Ho Ho Ho for the Holidays

I heard Matt open the door and greet Becca. He kissed her on the cheeks and took her coat. Heart in my throat, I walked down the stairs. "Hi Becca."

"Do I know you? You look familiar, but I can't quite place it. Where's Brad?"

"I'm Brad's cousin, Holly. From up North. He's kind of in a really bad way right now. He's just devastated, you know."

Becca sighed. "He really hurt me. Even though Stacey confessed everything to me, it still hurt. Maybe I over-reacted."

I handed her a little box. "It's Christmas Eve, and Brad said you always open his gift a day early. He told me he wants you to have this, even if you never see him again." She opened the box and gasped at the ring. It wasn't the biggest diamond in the world, but it was the best I had been able to afford. Even before her mom's hints, I knew she was the one for me.

Becca sat there somewhat stupefied until Matt broke her trance. He put his arm around her, and she leaned in to him. "I don't know Matt. I just don't know what to do. I love Brad, but he fucked my sister. While I was in the next room. I want to move past that, but I keep coming back to it."

I looked in her eyes, and felt an upswell of emotion. I wanted to hold her, to comfort her, but she didn't even know it was me. I reached out and stroked her hair. She pulled away for a second, then let me. This always calmed her when she was upset. I snuggled in close, letting her cry silently against my chest. The three of us just sat there a moment, letting the emotion drain out of Becca. "Shit, my mascara has got to be running all over your blouse." I dabbed at her eyes with a Kleenex. "It's ok, baby. Matt will like it better when I take it off anyway." She laughed her adorable little laugh. Without thinking, I kissed her lightly.

She stopped, then put her arms around me. "Oh, Holly. You feel so comfortable. I could just snuggle all night." She breathed in deeply. "Do I smell peppermint?"

I laughed nervously. "Oh, yeah. That's me. You can stay in my arms all night if you want. I'm sure Matt won't mind sharing the bed." She looked up at me, startled.

"You mean...but wouldn't Brad be mad if I did things with his cousin and his frat brother?"

"I'm pretty sure he'd understand." I kissed her deeply, her breasts pressed against mine and I could feel my pussy lubricating. I took her hand in mine and led her up to the bed. Matt followed behind quietly.

I kept kissing Becca, and she melted. I stripped her half naked, and then took Matt's pants off. I started playing with his cock, which was already hard. "No anal. I'm saving that for Brad," Becca murmured as she kissed Matt's cock. Matt moaned as the two of us began licking and sucking his massive hard on. I kissed Matt's ear and whispered "Fuck her good. I want to lick your cum out of her pussy." I lay next to Becca, kissing her as Matt entered her. I played with her tits, sucking on her nipples as she moaned. She tasted so good, and I loved watching the look on her face as Matt began thrusting. She was so beautiful. Matt's fingers began invading my pussy, and I held Becca's hand as he pleasured us both. They came hard together, and I kissed both deeply. As Matt pulled out, I licked up and down his shaft, then turned to Becca's creampie. She grabbed my hair, and I stuck my tongue deep inside her. I love the taste of their cum together. I kissed my way up to her lips, and began to grind my pussy on hers. Matt pushed into my pussy, pining me against Becca. I came hard, and that pushed Matt over the edge, and he filled my pussy. I was too horny to care. We kept kissing back and forth, until sleep took us all.

I woke to Becca stirring next to me. I kissed her, and she sleepily said "Oh, Brad, I had the most wonderful time." Then she sat up with a start. "Brad, why are you naked in bed with me and Matt? And where's Holly?"

I startled, and reached between my legs. Sure enough, my cock was there, and rock hard in the pile of naked bodies. "Becca, I'm so sorry about everything. I love you. Will you marry me?" Matt rolled over and kissed my hand. "Holly, you sure got hairy." He opened his eyes and looked at me. "Back to normal, bud?"

"I think?" Becca got very confused. "I will do my best to explain. How about some breakfast?" Matt started cooking as Becca and I found clothes. I grabbed some eggnog as I tried to explain the whole ordeal.

"So, you blew Santa Claus, became a woman, and now you're a man again?"

"It makes no sense. Also, I can't seem to lay off the eggnog." I finished the glass and kissed Becca. She was wearing the ring.

"This has been so weird, Matt. All the things we did...I still want to do some of them. It's like I can still feel my pussy getting wet watching you cook. Why is a man who can cook such a turn on, Becca?"

"Oh, fuck, Holly? Shit, I get my boyfriend back for like an hour, and I don't even get to fuck him?"

Matt looked thoughtful. "Holly, you said Santa tasted like eggnog? And you've pretty much been buzzed on it the whole time you've been..."

"A ho, ho, ho..." I laughed, then caught on. "You think it's the eggnog? I didn't have any yesterday, and I changed back. Then I had some, and instant hottie. God, you're so smart."

"So, now what?" Becca finally asked.

"Becca, I love you and want to marry you. And Matt, you have been amazing. Not just all the sex with that incredible cock of yours, but you've been so supportive and smart and caring. God, I don't want that to stop. Even if I was just Brad, I don't know that I wouldn't want to keep sharing this whatever it is. Let's just go with this, and see what happens."

Matt looked at me, and at Becca who was holding my hand. "So, I go from no girlfriends to two, both of whom are smoking hot, except sometimes one is a guy? I think I can work with that. I'll just have to keep making the eggnog."