Girls Next Door

That was on my mind again on Tuesday night, when she asked for some help with a math course I had aced the year before. I suspected a ruse, since Wendy had taken the same course, besting my grade by two points. I was right, as Susan leaned over to kiss me five minutes after I got into the girls' apartment, as we studied on their couch. Once again, a suspicious lack of roommates around. She was in a short sleeved grey sweater, and a matching skirt.

I kissed her back and my hand went to her hip, as we turned our bodies towards each other. I answered her tongue with my own and she nearly squealed into my mouth. I was giving her more than she expected and she liked it.

Both of my hands were working their way up her sides, while she was holding the back of my head, pulling us together. I reached the bottom of her sweater-covered breasts. I paused for effect, trying to act more hesitant than I actually felt, before moving my hands over them, to reach the same hard, pointy nipples that had been the feature of a lot of dreams over the past months.

I squeezed each one between thumb and index finger and pulled them away from her chest, getting a loud moan into my mouth as feedback.

"Oh, wow, Kurt," she gasped, when we broke from the kiss. "How did you guess my tits are my most sensitive area? You've got me so wet, right now."

"I guessed, that if your nips were going to respond from just a few seconds of cold, that they were extra sensitive. I'm glad I was right."

She smiled her naughtiest smile. "I want to make you gladder."

"Are... are you... offering... offering the same... same thing Wendy did, last night?" Even knowing the answer, my tongue still got tied up by the question.

"Yes," she said, taking my hands in hers. "Do you mind telling me why you turned her down?" Clearly, Wendy had been quizzed. I wondered whether the girls were coordinating their order of attack, wondered briefly whether it would be Colleen or Dani next, before returning my attention to Susan.

"Maybe later," I answered, before kissing her again. "I want to be thinking about you, right now, don't you agree?"

One of her hands let go of mine, grabbed my cock through my pants and I grabbed her breast again in response.

"Let's go to my bedroom," she suggested.

Taking her hand, I helped her up, walking into her bedroom, where she draped a sock over the door handle, in the universal "busy here" signal I'd been dealing with from Jasper now and then since Freshman year. As soon as she turned back into the room, I started to undress her. I think my taking charge was surprising her, but so long as I wasn't trying to talk, I could act bolder than I otherwise might. Being with Wendy had also boosted my confidence, it seemed. I wasn't as afraid of disappointing Susan as I'd been afraid with Wendy. I was still nervous, but not terrified.

Naked, we got on her bed together and began kissing again, our hands roaming over each other's bodies. I pulled back from her mouth, and whispered, "Could... could I lick you?" I'd not gotten a chance to do this with Wendy, and really wanted the experience.

Her eyes widened, but she nodded. I kissed my way down her body, taking about a minute to lick each breast. When I was down between her legs, I looked up at her and asked, "How do I start?"

Her blush actually made me excited, knowing that I wasn't the only one with nerves. Wendy's take-charge attitude had been exciting the night before, but it also felt good to be on a more even footing with Susan.

"You see how there are two sets of lips?" I nodded. Her inner ones protruded slightly, a scarlet color I knew was from them being filled by blood as she got excited, and she clearly was. "At the top of the inner ones is where my clitoris is, surrounded by its hood, like your cock is covered by its foreskin when you're soft. It's the most sensitive part of my genitals. Sometimes too sensitive, if you're forceful too soon. You need to get the rest of me excited first, so start by kissing and licking my lips. I'll tell you when to move on my clit, okay?"

"Okay," I answered, taking my first hesitant licks. I figured that Susan had probably washed up before I arrived, so her taste was fairly mild, a little bit of musk, a little bit salty. As I licked her, staying away from her clit, I sensed more and more moisture flowing out of her. Her taste got a little stronger but I liked it, liked exciting her, liked her a lot.

On my own initiative, I licked around her opening and she cooed, "Yes, like that. Lick my pussy," A couple minutes later, she told me, "Kurt, push your middle finger inside me, then explore the surfaces towards my tummy. You should find a rough spot inside. That's called the g-spot. It feels real good if you rub that or tap it." I followed her instruction, and soon found the spot she described.

"Oh, yeah, Kurt. That's it. Stroke that a little while you start licking towards my clit, really gentle though." I followed her direction, and her back arched when I ran my tongue across her clit for the first time. "A little softer than that at first, honey, just a little at a time. Use only the tip of your tongue, and work me up to wanting more."

I tried just barely making contact and Susan moaned, letting me know I was doing better. I resumed stroking her g-spot lightly, thrusting my finger in and out a little.

"Oooh, yeah, I like that," she said. "A little more time on the clit, but still gentle," she said.

I complied, doubling the amount of time I spent licking her clit, before circling back to lick the length of her lips and back. When I returned to her clit, she put her hand on the back of my head to let me know not to leave again, then whispered, "A little harder."

I continued licking around or over her clit, as she asked for increases in intensity or duration several times, as well as asking for a second finger. She was panting, thrusting her hips. When she screamed and her pussy walls spasmed around the two fingers I had in her, I knew she was cumming. I increased my tongue action. Her orgasm seemed to intensify, her body shaking under me, until she slumped and she pushed my face away, saying, "Sensitive, enough." I withdrew my fingers, and crawled up beside her.

She kissed me, before I could ask her whether her own flavor bothered her. She pulled back, and looked me in the eyes and asked, "That was really your first time licking pussy?"

I nodded, and asked, "Did... did I do good?"

"Mmmmm, yeah," she answered. She reached down, and grabbed my dick. "Now for the main event. Are you ready to give me your virginity? I'm on the pill, so don't worry about a condom."

"Gawd, yes." I momentarily felt shame at lying to her, but I couldn't deny wanting her badly.

"I want to be on top," she said. "I've been told I'm a bit small inside, so I like to control how deep a guy goes the first few times we're together."

"You think... you think I'll say no?" I got flat on my back, as Susan straddled me. Her curly, black hair surrounded my face, as she reached between us to take my cock in hand, lining me up.

She felt so much tighter than Wendy! But all of the extra juiciness from my saliva and her own excretions made it fairly easy for me to slide inside and soon she was pressed against my pubes. She kissed me again, trading tongues. I supported her upper body by holding onto her breasts and playing with her nipples, as she began rising and falling onto my cock.

"You can thrust your hips up into me, too," she suggested. I'd been holding off on doing that, not wanting to seem too experienced, but was soon slamming up into her on each of her downstrokes. I felt her start to shake again, amazed that she'd come again so soon. I was just beginning to feel the beginnings of my orgasm.

"Oh, you're the perfect length for me," she said, when she settled down. "Why did we wait so long to do this, again?"

"I was too scared to make a move?" I suggested. "I didn't know you wanted - " She cut me off with another kiss.

"I want," she said. "I want you, to fuck the hell out of me right now."

I did my best, thrusting into her faster and faster, squeezing her nipples, as we both went into oxygen debt, panting like crazy. Just as I felt myself start to cum, I pulled both of her nipples away from her chest, and squeezed them, probably too hard, as she screamed, but she also came once more, as I shot stream after stream of cum into her.

Gasping for breath, we held each other, as she lay atop me, her thick, curly hair all around us. I ran my hands around her back, as she continued having little shudders from the contact, then my cock slipped out of her.

Confession time. "So, about Wendy?" I began.

"Yeah? About why you turned her down?"

"Not exactly," I admitted. "It's about how I didn't turn her down, but asked her to say I did. And why I'm going to ask you to do the same, for a little while longer. I can even offer $150 as incentive." I'd taken $300 out at the ATM, thinking I'd need $100 for each of the first three girls to buy their silence until I got to the fourth, but since Wendy had passed on it, I could split it up two ways instead of three.

"You mean, I wasn't your first after all?" she asked, a little anger to her voice.

"Don't be mad at me, Susan. I only asked Wendy to be quiet so I'd have a chance to be with you, too, instead of Jasper's stupid bet being over. I know that if I had to go back to being the one to make the first move, I never would. I really wanted this with you before we graduated and I might never get another chance. Can you forgive me?"

"And now you want me to be quiet so you get a shot at Dani and Colleen, too?" she asked.

"Yes. Is that so wrong? More wrong than accepting a bet or bribe to take my virginity, something I was always willing, but dumb-fucked unable to do on my own? If I'd just been a normal guy, I bet I would have dated all four of you by now. I'm just trying to get caught up a little."

She said, "A normal guy wouldn't have made such a great study buddy, Kurt. So, I'm glad you're not a normal guy, and could be such a good friend to me, instead. I can accept being your second lover, and yes, I'll keep quiet. On one condition."

"And what would that be?"

"You can keep the money, but I want a couple more nights with you, after Dani and Colleen are done with you, one before finals, and one before graduation,"

I could only chuckle, which made her glower at me. "What's so funny?"

"Wendy asked for the exact same thing. Guess I'm going to be busy between now and Graduation."

"Oh, she did, did she?" Susan asked, before pulling her covers over us and snuggling in tight against me. We soon fell asleep.

~~~~~

I awoke in the morning, when Wendy snuck into the room she shared with Susan to get some clothes, before an 8 AM class. Susan didn't wake and I blew Wendy a kiss, which got me a smile. I hoped Colleen or Dani didn't know I was in Susan's bed. I knew they also had 8 AM classes, so I waited until 8:05 to shake Susan awake so I could give her a proper goodbye, then snuck back to my own apartment.

I ran right into Tom and Dave, who were having cereal for breakfast.

"Where did you spend the night, Kurt?" Tom asked, grinning, clearly expecting any answer but the one I gave him.

"Fell asleep studying with Susan. She let me sleep in her bed," Well, it was partly true.

Tom and Dave exchanged the most transparent looks and I had to force myself not to laugh or smile. As much as I appreciated their concern for me, it served them right for plotting behind my back.

I said, "Got to get ready for my 9:30 class," and headed for the bathroom to grab a shower.

~~~~~

Colleen and Dani, both asked me to study with them Wednesday night. I wondered how they were going to peel one of them off so the other could seduce me.

They could nearly have been twins, two brunettes with similarly short hair styles, petite figures both at 5'2", the distinguishing difference being Colleen's pixie nose, and a slight elvish look to her left ear, where there was apparently a quirk to the cartilage that made that ear look pointy.

They had started out Freshman year with Colleen as Wendy's roommate, and Dani as Susan's, but they bonded over a history of being football cheerleaders at competing High Schools in our city. The girls swapped roommates the following year, and the four were in the same apartments Junior year and now.

They were also the girls most likely to be caught sneaking out of all three of my roommates' rooms in the mornings, over the past four years. Why they never seemed to couple up with one of them, I didn't know.

I shouldn't have bothered wondering which of them would pursue me next, because the two decided to double-team me from the beginning.

I almost froze when Colleen kissed me on the mouth while Dani began licking my ear, then I let go and allowed them to take charge, as they both pulled me into their bedroom.

It would have been a tight fit on the bed if we'd tried to lie side by side, but I was soon on my back, with Dani riding my cock, while Colleen rode my mouth. I was a little surprised that Dani's pussy was not quite as tight as Susan's, even though she was an inch shorter, but I was sure not going to complain about it. I let them give me direction here and there, still trying to look like I had no experience, instead of just being less experienced than my roommates. Colleen's flavor was a bit tangier than Susan's was, her clit a little bit harder to find, but her reactions once I did were explosive, coating my face with her cream, squeezing me between tight thighs.

"Oh, gawd, Kurt, I think I love your tongue," Colleen said. "You get a bit more experience and you could have any woman on campus." I just continued licking, adding a finger into her when she asked, as I felt my orgasm getting closer. I focused on thrusting up into Dani as she began moaning louder and louder. I grabbed onto her hips, upped my pace as I lost control and came into her, just as her own orgasm started. I kept thrusting as long as I could, as she screamed and jerked over me.

Dani fell to my side and Colleen hopped off of me, to get into a 69 with her, while I watched, my erection returning in record time. Colleen looked up, licking some of my cum off of her lips, saying, "Would you like to learn doggy style, Kurt? Get behind me, and put that cock to good use."

I knelt behind her, tempted to just watch Dani's tongue dance across Colleen's pussy, wanting to learn more, when Colleen wiggled her hips at me. When I fumbled a bit trying to line myself up with Colleen's opening, Dani helped me, then licked at my underside as I slid into my last pussy of the four.

The sensation of having a tongue and pussy caressing my cock at the same time was yet another new one. I really didn't last as long as I had hoped to. The girls didn't seem to mind, as Dani burrowed her tongue into Colleen as soon as I withdrew, seeking her share of my cum. I just continued to watch, in awe at the Sapphic display in front of me.

They orgasmed simultaneously, then came after me one more time, kissing me, giving me plenty of compliments, before we lay down together on the bed, pretty much covering every inch.

"Time for us all to come clean, ladies," I said, as Colleen cuddled behind me, and Dani in front of me.

"About what?" Dani asked.

I answered, "I've known about the bet since the beginning. I overheard the whole thing through Wendy's window the day it began."

They started laughing. "What's so funny?" I asked.

Colleen pinched my earlobe, then said, "That wasn't the real beginning, Kurt, and you were meant to hear what you did. We were waiting until we saw you walking up the path, before we all went into our act."

"Hunh?"

She said, "This was all Wendy's idea, from the beginning, to take you to bed as a thank you for helping her so much these last four years. She's the one who wanted to make sure you didn't leave college a virgin, so she arranged the whole thing. From your roommates suggesting that you get a prostitute, knowing you'd say no, to letting you overhear about the fake bet. She thought that if she tried to approach you normally, that you'd get scared off. But if you thought it was all a secret plan to get you laid arranged by your roommates, you'd have some time to adjust to the idea, and let her take the lead. The whole idea was for her to win the bet. And it worked, too, didn't it? Of course, she didn't expect you to then want all of us. But, she realized when you asked her to be quiet about it that we all had just as much to thank you for as she did, if not more. You kept me from failing two courses that I know of, and Dani another, not just getting me to a D, but to a B and C. Susan has wanted you from the first day we met you as Freshmen, but she's a lot more like you than you realize, unable to take the initiative with a guy. She's better when she's pursued, but you were always the one she wanted to do it, and you didn't."

"I wish I could have..." I said.

"It's okay, Kurt, we love you anyway," she said, tousling my hair.

Colleen leaned away from me as Dani picked up the thread, "So, when Wendy told us that you were expecting us all to make our move with you, it took us each only ten seconds to agree to it. We let Susan go next and I'll tell you it was only finding out from Wendy that you wanted her too that let her play her part. She would have been too scared, otherwise. She also had a hard time pretending to be mad at you when you revealed that you'd had sex with Wendy first, since she already knew it. Colleen and I decided to do you together since we couldn't decide between us who should go actually go last. We thought it might be easier to get you to go along with a threesome if you had Wendy and Susan before us. Besides, that let us be another first for you, your first threesome. Susan got to be the first pussy you licked, so I think it worked out well for all of us."

At that moment, the door to their bedroom opened. In walked Wendy and Susan, in rather sheer nightgowns, and they sat down on the other bed. "Hey, boyfriend," Wendy said. "Colleen sent us the all clear."

Colleen waved the cell phone that had apparently been on the window sill next to the bed.

"Are you mad at us? At me?" Wendy asked, looking scared for my answer.

"Why would you think that?" I reassured her, pushing myself up on one elbow so I could see over Dani. Somehow, being naked actually helped me keep my guard down. "These last few nights have... have fulfilled every fantasy I ever had about the four of you since we first met, but could never make come true on my own. If I had graduated and only made love with one of you, it still would have been more than I expected to happen. Somehow the four of you agree amongst yourselves to share me for a few days, while letting me think it was somehow all my idea, and I'm supposed to be mad?"

Wendy and Susan both relaxed, then Wendy asked, "I don't want to put you on the spot, but if you had only been allowed to have one of us, who would you have wanted it to be?"

I knew the right answer immediately. "You, Wendy. It's always been you. I... I love you." Why did it still have to be so hard to say? "I think I always have and needed this experience to show me that."

"I love you too, Kurt," Wendy said, a tear sliding down her cheek into the corner of her mouth, where she instinctively licked it away. "You do still have promises to keep, you know. You promised Susan and I both two more nights before we graduate," Wendy said. When I looked over to Susan, she was trembling.

I hopped right over Dani, not caring that I was still nude, and sat beside Susan on the empty space on the bed, with Wendy on her other side. "What's wrong, Susan?"

She turned and buried her face in my shoulder, sobbing. I looked over her to Wendy, who mouthed the words, "She loves you, too, dummy." Oh, gawd. I had just professed my love to Wendy in front of Susan, having learned mere minutes before that she had harbored an attraction for me since we were Freshmen. Damn, I can be dense sometimes.