The Second Place Sister

"Oh my God! It's really you!" He said, "I just met your sister, but I didn't know you were here, too! I'm such a fan!"

"Um, thanks. Did you see where my sister went?"

"Oh, yeah. She went in the dressing room with her friend a minute ago. They were with two guys, but I don't know where they went. Hey, can I get a picture with you? My friends will never believe me!" he gushed.

"Yeah, sure," Stephanie agreed, a little calmer now that she knew the two girls were still in the store.

The sales boy stood next to her, put his arm around her, and took a selfie.

"That was great! Thanks so much!"

"Sure," Stephanie said, "Now, which dressing room was it?"

He pointed to a closed door, and Stephanie walked that direction. She was about to knock when she heard a familiar sound from within. Sucking. Moaning. Groaning. She had a pretty good idea, now, where the two guys had gotten off to. Stephanie smiled to herself.

"Oh, boys and girls, it's Stephie," she called through the door, "Could I come in please?"

The door opened a crack, and Stephanie quickly slipped inside. While she had an idea what was happening, seeing it firsthand still caught her off guard Kyle had Tori's head pressed against the wall, and her sister was squatting, fingering her cunt, while Kyle fed her his cock. Cindy was stroking and sucking Todd off like she couldn't get enough. Stephanie, quite the slut herself, though more in control, felt herself getting wet watching the lewd display.

"Hey, Steph," Todd said, "Sorry, but they said they needed some help, and well..."

He groaned as Cindy licked his balls.

"Tori," Stephanie said, "I can't believe you! I leave you alone for fifteen minutes, and you've got a dick in your mouth and a hand in your cunt!"

"Shtepie," Tori babbled around Kyle's cock.

"Well, you may as well get what you need," Stephanie said, "I know you need to cum, don't you?"

"Mmm hmm!"

Stephanie pulled out her phone and started recording, pushing herself between the two guys. She focused her camera on Tori, leaving Cindy out of the picture. It never hurt to have a good video, she figured. Especially if she could hold it over Tori's head.

"You like that dick in your mouth, slut?" Stephanie said to her sister, "You like your pretty mouth fucked?"

She recorded Tori's oral abuse for another two minutes, and then whispered in Kyle's ear. He grinned, and pulled his dick out of Tori's mouth. She tried to chase it and get it back in, but he stopped her, and motioned for her to stand up. Todd got the drift of what was happening, and pulled Cindy up, too. They turned the girls around and hiked up their short skirts.

Tori's stomach was aflutter. She'd only had one cock in her up to now, and she wondered if it would feel the same as Dr. Carlson's. Would it make her cum just as hard, or would it be different? She felt Kyle's dick poke at her slit, then push itself inside of her. She moaned as a few inches of his cock slipped between her pussy lips. Cindy began to fuck herself back onto Todd's dick next to her, her legs spread wide, her hands pressed up against the wall of the dressing room.

Stephanie zoomed in on Tori's slit. Her back was arched, her ass sticking out, her pussy dripping. Kyle's cock was 4 inches deep inside her, and he was pushing more in with agonizing slowness. He held Tori's hips, making her wait for it. Tori was trying to push her ass back against him to get his full length into her, but he held her firm.

"Please fuck me," she panted, "Please, I need to cum on your cock,"

Stephanie grinned broadly, hearing her twin say those words. It was going to sound great on the video. Cindy turned toward Tori and raped her mouth with her tongue as Todd fucked her. The little redhead started cumming, and Todd clapped his hand over her mouth to keep her quiet. She grunted and pumped her hips on his dick as she orgasmed. Tori was so hot and needy that she came, too, making strangled little squeaks as she tried to keep quiet.

"Kyle," Stephanie hissed, "Tori really likes it in her ass."

That was all Kyle needed to hear. He pulled his dick out of Tori, and re-positioned it. Tori felt his cockhead tease her asshole, and froze. Her lingering orgasm still flooded her body, and she couldn't have moved if she'd tried. She felt Kyle's slippery manhood push into her asshole, and she groaned softly. Stephanie made sure to get a good shot of Tori's ass spreading open for Kyle's dick.

Kyle grunted as he forced a few more inches up Tori's tight little teen anus. While she'd taken the strap-on in her ass a few times, Kyle's was the first real cock that had been in her ass. It felt much the same as the toy Cindy fucked her with, but it was so hot, and throbbing. Tori relaxed her asshole, felt him slide further inside, and then felt his balls slap against her pussy. She'd taken his whole cock up her ass! The realization made her cum again.

"Oh, shit," Kyle exclaimed, "She just came with my dick up her ass!"

Tori was too far gone to feel embarrassed. She was cumming so hard, Kyle's cock all the way in her asshole. The college guy was so on the edge, filling up this high school slut's asshole in a dressing room, that he couldn't hold it in. He grabbed Tori's hips and unloaded his balls in her ass. Next to him, he guessed that the little redhead's snatch was pretty damn good, too, because Todd was cumming in it right now.

"Cum up her ass," Stephanie was saying, "cum in that little slut's asshole!"

Kyle didn't need to be told. He'd never cum so hard in his life. Tori's asshole sucked at his prick, emptying his shaft of every drop of cum he could give it. The blonde teen was hardly able to hold herself up on her own legs, and Kyle realized his arms were turning to jello trying to keep her standing so he could fill her up. Finally, he let her slump against the wall, pulling his slimy dick out of her. Tori spun around and slowly slid down the wall in a euphoric haze.

She'd cum so good that she was seeing stars. She didn't even think to complain when Kyle put his cummy, ass-soaked prick between her lips and used her mouth to clean himself off. He pulled his softening cock from her mouth, leaving a string of drool and sperm hanging from her lips. Her eyes still closed, she caught the familiar scent of Cindy's hot cunt near her face, as well as the tangy smell of Todd's cum, obviously deposited within her.

"Lick it out," Stephanie was saying, through an orgasmic fog.

Tori obeyed, and let Cindy rub her gooey fuckhole against her mouth. Tori lapped Todd's cum out of it like a kitten, swallowing the tasty spunk along with Cindy's strawberry fuck honey.

"Fuck, your sister's some kind of slut," Todd was saying.

"Isn't she?" Stephanie agreed.

Now Cindy was kissing her, sucking all the sexy mess off of her tongue. Todd cracked the door open, checked that it was clear, and then he slipped out. Kyle followed him a second later, leaving the three girls in the dressing room. Stephanie and Cindy pulled Tori to her feet, where she swayed unsteadily for a moment before catching her balance. Her eyes took another moment to focus on Stephanie's smiling face, and she grinned like an idiot. Cindy, her top askew, hugged her.

"Did you get to cum good?" Stephanie asked.

"Uh huh," Tori managed.

"Good. Now that you got that out of you, we still have shopping to do,"

"Okay," Tori griped, "Just another second..."

Her breathing was slowing, her heart getting back to a normal rhythm. Now that she was coming off her sexual high, she was starting to feel the guilt wash over her. She resolved not to cry, and choked on a sob.

"Oh, Tori," Cindy said, "Don't cry! I know your first real cock in your ass hurts, but it'll go back to normal size soon!"

The utterly ludicrous way in which Cindy interpreted her feelings made her laugh, which felt good. She was still ashamed at the way she'd acted, getting fucked by a stranger in a dressing room. In her ass, no less. Still, it was hard to feel down when Cindy's utterly slutty innocence made everything so funny.

Tori took a breath and got herself up. She could feel Kyle's cum dribbling from her asshole. She straightened her clothes, helped Cindy tuck her tits back into her top, and then she noticed the clothes on the floor. She remembered that there had been a reason they'd come in the dressing room, and it wasn't to get fucked. It was to try on clothes.

Both tops were crumpled and stained with pussy juice and drops of semen. The skirts had made it through unscathed, but there was no way they were going to be able to put the tops back on the rack. Tori picked up the clothes, showed them to Stephanie, who laughed.

"I guess we're buying them," she said, shrugging, then her face lit up, "Oh, I almost forgot. I found something for you, Cindy."

"Oh, did you? That's so great! See, there's the proof that you need to keep me in line," she pointed to the shirts, "I'm such a stupid slut, that I'll just open up my pussy for anyone if you don't keep an eye on me!" She giggled.

Stephanie pulled a collar and leash from the white bag. The toy collar was pink, like the rest of Cindy's outfit, with little sparking studs around it. She put it around the redhead's neck and fixed the strap.

"Too tight?" She asked.

Cindy shook her head. She looked genuinely pleased and proud. Next, Stephanie clipped a pink leather leash to the collar, and gave it a little tug. Cindy followed the tug like a well-trained bitch.

"That's gonna be so much better," she said, "Thanks, Stephie!"

"Yeah, sure," Stephanie said.

She and Tori shared a look that said, 'are we going to be able to do this without getting arrested'? Stephanie opened the door, slipped the leash's loops around her wrist, and Cindy followed along happily. Tori was the last one out, holding the messy bundle of clothes. The two guys were waiting for them outside.

"Oh, wow!" Todd exclaimed, "Cindy you look so hot!"

"Really?" Cindy said, "You're so sweet!"

"I'm surprised you didn't cum and run," Stephanie said slyly.

"Hey, we're your stalwart protectors, right? Defending the honor of those with friendly vaginas, remember?"

"And friendly asses," Kyle added, more softly.

Tori blushed and wanted to die. As they made their way up to the counter, Tori passed a mirror and gasped. Her makeup was destroyed. She looked like she'd been facefucked, then had a slimy dick and gooey cunt rubbed all over her, which is exactly why she looked the way she did. Without thinking, she used one of the stained tops to wipe her face off, and looked halfway human again.

She met Stephanie at the counter. The sales boy looked like he might pass out, or cum his pants, or both. His eyes kept bouncing between his current wet dream girl, Stephanie, to the collared and leashed redhead beside her, and then back to Stephanie. When Tori came to the counter with the clothes, he visibly drooled. The sight of the twins together was obviously more than his mind could handle. Like a robot, he rang up their purchase and stuffed everything in a sack. Amazingly, he did it all without ever looking at any of it.

"Uh, come back and see us again," he said.

"Thank you!" Cindy called, as Stephanie tugged her leash gently.

Flanked by Todd and Kyle, Stephanie marched them out of the store, and on to the next. Stephanie paraded them through shop after shop, buying jewelry, lingerie, clothes, accessories. All the while, people parted for them like the Red Sea. Tori figured that most people were just a little put off by Cindy being lead around on a leash, her ass practically hanging out, tits bulging in her top. Cindy certainly wasn't put off. She actually seemed to enjoy it. Every time she got catcalled, whistled at, or propositioned (which was frequently) Stephanie would give the leash a little tug and she'd fall back in line happily.

By the time they were walking back toward the car, Tori's curiosity got the better of her.

"How in the world are you affording all this stuff?" She asked.

"Did you see the ad in the first store?" Stephanie replied.

"The modeling thing," Tori concluded, "how long has that been going on?"

"Oh, almost two weeks," Stephanie said.

"Stephie, I'm so proud of you!" Tori cried, hugging her sister tightly.

Stephanie was taken aback. She couldn't remember the last time Tori had said anything of the kind. She awkwardly hugged her back, mentally stamping out the tiny twinge of guilt that had started to creep into the back of her thoughts.

"Uh, thanks, sissy," she said sweetly, her mask firmly in place.

Todd, walking beside the collared Cindy, asked her, "Hey, do you think I could, maybe, get your number or something? I had a really good time today,"

"Oh, that's really nice!" Cindy replied, "I did too! I really liked the part where you fucked me and came in me! But, I don't have a phone,"

"You can have mine," Stephanie said, "We live together."

"Okay, great," Todd said.

Kyle looked at Tori expectantly.

"Hey, Kyle," she said as they approach the car, "I, well, you seem like a nice guy, but I kinda have a boyfriend," Tori said, instantly feeling ashamed. She hadn't even called Tim since she'd been out, and had ignored his messages.

"I get it," Kyle replied easily, "I'm not looking to mess up whatever you got going on. Hey, if it was a one-time thing, I can be cool with that, but man, you're something special, Tori. Why don't I give you my number, and if you want to, you can call me some time. Sound fair?"

"Okay," Tori agreed, and he let her punch the number into her phone.

The girls loaded their loot into the trunk of the car, while Stephanie put the top down on the convertible. The guys walked off with cocky swaggers, and the three girls piled into the car. It was just before 4 in the afternoon. They were partway home when Cindy suddenly broke into tears.

"Cindy, what's wrong?" Tori asked, laying a hand on her shoulder from the back seat.

Cindy shook her head.

"Tell me what's wrong," Tori said again.

"Its...well...Oh, my stupid cunt made me want that guys' cock! Ted, no, Tom, no, I can't even remember his name!"

"Todd," Stephanie added helpfully.

"Todd! Fucking Todd and his juicy dick!" Cindy went on, "I didn't even think about Mike, and I really like him! Oh, I'm such a dumb slut," she cried, "Now he's going to think I don't like him. What am I supposed to do?"

Tori didn't know what to say. Stephanie started to laugh.

"Are you fucking serious?" Tori said, "Can't you see that this means something to her?"

"Oh, ease up, pussy girl," Stephanie snapped, enjoying the blush in Tori's cheeks.

"Cindy, have you watched any pornos with Mike, yet?" She asked.

"No?"

"Have you seen his internet history, and looked at what kind of stories he reads?"

"I don't know what an internet history is,"

"It doesn't matter, the point is, I have done those things. If anything, what you did is only going to make his dick harder,"

"What do you mean?" Tori asked.

"Mike has a huge fetish for cheating. Slutty wives, slutty girlfriends, all that shit. It's like his number one fantasy. After we fuck, sometimes we talk about this shit. Look, Mike loves sluts. If he could have a girlfriend, like you, that was completely obsessed with cock, and just couldn't control her pussy, that's what he'd ask Santa for for Christmas. Do you get it?"

"So, you're saying that he would be happy that I fucked that guy?" Cindy asked.

"Yes, that's what I'm saying. Now, here's what you're going to do..."

*The Butt Slut*

When they arrived home, Stephanie had been quick to get her sister's cunt locked up again, and as she made Tori lick out her sweaty pussy, she'd berated her for her behavior.

"I accept the blame for today, Tori," Stephanie said, pushing her sister's face into her steaming snatch, "I let you go out without your belt on, and look what happened. You got fucked in your mouth, your pussy, and up your ass. What's worse, is that you played with your dirty little cunt while you let that guy fuck your mouth,"

Tori worked at Stephanie's pussy like a good cuntsucker, her own sluthole growing more aroused as Stephanie reminded her what a tramp she'd been.

"The next time, we'll make sure you keep your belt on, and we won't have to worry about you playing with your snatch, okay?"

Tori hummed her assent into Stephanie's pussy as her sister came on her face. Tori happily drank down her fuck honey, as her little locked-up box got even hotter. Stephanie pushed Tori's hungry mouth away gently, and began kissing her.

"Are you my pussy girl, baby?" she asked, looking into Tori's wild eyes.

It was clear that getting that dick shoved in her holes had done something to her sister today, awakened some carnal urge that had finally pushed her from reluctant slut, to mildly willing slut. In fact, Tori kneeling on her floor right now wasn't even at Stephanie's request. They'd been going through their bounty from the mall trip, when Stephanie laid on the bed to get off her feet. Before she knew it, Tori was between her legs, licking at her slit.

"Yes, Stephie," Tori said, "I'm your pussy girl,"

"That's right, baby. I'll bet you want to cum now, don't you?"

"Yes, please!"

"Well, don't worry. Your sister knows you've got a horny cunt, so I got a few more things at that store where I bought the collar,"

Tori waited on her knees. Stephanie was pleased. She hadn't even asked. Tori just assumed that she needed to stay there until she was told otherwise. Stephanie rifled through the sacks on the bed until she found the white one from the adult novelty shop. She motioned Tori up on the bed, and made her lie on her stomach. Tori figured her sister was going to unbuckle her belt.

She watched Stephanie pull a big black dildo out of the bag, and then something else that looked like a little pyramid-shaped thing. Stephanie laid the toys on the bed, and pulled Tori's hips up, so that her ass stuck in the air. Then, she felt her sister's tongue on her asshole. Tori groaned as Stephanie licked at her ass, spit in her asshole, and slowly worked her finger into her bottom.

"You know," Stephanie said, her voice husky with excitement, "I noticed something today, when that guy had his dick up your ass," she punctuated the statement by adding a second finger to Tori's asshole, making her moan and grip the sheets, "I noticed that you came really hard. You did, didn't you?"

"Oh, God! Yes!"

"That's something we have in common," Stephanie went on, working her slippery fingers in and out of Tori's perfect behind, "I didn't realize it until Mike had ten inches of dick in my ass," Tori quivered, "but we can both cum from anal sex, and cum like crazy,"

"Yes!"

Stephanie pulled her fingers out of Tori's ass, put the tip of the black dildo to her backdoor, and then made Tori lick her fingers clean as she pushed the head of the toy inside her sister. Tori groaned as the big toy spread her open, wider than she'd ever been. Tori yelped, and Stephanie spanked her perfect ass cheek.

"Oh, Tori," she said, "I wish you could see this! You've got such a great ass, and it looks so good getting opened up like this,"

"Stephie, it hurts!" Tori cried, clutching the sheets.

"I know, baby," Stephanie cooed, "but it's going to feel so good once it's inside,"

She pushed a little more of the toy up her sister's round bottom, Tori's whimpers making her wet again.

"Oh, oh, ooooh!" Tori cried, 5 inches of the dildo buried in her rectum.

"That's my girl," Stephanie said, "Just relax. You're going to take the whole thing for Stephie, aren't you?"

The pain was awful, but Stephanie had been right. As another 2 inches of the toy went into her tiny ass, she started to get accustomed to the fullness, and then it started to feel good.

"Yesss..." Tori hissed.