppose I shouldn't tell her that daddy came in my pussy without a condom on TWO times tomorrow at breakfast?"

"No, you probably shouldn't mention that," Tim said with a laugh. He wrapped his arm around his naked daughter and pulled her tight to him. "Now get some sleep honey."

Sarah cuddled up to him with the biggest smile on her face. A naughty little part of her hoped that he meant to get some sleep because she would need it. Her recently filled pussy was still recovering, but Sarah knew she'd want her daddy to fuck her again before too long.

Tim had fallen asleep deep in thought, planning what to do next. With his beautiful daughter nuzzled against him, he felt certain that everything would be different. They had a whole new life ahead of them.

As they drifted off, Sarah's young womb was striving to make a new life as well. By morning, she could already have conceived her father's child. For now, it was enough that the beautiful teenager could fall asleep, claimed in the arms of her loving father. Tomorrow was another day, and they could spend it and many more tomorrows falling more deeply in love. Sarah was so young it could be many months before her belly showed evidence of the night they had shared... or those to come.