I'll Take The Uglier One

"Fuck you," Nicole replied. Alice grabbed her blouse and pulled, ripping off all of the buttons and exposing her lacy white bra. "You bitch!" Screamed Nicole, and with a tremendous effort threw Alice off of her. Alice landed on her back and Nicole quickly leapt onto her, grabbing her flowery blouse and pulling until all of her buttons popped off as well.

"Ugh!" Screamed Alice, seemingly too angry for words. She grabbed Nicole's blouse, and the two of them began to pull on each other's tops until they had pulled them off. They grabbed each other and began to wrestle again, now clad in only their bras. They ended up in a mutual bear hug on the floor, and I realized that they were both trying to undo each other's bras from behind. They were both women, you'd think it would be easy for them. For a few moments I was amused at how much trouble they were having. They managed to unclasp them at pretty much the same time, and began to try to pull them off. Alice rolled on top of Nicole and pulled at her lacy white bra until she got it around Nicole's arms and off. Nicole was pulling down at Alice's bra, her big blue bra, and managed to pull it off a second later. Once they were both topless, Alice threw herself down on top of Nicole and they began to wrestle again, naked breasts crushed against each other. Watching them strip each other made me aroused, but I was too preoccupied with being vigilant making sure they didn't hurt each other to pay any attention to my arousal.

They weren't wasting any time, already going for each other's skirts. Alice grabbed a hold of Nicole's long brown skirt and began to slide down Nicole's body as she pulled it off. Alice dodged Nicole's kicks as she pulled her skirt completely off, and then grabbed and pulled off her sandals for good measure.

Now Nicole was left wearing only her customary white cotton panties. With a grunt she threw herself at Alice, knocking her backward onto the floor. Nicole grabbed Alice's skirt and pulled it off of her in one swift motion, and also pulled off her sandals. Alice didn't even struggle; she just let Nicole undress her until she was left wearing a blue thong.

Alice sat up and she and Nicole stared at each other. "Slut," Alice said.

"Prude," Nicole replied, but neither of them sounded angry anymore. They grabbed each other and began to wrestle on the floor again, but now that they were nearly naked it was much more sensual. Their naked breasts pressed against each other, and their legs intertwined. As they rolled back and forth, whoever would wind up on top would begin to grind their hips into the other one. Eventually Alice wound up on top, pinning Nicole's arms behind her, rubbing her body back and forth along Nicole's. Alice took great care in lining up their nipples and brushing them lightly across each other. Alice looked deep into Nicole's eyes, and then kissed her.

I breathed a sigh of relief. It looked like they weren't going to kill each other. They weren't done 'fighting', though.

"I still say I'm hotter than you are," Alice said after she broke the kiss.

"Bullshit," Nicole said, "I'm way hotter than you."

"I bet I can make you cum first," Alice said.

"You're on," Nicole said. Without another word, Alice and Nicole got up off the floor and headed for the bedroom. I followed close behind them. When they reached the bedroom they stripped off their panties and climbed up onto the bed, completely naked. They arranged themselves in a scissors position and began to grind their mounds against each other. It was something I had seen them do with each other several times before, but this time they insulted and taunted each other as they tribbed.

"Can you feel my clit fucking yours?" Nicole asked.

"My clit is going to dominate yours," Alice replied.

"Admit it, I'm hotter than you are," Nicole said.

"I'm hotter than you, slut," Alice said.

"Prude," Nicole said. After a few minutes the taunting gave way to gasps and grunts and they got more turned on. In the meantime I had stripped out of my clothes and was now stroking my hard cock.

Suddenly Alice leaned forward and pushed Nicole back down onto the bed. She held Nicole down with one hand and began to aggressively finger fuck her, sticking three fingers into my girlfriend's pussy. I know how competitive Nicole is, but she was also a sexual dynamo, and was really turned on by how aggressive Alice was being.

"Ugh... ugh... oh my god... fuck me... yes... I'm coming!" Nicole screamed as her orgasm hit her. Her orgasm seemed to go on and on... my multi-orgasmic girlfriend probably came two or three times in quick succession as Alice continued to finger-fuck her mercilessly. She finally relented and let go of Nicole.

"Who's the better woman, slut?" Alice asked.

Nicole looked up at Alice, almost dreamily. "You are," Nicole said.

Alice smiled. "Don't ever forget it," she said, and without another word climbed up on Nicole and perched on her face, lowering her pussy to Nicole's face. "Now eat me like a good little slut," she said.

I never saw Alice act like this before. It was quite a turn-on. I found myself moving around the bed, trying to get the best view of Alice riding Nicole's face. Alice reached back with her hand and tweaked Nicole's nipples as she continued to taunt her, the very picture of a dominatrix. "Lick my clit, slut," Alice said, "Suck my cunt... yeah... just like that... that's my good little slut." It went on for quite a while, Alice taking her time reaching her orgasm. I was trying to hold off, myself, trying to ignore my aching, tingling cock because I was close to the edge. I don't know what I was waiting for, but I held off.

Alice's orgasm was approaching, and I could tell it was going to be a big one. Her whole body started shaking. "Oh yeah, I'm gonna cum all over your face. Lick my clit... lick it... ugh... ugh... ugh... ugh... UGH!!!" Alice fell forward, using her hand to brace herself against the wall as she shook from wave after wave of orgasm. Finally Alice was done, and rolled off of Nicole to lie beside her on the bed. Nobody said anything for several seconds. They were both trying to catch their breath. You could see how wet Nicole's face was from having Alice cumming on it. Both of them started lightly stroking themselves, Alice from her afterglow, and Nicole from her arousal at being used by Alice like she was.

Alice leaned over and kissed Nicole. "Did you like that, slut?" She asked, but she said it playfully.

"Mmm... that was great," Nicole said.

"Who's the better woman?" Alice asked.

"You are," Nicole said dreamily.

Alice looked over at me. I was holding my cock. I think she could tell how engorged and close to cumming I was. "You," she said to me. "I want you to shoot your load on Nicole. I want her covered in cum."

I looked over at Nicole. She didn't look like she was going to protest. I climbed up onto the bed and positioned myself between Nicole's legs. I gazed down at her naked body and her face covered in Alice's juices. I was so turned on it wasn't going to take me long. "Do it," Alice said, "Cum on her tits."

I grabbed myself and started stroking. It probably didn't take me 30 seconds to cum. I shot my load onto Nicole, the first spurt landing right between her breasts, the second and third by her belly button. I fell back on my haunches, spent.

Alice wasn't done ordering us around. "Now lick him clean," Alice said. Nicole obliged, leaning forward and taking my cock in her mouth, cleaning the remaining cum off of the tip of my cock with her tongue. When she was done she plopped back onto the bed, streaks of my cum dribbling down her torso. I was still rock hard, wondering what Alice was going to do next.

Alice rolled over and reached into the nightstand drawer where I knew Nicole kept all of her 'sexual' stuff. She rummaged around and pulled out a condom. "Tonight is your lucky night," Alice said to me, "You're finally going to get to fuck a real woman." She tossed the condom to me. "Put this on," Alice said, leaning back on the bed, "You're going to fuck me while this slut watches us, covered in our cum."

I looked at Nicole. I didn't expect her to object. She had all but insisted that Alice share me, so I knew it wouldn't bother her. I was just shocked at Alice's behavior, but turned on by it all the same. I put on the condom and climbed on top of Alice. I went to kiss her but she reached out a hand to block my face. "Just fuck me, stud," she said.

I entered Alice easily. She was very wet from grinding her face on Nicole. She was also... how should I say it... roomier than Nicole. Nicole had a tight pussy, and we fit together fairly well. Alice was looser, and I felt myself sliding around inside of her. I had just had an orgasm, so it was going to take me a while to work my way to another one.

Alice seemed to be enjoying herself, a little too much to be believed, really. "Oh, yeah," Alice moaned, "Fuck me, stud. Fuck me with that rock hard cock. Fuck me while your girlfriend watches." I looked over at Nicole. She was watching us with her left hand between her legs. Her face was still glistening from Alice's juices and my cum was still visible on her torso. I guess I wanted to make sure she was still okay with me fucking Alice. Nicole winked at me, and I smiled at her.

"Don't look at that slut!" Alice shouted. "Look at me! It's my cock now," Alice said. She reached up and pushed me over, knocking me into Nicole. She climbed on top of me and lined herself up with my cock. She slid into me and began to ride me. "Oh yeah," Alice said, "Now I'm in control."

I watched her bounce up and down on me a few times. "Squeeze my tits," Alice commanded, and I reached up and grabbed her enormous breasts that were bouncing above my head. She would alternate between bouncing straight up and down and leaning over me while I tried to keep my hands on her breasts. Alice was using one hand to steady herself, and reached back with the other to stroke her clit as she rode me. "Do you feel that?" Alice asked. "Do you feel my pussy eating your cock?"

"Yeah," I said.

"Am I the hottest woman you've ever fucked?" Alice asked.

"Yeah," I said.

Hearing that seemed to push Alice over the edge. She began to shake, her whole body trembling as she orgasmed. "Oh my God," she said, "Fuck me with that big, hard cock." Then she seemed to take things over the top. "Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes!" She cried, and fell against me. I looked over at Nicole, who was looking back at me, bemused.

Alice seemed to be done, but I wasn't. I rolled her over and continued to pound away at her pussy. Alice moaned and wrapped her legs around me. I pushed myself into her as deeply as I could go and kept fucking her for all I was worth. I could feel my orgasm building, and I knew that I didn't need to hold back. I grunted and shot my second load in fifteen minutes into Alice's pussy. Alice bucked her hips in an aftershock as I climaxed into her. I fell against her, spent. Beside me I could hear Nicole whimpering as she frigged herself to orgasm.

We were all silent for a while, recovering from our wild sexual escapades. I was lying against Alice, facing Nicole. She turned to me and we kissed. I could taste Alice's pussy on Nicole's lips. My cock was still inside Alice. I lifted myself up to look at Alice and found that she was crying.

"What's wrong?" I asked.

"I don't know what came over me," Alice said, and she sobbed, "I was so mean to both of you, I'm so sorry!"

"Don't be sorry," Nicole said, "You were amazing! You've got a real future as a dominatrix."

Alice tried to laugh through her tears, "You really think so?" She asked.

Nicole gently nudged me off of Alice so that she could comfort her. She wrapped her arms around her and kissed her on the cheek. "You can dominate me anytime, honey," she said.

"It's just that... it's just that... I love you!" Alice wailed.

"Oh, I love you too!" Nicole said, and she started crying too.

I watched them, crying and kissing each other, and part of me went cold. What was my role in all of this? Nicole and I had been together nearly six months and we hadn't said we loved each other, yet. To be honest, I wasn't sure I was ready to be in love again. In some ways I was still getting over my marriage, but in a lot of ways Nicole was the woman I was hoping that I would find. I thought about saying, "I love you both!" And throwing myself on top of them, but in the end I let them have their moment.

Eventually Nicole looked up and saw me watching them. "You don't feel left out, do you?" She asked. "We put on this whole show for you."

"You did?" I asked.

"Well, yeah," Nicole said, "Most of it, anyway. The other night when it was just me and Alice we went on the internet and looked at some cat fighting and sex fighting stories and videos. It turned us both on. We had pretty good sex afterwards. We were actually planning to buy a kiddie pool and a bottle of baby oil, strip naked, and wrestle for you, but that drunk at the restaurant gave us the idea to stage a fight over who was uglier. Luckily you lagged behind us so that we could quickly work out the details before you got here. The sex fight was planned. The part where Alice dominated me and then had you fuck her while I watched, that was improvised."

"Well, it was quite a performance," I said, "Thank you both." I leaned over and kissed Nicole, and then Alice.

"And Fred," Nicole said after the kiss, "I love you too."

Forget everything I was just thinking about not being ready for it. Hearing Nicole say that made me so happy. "I love you too," I said, and we kissed again.

"Can we stay like this forever?" Nicole asked. "I mean, the three of us, together?"

"I wouldn't complain," I said quickly.

We both looked at Alice. She was looking back and forth at me and Nicole as we hovered over her. "I can't promise forever," Alice said, "Fred is the first man I've been with in years. I was with a couple of men when I was younger, and they were awful assholes. Cheaters, lousy in bed, treated me like shit. Fred, you make me want to find a man like you for myself, and I can't promise that I won't someday. Until then, I would be happy to share Nicole with you, and you with Nicole."

"Okay," Nicole said, and we all traded kisses.

"Nicole," Alice said suddenly, "You're covered in cum! How did you get like that?" We all laughed.

The end?