The Bisexual Boyfriend Dilemma

Story Info
An anal exploration.
1k words
4.05
105.3k
6
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

I learned fairly early on in our relationship that my boyfriend is bisexual. It's a source of curiosity for me, and apprehension. I'm intrigued by what he's done, with whom, when and where. I also am scared that I, with my large, soft breasts and tight, shaved pussy,am not what he really wants. The problem, of course, is that I love him.

Mike, he tells me, likes to suck a little dick. Not small dick- in my imagination, it's always big, throbbing cocks attached to very good looking men- just not frequently. Sometimes when he's going down on me (which I know he enjoys), I wonder how many times he's flicked his tongue that way, just so, in order to make someone's cock shudder the way I do under his probing.

He says he goes for Italian-looking men. Tall, dark and handsome. When we walk down the street, I sometimes wonder if he's checking out passing men, undressing them with his eyes. Sometimes I point out men I think are attractive. Mike, who loves me and knows my torment, always refrains from comment. It kills me that I put him in that situation- asking if so-and-so is hot, without really wanting to know the answer- but I can't help myself.

We've recently begun experimenting with anal play. It began simply enough, with him inserting first a finger, then a butt plug, then his cock, into my ass. Felling my ass filled while Mike pups inside my cunt brings a certain intense feeling I find nearly indescribable. There's pain,but it's dwarfed by pleasure and I find myself having larger climaxes than ever when he takes me from behind, thrusting his hips and plunging the butt plug deeper and deeper in my ass.

Given that- given the amazing pleasure that comes from anal stimulation- how could I deny his request that I turn the butt plug on him? I know how much courage he had to work up to even ask, though surely he'd been wondering for some times what it'd be like. And that's why I said yes, though it scared me. "What if I'm 'pushing him over the edge,'" I couldn't help but worry. I knew it was silly to think that pleasuring him anally would make him love or enjoy sex with me less, or somehow make him more gay than bisexual, but there it was.

You have to understand that this is the man I want to marry. The man I want to father my children. The thing I don't want is to find myself alone years from now because my beloved has moved closer to the "7" (homosexual) on Kinsey's sexual continuum. That being said, it is the man I love. And so with trepidation (on both of our parts), we set off on our exploration.

That night, Mike laid on his back, legs splayed apart so I'd have better access to his ass. I was silent, preferring to concentrate on the task at hand than make small talk or even talk dirty. Sticking out my tongue, I licked his asshole, causing him to jerk and gasp with pleasure. Immediately, I pulled away, teasingly directing my warm breath to where my tongue had been. He begged for more. "Please. Please lick my asshole again." I did. While doing so, I reached for the butt plug, 4 inches long and 4 inches at its widest, and began lubricating it with the Astroglide I'd placed next to the bed. His pupils were dilated with anticipation and he asked me to be slow and gentle.

I have to confess, I felt tremendously aroused by the power I wielded over him. My pussy got wet as he begged me to insert the butt plug, Still silent, I placed the black plastic tip against his puckered asshole, applying light pressure until he opened. I stopped when the tip was in, allowing him to adjust to the feeling of having something wedged inside him I watched as he closed his eyes in pleasure, moaning softly, and when he asked me to continue, I did.

I plunged the butt plug deeper and deeper into Mike's ass, centimeter by centimeter. The lubed plastic slid in easily, giving the impression Mike was greedily swallowing it. I told him so, and the erotic imagery made his cock- hard but alone, as his hands were clenched in fists as his side and mine were full of ass and butt plug- pulse. He asked me to take his dick into my mouth, but I refused, deciding to watch in awe as the plug went further and further into his tight and previously unexplored asshole.

Mike too my silence and reluctance to touch him as discomfort with what we were doing and asked to stop. I protested, suggesting we continue, but he'd have none of it. When he reached around and placed his hands on my pussy, Mike was genuinely surprised to find I was very, very wet.

We had sex- him pushing his cock into my cunt, thrusting and grinding until we both came- and fell into a sort of silence on the subject. When I brought it up a few weeks later, he demurred- convinced it would bring more trouble than it was worth due to my issues- and since then I've tried to do everything I can to allay his concerns.

The truth is, over time, I've become more comfortable with the idea. The power turns me on, as does the bond we share as we learn each other's body (literally) inside and out. Mike loves me and one of the cornerstones of our sexual relationship is trust. I feel very comfortable telling him what I want, and I want him to feel the same. I want to try new things with him and evolve together sexually. That is what I have every intention of initiating anal play tonight beginning by licking Mike's tight little fissure and ending by climbing on top him him- holding the butt plug inside his ass and riding his cock until he comes.

Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
5 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousabout 8 years ago

Wish you were with me babe you could play with my ass 24/7!

abc101abc101over 12 years ago
great story

It was short but a nice plot line i have not seen yet. And even though im straight this turned me on. Ive dreamt of a woman using a dildo or something on me in a fun and caring manner such as this. Please write more.

KatherineBlackersKatherineBlackersalmost 18 years ago
Realistic love story

Not bad at all. life-like. my greatest compliment is that it is realistic.

OlderBiManOlderBiManalmost 18 years ago
Fabulous !

One word describe this story : Fabuloso !

PredatorSmilePredatorSmilealmost 18 years ago
A hot story

Hello, there. I really enjoyed your story. It's quite realistic. I'm living with a bi guy and I love him.

Share this Story

Similar Stories

Johnny's Ass Gets Used And Abused Steph and Sasha have fun with Johnny's ass.in Anal
I Bet You'll Like It His roommate is sweet, cute and she's into butt stuff...in Anal
The Yoga Instructor College boy runs into his yoga instructor on campus.in Transgender & Crossdressers
First Bi MMF College friends are guided on an unexpected bi experience .in Group Sex
I Made Two Men Submissive to Me She guides her two boys into bisex.in Group Sex
More Stories