Love Like a Blue Shell Pt. 03

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

Zach shrugged as if to say, yeah, well, what else is new?

*

Tim was surprised as everyone returned to their seats. He thought for sure he was losing at least Zoe and Paige. Instead, well, things were about to get interesting.

Courtney won the next race which meant that she was now tied with Tim for the lead at two wins apiece. Paige and Zach undid their belts, and Zoe lifted off her preppy little sweater. It revealed nothing, just a white dress shirt. Yet it seemed monumental in the moment.

After all the arguing, with the threat of real nudity was on the table now, Tim expected the room to get somber. Instead everything seemed to lighten. People started laughing, teasing. It felt like a real game again. And slowly, the clothes began to slip away. Tim stopped really paying attention as the races ran by and just watched the girls got naked.

First Courtney slid off her stockings. She did it slow, like a striptease, rolling down the sheer material to reveal her pink, freckly legs. Then Paige lost her shirt and did the same, though it was a bit less sexy what with her wearing a Super Mario t-shirt. Paige might have been the youngest - she was only 20, Tim remembered - but she looked like she could easily have the largest breasts in the room.

Then Zoe unbuttoned her shirt and showed off a nice, conservative cut black bra. Her breasts were a little small for her build, so probably about as big as Paige's.

Taylor took off her pants next and Tim noticed the boys all staring at his girlfriend's perfect, heart-shaped ass. Courtney lost her top soon after. She seemed to be wearing the same green bra as last time - for good luck, perhaps?

Tim was enjoying the women so much, he almost forgot he was supposed to be racing. That lack of attention cost Tim his slim lead, along with his shirt and pants. At this point he was almost more comfortable sitting around in only his boxers, anyway.

Colin quickly joined Tim in underwear-hood, as did Zach. Tim didn't want to focus on his friend's physique too much, but he couldn't help but notice that Zach looked way more toned than he had back in college. Zach was a big guy and while he wasn't fat, he hadn't exactly stayed in shape either. Now though, Zach looked like someone who spent time at the gym. The other girls seemed to appreciate Zach's new body, as well. For the first time ever, Tim thought maybe he should start working out.

Tim heard his phone buzzing so he reached down to pick it up. There was a text from Sydney waiting for him. He quickly covered the screen and looked.

Syd: Hey, how's the party going?

Tim looked around the room and smiled. The beautiful blonde said more in text than she ever did when speaking. It was nice, actually, like getting to share a secret part of her.

Tim: Doing OK. Everyone misses you, though

Syd: Yeah sure.

Tim: No one here as beautiful as you

Syd: Not even Taylor?

Tim looked over at his girlfriend. She was focused on her race and didn't see him staring.

Tim: No.

Syd: You're sweet. I'll be there next time, I promise.

Tim: K

She didn't write anything more. He put the phone down. Then he heard it buzz.

Syd: I miss you.

Tim smiled. He wrote back that he missed her too and then deleted the whole conversation. He wanted to read that "miss you" over and over, but he knew it was safer this way.

When he finished texting, Tim realized it was time for what had become his favorite part of the game: the point where the girls had to decide whether to take off their bra or remove their pants. Either way, Tim thought, he was a winner.

It all happened in one race. Taylor took her first win, preserving her privates for another day, but Courtney, Zoe, and Paige all lost. Paige took off her jeans first, revealing plain white underwear that was very sexy in its simplicity. She smiled widely as she sat back down, clearly having more fun than she was supposed to.

Courtney shucked her skirt next. Tim wasn't surprised to see that her green panties had returned, as well. She saw him looking and gave him a little smile.

Zoe, however, was a bit of a surprise. She slid her pants off and revealed a dark black thong. She gestured to the room as if to say 'happy now?' which of course everyone was. Even better, Tim noticed a bit of wet patch at Zoe's center. All this time she was pretending to be offended, yet there it was for all to see. Zoe was just as "immature" as everyone else.

"Yeah, yeah, yeah," she said and flopped back down into her seat.

By that point, Colin and Zach had both collected three wins. If either won their next race, they'd take the first round. Sure enough, Zach took the flag and the number one seed. With everyone now in underwear only, it was time to move on to far more exciting competition.

*

The group took a bathroom/drinking break while Taylor figured out the next round of racing. Colin leaned against the kitchen counter - mostly so he could drink and listen in on other conversations.

"Yes," Zoe said to Taylor, "I have to admit I'm having fun."

"You look really good," Courtney said to Zach, "Have you been working out?"

Colin felt a little uncomfortable watching his naked wife flirt with his naked friend. But then, wasn't he enjoying the view of Taylor just as much? The lithe brunette was amazing. Her body just seemed built for sex somehow. Colin kept thinking back to a month before ("Mine. Mine only."). He couldn't help but desire a repeat.

Then there was Zoe - he'd never liked the girl, but he had to admit she was pretty hot. Tall with defined calves and a flat stomach. Eye-catching breasts and bottom. He imagined her glaring at him while she stroked him off. Well Colin could kind of see the attraction in that.

And of course, Courtney was there, too. His wife looked good in her lucky green underwear. He still wanted her - wanted to be with her. But she seemed to be having so much fun, Colin was starting to wonder if she'd ever want to stop.

"Hey bro."

Colin looked up and saw Paige standing on the other side of the counter. He'd been trying to avoid looking at her all this time, yet there she was. Her eyes, big and brown. Her breasts, even bigger. Her perfect fucking bottom. Holy fuck. Colin had seen Paige in a bikini just that past summer but somehow this was so much more.

Colin tried to control himself. There was nothing wrong, inherently, with recognizing Paige was attractive. But Colin couldn't help but feel like he was doing something wrong. That was the real reason he was behind the counter. Every time he looked at his sister, he felt his cock jump a mile high. At this rate, it'd be six feet long by the end of the night. And he knew exactly where it was aiming. Dammit.

So Colin tried to focus on anything else but his little sis. Except here she was, staring right at him.

"Dude," she repeated, "Hello."

"Huh? Oh sorry," Colin said, "Lost in thought."

"Yeah, I'll bet. So now that I have your attention I'll ask again, what happens now?"

"Well, we keep racing and people start getting, y'know, naked. Well, naked-er, I guess."

"And what happens after that?"

"This is weird right?" Colin asked, "This is totally weird. I'm sorry. I never should have brought you here. I should have knocked you unconscious and run off before you woke up again."

"It's OK. I know you can't tell me no, Col. I was practically planning on that. So what happens after everyone is naked?"

"Well last time there were, ummm, favors."

Paige looked at him very seriously then. Like trying to read his mind.

"You don't have to do them or anything. I mean, I'm sure you and I wouldn't have to. You know."

"It's OK, big bro," Paige said, "But you sure do invite me to strange parties." As she walked away, God help him, Colin couldn't help but stare at his sister's amazing ass.

*

Taylor managed to get everyone's attention. She was back to doing her mostly-naked monologues. It really was much easier to get everyone's attention this way. Though Taylor had trouble focusing herself.

Zach's nearly bare body was quite the distraction. Whatever else Zoe was doing to that poor boy, she deserved credit for getting him to look like that. And of course it was nice to see Colin's goodies once again. With nearly-naked Tim out there as well, Taylor certainly wasn't spoiled for options.

Ahem.

"Here's how it works," she said, "Everyone is split into two groups based on how they finished. Group A is Zach, Courtney, and me. Group B is Colin, Tim, Zoe, and Paige. Everyone plays everyone in their group twice, plus the group of three will get a wild card from the other group to make it even. Because Zach has the best record, though, he doesn't have to deal with the wild cards - they just count as wins for him."

"This is really getting involved," Zach said.

"I know," Courtney said, "It's totally awesome, right?"

"If you beat someone who is clothed," Taylor said, "they just lose a piece of clothing. If they're naked, however, the winner can request a favor."

"So I can make Courtney do my... dishes?" Zach asked. The room broke into laughter. There was the old friend Taylor remembered! Who knew that taking off his clothes would get Zach to comeout of his shell.

"A favor within reason people," Taylor said, "Play nice."

She got a few scattered boos for that one. Play nice was not exactly the most limiting of rules, though, really. She assumed the party wouldn't go much farther than the previous one. Especially with the two newcomers and Colin's younger sister there. She didn't imagine either sibling wanted to see the other do much of anything.

Some innocent rubbing, mostly of themselves, and nothing more. Would someone go to oral? Maybe? Taylor just couldn't see it. So just some harmless exhibitionism, mostly. At most. That was plenty to feed her and Tim's bedroom fantasies without putting any relationships at risk. And really that was all anyone wanted.

*

The first race was Courtney and Zach. Because they were 'paired' in the race - and with everything else going on - Taylor couldn't help but imagine them, for a moment, as a couple. They would definitely be strange together and not just because Zach was nearly a full foot taller than Colin's auburn-haired spouse.

Courtney was so serious all the time and Zach, at least the Zach that Taylor remembered, was so jocular. Courtney worried about, well, almost everything. Nothing seemed to bother Zach, sometimes to a fault. If they got together, they'd probably murder each other, Taylor decided.

Zach's byes gave him a huge lead out of the gate- if he won here he'd have three wins banked before the races even started. Fortunately, Courtney beat him easily. Even more fortunately, Taylor thought almost giddily, that meant Zach's dong would be the first to come out.

Taylor waited for Zoe to say something. The whole room paused, but the statuesque, woman just smiled and gestured for Zach to get on with it. He dropped his boxer briefs and, to Taylor's delight, his erection popped right out.

He was long, longer than either Colin or Tim, but thinner than both. A tuft of brown hair surrounded everything. It was a nice dick, Taylor thought, proportional. She wondered what it might be like to try it some time.

Damn, this is getting out of control.

Zoe and Paige went next. They were from the other group and Taylor didn't think she'd be taking on either of them at the end. Plus it was girl/girl so Taylor didn't care nearly as much. Paige won and Zoe stepped out of her very skimpy panties. Her bush was trimmed down to a dark stripe, Taylor noticed. How very mature.

Now it was Taylor's turn. She had the wild card, which meant she was facing someone from the other group - in this case Colin. She'd been hanging back for this moment. Sydney had taught her well. Meanwhile, Taylor had figured out Wario who was tough on the corners but hella fast. Taylor was able to use that to her advantage and took the race, easily.

"Was wondering when the real Taylor would show up," Colin said. He seemed legitimately excited for her to do well, even though he'd lost. Always the gentleman, Colin, Taylor smirked - unless he was begging for her to make him cum.

Colin took off his boxer briefs and his penis flopped out. He too looked pretty hard, Taylor thought. She noticed he kept looking over at Paige, nervously. This had to be mortifying for him, Taylor thought.

For the last race, Colin had to go again - this time against Tim because of the wild card. It was still early, but the race had super high stakes. If Tim lost, then all the cocks would be accounted for. Taylor wanted to see her boyfriend come out and measure up, as well. The other girls had playfully oohed and ahhed at the other shlongs and competitive Taylor knew that her boy had the best.

On the other hand, if Tim won, then they would be up to the first favor since Colin was now completely naked. Taylor didn't think her boyfriend would pick anything risque, but still. She was earnest to see what would happen.

It was close, but Tim got lucky with weapons and took Colin out. Tim got to keep his underwear. He smiled wickedly.

"Colin, I order you to... take off Courtney's bra."

"Whoa, he can't do that!" Paige cried. But Taylor had seen this play out all before. She just nodded and agreed that Tim, indeed, could. Apparently she wasn't the only one who'd learned from past encounters. Courtney certainly wasn't complaining. Colin went over and deftly snapped open his young wife's bra. Courtney's pink, freckled tits bounced joyfully at their release.

Taylor had gotten over her own lack of assets but, seriously, why did everyone have to have bigger breasts than her?

"It's not fair," Paige said, still pouting.

"When you win you can make someone take off Tim's boxers," Taylor said.

"Good point," Paige said and smiled, clearly placated about the whole thing.

*

Tim knew it was coming. He was matched up against Paige the next round, who clearly didn't like how Tim had distributed his favor. She seemed particularly driven to take him down and sure enough, she did.

Tim was the last boy to take out his member and he got a nice bit of appreciation from all the girls, including a thumbs up from both Courtney and Taylor. It was all very gratifying.

The next race was Zach against Taylor which, Tim reflected, should have made him nervous. But by now it was old hat. If anything, he found he was anxious for things to move on. He'd seen most of these people naked and while the new players intrigued him, he anticipated far more interesting things were on the way.

Taylor took the race and asked for a kiss. Zach leaned over to reach her cheek but Taylor quickly corrected him.

"A real one," she said. Zach pressed his lips to hers - it was a little funny seeing him bend over to kiss her. Tim looked over at Zoe, but she looked rather dispassionate about it. She just smiled at Tim and shrugged.

Tim was beyond beating himself up over this. He thought it was hot watching Taylor kiss Zach, especially since she would be back in his own bed that night. Besides, Taylor had once again escalated the action with everyone else. Tim could hardly complain about that.

While the room recovered from watching Zoe's boyfriend kiss Tim's girlfriend (and it was no little peck on the lips, either, Tim could have sworn he saw Taylor's little tongue slip out of her mouth) Colin crushed Zoe. The tall, dark-haired woman didn't wait for Colin to say anything, she just quickly stripped off her bra.

As Tim had thought, Zoe had good-sized tits. Maybe a bit small for her body, but still lovely and pale like the rest of her, with the lightest of light-pink nipples. If there was any doubt, Zoe's breasts showed she was quite aroused. The little nubbins pointing proudly forward.

Since she'd done so during the kiss, Tim gave Zoe a little smile and a shrug. He was shocked when she smiled back, and squeezed her boob at him. They both laughed.

The last race of the round was Courtney's wild card. They picked randomly again and Tim got the honors. Luck stayed on his side and Courtney spent most of the race mired in fifth. Before it was even over, Courtney jumped up and started to slide down her panties, but Tim stopped her.

He got down on his knees and reached for her waistband. Then slowly he dragged the green briefs down, careful to nudge her sex with his nose. Courtney was still clean shaven, though Tim was surprised to see a bit of auburn stubble starting to show. Courtney smelled sweet and tangy. Maybe a bit headier than Taylor, though certainly quite pleasant. Tim thought about taking a quick taste before he stopped himself. As always, go too far now, you might lose the chance to go even farther, later on.

Instead Tim just breathed lightly on Courtney's intimate folds and was gratified when she gave a little shiver. The whole room seemed to exhale along with her.

Tim looked around the room, expecting some recriminations, but Colin gave him a little cheer and Taylor showed him the thumbs up. Instead it was Paige that was now staring Tim down. He couldn't imagine why, though. It seemed he'd made an enemy of Colin's cute little sister, though he couldn't imagine why.

*

Taylor watched her boyfriend strip Courtney's panties and was amazed at how much of a player he'd become. Where was the shy, nervous fellow from the first game months ago? This Tim was confident, sexy. Taylor couldn't wait to take her new Tim to bed.

Once again, Taylor had to admit that she was having fun. It seemed the rest of the room was, as well. Even Zoe and Paige - though Colin's little sis seemed less than pleased with how Tim chose to play the game.

Still, Taylor amazed at how something that should have destroyed her relationship had made it stronger. How it had taken her and Tim and made them better. She pictured writing the article for Cosmo: "How to fix your relationship and improve your sex life by cheating on your boyfriend!" She doubted that one would make it past the editors.

They were in a weird spot, game-wise: Zoe, Tim, Colin, and Zach were all completely naked. But Taylor and Paige both had their bra and panties on, which in this group felt almost like being completely clothed. As much as she enjoyed having a lead, Taylor was really hoping that things would keep moving and that meant she would have to get naked soon. The way both Colin and Zach had already been eyeing her, Taylor was pretty OK with that idea, anyway.

The group decided that since Zach got an automatic win for his wild card, he could demand a favor of anyone in that moment. To Taylor's delight, he smiled and gestured for her to remove her bra, which she happily did. Her little breasts did their best to bounce like the other girls' had, which wasn't all that much, sadly. The boys all seemed appreciative, however.

Next she had a race against Courtney. Taylor knew she could take down Colin's wife, but decided that her own nudity was worth sacrificing for the greater good in this case. So she missed a few easy turns and then 'reluctantly' stripped off her undies.

Taylor's only regret was that no one pulled them off the way Tim had done. However, that would have been Courtney's job and Taylor wasn't really feeling that. So now the only person in clothing was Paige, and even the 20-year-old could feel the conspiracy growing against her.

No surprise - when Tim beat Zoe, he told her to remove Paige's bra. At this point, the coed brunette didn't even complain. She just raised her arms to give Zoe easier access. The taller woman reached down and snapped Paige's bra off in one shot, revealing the girl's ample globes.

She was the youngest there, but her breasts were clearly the biggest. The guys all smiled at her, even Colin, but all Paige did was blush and quickly cover herself with her arms. She had to move, though, because she was racing her brother next.