Musical Dicks: A Sibling Fuck Story

"Come fuck her ass," Amber ordered the most recent nerd pulled from the game.

"Please, I've never had it back there," Sarah pleaded.

"Don't worry, we will have Brenda eat your asshole first and get it nice and ready," Amber said, glaring down at Brenda, waiting for the pledge to question her.

Brenda didn't.

"Go to Brenda, get on all fours and she can prepare that nice asshole for insertion," Amber ordered.

"Yes, Mistress," Becky obeyed, clearly nervous.

I watched in awe as the bitch Brenda stared at Becky's ass and then Sarah grabbed the back of her head and shoved it between Becky's ass cheeks and ordered, "Get eating, Fluffy."

I enjoyed the humiliation and undeniably sexy sight for a few seconds before the music again started.

I reluctantly pulled my eyes away and started walking in the circle again. I was getting close to my brother again, when the music stopped again rather quickly... just two cocks away from my brother. I watched Josie take my brother's cock in her mouth as I was pushed. I quickly realized I had been distracted by my brother and turned to see there was once again one cock left and two of us girls. Suddenly, in desperation to get that cock in my mouth, I pushed back the girl behind me hard, as she was about to take that eight inch cock in her mouth, and devoured it even as she tried to yank my arm.

"She pushed me," the girl protested as I bobbed five times on the nice cock.

Amber said, "All is fair in musical cocks. Unfortunately, Shannon, you have been eliminated."

"You fucking bitch," Shannon said, yanking my hair back hard just as I took my mouth off his cock.

"Sore loser," I retaliated, smirking at her as I stroked the nerd's cock slowly.

"Bitch," Shannon repeated.

"I've been told that before," I smiled, before I glanced over to my brother's cock. Fuck it was big. It was like the Mona Lisa of dicks: thick and long, with a slight up curve.

"Pick a dress," Amber ordered.

"Fine," Shannon said, still pissed at me.

Like Brenda, she choose a nice dress... not considering the consequences of that. In the end, one of the final few were likely to take that dress from her. Her dress was gold and seriously looked like the dress Belle wore in 'Beauty and the Beast'.

As usual, Sarah handed her an envelope.

Shannon opened it and read the rather vague order, "Fifth out, don't you pout. You'll be on your knees, eager to please."

I quipped, unable to resist, "That sounds like her daily ritual."

"You fucking bitch," Shannon snapped, starting to move towards me.

"Enough!" Amber said firmly. "Shannon stop having your hissy fits. Tiffany you only speak when spoken to."

"Sorry, Mistress," I apologized

Sarah explained, "Shannon, you will be taken to the Alpha Kappa Pi and be their glory hole cum deposit all night. You are allowed to use any of your three fuck holes you wish, but must retrieve every load offered until 3am."

"Oh, God," Shannon said, as she glared at me.

I just smiled my sweet smile. Although, it wasn't the worst punishment ever. I mean sure her jaw would be killing her, but if she saw a nice cock she could take it in her pussy or up her ass if she did that type of thing. It could be worse.

Sabrina was still licking the same senior, but Becky was now getting fucked in the ass. What made it hotter was the nerd would pull out every few strokes and shove it in Brenda's mouth. I was impressed with the confidence of these nerds... behind the geeky exteriors were a bunch of big cocks and confidence... the two things I found sexy as hell.

The music started and I walked past my brother's big cock again. Fuck, it was an amazing dick.

Amber explained, "The next round you will sit on the lap of the cock of your choice. No riding. Just enjoy the big dick in your slut box."

My cunt was burning, so this sounded delicious. A few others, though, they were more concerned. Some because they likely thought sex was special, some because these were still nerds. Giving a hand job, or a blow job was one thing... that was pretty much first or second date expectations... but fucking a nerd was a whole different thing.

I, on the other hand, was more than willing to do some charity fucking. Plus, every cock was impressive.

After the last couple of quick stops, this time the music played for a while. I passed my brother three times. Each time I couldn't help but stare at his cock. I also couldn't help but realize he had the biggest dick here.

There was a really good chance I would have to fuck him if I was to win.

As I pondered this, my cunt leaking ever so slightly, the music stopped. I turned around and easily devoured the nice, thick nerd dick right beside my brother. I moaned, as did many of my fellow pledges as their cunts were filled.

"Aaaah, poor Josie doesn't have a lap to sit on," Amber declared, acting dramatic.

This didn't surprise me. She was the most conservative girl here, an actual preacher's daughter. I'm guessing she didn't even try to win this one. Actually, in retrospect, I'm surprised she even did the previous few rounds... although the earlier tasks had prepared her for this.

Josie went and picked the simplest of the gowns. It was pink, straight and long. No one was going to take that away from her.

Sarah gave her an envelope.

Josie was even more nervous than the others. She opened the envelope, hands literally shaking, and pulled out the message. "You are number seven, time to take you to heaven."

The girls roared at the irony of the statement.

Josie looked confused at the ominous message.

Thus confusion remained, but became clear to me, when I saw a couple sophomore sorority sisters roll out the Sybian from yesterday.

"Get completely naked, but keep on the garter-belt and stockings," Amber ordered the shy girl, before adding, "and that will be an expectation for each of you when you lose from now on."

Josie didn't protest... she was clearly submissive... one of the impacts of a religious upbringing, even as her hands continued to tremble.

Once naked, and man she had a huge rack, Sarah took her hand and led her to the Sybian.

"Disgusting," Brenda said, from another part of the room. We all glanced over to see her with cum all over her face.

"You look better now," the nerd who just splattered his load all over her said.

"You asshole," Brenda snapped, still not learning her place.

Amber sighed. "The last two of you nerds pulled, you can use Fluffy as you wish."

"I get her ass," one nerd said.

"Let's dp the bitch," the other said.

"What? No!" Brenda protested.

Amber snapped, "How fucking dense are you? Tonight you do as you're fucking told. If they want to fuck your ass and cunt you let them. A skank like you has likely been dp'd before anyways."

"I'm out of here," Brenda said, standing up.

"You're welcome to leave, slut," Amber said calmly, "but remember we have video of you at the glory hole, of the other tasks and of tonight."

Brenda froze.

"So either leave and watch your past few days go viral," Amber said, not seeming to care either way, "or straddle that dick and take it in your ass."

"You're blackmailing me?" Brenda questioned.

"Call it blackmail, or call it a back-up plan in case you decide to do something stupid and rat out our traditions," Amber explained. She turned to all of us and explained, "We are sisters. Sisters fight. But sisters are loyal. If any of you betray the sisterhood then the sisterhood, will respond in full force. Be loyal to your sisters and the rewards are extensive."

Brenda's face paled. It was obvious she had finally caught on to her reality... as it was for all of us. Being a part of this sorority came at a price... but the rewards we also knew were bountiful.

A nerd had lay down and he ordered, "Come straddle me, bitch."

Brenda glared at him, but was completely defeated. She reluctantly moved to the nerd and awkwardly lowered herself on the nice cock.

The other nerd moved behind her, pushed her forward and lubed Brenda's anal entrance.

"Please go slow," Brenda pleaded, just as Josie moaned loudly.

"Oh, God," Josie moaned. I glanced back to see her cupping her breasts as the vibrations of the massive toy pleasured her.

"Noooo," Brenda cried. I turned back to watch as her ass was invaded.

"So tight," the nerd groaned, as he filled Brenda's ass.

I wanted to watch... I was enjoying the live porn show, but the music started.

I started walking, past my brother's cock, shiny with pussy juice wetness, as Amber said, "This time you will clean the pussy juice off the cock."

'Interesting,' I thought to myself, as I continued walking around big, hard, wet cocks.

As I did a full loop, I watched Brenda, who was now getting dp'd and making sounds of pleasure and pain.

"This time the music will stop when Josie has her first orgasm," Amber declared.

We kept walking in a circle, as Josie's moans kept increasing... her orgasm clearly imminent.

Brenda groaned, "Shit, slower."

I did another half lap, passing my brother's flagpole, when Josie screamed, "Oh, fuuuuuck."

The music stopped, and I quickly dropped to my knees and began sucking a nice cock, tasting the sweetness of the pussy that was recently on it.

"Oh God," the nerd I was sucking groaned.

"And Chelsea is out," Amber declared.

"Damn it," Chelsea cursed, as she went to the dresses. I sat up to see her choose an orange gown. It was quite nice and unique... although it was orange. I assumed she was safe. She would look like a cute pumpkin.

Wendy, another senior, handed Chelsea the number 18 envelope.

Chelsea opened it. She read, "I'm sure you will be a huge hit, as you become a banana split."

This made me curious.

Amber explained, as Wendy led Chelsea to a chair and sat her down, "Each loser from now on, will crawl to Chelsea and pull out the banana cooking in Chelsea's oven."

We all watched as Quinn, another senior, peeled a banana, spread Chelsea's legs, rubbed her pussy lips for a few seconds and slid the banana inside the big eyed Chelsea.

Pussy and banana... Yummy... two things I enjoyed... like peanut butter and jelly.

The music started again and Amber explained, as I started walking, as another nerd was pulled from the game, "This time, you will take both balls in your mouth. Guys, you will raise your hands when both balls are in your slut's mouth."

I barely walked past three hard dicks before the music stopped.

I was in between guys and had to make a quick choice. I moved forward, colliding with another girl. She fell backwards and I moved between the skinny legs of a nerd and took his whole ball sack in my mouth.

God, I loved winning.

"Oooh, this one is close. Two girls fighting for the ball sac. Don't bag the poor guy," Amber said, as I kept the two big balls in my mouth. I wasn't moving until I heard a declared loser.

A few seconds later, as one girl screamed 'bitch', Amber declared, "And Amanda is the next loser."

I took the balls out of my mouth to see what dress Amanda took.

Amanda's face was red and she was huffing a bit... I wondered what I missed. She went to the remaining dresses and chose one of the pink dresses. It wasn't the best of the three left or the worst. I thought it was a good choice as it was unlikely to be one that another pledge would want.

Amanda was handed the envelope and opened it. "There's a twist, time for a fist."

Although some of the others were cryptic and had to be explained, this one was rather self-explanatory.

Amber said, looking at the skinniest of the 24 pledges, "This should be interesting. Go get your banana and then go to the blue open chair."

"Yes, Mistress," Amanda said, looking nervous.

We all watched as Amanda moved between Chelsea's legs and pulled the banana out.

"Now eat it," Amber ordered.

We all stared in awe as Chelsea ate the pussy juice coated banana. I couldn't deny it, I was curious what those two yummy things mixed together would taste like. Sometimes it was perfect like peanut butter and jam... other times it was like ice cream and ketchup.

I watched Amanda eat the banana as Quinn slid another peeled banana into Chelsea.

The music began again as another nerd was pulled from the slowly shrinking circle.

I passed my brother again, still in awe of his majestic cock... how did he hide such a weapon behind his clothing? Of course, it's not like I'd been looking... it never occurred to me that my brother would have such a big dick.

"This time you will straddle a cock and ride it five times before remaining on his lap," Amber explained.

The music played and I glanced over to watch Amanda, who was now on a chair, legs spread and getting fisted by a nerd. Josie was still on the Sybian and her moans were implying she was close to her second orgasm.

I was close to my brother again as the music continued. As I pondered if I would ride his cock, which was worse than briefly deep throating him, the music stopped.

My instinct to win overrode any time to think of the moral issues of my decision, as I straddled my brother and engulfed his entire cock... the biggest I had ever had inside me. I moaned loudly, "Holy crap," as it reached new depths inside me.

I briefly forgot to ride as I was overwhelmed by the sheer length and girth of my brother's cock.

"Ride me," he ordered, his tone surprisingly firm.

I obeyed, pulled back into reality, even as I felt a rush at both the reality I was committing incest unbeknownst to everyone here and also my brother seemed to be a bit authoritative... something else I liked. I liked a man who knew what he wanted.

I bounced on his cock five times, each downward thrust sending intense pleasure throughout me. God, I loved this cock.

As I finished, and sat with ten inches deep within me, desperately wanting to ride it all night, I looked around just in time to see Ariel walking to the dresses.

Amber announced, "Ariel is the next one out."

Ariel, a sweet slightly chubby girl, grabbed the ugliest of the pink ones, assuring herself likely of not getting one of the more hideous outfits... as it was very unlikely anyone would take this away from her.

Ariel was handed an envelope. She opened it and read it out loud, "you were slow like a mule, now you'll be everyone's stool."

Amanda explained, as I slyly grounded my cunt on my brother, somehow completely turned on by the secret act of incest (and his big fucking dick), "After you eat your banana, you will get on all fours and offer yourself as a foot rest for your elders."

Boring, I thought to myself. Humiliating... but with none of the fun.

"Are you grinding on your nerd, Tiffany?" Amber questioned, looking directly at me.

"Yes, Mistress," I admitted, stopping instantly.

"Was that part of the task?" She questioned, looking perturbed.

"No, Mistress," I said, worried I may be disqualified.

"He does have a great dick though, doesn't he?" Amber asked, smiling suddenly.

"It's perfection," I nodded, as I felt his cock flinch inside me.

"This is a warning for all. Do exactly as you are told, no more, no less, or you will be disqualified," Amber threatened to all.

"Sorry, Mistress," I apologized.

Ariel was eating a banana as the music suddenly started again, just as Josie screamed, "Fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck!"

I reluctantly got off as Amber explained, "This time your job is to clean your own juices off the cock you just rode, except for Kerry, whose cock is being pulled out. She can go for anyone she wants."

Shit, I thought to myself. This benefited Kerry the most. She could go to anyone. And if she had choice she may pick the biggest dick of all...Chris's.

I heard moaning, I heard one of the seniors have an orgasm, likely at the tongue of Sabrina, but I didn't look up... I focused on getting back to my brother... focused on Kerry, who was three in front of me.

I passed him twice.

And when the music stopped, I was four away from him. I spun backwards and rushed towards him. Luckily, Kerry was nowhere near my brother and thus I easily got in front of him, onto my knees and eagerly took his dick in my mouth. I no longer cared about the moral wrongness of it as I sucked my own juices off my brother's cock.

I loved my brother's dick.

I also enjoyed my own pussy taste.

I wanted it back in my cunt.

I sucked my excessive pussy juice off his thick rod as I bobbed hungrily up and down on his cock.

"Tiffany really loves that cock," Amber declared, as I kept sucking long past the cleansing of my cum.

I stopped and shrugged, as I reluctantly took his cock out of my mouth, "What can I say? I'm in love with this cock."

"We can tell," Amber chuckled, as Sheila, one of three black pledges, grabbed a pretty nice white dress... a dress that would definitely look amazing on her... although I wasn't sure she would get to keep it with the other two black girls still in competition.

Sheila was handed an envelope which she opened, looking nervous. She read it, "You've been outplayed, for the month you will be the maid."

Wendy brought Sheila a maid's outfit, as Amber explained, "Starting now, you will be the serving maid for the entire month."

'Again, boring,' I thought to myself as I glanced back to my brother's amazing prick.

"But for tonight, you will do it with vibrating eggs in your box," Amber added.

'Oh, that's more interesting,' I approved as I watched Wanda slide something inside Sheila. Sheila moaned and I wondered what such a thing would feel like inside me.

"Now get your banana, and then start serving the seniors drinks," Amber instructed.

"Yes, Mistress," Sheila nodded, as she moved to Chelsea.

The music again started and I reluctantly left my brother and his big dick.

As we walked around Amber explained, "This time you will need to have a dick in both hands."

I was really enjoying the variety of tasks, and the wickedness of punishments... I hoped to win, but was already thinking of ways to make this game even more fun, even more twisted in future years.

"I need to pee," Josie whined, as she remained on the Sybian.

Amber said, "You may go pee on Erin and then return."

I'd forgot about the human toilet.

As I envisioned peeing on her, something I had never considered doing before today, the music stopped.

I was perfectly between two guys and quickly reached for and grabbed two dicks. Kerry also grabbed the one on my left.

A couple groans happened as girls were too aggressive and desperate to grab dick.

Amber announced, "And Keisha is out."

Kiesha was our only Asian pledge, although I had no idea where she came from. I was guessing Japan.

She went to the dresses and chose a dark purple dress that was quite nice. I wondered if someone may take it from her.

An envelope was given to Kiesha. She opened it and read it out loud, "Yummy, yummy, a dozen loads for your tummy."

Kiesha's face went pale.

Amber somewhat reassured her, "Don't worry, you won't be sucking any cock. Get your banana and kneel on the pillow in front of me."

As the music started again, another girl screamed, "Yes, I'm coming, you little cunt licking whore."

I smiled, thinking how much fun this would be once I wasn't a freshman. Three years of having freshmen to munch on me whenever I wanted. At least that is how I envisioned the rest of the sorority house time.

I noticed they hadn't pulled a chair.

I walked around, past my brother, as Amber explained, "We are almost at the half way mark. Thus, what a great time to get our first loads out of our generous guests. Once the music stops, immediately take a cock in your mouth and suck it to completion. Your job is to catch the cum in your mouth and then, to prove you got him off, walk over to our cum bucket Kiesha and deposit the cum in her mouth."