Tim and Tina Ch. 07

"What a whore," Tina whispers with a giggle and then pulls me back to her to continue making out.

As our tongues dance, Melody's hand reaches into my loosened jeans and then through the trapdoor of my boxers for my cock. It's already beginning to grow hard just from the attention I'm getting, but when she pulls it free from its confines it almost stands at full mast. She grips my thick pole in her thin hand. I can't help but look down to see just how it looks in her hands. I think this is the first time I've noticed just how long her fingers really are; no wonder she's such a good basketball and volleyball player. Though her hands are still very feminine and slender, they're long and have a strong grip.

"How does that feel, stud?" Melody whispers in my ear.

All I can do is nod and then Tina pulls me back to kiss her again. Melody starts stroking my cock slowly as Tina and I make out. I rub Tina's ass over her wraparound skirt until I find the hem and slip my hand inside, taking notice of the very thin G-string she's wearing. Suddenly I feel Melody's mouth around my cock and I have to look down at her; Tina joins me in watching. Her tongue glides along the underside of my cock as she expertly bobs her head up and down slowly and then quickly, sucking here and there as she does.

Suddenly, on the other side of the theater, I see a flashlight quickly searching the rows. I tap Melody's head quietly but she misunderstands my meaning and picks up the pace, thinking I'm ready to cum already. I tap her more and she increases the pressure, which, of course, increases the pleasure and I can no longer control my actions. I really am about to cum and Tina can tell. She looks at me fearfully, unsure of what to do. She knows there isn't much we can do to stop me from cumming in the next few seconds, but the theater manager is getting closer to spotting us.

"Fuck," I whisper as my cock begins to tingle, ready to shoot my load into Melody's mouth.

"Sh!" someone in the row in front of us hisses.

"Sorry," Tina responds and then kisses me hard on the lips to keep me quiet.

Finally I explode into Melody's mouth but I'm a few seconds too late. The manager shines her light on us as Melody cleans up her lips while I try to refasten my pants.

"Tim? Tina? Melody?" A familiar girl's voice asks.

"Jenny?" Tina replies.

"Come with me, right now," she says angrily and I zip up my pants, following the girls out of the theater.

Jenny leads us down the hall to a small office and slams the door once we're all inside. She even locks it to keep anybody from interrupting us.

"What the fuck is going on with you three?" she demands as she storms around us to the big chair behind the small office desk with tan paint chipping off at the corners. Jenny's been working at the movie theater since her sophomore year and is the youngest manager to work for the theater. The head manager had to make a special request to allow her to be one despite her age. Since she'd just turned eighteen recently, it was no longer an issue.

I don't know about the other two, but I could tell my face was beet red.

"Look," she says and I actually do look up at her. She looks angry but it seems almost more out of jealousy. "This isn't the first time I've caught people going at it in the back of the theater," she says. "It IS however, the first time I've caught three people, two of which are fucking siblings!"

I look at Tina and she looks shocked at the way Jenny is talking. "Jenny," Tina starts but Jenny interrupts.

"Don't talk, Tina," she says angrily. "So, Tim, is your sister the girlfriend you told me you had or Melody?"

I look at her, trying to gauge how I should respond, or if I should at all.

"Well?" she demands a response.

I look at my knees. "Tina," I answer honestly.

The room goes dead silent for a long time, so, my curiosity gets the better of me and I look up to see what Jenny was up to.

"I should call your parents, but how do I explain this to them?" Jenny says, reclining in the big leather chair.

"What if we made it up to you?" Melody asks.

"Shut up, skank," Jenny replies in a dangerous but quiet tone.

"Excuse me?" Melody shouts, getting out of her chair.

"Melody, sit down," I say gently, grabbing her hand as I do.

"Fuck that! This bitch thinks she can talk to me like that?" Melody shrieks, but doesn't pull away from my hand.

"Melody, please, she's the only one who can keep us from getting into trouble with any of our parents," I reason with her.

Melody sighs heavily and then sits down, glaring at Jenny, who wears a new, smug smile on her face as I just reminded her of the power she wields.

"That's right; I do have the power here, don't I?" she says, eying the phone.

"You do," I agree with her. "And it's up to you what you do with it," I say and then look at Tina. She narrows her eyes at me, trying to figure out where I'm going with this. After a few seconds, it's almost like she's read my mind telepathically and then nods at me to proceed. "You know the truth about us, Jenny, and that's powerful information to have. You could use that to get us to do whatever you wanted."

She stares back at me, studying my eyes, but she can tell I'm not hiding anything.

"I'm going to ask you something," she starts. "And I want complete honesty from whoever I ask," she adds. "As soon as I think someone is lying to me, I'm calling the police and they can deal with you from there."

"The police? Why them?" Melody demands and Jenny shoots and icy glare at her.

"Indecent exposure," she says eying me but she glances down at my crotch which makes her blush slightly before she continues. "Lewd behavior in a public place," she says looking at both me and Melody in turn and then adds, "and incestuous acts between siblings," she concludes, looking at both me and Tina.

"Like I said, Jenny, you hold all the power here," I tell her.

"So, what's to stop me from calling right now?" she asks me.

I shrug. "Nothing, I guess. Unless...." I trail off, looking at Tina again and she nods reluctantly.

"Unless, what?"

"Unless you'd like to go out with me sometime," I say.

She stares at me for a long time before responding, which makes me nervous because she may take it as more of an insult than anything.

"You arrogant prick," she says quietly.

I look at her confused. "What?"

"You think I like you so much that a date with you would buy me off?"

I shake my head. "Jenny, no, that's not how I meant that."

"Then how DID you mean it, Tim? Did you think I would suddenly swoon because you finally agreed to go out with me? Do you really think I'm THAT desperate for a guy to notice me?"

I shake my head. "No, not at all! Jenny, when we met the other night at rehearsal, a part of me did wish I was available to go out with you. I love Tina so much, though, that I could never do anything to break her heart. I was completely honest with you, just like I'm being now. However, it seems as though you may be bringing what we have to an end, so we're both trying to look at this in the best light."

She looks at me skeptically. "What do you mean?"

"I mean, she and Melody really like each other, and that's more acceptable to society than me and Tina being together. I really did like you when I met you, and no one would think twice about that."

I look at Tina and she looks hurt but holds some of that hurt back and nods. "He's right, Jenny. I think it works out for the best. He did bring you up the other night," she lies beautifully; heck, I almost believe her.

Jenny's demeanor changes a little; her expression softens and she leans forward on her elbows on the desk. "You two really love each other, don't you?" she asks in almost a sweet voice.

I look at Tina and then take her hand in my own. "We do," I say and then look at her again. "But we don't want our relationship to cause others any troubles or pain; we obviously don't want to go to jail for loving each other, either," I wrap up, hoping I struck a chord with her.

Jenny looks directly at Tina. "Did you mean to write the play about a brother and sister?" she asks.

Tina shakes her head. "Not at first, but I think it was a subconscious admission of something I didn't realize I felt or wanted," she says, squeezing my hand as she looks in my direction.

Jenny falls back against her chair again. "As crazy as it is, I can't bring myself to get you in trouble for loving each other. I'm willing to cut a deal, though," she says.

"What's the deal?" I ask curiously.

She gives me a flirty smile, the same one she gave me at the school's theater the other night. "I don't want to break you guys up," she assures us. "And your secret's safe with me. Even whatever you have with her," she says pointing her thumb at Melody. I look over and she looks ready to take Jenny's pretty little blond head off. I reach over and grab her hand, hoping to calm her down but she wrenches it away angrily.

"We appreciate that," I speak for all three of us.

"I'll take you up on that date, but I have a suggestion of two options for the date," she says looking at each of us in turn.

"What's that?" I ask.

"Either we go on a date and it's just the two of us and we go as if we're both completely single," she says.

"And the other option?" Tina asks.

"A group date of the four of us. No one is more paired off with another, no exclusions, just the four of us out together, doing everything together. And I mean everything," she says.

I knit my eyebrows together trying to understand if I'm hearing her right. I look at Tina who seems to be considering the two options and then at Melody who is completely unreadable.

"I guess I'll leave this decision up to you, Tina," I say.

"Why me?" she asks.

"Because I think both options are fair. Jenny, if you and I go out for one night, that's all it is, right? Just one night and that's it?" I ask her.

She nods. "Unless we have a great time and you include me in your little orgy of a group."

"Are you even into girls?" Melody asks in a nasty tone.

"Wouldn't you like to know?" Jenny spits back haughtily, which makes me chuckle a little. I kinda like this girl's spunk.

I turn to Tina. "Can I talk to my sister alone?" I ask Jenny without looking at her.

"Sure, you can step outside if you want."

"Thanks," I say and then take Tina's hand and pull her out the door with me.

"What are you thinking?" she asks.

"She just wants to be included, what would it hurt to bring her into our circle?" I ask.

"I don't want a circle. I want it to be us; we're the relationship," she says in a hushed tone as a theater employee walks by.

"What about Melody?" I ask.

"She's just for fun, right?"

"Is that how she sees it? I think she likes you more than that and I know you like her more than that, too."

Tina sighs and leans against the wall. "You're right. Jenny's a sweet girl deep down; she's just upset and hurt right now. I guess you should take her out once to test the waters. I trust you if you think she can be a part of this. But I want it to be clear that you and I are the ones who are together and they just get included when the mood strikes."

"Now, let me get something clear before I fuck something up," I say with a chuckle.

"If you have an itch that needs scratching and I'm not available and one of them is, as long as we agree that Jenny is a part of this group, then you have my permission. Just communicate with me about it. "

"So, are we agreeing to being in a polyamorous relationship?" I ask.

Tina takes a deep breath. "I think so. After what Melody and I did today before we decided to go out with you tonight, I don't think I could ever give her up. I love her too. I also decided that after the way she made me feel, I could never be with a guy other than you."

"Are you saying you're more of a lesbian than straight?" I ask.

She shrugs. "Maybe, but I'm head over heels in love with you, so I don't think that's what it is. I think it's more that if I'm not with you, I'd rather be with a woman."

I think about that and nod. "I think I'm okay with that."

She slaps my arm. "Pervert," she accuses me.

"Hey, can you blame me? You're both hot, and Jenny's not so bad herself. Those hazel eyes of hers are kinda hypnotizing," I admit.

"So you do like her," she says.

"I wasn't lying about that earlier. She's really cute and really sweet."

"You better kiss me before I think you're falling for someone else," she says and I kiss her passionately.

"So," I say, breaking our kiss. "Solo date with her first and then report back to you?" I ask.

Tina nods and then kisses me on the cheek. "I trust you."

"Thanks, that means a lot."

We enter the office again and take our seats. "We've agreed on you and I going on a date just the two of us for one night," I tell her, still holding Tina's hand.

"You two have other conditions or plans connected to this don't you?" she asks.

"Yes, but nothing that will interfere with a date with you," I tell her.

"What are you scheming?" she asks.

"No schemes, just an observation on my part, but I'm keeping that to myself so it doesn't influence the date at all," I tell her.

She smiles at my slyly. "Mysterious. I like it. Okay, fine, it's a date. Next weekend, then?" she asks.

"It's a date. I'll pick you up at seven," I tell her.

"Perfect. You guys can go. Just don't come back to this theater for a while, please. I have to punish you in some way."

"I think that's fair," I agree and then stand up. Jenny stands as well and then walks around the desk. Melody storms out of the office and Tina follows quickly behind, flashing an apologetic smile at Jenny. Jenny grabs my hand before I can follow them. "What's up?" I ask.

She pulls me in and kisses me full on the lips, slipping some tongue as well. I'll admit, she's a pretty good kisser.

"Just a preview of what to expect next weekend," she says as she sits on the edge of the desk.

I grin a little awkwardly and then hurry after the girls. I catch up with Tina quickly, but Melody is already outside waiting for us.

"What did she want?" Tina asks.

"She, uh, she kissed me," I tell her; I can't lie to her and I'm not about to start now.

"And?" she asks expectantly.

I put my arm around her shoulder and kiss the top of her head. "She's nothing compared to you."

Tina slides her arm around my waist and presses her face into my chest. "Good," she says just before we walk out the doors into the cool night air.

Melody is leaning against one of the cement pillars outside with her arms folded across her chest; she looks pissed.

"Let's go home," I say, reaching my other arm for her.

She allows a small smile to betray her anger as she reaches for me and I walk both my girls back to my car.

"By the way," I say into Melody's ear before I let her go. "That was a great blowjob, thank you," I add and then kiss her on the cheek.

She blushes slightly and then turns her head to kiss me on the lips. It's a sweet, gentle kiss, but I can taste the saltiness of my cum residue left behind. Strangely it doesn't gross me out; in fact it turns me on because it makes me remember just how it got there.

As soon as we get in the car, we sit for a moment in silence as the reality of what just happened sinks in. I look at Tina and she looks ready to burst out in laughter, so we both look back at Melody in the backseat. A smile tugs at the corners of her mouth.

"Fuckin' bitch," Melody blurts out and we erupt into hysterical laughter.

Firing up the engine, I rush us back home, park on the street behind the squad car. The officers step out of their vehicle as we get out; both of them nod at us as they recognize me and Tina so I nod back with a quick wave as we walk up to the door.

"Lucky guy," I hear one of them say.

"You know one of them is his sister, right?" the other one says with a chuckle.

"If my sister looked like that..." he trails off and the other laughs.

"You're sick, man," the second one says and then I hear their car doors shut.

"So, they suspect something," Tina says as I unlock the door.

"Let them think what they want; it doesn't sound like they'll say anything to Mom and Dad," I say with a grin and then push the door open. The alarm chirps but doesn't go off; Aunt Dana's still home.

"Should we get her?" Tina whispers.

I shrug and then look at Melody and she shakes her head. "I guess not, so where do we want to take this?" I ask.

"How about the family room? Neither of our beds can hold all three of us," Tina suggests.

"We could always use Mom and Dad's bed," I offer.

Tina shakes her head and her eyes grow wide. "They'll figure something out for sure."

"Really? We already fucked there yesterday, sis."

"True," she says and then looks at Melody.

"This is your house. I'll fuck you guys wherever you take me," she laughs.

My lips curve down, impressed with her response.

"Fuck it, let's just go to the family room. If Aunt Dana catches us, she'll probably just join in," I say.

Melody shrugs. "I'd be okay with that; I just don't want to disturb her if she's sleeping or something."

"Is that the only reason you didn't want me to go get her?" Tina asks.

Melody shakes her head as she finally shuts the door. "No, I want just you two first. You and I had our time, Tina, and it was amazing, but now I want you both. If the night leads to Dana joining, then great, if not, it's you two that matter to me."

Tina smiles at her and then reaches up and pulls her face to her own, kissing her passionately. Tina then reaches back and pulls me in closer. Once I'm close enough, she pulls away from Melody and guides us together. Melody smiles at me and then wraps her long arms around my neck as we press our lips together again. Our tongues swirl around each other for a minute before I break the kiss and then take both girls' hands and pull them into the family room. I slingshot them to the big, soft couch and they laugh as they fall into the middle of it together. I drop to my knees in front of Melody first and spread her legs apart which forces her tight dress to slide up her thighs to reveal the bright green thong she's wearing that matches her dress perfectly.

"Green; my favorite color," I say and then grab her tiny, round ass and pull her forward.

She gasps and giggles at my forcefulness and I grin up at her devilishly as I slide my hands up her silky, smooth thighs, pushing her dress up the rest of the way over her bubble butt and then grab the thin fabric of the thong and pull it down to reveal her smoothly shaved, pink pussy. Her small, but slightly puffy lips are glistening with her juices already. I remove her thong from her legs and toss it behind me as I spread her legs a little more and then kiss up her left thigh, breathing in the musky scent of her cunt as I grow closer.

"He's really good at this, Melody," I hear Tina whisper to her and then I hear the unmistakable sound of kissing; just the thought of them making out while I eat Melody out gets me hard. But, I don't think about myself; I want to show Melody how grateful I am for the wonderful blowjob at the movie theater. So, I place my tongue against her pussy gently and flick my tongue up slowly, taking in her tangy, yet sweet, flavor. I hear her gasp slightly as she breaks her kiss with my sister. I imagine Tina between Melody's legs earlier today as I lick her from bottom to top again. Her juices begin to flow as I lick her lips a few more times before freeing her clit from its hood, flicking it with my tongue rapidly.

"Fuck," she whimpers and then grabs the back of my head as she grinds her sex into my face. I wrap my arms around her legs, holding her down to keep her in place so I can better service her. She keeps trying to fuck my face, though, and I enjoy torturing her by keeping her from being able to move freely. After a few minutes, though, I release my grip on her upper thighs and let her rub her pussy into my face, mostly against my chin, for a minute before I stop her again and shove my tongue deep into her pussy.