As it was, Penny's twice fucked and once vigorously sucked pussy needed some cool-down time anyway. Beth apparently wasn't tired of eating the bald muff, because she was still taking long, eager licks and giving it deep, passionate kisses even after all the white filling had been sucked and gulped down. Beth's hunger and Penny's need for a time out gave Penny an idea.
She sat up on her knees, straddling Beth's face, and presenting her girlfriend with an entirely different hole. Penny had tongued guys there before, and she'd had a finger up her bum on a couple occasions, but otherwise she usually veered away from the anal area. Today, though, it just seemed right--maybe because, since her body was already so on edge from the taboo of this whole situation, the naughtiness of some virgin anal play only added a current to the electricity flowing through her body. If she couldn't try it now, she might never have the nerve or the desire to try it again.
Fortunately Beth seemed to feel the same apprehension mixed with daring excitement. She did not just jump into this new prospect, but she was obviously intrigued. As the guys watched, not seeing under Penny's skirt but knowing what was likely going on underneath, and confirming it by watching the expressions on Penny's face, Beth licked the bottom of Penny's ass. Since Penny was a little bit on the heavy side, her legs needed to be spread further to allow a direct route to her anus, as her deliciously plump cheeks concealed the little bud.
As Beth nibbled, kissed, and licked at Penny's ass, fire and lightening rolled up Penny's spine. She didn't know if Beth would actually go for it and tongue her there or not, and in a way, not knowing made it even better because each touch filled Penny with the anticipation of what might come next, and how far--or close, depending on your point of view--Beth had come already. Penny was so excited, she grabbed her own breasts and rolled her hard nipples in her fingers. She tried to take slow breaths to control herself, but instead every other breath she took caught in her throat.
The next phase of Penny's plan in mounting Beth this way came naturally. With Penny straddling Beth's face, the rest of Beth's body was uncovered. The skirt Beth wore was bunched up around her waist, so the guys had an unencumbered view of her taut little cunt and the greatest pair of tits on the planet...well, maybe the second greatest pair, since, now that she was sitting up, Penny's magnificent Ds were fully visible for the first time, too.
After a bit of playful arguing, one of the guys, a blond surfer-looking type--won out the rights to test the mystery girl's muff first. He got between Beth's legs and entered her slowly. Even though she was so wet the mat below her was slick, Beth was also so tight that she still couldn't be entered in under six seconds. Of course, it wasn't too much longer than that when the surfer started pumping, holding her narrow hips to steady himself.
Another new guy stepped right in front of Penny and presented his dick, but just as she was about to take it in her mouth, he dropped down and squatted on Beth's tummy (the surfer fucking Beth gave a memorable expression of horror when he almost brushed this new guy's ass with his face on the way down). Once there, the new guy rested his hard-on between Beth's firm Cs. Now understanding, Penny actually helped him out and reached down to push Beth's breasts together around him. Fortunately the guy had already been jerking off, and had lubed himself with a good amount of pre-cum, while Beth's body was slippery enough from her own sweat to accommodate the afternoon's first tit-fucking.
As he fucked the young chest, the new guy also found himself with an eye full of Penny's tits, and he ducked a little so he could lap them with his tongue. Since his hands were free, he used them to move Penny's boobs accordingly, pushing them together or drawing one to him for some nipple sucking. The guy didn't look like he had a freakishly big mouth, but she swore he was getting more tit between his lips than any other guy had with her, and it felt awesome. As if that weren't enough, an occasional stroke between Beth's boobs below brought his cock head right up to Penny's clit, giving it just the right amount of tease to get her juices flowing.
The next guy to take part was the first black guy, which Penny was particularly excited about since he would be the first black guy she'd ever been with. Even as he approached her with an unexpectedly shy stance--his hands loosely covered his groin--she could tell from the flesh peeking out that he fit the big-cock stereotype. He wasn't the biggest in this crowd, or even the second biggest from what she'd seen, but big nonetheless, and Penny actually licked her cum-laced lips in anticipation.
Obviously the guy didn't want to have the tit-fucker's head to worry about, so rather than stand over him, the black guy stood to the side. Penny turned to face him, and since her hands were busy holding Beth's tits together--and occasionally pinching her nipples--Penny had to move her head to take him. He was either teasing her or he was really shy, because the guy didn't help direct his dick into her mouth, but let Penny fish for it with her face and even stuck out her tongue to try and wrangle him up. When she finally did catch his tip with a curled tongue, she continued the tease by licking him good instead of sinking her mouth over him, and his moans told her she had made the right decision.
It wasn't a precision blow job, which actually made it more fun for the both of them. Penny's tongue accidentally batted the big hard cock away as much is it drew it closer, and this often resulted in the erection swinging and gently slapping against Penny's face. The guy must have really loved playing hard to get, because he never helped Penny out. He just let her use her face and tongue to maneuver his member, which left him feeling his cock against her nose and forehead. Penny was surprised he wasn't turned off when some of the other guys' cum on her face touched him, but maybe he didn't mind because she was so quick to lick it away.
This oral tango the two of them played continued until, with the underside of the black dick rubbing up against her nose, Penny saw a chance to seize his balls, and so she took it. She wrapped her lips around his nuts and sucked. Her mouth had been getting dry, but now she found it watering again, and she swirled her saliva around the testicles as she gobbled them. She savored every second.
Below, Penny felt like the guy sucking her had half of one of her huge boobs in his mouth, and his tongue seemed to be everywhere on it at once. He held her breasts gently, but his skin was rough, and she delighted in the contrast.
Below that, Beth was still being tentative with Penny's ass, though she was obviously enjoying herself. She still hadn't gone so far as to actually spread Penny's cheeks and lick her rosebud, but the conflict she had in wanting to try it but also too afraid to go forward made her all the more wet. And even as this temptation drove her crazy, Beth was getting very thoroughly pounded by the guy between her legs, giving her pussy a much-needed toy to chew on. As she took his thrusts, Beth switched from licking and kissing Penny's ass cheeks to gnawing on them and gently biting the flesh.
As good as the cock in her mouth was, and as good as her tits were feeling as they were sucked and kneaded, Penny couldn't help but realize that what Beth was doing to her was generating the most heat and rampant arousal of all. It was such an erotic rush for Penny to realize that even at a time like this when she was so bold and free with herself, she could also be afraid of and intimidated by something new. To know, despite all of her raunchy experiences, that she could still find innocence in herself was beyond thrilling. God, how she wanted to feel the brunette's hot little tongue in her ass; but at the same time she hoped Beth would never move past this teasing.
"Oh man!" one of the guys exclaimed, breaking both girls' concentration. "I'm there...Where do you want me to cum?"
It was the guy fucking Beth; the surfer guy. By the way he had suddenly increased his pounding, he didn't have more than a couple seconds to wait for answer. And because Beth couldn't see who had asked the question, she wasn't likely to answer. Penny took it upon herself to give him the good news, sure that Beth would agree.
"Cum inside her," Penny said, letting the back balls dribble out of her mouth. "Fill her good, cause I'm gonna suck that shit out in a minute!"
The surfer guy was crying out instantly, holding Beth's thighs and shoving himself against her as he emptied his load deep inside. Beth screamed out as she felt the waves of cum spilling through her, and she had to press her wide open mouth against Penny's bare ass to stifle the sound.
This orgasm sparked a chain of them, with the tit fucker humping Beth's chest and tasting Penny's the next to go. Even as streams of jizz were still shooting into Beth's body from the guy between her legs, the tit-fucker announced his climax. He pushed his face full into Penny's cleavage and lunched his hips forward, driving just the very tip of his penis into Penny's pussy. Penny wasn't sure what, exactly, he wanted--to be fully inside of her, to be closer to Beth's face, or maybe he was happy where he was--but she grabbed him, adjusted her position slightly, and decided to give him everything.
She jerked the guy off and moved his rod slightly up and down while doing it, so he was going back and forth from having his cock head just barely inside her to rubbing against her clit. When his sperm was unleashed, the thickness and pressure of its stream massaged the folds of her pussy and her clitoris. But Penny had reluctantly moved her ass from Beth's mouth and positioned the girl's cunt over her face instead, so rather than going inside Penny, the cum sprayed back or spilled down, right onto Beth's face and into her waiting, open mouth. The guy couldn't see this because of the skirt and because of the giant tits in his face, but he knew as soon as he felt Beth smothering his cock with licks and kisses as it continued to shoot cum and jerk from Penny's hand.
Somehow Penny had managed to do all of this while continuing to lick and suck at the black cock at her face, but as soon as she felt Beth's tongue lapping at the steamy sperm flowing over her pussy, Penny lost her control. She engulfed the black cock and sucked it hard for one deep stroke, but that was all it took. The guy pulled himself out immediately, either as a failed attempt to hold off his explosion, or because he just really wanted to give Penny a facial instead of a blast down her throat.
He ended up getting both, because when Penny tried to recapture his spewing shaft, he again kept it at bay. The result was her only barely getting her lips around the spongy head, and having to then use her tongue to lap at the creamy discharge like she would at a stream from a water fountain. This brought plenty of his white treat into her mouth to taste and swish and swallow, but an awful lot of it squirted all over her mouth and dribbled down her chin, then under her chin and down her neck. Because she was still facing to the side, the gobs of cum that dripped off her face spilled onto her shoulder rather than on the guy moaning into her tits, who was still, by the way, jetting cum onto her clit and Beth's face.
The last of the former tit-fucker's cum was finally drizzling onto Beth's face when she hit a remarkable orgasm. The sensations had actually been too much; a hard dick between her legs, pumping her with sperm; her breasts wet and sticky and on fire from having been just fucked; the brushing of hairy, swinging balls against her chest as the guy there was jerked off; the hot, seemingly unending downpour of semen onto her face; the sweet smell of Penny's excitement just inches above her nose. It was all too much--and her body needed this momentary lapse to pull it all together for a long-awaited climax. She began gasping for air, and flailed her arms and legs in a panic as the storm in her blood grew stronger, stronger...
"I need a cock! Give me a cock! Fuck! Fuck!"
Penny knew what was happening, and wanted to help out as much as she could. The black cock had just finished cumming anyway, so she left it, then pushed the guy straddling Beth's chest away and dropped back down into the good old sixty-nine, planting her nose right into the entrance of Beth's cream-filled vagina and licking the girl's sizzling clit.
Behind her, one of the guys who'd until now just been watching and jerking off to the whole scene granted Beth's hysteric demand. He got down behind Penny, pushed his dick under her skirt, and had his erection just to Beth's lips when the orgasm finally hit her hard, tossing her body inside out, tightening every muscle she had and sending ripples of pleasure through her bones. She devoured his cock with such aggressiveness and frenzy that the guy was cumming in record time, pouring himself into her. He grew light-headed from the way her fanatical screams reverberated onto his shuddering cock.
Penny sucked and licked and consumed Beth's pussy and the treat within it with the same gusto that Beth had shown her when the roles had been reversed just a few minutes ago. She slurped as much of the cum out from Beth's crotch as possible, pausing only to make sure Beth's clit never went too long without more direct attention.
Beth was still on fire, still guzzling cum, and still reeling from her greatest orgasm when the school bell rang. She heard one of the guys say what time it was. Classes were resuming. If Beth was right, then there still wouldn't be any classes in the basement for another hour or so, but it was only during the lunch period that the basement was off limits. Someone could come walking by. Plus, these guys needed to get to class or someone would come looking for them. And besides, Beth had also forgotten about the shop class altogether. Who knows what other surprises might await?
By Penny's quick count, there were still two guys who hadn't participated yet, and two others--the former jerk and the hand-job half-cummer--who had unfinished business. This had to end quickly, so Penny needed to be creative.
She had promised to suck the half-cummer, so she beckoned to him even as she maneuvered her body once again. Keeping Beth's face hidden beneath her skirt, Penny climbed off her friend until they made an L shape on the blue mat--Penny was still on all fours, and Beth was still on her back, but they connected at Beth's face and Penny's crotch.
This enabled the former jerk to approach Beth's pussy as first promised, one of the new guys to mount Penny from behind, and the last new guy to stand to the side of his friend--rather than sitting naked on top of him--and offer his dick under Penny's skirt to Beth.
Penny expected the half-cummer to kneel in front of her for his blow-job, but she was pleasantly surprised when he opted to crawl under her and present his hard-on to her hanging breasts. She felts tingles of excitement when he grabbed her heavy boobs and suffocated his cock with them, and felt a further rush when he began bucking into her cleavage. She looked down, relishing in the feel of the cum on her face cascading across her skin, and made sure to lick at his cock head each time it emerged from her ample flesh.
The guy behind Penny also turned out to be creative. Apparently apprehensive about putting his dick where another, larger cock had already cum, this guy opted to instead fuck Penny's ass crack (though she was sure she would have loved it, she was glad he didn't try to take her anal virginity...that was something, as crazy as it sounded even to her, that she still needed to think about). The guy was lubed up nicely with spit and pre-cum, and he simply rubbed his buttered up cock between Penny's round, generous cheeks. As he plunged back and forth, his balls plopped against the bottom of her ass where Beth's saliva still remained, and just above that tantalizing spot Penny still forbade herself to yet indulge.
Beth, meanwhile, was still catching her breath from that last orgasm when she felt a cock slipping into her juicy cunt. The guy actually took a hold of her ass and lifted her halfway off the mat so he could better sink into her, and she wrapped her legs around him, crossing her ankles behind his back to keep him close.
The last dick of the afternoon poked her on the top of her head when it first appeared under the skirt, but rather than adjust, the guy rubbed himself all over her dark, silky hair, no doubt smearing pre-cum into her that would definitely cause problems, but she enjoyed it immensely anyway. Beth actually took this as an opportunity to use her fingers to push some of the built-up portions of sperm on her face toward her mouth, giving this guy a slightly cleaner slate once he finally went for her mouth. She swallowed the facial cum greedily, sucking her fingers clean.
The guy in Beth's hair eventually moved to her forehead then bobbled his cock hole on the tip of her nose. She seized the moment and grabbed him with her mouth, and from then on that was all he wanted. She sucked him slowly but firmly, and took him deep so she could feel his warm balls rest against her nose.
The guy tit-fucking Penny was the first to go. He called out, and Penny replaced her tits with her hands to jerk him, and she took him into mouth, letting him fill her. She was pleasantly surprised by how much jizz he had to offer considering he'd already lost some earlier. When he finished, Penny didn't swallow or dare open her mouth, but she did pucker her lips and lightly kiss his testicles before letting him scramble out from under her and go for his clothes.
The next guy was the former jerk, who was probably everyone in the room's favorite person right now. He slammed into Beth's body as he clutched her ass, and then, just before cumming, he let her down, pulled out and jerked himself against her lips, freeing his head to shoot a good few rounds of sperm at her tummy. The first two didn't go too far, but the third passed all the way to the top of Beth's right breast, leaving a bold streak of white across her areola and nipple, and leading a trail down to her belly button.
The last guys came together just as the former jerks spurts were turning into dribbles. The guy being blown by Beth erupted into her mouth, and she accepted it with a happy and satisfied "Mmmmm". She jerked him empty while teasingly trying to plug his spewing hole with the tip of her tongue.
And finally, the guy fucking Penny's ass crack indicated his orgasm by spreading Penny's cheeks apart and then back together again, running himself into as deep and tight a fit as possible. Strings and splatters of warm, white goo rained across Penny's back, and she shuddered at every drop. But the real event was when, during one of his last strokes, the guy just barely grazed Penny's asshole with the underside of his shaft. And then he did it again.
This wasn't enough to send Penny into orgasm, but it was such a wonderful, startling shock that she was momentarily disabled by the sensations that spurred through her. It didn't make sense to her why she should be so willing to do all of these things, and yet be so unsure about experiencing what anal could give her, and yet it was that very distress that made it such a fucking turn on. She almost choked on her mouthful of sperm.
When the guys left, they didn't cheer or talk about their individual experiences as Penny and Beth expected. Instead, they were abnormally quiet. Maybe it was because they had managed to get away with making enough noise, and didn't want to press their luck. Or maybe they were so overwhelmed with the weight of what had just gone down that they didn't know how to respond. A couple had asked for Penny's name and number, but she politely declines. She wasn't against a repeat performance, but she didn't know if seeing any of them again might threaten Beth's secret. One thing was for sure, though--the guys never once tried to sneak a peek at the girl under Penny's skirt...and the fake tattoo Beth had on her breast would do well to throw them off her trail.