That First Night Ch. 05

A few days after the beginning of the new year, I was ringing in the spirit of the new beginning, while silently brooding now that my beautiful Ashley had gone back home. I knew that I would remember the moments we shared forever... I just wished I could have had more.

I wish I could have had more, and I wish I could have given her more. I truly loved to give her the pleasure she deserved. Hopefully she still felt the same way I did, that our love was real.

I was like this, loving her from afar for 8 years... with 2 of those years wanting her sexually as well. A few months might seem like nothing... but having already tasted the sweet nectar, I didn't know if I could withstand the time without her.

I don't know what it was... But the visit itself still felt unfinished, despite Ashley being in California for a few days now. I just wish we could meet one more time before July...

I got a text from her at 5:27 PM: "Meet me @ the Motel 6 on Lakepoint tonite. Room 271, 9:30, don't you dare be l8"

I knew from the second I finished reading that my wish had been granted. Sometimes wishes do come true.

After telling my parents a passable story about how I was going to hang out with a friend, I made my way to the Motel 6.

Just as I made my way to the stairs, I got another text: "I have a surprise for you."

As I approached Room 271, I found myself a bit nervous and excited. I willed myself to calm down a little. This was just the same as it had been before. Although I wondered just what she had in store for me. Part of me wondered, if maybe she wanted to fuck her ass. I had always thought that would do nothing but hurt us both, but I would be willing to try...

Then again, maybe this was all a ruse. A sting being conducted by the police to catch us in the act of committing incest.

But it could also... My brain swirled with all the possibilities and eventually I thought that I would only know one way.

I took a few deep breaths in and out, and knocked on the door...

"It's unlocked," said a seductive voice behind the door.

I opened the door... and one moment later, my jaw dropped onto the floor.

There she was, my beautiful cousin on the bed looking right at me. Ashley was in a see-through red nightie. She looked simply breathtaking. But it was the other sight to behold in the room that shocked me.

Sitting alongside her on the bed was my 36-year-old cousin Laura, Ashley's sister, with not a stitch of clothing on her.

"Surprised to see me?" said Laura.

I was speechless as my brain tried to process this turn in events as I took my cousin in. What was going on here?

Laura wasn't really like Ashley, physically speaking. She had green eyes and red hair that was not quite ginger. After some leering that I may have done with her when I got to see her, which wasn't so very often, I knew that Ashley had bigger breasts. That being said, Laura made up for that with a large ass.

Laura let out a snicker "Let's try again... Surprised to see me?"

"Um... Yes... Ashley, what's going on here?"

"Laura's boyfriend broke up with her a little while ago after he cheated on her. He gave her a lame excuse about how she 'wasn't taking care of him,' and how she 'looks ugly.' I told her about you... about us... And She figured after all I told her, you could help her remember she is wanted."

I looked at Laura wide-eyed "You know about Ashley and me?"

"We're sisters, remember? We tell each other everything. Ashley told me she had found a sweet lover during her visit... She told me that it was you a few days ago. I was shocked at first, but after hearing Ashley describe it... I want it. I want to feel loved. I want to feel wanted. And with something like this... it just sounds so true and so pure... going against what society has to say."

"Wow... I feel exactly the same way." I replied.

"So babe..." Ashley chimed in "After that revelation, do you think we can let Laura in on our fun?"

"Sounds like I'm in for quite the night... I just have one question."

They both looked at me expecting the question...

"Who first?"

After my beautiful cousins stopped laughing, they told me it would be a full on threesome.

"Ashley, our cousin is a lucky guy, isn't he? Losing his virginity, then having his first threesome all in such a short time."

"Yeah, and we're about to be lucky girls." said Ashley as she started to take off her nightie.

"You are quite overdressed, my dear cousin cousin; wouldn't you say?"

Well I didn't have to be told twice. I quickly undressed to my underwear and was about to take them off when Ashley stopped me.

"No, no sweetie. That's my job. Laura, watch this."

In a blur, she pulled down the only thing keeping my hard cock from being on full display.

"Wow Ashley, you weren't kidding when you talked about how big he was."

"Have I ever lied to you, dear sister?"

"Enough talk ladies. How do you want to do this?"

"Well actually, the question is... how do you want it?"

I then positioned them on the bed so that Ashley would be blowing me while I would be licking Laura.

"So what do you think girls?"

"Looks perfect to me, what do you think Ashley?"

"I think this is going to be the most magical night of my life."

Sliding into my position on the bed, I then started to lick Laura slowly and deliberately while Ashley started to suck my cock as best she could

After a few minutes, Laura started moaning out, clearly loving this.

"Oooooh, damn. You're weren't kidding about his tongue either Ash. But I wonder why- OOOOHHHH!"

"What do you wonder sis? Ask and I'm sure he'll answer." Ashley knew the question, and she also knew the answer.

"Cousin... why did you insist on pleasing us first?"

"Like my mother always taught me... ladies first."

After they stopped laughing, I started to move my tongue faster around Laura's slit. I could tell she was already sensitive... I thought that maybe she and Ashley were playing before I got here. That thought just made me try that much harder. Now I was determined, now I wanted to make Laura's first good so she would want more.

Laura certainly responded, her entire body started to shake like a leaf as I pushed her over the edge.

"Oh fuck, I'm going to-"

I found out a few seconds later that Ashley wasn't the only screamer in the family.

"Whoa! So that's what I sound like," Ashley said with a laugh.

I decoupled from Ashley and crawled up to Laura, coming down from her high.

"Wow cousin... If only I had known-"

I silenced her with a deep, loving kiss which she gladly returned.

"Hey, don't hog him Laura, I want a turn." It was funny how Ashley sounded like a little kid when she said that.

"Well come up here beautiful, I want to kiss you too."

She complied and beat me to it before I could start kissing her. She kept kissing me for what seemed like hours with a deep, loving frenzy to her kiss.

I pulled away and dodged her when she tried to kiss me again.

"I think my lips could do something better... don't you?"

She quickly rolled over so her beautiful pussy was facing me.

"I'm already worked up, so it won't take long handsome."

Ah, so they were playing with each other.

True to her word, it probably took about 45 seconds before she started screaming too.

I scooped up some of her cum that was leaking from her wet pussy and offered my finger to Laura... After looking at me with a look that was half disgust and half thought, she smiled and opened her mouth.

Placing my finger in her mouth, she started to suck on it cautiously before becoming more eager as she tasted her juices.

After sucking my finger dry, she opened her eyes wide in realization.

"Hey sis... I don't think he has cum for us yet... has he?"

"No he hasn't... which one of us gets- Wait... are you thinking what I'm thinking?"

"What are you thinking?"

After an exchanged whisper and some giggles, Ashley kissed Laura's ear and crawled over to me, with Laura following suit.

Ashley then started to suck my cock while Laura decided to start kissing and sucking my balls.

Two girls doing their best to get be off... and an even better thrill since they were sisters. I was just in pure heaven in a matter of seconds.

Ashley could sense the state I was in and decided to tease me a little by pulling off...

"Do you mean to tell me that you've never had this done to you?" she said in mock shock.

"Please don't tease me Ashley. I'm going to be so close with you two."

"Oh, and with manners. Your mother raised you right."

This caused Laura to laugh with one of my balls still in her mouth.

As Ashley started working my cock again, I felt a shiver going up and down my body as it felt like I was a bit far off, yet just about to explode. This sensation heightened my awareness of what exactly was going on here, and increased the pleasure I was receiving to levels I had never felt before.

"Ashley I'm going to-"

She responded by quickly taking me way down her throat.

"Oh shit Ashley, how did you learn that?" asked Laura.

I'm not sure her she thought Ashley would answer since I was starting to cum in Ashley's throat with her throat muscles working my cock from all directions.

This lasted for what seemed like eternity until finally my spent cock had no more to give and I laid down on the bed afterwards.

Ashley and Laura had mercy on me and we all decided to take a minute to recover... And then Ashley finally said something that was music to my ears.

"Hey guys... it's getting later and later... Want to order some pizza?"

We decided to order a feast from Papa Johns. It made sense, considering that we would need our strength throughout the night. And we ordered from Papa Johns for three reasons.

Reason 1: We all loved their pizza.

Reason 2: I could always be counted on to have a sweet coupon for Papa Johns. In this case, it was for 40% off the entire order.

Reason 3: I was, and still am a member of their Papa Rewards Program, which is their frequent eater program.

In the end, we got quite the order... And here's what we got:

To start off with/continue eating throughout the meal, we got some Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks and Cheese bread.

Ashley and Laura trusted my guidance on all things pizza and we got two Extra Large Spinach Alfredo Pizzas with extra sauce, black olives, and mushrooms. One pizza had sausage, the other had beef.

For dessert, we settled on a Double Chocolate Brownie, which is better than their cookie in my opinion.

A 2-liter of Pepsi, our favorite drinks from Starbucks, and two bottles of cheap wine rounded out our meal.

Our order would have been $72.69 but with my coupon, I got it down to $43.62 for a savings of almost $30 on our feast. (This is how it's done people) And I also would be getting 8 points from this order, which would fill up my total and would allow me to get a free large pizza on my next order.

The girls and I had a challenge going where I would meet the pizza delivery if it was a girl, and they would if it was a guy. And we had to do it naked. Sure enough as I watched the window, it turned out to be a girl. So when I walked to get the door and pay her, this is what followed.

"Man, you sure ordered a lot, it will be... Do you REALLY think you're the first person to try this?"

"Probably not, but I was busy a second ago."

"What do you-?" And surprisingly the girls came to the door and kissed me "Oh... Okay. Um... It'll be $43.62"

I felt a bit sorry for putting the poor pizza delivery girl through that, so I made sure to give her a good tip.

After a few minutes, my cousins made it clear that I hadn't steered them wrong on the pizza, and they bowed down to my pizza prowess... Well, not really, but that's how I felt right then and there.

We feasted mightily on our tasty dinner and eventually I got a call from my parents.

"Where are you?" Mom asked.

"I'm with Leroy. Something came up and I'm going to have to spend the night here to fix a little problem."

"Okay... well be safe."

"Thanks mom. Love you."

"Love you too. Bye."

As soon as I hung up, the girls broke out into laugher that I really didn't get.

"What- what happened?"

"I love you." Ashley said in a mocking tone.

"I love you." Laura soon chimed in.

They continued this for a few minutes before I started to laugh as well.

"Hey... hey, something came up."

Which of course brought on a new wave of laughter as we digested our pizza and the humor resulting from my cheesy wordplay.

"Well this was delicious," said Ashley after we had largely finished our dinner. "But I can think of something else I want to eat... provided you're up for it Laura."

"Are you asking what I think you're asking Ashley?"

"Yes I am Laura. Yes, I am."

"But that would be incest."

"And what we've already done, what you've already done with your cousin isn't? How would it be any different?"

"...I guess it wouldn't... Okay, I'm game for it."

"Awesome sauce."

As Ashley crawled to meet Laura on the bed, I just took in the sight. Wow... just so... wow...

Then I got an idea.

As Ashley started to lick Laura's beautiful slit I stealthily moved to do the same to Ashley. She gasped and looked down, surprised to see me between her legs while she was between her sister's legs.

"I hope you don't mind Ashley... I just can't resist."

"Oh yes... Stop... No, I mean don't stop hottie."

"Hey Ashley, stop for a sec," said Laura "I just had an idea."

"What's your idea sis?"

"Well, if we can get our hottie up here eating me out..."

I certainly didn't need to be told twice, so of course I crawled up there and started eating Laura out...

A few seconds later, I heard a camera shutter and looked up to find Laura had just taken a picture with her iPhone. Ashley had the same shocked look on her face that I did.

"What are you doing Laura?" we said in unison.

"I want to send a few shots to my EX-boyfriend so he knows what he's missing. Don't worry, he doesn't know we're family. Now my darling, put that hard fucking cock in me."

Once again, I did exactly as she said... I could feel that she was close, so I started thrusting into her, using my cock like a bayonet.

"Oh, look at you not needing to be told... You're going to have me cumming in no time baby. Just keep going like that."

I decided I would start fingering Ashley while I was fucking Laura, seeing as Laura was getting most of the attention right now.

After probably 30 seconds, Laura let out the scream that I was now convinced was the most beautiful sound I could ever hear.

I kept going with Ashley, having found her G-Spot, and shortly thereafter heard her beautiful scream as well.

Their screams were a bit different... I can't really describe how... A different tone, a different volume? Hard to say.

"Now just let me send these photos."

"Wait Laura, wouldn't a photo of you blowing me really mess him up?"

She flashed me a taletell grin. "Hmm... You've got a point there hot stuff."

She started by kissing the head of my cock and was soon licking the shaft.

"I'm teasing, sorry. But this isn't where you're cumming anyway."

"N-no complaints here."

"I bet not. Sorry I don't look as sexy as Taylor Swift." She let out a slight giggle.

I groaned out slightly, partly in pleasure, partly because Ashley told her about that.

"She doesn't hold a candle to you Laura."

"Mmm. That's a good boy." she finished that statement by inhaling my cock. As she started bobbing her head up and down on my dick, she gave me the iPhone and looked up at me. I had to stop for a second to look at her beautiful eyes... and just how amazing this entire scene was.

She gave me a look that said 'Take a picture, it'll last longer' and I did as such, knowing that it was so true.

I let out a disappointed groan when she released my cock from her luscious mouth. I was close again...

"Put it back in me. You're not cumming there, because I'm not on the pill... But I can think of a really great photo I could capture."

"I'm on a hair trigger," I warned.

"Just let me know when you're about to cum."

Once again... why do I need to be told twice? I don't, so I proceeded.

After a few seconds of us exchanging groans, I looked over to find Ashley playing with herself.

"You up for another round Ashley? You're next beautiful."

"I'm gonna hold you to that, my little boy toy."

After what seemed like a while to me... but in reality was probably not long at all, I could feel my cum bubbling up from my balls.

"Almost there Laura. Where do you want it?"

"Shoot it on my tits. Soak me baby!"

I pulled out and jerked myself fast as lightning for those few seconds before my giant load let loose.

As the waves of pleasure overwhelmed me, I had to close my eyes. But I tried to remain focused on keeping my cock lined up so as much cum as possible would hit Laura's tits.

"Oh damn, look at all of that." I heard... but I was too busy to identify the voice.

After about 30 seconds of this spectacle, I could open my eyes again and I saw my handiwork, just as Laura was about to take the picture.

"Actually... get my whole body cousin. It's better if you take this anyway." she said as she handed me the iPhone again.

After getting a good angle with the poor room lighting, I took a picture of her laid out on the bed, with my cum showing and glowing from the light.

I looked over at Ashley to find that she was still playing with herself... On impulse, I took a picture of her.

Both girls started laughing, knowing that I just couldn't resist.

"Even if I don't send that to my ex, which I might... I'm keeping that."

"You're too kind, big sis."

"Are you close Ashley?"

"YES I AM!" she said before screaming out once again.

I quickly took my position and slid my cock deep in her... I got the idea to kiss her while I was doing this, and did so. She smiled and gave me a lingering kiss back.

"You love me, don't you hot stuff?"

"I love both of you. How could I not? We're family after all."

"He's got a point sis." Laura said as she moved to start sucking on Ashley's tits.

A few seconds after, we all heard the sound of a police siren.

I looked out the window to find that it was a friend of a friend of mine in the local police department. I knew this guy from having the call the police after one too many false alarms at work.

I of course pulled out of Ashley, took a towel out of the bathroom, and told the girls to hide in there.

Making myself semi-decent, I waited for the cop to come to the door of the room.

After a knock on the door, I opened it and we regarded each other for a second, remembering each other.

"Evening Jimmy."

"Evening buddy."

"...Noise complaint?"

He nodded "...Noise complaint."

He stared at me for a few seconds, then noticed the smell coming from the room. He knew exactly what it was, I could see it in his eyes.

I could also see in his face that since we knew each other and he somehow knew I was a virgin; he wasn't going to cause trouble for me.

"You lucky bastard. And you got a screamer too?"

"Two of them."

"Haha. I doubt that, but okay. Uh, just try and keep her quiet... Otherwise the boys will have to hear about this, and you know they'll tell your parents.:

"I'll keep her down, don't worry,"

After saying our goodbyes, I closed the door and told the ladies they could come out.

"Ready to pick up where we left off, sexy?"

"Okay," I replied, "but we have to keep you quiet... Now how are we going to do that?"

In response, Laura reached into her purse and pulled out a roll of duct tape.

"Really sis? You brought that with you here?"

"You never know when you're going to need duct tape little sis. Duct tape has saved me more times that I can count when I've had to fix something on the fly."