My Twin Sister is a Cheerleader Ch. 02

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here
Callicious
Callicious
1,837 Followers

I opened her lips as I had the twins, and traced the inside of her pussy with my fingertip, finding it to be rather wet and getting hotter. She was shifting on the couch, and gave an obvious gasp when I rubbed across her clit, which was sticking out, and obviously quite sensitive. "I think you have a lovely pussy, Jessica. I could enjoy playing with it a lot longer," but I had had my fun.

Next was Marissa. "Marissa, you don't have to do this. You weren't responsible for what happened."

"My dad always says the man who buys the meat is just as guilty as the butcher that killed the cow. I'm a part of this."

Secretly, I was glad. Marissa was my ideal of a girl. Not only was she pretty, she was not stuck up, but quietly sweet and gentle. She had never taken part in tormenting me, but had always looked at me sympathetically when the others bothered me. I felt badly about including her in what I was doing to the others, because I wanted to do so much more with her. I didn't want to mess up my chances, not that I had a prayer of having the guts to ask her out! Nevertheless, I knelt between her legs, and caressed them in awe, as she looked me in the eyes and smiled at me.

It was a trembling hand that combed through her pussy hairs and stroked her pussy. It was hot to the touch and quite wet. Her lips were quite swollen, and seemed to grip my finger when I slid it through her crease. She hummed in pleasure as my finger slipped through her juicy love box. With quivering fingers I spread her outer lips open to look into her pink heaven. I gently slipped a fingertip into her vagina in and out just a little bit, very gently.

"You can put your finger in further if you want to. I'm a virgin, but my hymen was broken in a bicycle accident my freshman year."

I slipped my finger on up inside of her, feeling the moist warmth of the first pussy I had ever penetrated with anything. I slid it in and out a couple of times, and felt an area on the front side of her vagina that felt different. Marissa gasped when my finger stroked it a couple of times, and was very disappointed when I pulled my finger back out and I moved on over to Sally.

Purposely, I had saved Sally for last. She was my nemesis. She also was the one who most flaunted her sexuality, constantly tormenting me with it. Jessica was bad about things like teasing about her panties, but Sally was the one who would go without her bra and draw my attention to it. I had been pretty tame with the others, except for Marissa, at her urging, but I had plans for Sally. She had been watching closely as I diddled with Marissa and the others, and she was visibly stimulated.

My approach was much more direct with her than with the others. Her lips were also swollen with arousal, but they were not as fat as were either Jessica or Marissa's. They were opening, showing the building moisture in her pussy. I cupped it in my hand and reached up and pinched one of her nipples lightly in my fingers as I caressed her pussy in a circular motion while simultaneously gently squeezing her pussy lips together with my fingers.

Her nipple hardened rapidly in my fingers, and she moaned. I slipped my two middle fingers into her crease and slid them back to front, pressing into her pussy while pulling and lightly twisting her nipple. After doing this for a couple of minutes my fingers rubbed directly on her clit, causing her to pant and arch her pelvis forward into my hand. After just a little of this attention I stopped, knowing I was leaving her hanging. She had been a cock-tease long enough. I thought it high time she got some of her own treatment back.

"Jimmy, please don't quit now! That feels so good!"

I just smiled and shook my head, and with a fingertip rubbed directly on her clit eliciting a gasp, and then I quit again. My cock was so hard it hurt! I also had a big wet circle on the front of my shorts.

Ginny spoke up from the other side of the room, "That was so hot! I almost wish you weren't my brother so I could get in on that!" We had forgotten she was even in the room, and we for sure had forgotten she had the camera!

To be continued.

Callicious
Callicious
1,837 Followers
12
Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
8 Comments
JohnWilliamslikesbootyJohnWilliamslikesbootyover 3 years ago
so lucky

i would have been making out with all of them and grabbing there ass and boobs

phoenix23ninjaphoenix23ninjaover 8 years ago
Oops

The email is phoenix23ninja@gmail.com

AnonymousAnonymousover 8 years ago
Wow

I would love to experience this

phoenix23njnja@gmail.com

Email me if you want to make this happen

By the way i dont check email that often

GingerCat1GingerCat1over 10 years ago
Nice

In many ways I am slightly conflicted about this story as there are huge elements I love about it a lot but small elements I don't like, like when Jimmy think "no satisfaction from embarrassing and humiliating them" but then a bit later is happy to emotionally manipulate Tricia into spreading her legs. I do really like the more shy moments he has though as I think that really works very well. Personally I would prefer it if Jimmy was still rather shy (though improving from the start) and it was his sister that was getting a bit of revenge on Jimmy's behalf knowing that he can't do it.

However despite what I have said here this is still a very good story, one that I am enjoying a lot. Thank you for writing it.

ammomanammomanover 10 years ago
AGAIN...

outstanding. As I had commented at 1st chapter, all the essentials. Story, pace, emotions and innocence of all. You have created an outstanding situation. Thank you'

Show More
Share this Story

Similar Stories

A Blizzard & the Night of Firsts A storm forces a virgin to find warmth with 3 women.in First Time
That's What Friends Are For Justin's best friend Samantha will do anything for him. in First Time
Bosom Buddies Ch. 01 A nerd befriends the 5 hottest girls in school.in First Time
Comforting My Neighbor's Daughter I fuck my innocent neighbor when she comes to me for comfort.in Mature
Hero's Reward One brave deed holds the key to unlocking a scarred heart.in Romance
More Stories