Sisters

Many thanks to jellybelly2 for all the hard work editing and improving this story from a previous version.

He could see she was hot, but when she walked up to him, Zeke had no idea how hot she really was.

"Hi Zeke," she said in a high giggly voice. "My name is Nina. You know my friend, Tina."

"Tina," he said, disappointed. "Yes, she's a great gal."

"You're right about that," said Nina. "She's my sister in Pi Kappa Upsilon. We all love her."

"She's very lovable," said Zeke, "You're right."

"Did you know she's at this party, too?" said Nina. "She's right over there. Do you see her?"

"Now that you point her out, I do," said Zeke. "There are so many people here on Saturdays after the game that sometimes I can't see my friends."

"What a great game," said Nina. "You were amazing, making all those tackles. I think you should have gotten the Player of the Game award instead of the quarterback."

"Why thank you, Nina," Zeke said. He was trying to decide whether to make a move on her. But as hot as she was, it wasn't worth it since she was a friend of Tina's. So he just continued to be polite.

"Do you think of her as a friend?" asked Nina.

"Who?" he said. "Oh, you mean Tina. Sure, a good friend."

"Can you see her walking over there?" said Nina. "Don't you think she walks funny?"

"I never noticed that she walked funny," he said.

"Oh, she doesn't walk funny all the time," Nina said. "The sisters noticed that it only happens after some dates with you, in fact most of her dates with you, because she doesn't date anyone else. She's walking like that because somebody hurt her."

"Well, it wasn't me," said Zeke. "I would never hurt a woman. That's not the way I was brought up. Did Tina tell you I abused her?"

"No," said Nina. "Even if you did, I don't think she'd do that. All she does is defend you. But the sisters found out why she walks that way, and it's because you're so big, if you know what I mean."

"Well, I'm a big man," said Zeke, "and sometimes girls have told me that I need to be more careful, if you know what I mean. I don't like to talk about this, Nina, but I can see you're concerned about Tina. I promise you that I always use lots of lube, and she seems to enjoy herself. Haven't you ever been sore after a really exciting night? I'm sorry if I'm offending you by saying that."

"Not at all," she said. "I've hooked up with some big men, and I've been rubbed in all the wrong ways if you know what I mean. But that's not Tina's problem. She's a tiny little thing, but I think she's found a way to accommodate you; except when you put it in the wrong place."

"What do you mean?" he said.

"Well, you can't expect to put it where the sun don't shine when you're with a little girl like Tina without causing damage," said Nina.

"But I told you, I'm very careful," said Zeke. "And I never force her. She's never said anything about me hurting her."

"I believe you," said Nina, "because I think she feels differently about you than you feel about her, if you know what I mean."

"I like her a lot," said Zeke.

"That's what I said," said Nina. "You like her a lot, and she feels differently, if you know what I mean."

"Well, a lot of girls like to be with football players," he said. "It makes them feel good. I don't know why."

"I don't either," said Nina. "Oh, nothing against you, Zeke. Yes, a lot of girls like the football heroes, and I'm sure a lot of those girls get hurt. But those girls aren't sisters in Pi Kappa Upsilon like Tina."

"What are you trying to say?" said Zeke. He was getting tired of this conversation.

"I'm saying we'd appreciate it if you would stay out of Tina's ass from now on, if you know what I mean," said Nina.

"Did you talk to her about that?" he said.

"No we didn't, Zeke," she said. "We're asking you politely because we care about her, and we don't want to see her in pain."

"Well, I'll tell you, Nina," he said. "I like Tina, and I want to continue to be friends. I do things for her, and she does things for me. I promise you, I will never force her to do anything she tells me she doesn't want to do. But she's a grown woman, just like you, and she can make her own decisions. Whatever she tells me, I'll respect her."

"What if she told you, she didn't want you in her butt anymore, Zeke," said Nina. "What would you tell her then?"

"What do you mean?" he said.

"I mean, would you stop taking her out, would you drop her fast?" she said.

"I don't drop anyone fast," he said. "I was taught to respect women. You can ask any of my old girlfriends. I never disrespected them when we broke up."

"Let me put it another way," said Nina. "Would you say to Tina something like, 'Hey, Tina, if it hurts you, please tell me. I promise you it won't mean anything to our relationship.'"

"I'm not going to agree to letting you and your sorority sisters stick your noses into what Tina and I choose to do or not do," he said. "I think I've made myself clear. If she chooses to listen to you, that's up to her."

"I think you've made yourself perfectly clear, Zeke," said Nina. "If she doesn't give you her ass, you'll respectfully drop her as fast as you can. You obviously have no feelings for her, and you're lying when you say you respect her."

"You're calling me a liar?," said Zeke. "If I wasn't raised to respect all women and never lift a finger against them, I would be hurting you right now. I'm one of the biggest men on our football team and the biggest linebacker in our conference. Nobody's going to call me a liar without me wailing on them. You're a woman, so you get a pass. But I don't have to talk to you anymore, and I'm not going to."

"I understand, Zeke," she said, "I've tried to get my message across, but you don't seem to have the brains to understand it. So I'll make it so simple that a chimpanzee can get it. If you don't stop hurting Tina, you're going to get hurt yourself. When we were pledges and went through initiation, we stuck a pin in our fingers and signed our oath in blood. We swore that we would never let a sister down and that we would do anything to protect each other. Next time Tina has a date with you, we're going to be watching. After you bring her home, she better not be walking like she is tonight."

Zeke was scared a little. He knew that girls in top sororities like Pi Kappa Upsilon never did anal, not even for football stars. There were plenty of tramps from some of the slut sororities who were more than willing.

That's why Tina was so special. She was so small and beautiful that he couldn't believe she didn't tell him off when he made the standard attempt that he tried with all the girls he hooked up with. He expected her to turn him down, like the other Grade A girls did. Then he saw how hard it was on her, and he was even more shocked when she didn't turn him down the next time. After that, she became one of his regulars. He didn't always put it in her ass, but whenever he felt like plugging some booty, she was the one he called.

He wasn't worried about Tina's friends, except he knew even a girl could hurt him with a gun. So he surprised Tina the next time they went out. They were in bed, and she asked him, 'Do you want to do that thing you like now? I've got to leave in half an hour."

"No," he said, "I don't feel like it tonight."

"You don't?" she said, and she smiled.

She didn't ask him after that, and he didn't ask her for a couple of months. But then one night he was feeling down. The team had lost a close one two days before, and he was moping around. Without thinking, he called her up, and when he started going for her ass, she was surprised and a little upset. "I thought you weren't interested in that anymore, Zeke," she said.

"I'd really like it tonight, Tina," he said. "But if you don't want to, I understand. You're so little, and I'm so big. I'm sure it hurts."

"Did I ever say that, Zeke, you big boob?" she said. "You know I will never say no to you, no matter what you ask. I know you date lots of girls. Have any of them ever told you what I just told you?"

"No," Zeke said. "You're the only one, and I respect you for that. Now bring that pretty round thing over here."

The next day, he got a text from Nina. "saw tina 2day. u r ded meat!!" He kept alert for a while. The only thing he noticed was that whenever he saw someone from Tina's sorority, the girl would glare at him. He didn't call Tina, but after a few weeks, she called him in tears. "Are you dropping me, Zeke," she said. "Please tell me if you are. I'll understand. I know you have your pick of the prettiest girls on campus, and I appreciate that you dated me for a while. I hope we can still be friends."

"I'm sorry, Tina," he said. "The season is getting really intense now, and I've got to watch a lot of film. But are you free after the game Saturday?"

"Of course," she said, and he heard the excitement in her voice.

Saturday night, she offered him her ass, and he accepted. Afterward, he wondered whether he should have done that, and he decided that he didn't want to worry about it anymore. He would find some skank from another sorority. But maybe because of what Nina had said, he was hesitant to drop Tina. Though he didn't call her often, each time he did, she insisted on anal. Sometimes he thought of his conversation with Nina and noticed how much it hurt her. He felt bad, but he didn't ever turn her down. She was so pretty, and her ass was perfect. How could he?

His fraternity's party after the homecoming game was a wild affair. There were at least three girls for every guy at the party, and many of them surrounded Zeke, who had seven and a half tackles and was named the player of the game.

During the evening, he saw Nina, Tina, and several of their sorority sisters. He went up to Tina and gave her a big hug. "I'm so proud of you, Zeke," she said and gave him a passionate kiss. It felt good, but he soon excused himself because he wanted to check out some of the other women who were offering themselves to him. He got some phone numbers, but he didn't expect to get any action tonight. Tonight was for getting roaring drunk. Sunday was for recovering, and Monday after practice, he would start calling. By the end of the evening, he and a few of his buddies were passed out on the carpet, and those who were still partying had to walk around them.

His buddies woke up on the carpet the next morning, but not Zeke. He woke up tied to a bed in a large, empty room. He felt funny when he opened his eyes and saw Nina and three of her sorority sisters sitting in chairs and staring at him. Then he realized he was naked and tried to move. He found he couldn't.

"What the hell?" he said.

"Yes," said Nina. "What the hell? Hi Zeke. This is Lyla, and this is Sophie, and this is Josie. We are all sisters, and we have a surprise for you. Would you like to scream and yell for a while first before we tell you about it?" She paused. "We are in an old house, way out of town. There's nothing and nobody for miles. You may have been here before, because they rent it out to fraternities and sororities for parties. It's just across the county line, so the school cops don't come here, and the sheriff in this county doesn't care, or else the owners pay him off."

"Today, we're having a party, but it's a small party in honor of you. You're having quite a season both on and off the field. On the field, you are the hero. Off the field, with Tina, you are the villain."

"Does Tina know you're doing this?" said Zeke, shaking his head painfully. He had a huge hangover.

"Of course not. She wouldn't let us touch you. She adores you, you jerk. She's always telling us that she knows you are a wonderful person deep down and that you just have to sow your wild oats until you mature, when you will miraculously become a wonderful man instead of a disgusting pig. She's so much in love with you that she can't see straight. She won't even tell you her feelings because she's afraid it would drive you away. So let's not talk about Tina. This is about you and us today.

"What we're going to do to you today is nothing compared to what you're going to do to yourself after you graduate, Zeke, or should I call you.. Arthur. Yes, we found out everything about you, your weight, your height, your real name. Instead of realizing how lucky you are that the most amazing girl on campus wants only you, you're going to marry a cold-blooded rich bitch who you'll be tired of in a few months. That's when you'll wake up and realize you're no longer Zeke, the biggest linebacker in the conference. You're just Arthur, and you totally messed up your life.

"It's going to be too late then, because even though Tina will probably never stop loving you, we'll make sure she gets married to a nice guy and has children right away. That will immunize her, because we know she would never break up anyone else's marriage -- not yours or hers.

"But that's all in the future for you, Arthur. I'm surprised you're not yelling. We thought you'd really be bellowing by now. I think it's because of your hangover. Don't worry. It's going to go away soon, because we've got some stuff planned that will push it right out of your head.

"We knew you and your pals would be getting stone drunk last night. So while you were lying on the rug, the four of us managed to slide your body as close to the door as we could. As soon nobody was looking, we got some help and carried your carcass to our van and threw you in the trunk and brought you here. It was too easy.

"Come in, Butch. Butch is the one who helped us. You're right, Arthur. Zeke is one of the biggest men on campus and maybe the whole county. But didn't anyone tell you, there's always someone out there who's bigger. We found Butch in the Internet. Our ad on Craig's List got 20 responses, and it turned out Butch lives only a hundred miles away. He's not cheap, but all the sisters pitched in, because they'll get to watch the video. You're 6-4 and weigh 320 pounds, according to the football guide, and I know it always adds inches and pounds. Butch used to be a lineman, and he's 6-10 and weighs 450 pounds. He carried you easily.

"As you can see, we've got a lot of lights set up here. Look up. See that camera on the line crossing the bed. And see those others all around you on tripods. We girls also each have a camera, and we're going to shoot lots of close-ups.

"For tonight, this is a porn studio, and the star of the video will be you. Butch is a real porn star, but tonight he's playing a supporting role. The plot is about an asshole who likes to hurt a beautiful coed who loves him, and how some friends of hers decide to show him how it feels to be a woman whose ass is invaded by a cock that's too big for her.

"That's right, Arthur. Struggle a little bit. Would you like to yell? I'd advise you to save your breath, because you're going to need it when Butch goes after you. Yes, it is a gay video, but I was kidding about the plot.

"It's actually about a young gay man who's big and strong; and a linebacker. He falls in love with this lineman who's even bigger than he is, but the linebacker is shy. So when they get together, the linebacker at first plays coy and runs away from the lineman. But soon the bigger man catches him, and then they both enjoy each other like gay guys do.

"You play the bottom, and you also get to give your first blow job and swallow a lot of Butch's come. Wait until you see how much he has. It will choke you unless you can swallow fast. There's so much, that he will fill your mouth and then pull it out to a thick coat of it sperm all over your face; from your hair to your chin. It will look like you've been dipped into a vat of marshmallow cream, but it won't smell or taste like that as it dries on you.

"One thing that really arouses Butch is when guys eat out his asshole, and that's how you're going to get him hard again. You'll toss his salad until he's ready to put his thing into your ass. For us and the cameras, he's going to demonstrate all the different positions that gays enjoy, including some that most of them don't enjoy. We asked him to pound you as hard as he could in each one.

"While you were asleep, we cleaned you out really well with a couple of enemas, and then we filled you up with really slippery lube. Maybe it's the same kind you use to keep Tina from getting hurt. We hope it helps you just as much as it helps her.

"In a minute, we're going to untie you, and then we'll let you do whatever you want. We think you'll want to get away from Butch. See him starting to take his clothes off? Watch. There go his pants. Now pull the boxers down slowly, Butch. Have you ever seen something like that in the team showers, Arthur? I don't think so. And it isn't aroused yet. None of us could get our hands around it when it was hard. Yes, we checked out everything to make sure you would have a special experience.

"It will be fun watching you run from Butch. Here's some advice. Running around the bed is your best chance, because once you go somewhere else in the room, he'll corner you easily. He's great at tackling, just like you. You can shout and scream all you want while he's after you, because we'll put some funny music over your voice on the video and speed the two of you up, so it will seem like you're both just playing a game.

"Once he catches you, it's time for you to start acting. You're going to give him some deep kisses with a lot of tongue, and you're going to hold him and stroke him like you worship him as much as Tina worships you. You'll be really enthusiastic as you make him come in your mouth. After that, you'll persuade him to let you put your face up his ass and worship his asshole with your tongue to get him hard again.

"Finally, you're going to beg him to put it deep into your ass, and when he does, you're going to respond enthusiastically. You'll work with him when he's behind you and push your ass at him as he slams into you. You'll get on top of him in a squat and pound down on him really hard while facing us. And when you turn around and do the squat slam facing him, you'll kiss him tenderly as you ride him hard. And all the time you'll be telling him how beautiful he is, and how grateful you are to him for making love to you.

"And you'll be smiling all the time, although we know that when it really hurts, there will be a lot of moaning and grimacing that you won't be able to control. It will be just like those porn videos with girls, where you can always see how much they're hurting even when they try to pretend they like anal. That's what will make your video special.

"We'll be patient because it's your first acting job, so we'll stop and start as often as necessary until we get it right. We know you'll do a really good job at convincing us and the cameras that you are hot for Butch, because you'll be motivated. Here's a sample of your motivation."

She reached over and grabbed his balls with her hand and squeezed. He jumped.

"That's nothing," she said. "I really hope you aren't motivated at first, because your balls feel so good in my hand. I want to really give them a big squeeze, a lot of big squeezes, when I think of what you did to Tina. But if you can really convince Tina and anyone who watches the video how much you love Butch while he destroys your asshole, I won't squeeze. Well, maybe a couple times just for fun.

"OK, is everybody ready? I'm going to untie Arthur now. If you don't try to escape, Arthur, we can finish this a lot sooner. Whee! There you go. I knew you'd recover from that hangover quickly. Looks like you and Butch have both done a lot of wind sprints. Only he has longer legs than you. Look at the two of you tearing around the bed. What a great start!"

Butch carried Zeke to the door of his apartment and rang the bell, then lowered him to the floor and left. Zeke's roommates found him lying there, and the first thing they noticed was the smell. The come had dried on his face, and he could barely open his eyes. They dragged him into the shower fully dressed and turned it on. He sat on the floor with the water running over him and began to cry. They asked if they should call a doctor, and he told them no and to please leave him. He sat under the water for 15 minutes, and when got up, he felt like a pitchfork was stabbing him in the crotch. Even the slightest movement of one of his legs caused stabs of pain in his anus. He tried to hold his legs together as he moved to get a towel, but that didn't work either.