Tom & Sue & John & Debbie Ch. 14

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

"I grinned at Ryder, 'I'll hold you to that promise! I'm not crazy about the idea of either you or Andy, yanking my hair back at full force when your dick is ramming into me fast and hard making me feel like a horse being ridden. However, I'd enjoy a little light hair tug, a nice light spank on the ass with a juicy kiss while you thrust your dick in, out, and in again, as I move my hips around, back and forth, changing the arch of my back, bringing me pleasures I've never felt before.

"'I'm not all that hung up on the idea of doing anything kinky—just vanilla sex with two new strange big cocks going deep inside my pussy where no other cock has ever been—both my cervix and cul de sac are unconquered territory, just itching to be conquered!

"'Jimmy's cock head did hit my A-spot prom night when I was riding him cowgirl, but usually, he just hits my G-spot like clock- work sending my pussy into a frenzy!

"'Now it's your turn!'

"Ryder smiled, 'Damn girl, those are some serious foxy measurements! And those titties! I could nibble those nipples all night long! I can't wait to have you wrap those sexy legs around me and work those pussy muscles like you did Jimbo! Trust me cutie, I'll give you a doggie fuck you'll never forget.

"'My dick is already getting hard just thinking about the M-M-M-F! I have a feeling you and me are going to get along just fine! I wish we didn't have to wait until Homecoming—that weekend seems like an eternity away!

"'Now, to answer your question properly, I'm third biggest on the wrestling team behind Joe-Bob and Leroy. Andy is fifth, and, well Jimbo is down the ladder a ways.'

"I questioned, 'Third biggest? What the hell are y'all doing in that locker room? Jimmy told me, 'he noticed both you and Ryder after the first day of practice in the shower stalls!'

"Ryder quickly cleared the air, 'It's not what you're thinking! The first day of practice—well, it's a freshman initiation of sorts, and after practice while you're in the shower stalls, all the freshman have to get a stiffy on and have their cocks measured to the nearest quarter inch!'

"I laughed, 'So who does the measuring?'

"Ryder chuckled, 'Well, once we get a stiffy on, we're given a ruler and a cloth tape measure. The ruler is placed along the top of our shaft, pressed firmly into the pubic bone and we're measured for length from the base of our shaft to the tip of our cock.

"'We wrap the cloth tape tight around the widest part of our shaft to get our girth measurement. Leroy verifies our measurements and gives them to Joe-Bob—he's a senior and team captain.

"'Joe-Bob, then takes the measurements, computes the width and converts them to the Hungfun method. The results are posted on the 'cock board.' Those not in the top ten have to clean the shower stalls, pots, pissers for the semester and provide the condoms of choice for the top ten. Most guys are picking the real sensitive type, the closest thing to going bareback! Both Andy and I have picked the Crown Skinless Skins. The length is perfect for Andy at 7-1/2 inches, but it's just 3/4 of an inch too short from being able to cover my cock from the tip to its base. However, the width is a perfect fit for both of us!'

"I jokingly snapped at Ryder, 'Okay you quit stalling, tell me how big! I want to know everything about you—length, girth, width, and volume!'

"Ryder was laughing his ass off, 'How do you know about volume?'

"I giggled, 'I looked up Jimmy on the web, checking out the average penis size in the USA and stumbled onto the Hungfun averages!'

"Ryder just smiled, 'Okay, I was measured like 8-1/4 inches in length, but sometimes I've been a bit more. My girth was measured a tad over 6-1/4 with a width of 2 inches or so, and a volume calculation of 26.21, which according to the Hangfun averages only 2 guys out of a 1,000 will have a longer dick with more girth than me and I'm packing 99.98% more volume than the other dudes! So, does my cock meet your qualifications?'

"I grinned a sheepish grin, 'Maybe... I'll reserve comment until after Homecoming night—you know, to determine if you can live up to your boast of being able to 'rock your boat in sync with the motion of the ocean!'

"I was giggling, 'Okay, if you're third with a 26.21 volume, what were Andy and Jimmy's cock board scores? Just curious, what this Joe-Bob character scored!'

"Ryder was smiling a shit-eating grin, 'Like I said, I was third at 26.21, Andy was fifth 21.49 and Jimbo was down the ladder with a volume of 10.63!

"'Joe-Bob—well, he carries a horse between his legs, not the longest at 8-3/4 inches, but the highest volume at 30.5!

"I laughed at Ryder, telling him a little white lie, 'Y'all measured Jimmy wrong! Jimmy's volume is bit over 12, and I think I should know—don't you?

"'Ryder giggled, 'Okay, maybe Jimbo was a bit nervous when he got measured, and couldn't really get a good stiffy up. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt on his volume—but he's still not in the top ten!

"'Just curious, since Joe-Bob is so much bigger over four full inches in volume, you thinking of trading me in for him?'

"I grinned a shit-eating grin at Ryder, 'Hmmm... never thought about it, but since you brought it up... maybe... after all, this 'get together,' it's, well, just about experiencing a 'big' one!

"I looked Ryder in the eyes, giggling a girlish giggle, 'Just kidding! Naw, I guess I'll have to settle for third best and keep you as a player in the M-M-M-F! It's something about those sexy hazel eyes... and I guess—well, in case you haven't noticed, I'm already sort of physically attracted to you! Now that you know it, don't go and get the big head!'

"Ryder smiled, 'Sweetie, I've been physically attracted to you since the first moment I laid eyes on you!

"'Okay, enough talk about dicks... have you and Jimbo established the pecking order yet?'

"I smiled, 'No, we've only discussed what our boundaries might be, but seriously Ryder, I don't think you'll have to worry about the pecking order... a little bird told me you'll be first up!'

"The song ended and Ryder and I walked back to the table rejoining Jimmy and Andy.

"Jimmy said, 'Cat, next slow song, you and Andy hit the dance floor. Andy and I have been discussing some suggestions for the foursome while you two were on the dance floor. We've discussed the pecking order and it seems since this is our fantasy, it should go from smallest to biggest, in other words, I'm first up, followed by Andy, then Ryder being the tailgate. Cat what are your feelings? I'm not going to even ask Ryder—I already know his answer!'

"I smiled at Jimmy, 'Hon, please don't take this the wrong way, but since this fantasy is for me to experience something bigger than what God blessed you with, well, I'd prefer it the other way—biggest to smallest. I've already hinted to Ryder he could be first up and I never go back on my word. But Hon, you make that choice for both of us.'

"Jimmy smiled, 'Okay Cat, it'll be Ryder first up, followed by Andy, and then I'll be the caboose of the mini train!

"I replied, 'Thank you Hon!'

"Andy asked, 'Jimbo, what about seconds, thirds, or fourths? Are we still going to follow the same pecking order? I mean, what if someone peters out?'

"I laughed before Jimmy could answer Andy, 'Now Andy, don't go getting the cart before the horse! Seconds, most likely the same pecking order, but thirds, and heaven forbid, fourths just may be out of the question—at least in the same night!

"Sure, this M-M-M-F fantasy is all about having sex with you and Ryder, along with my future fiancé, but to get fucked eighteen to twenty four times in two nights—well, that's just a bit more than I'm willing to bargain for!"

Cathy grinned, "I looked Andy straight in the eyes, 'Like I hinted to your Roommate on the dance floor, I'm more interested in QUALITY as opposed to QUANTITY and superb QUALITY always comes in moderation!'

"Andy snapped back with a cocky remark, 'Cutie, that's not always the case, more times than one, five-star quality goes hand in hand with quantity—I'll be sure and prove that Homecoming night!'

"Jimmy laughed, 'Okay guys, now that we have the pecking order taken care of and Cat has enlightened Andy regarding thirds or even fourths, I think it's time to go over some basic ground rules we've set for our upcoming M-M-M-F.

"'Cat and I have agreed our foursome will be all about conventional sex—no twists or kinkiness, BDSM, or S&M. Basically, sweet and happy, lovey-dovey, plain vanilla sex to satisfy Cat's itch for something longer, thicker, and wider than what the good Lord blessed me with.

"'First off, Cat needs to be turned on with plenty of kisses, rubbing, licking, sucking, and nibbling her nipples before anyone invades her secret garden with fingers and tongues. In other words, anything goes while we're revving Cat up for that irreversible moment of truth.

"'I've got to veto any type of oral. I don't think I can handle watching either of you work your dick in and out of Cat's mouth so there will be no blow jobs, 69's, or Spit Roasting.

"'I don't want Cat sexually disrespected, so there will be no tit wanking, cumming on her body, anal, or double penetrations either—understand?'

"Ryder and Andy both nodded their heads, 'Yes.'

"I smiled in Ryder and Andy's direction, 'Hon, I've got to get something off my chest we haven't discussed yet.

"'We've all passed our athletic physicals and since everyone is clean, no STDs or STIs, I don't want to use condoms! I want everyone to go bareback—that is, if my cycle permits it. I'm usually regular as clockwork and ovulate between the 12th and 15th day. Hon, we've only gone bareback on two different occasions, when we lost our virginity together and then Prom night. The feeling of your cum mingling with my juices was something out of this world. It was the most intimate feeling I've ever experienced and for the M-M-M-F, I'd like to experience those feelings again and Homecoming night should be my 17th day... '

"Jimmy butted in, 'Cat, I assumed we'd all be using condoms and for double protection, you'd have your diaphragm securely in place! WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT THIS IN PRIVATE!'

"I sighed, 'Okay Hon.'

"I giggled, quickly looking in Andy's direction, 'Your roommate told me you were rated fifth on the 'cock board' in the locker room.

"'Just curious, since you're in fifth place, I really have to wonder, how much manhood you're actually equipped with and what I can expect in the way of sexual pleasures from you Homecoming night—after all, you're in fifth place.'

"Andy looked startled, 'Why do you need to know my size? You've already had a good look at what I have to offer—haven't you?'

"Ryder laughed, 'Shit Andy, she quizzed the hell out of me on the dance floor! She's done her homework and knows all about the Hungfun method, so you better come clean or else Joe-Bob may end up taking your place Homecoming night!'

"Everyone had a good laugh at Ryder's remark and Andy grinned another one of those cocky shit-eating grins in my direction, 'Like just a smidgen short of 7-1/2 inches long. Trust me you'll never know the difference!

'I got a nice six-inch girth with a width of just under two inches. Cutie, in a room of a 1,000 other guys, you'll be pleasured by a cock with more volume than 99.66% of the other cocks in the room! Like I told you a few minutes ago, 'five-star quality goes hand in hand with quantity!' Does that meet your approval?'

"I giggled, 'Sounds like you might be equipped with a nice size boat, but can you maneuver your boat with the motion of the ocean... or does it just sorta float on the ocean?'

"Andy replied, 'After Homecoming night, I believe you'll be able to answer that question for yourself.'

"We all had a good laugh and now everyone seemed relaxed about the upcoming M-M-M-F, even though it was about five weeks away. It was like we'd all just sort of broken the ice.

"Andy and I danced the next slow song, and upon returning to the table I mentioned to Jimmy, 'Hon, it's getting late and all this talk has made me horny, so let's bid our guests goodnight and head to the lake! Remember, your birthday is Tuesday!'

"Ryder said, 'Just like that with no good night kiss? What a bummer!'

"I smiled, 'Both of you follow Jimmy and me outside and you'll both get a goodnight kiss!'

"Once outside, first Andy, then Ryder, locked lips with me, each one giving me one of those sweltering sexy French kisses, causing my toes to curl and my knees to buckle! Trust me, Jimmy is a good kisser, but both Ryder and Andy were fantastic kissers!

"Jimmy looked at each of them after the goodnight kisses ended, 'Guys, tonight Cat and me need some one-on-one time, especially since she plans on giving me my nineteenth birthday present a few days early! Remember Hon, you promised me a piece of your virgin butthole tonight, and like you said, 'You never go back on your word!'

"Andy smiled at Jimmy, 'Jimbo throw away those Trojans for tonight! Since it's your nineteenth birthday present, and tonight you'll be getting your first piece of Cathy's sweet booty, try one of my 'skinless skins'—seriously, they're like having nothing on at all—that's why all the porn stars use'em!'

"Andy pitched Jimmy the packet of skinless skins and Jimmy grinned, 'Thanks Andy, I'm sure Cat and I will both enjoy them tonight!'

"What happened next caught everyone off guard when Jimmy said, 'But, maybe tomorrow night after partying at the Horseshoe, well, perhaps you guys would like to join Cat and me at the lake? You know, maybe breaking the ice a bit more, before Homecoming night?'

"Ryder asked, 'Jimbo, you serious? '

"Jimmy replied, 'Serious as a heart attack! I know I agreed to let Cat experience a strange cock one time, well, it's now become two strange cocks, to get it out of her system, but after we all sort of broke the ice tonight, well, if everybody is up for it—yeah, maybe we should think about everyone getting a taste of what our Homecoming foursome will be like—I guess, will, you could call it a scaled-down trial run.

"'What about it Cat?'"

Cathy smiled, "I answered Jimmy, 'Hon, it was my fantasy for it to be a once in a lifetime experience, with you and one other in an M-F-M. We couldn't chose between two super-hot guys so our M-F-M became our M-M-M-F.

"Because of the Homecoming events, instead of Homecoming night, well it became Homecoming weekend, a two night M-M-M-F experience.

"Now, Hon, don't take this the wrong way, but, after tonight, I'm all for a so-called trial run. But, only if we just let it happen naturally, something on the spur of the moment, spontaneous and we all agree everyone's got the green light, to get with it, like it was Homecoming night—in other words a trial run with no holds barred!

"'What's everyone else's opinion?'

"Andy said, 'Count me in!'

"Ryder looked into my brown eyes with those sexy hazel eyes smiling, 'I'm in too.'

"Jimmy said, 'Okay, it's all settled. If things get hot and heavy tomorrow night, we'll just let the chips fall where they may with no second thoughts and we'll do a scaled down version of the foursome like we planned—Ryder's first up, Andy's next, and I'll bring up the caboose!'"

Cathy smiled, "Jimmy and I bade our future foursome guests good night and headed toward the lake.

"Once at the lake, Jimmy and I quickly stripped off and crawled into the Chevy's back seat. After some serious tongue action and foreplay, I was ready for Jimmy to get his birthday present.

"We were in the spooning position, I was lying on my right side, draping my left leg off the back seat. Jimmy went to roll the skinless skin on his rock hard six-ish inch cock and I stopped him, 'Tonight Hon, forget the condom, go bareback and cum in my butthole—after all, it's your birthday present!'

"Jimmy lubed up his cock with a healthy dose of KY and started massaging my bum cheeks softly, rubbing them, gently pulling them apart and then squeezing them together again. I felt the tip of his spear-shaped cock head pressing against my butthole, meeting a little resistance before the head popped inside, leaving a tight sensation in my throat, kind of like you'd feel after a bad scare.

"Jimmy paused just a bit after the head popped inside, giving me time adjust before he slowly pushing his dick further until it was about a third or a little more past the head—the widest part of his cock. I noticed the definite change in diameter, his shaft sliding in further and further until all six-ish inches were bedded deep inside my rectum. My cheeks were pressing firmly against his body causing a bit of pain as I moaned out in a series of low deep guttural moans.

"Jimmy then slowly slid his cock out and back in again. The in stroke left me breathless, sending shivers up and down my spine. I was now relaxed and ready for Jimmy to fuck me and fuck me hard in the ass! I mumbled, 'FUCK ME HON'

"Jimmy started with slow deep stokes gradually picking up the pace until he was balls deep, slamming away with everything he had—taking me fast and hard. I was moving my ass rhythmically to his thrust, squeezing his cock with my anal muscles so tight he had a hard time moving in, out, and in again.

"Jimmy was really getting into it and enjoying his birthday present, but like all good things they have to come to an end!

"I could feel Jimmy's cock twitching and pulsing in my butt. His balls were no longer banging up against me, but now tight in his sack.

"Jimmy let out one deep cry, 'Hon, I'm about to shoot,' as he thrust wildly in and out until his cock exploded, releasing three—maybe four powerful spurts of hot liquid bullets into my ass. I never expected it, but it was so freaking hot, an insane feeling when Jimmy's semen was shooting into my ass.

"Jimmy finally quit cumming and I rolled over, smiled in his face and gave him a happy birthday kiss! The emotions we both felt can't be described as we just snuggled in each other's arms before getting dressed.

"Once we were back at the dorm, I asked Jimmy, 'Hon, tomorrow night—well, if it happens and I'm getting it on with Ryder and Andy, are you going to be able to handle it? If not, let's just forget the trial run!'

"Jimmy replied, 'Cat, if it happens and you're getting it on with Ryder and Andy while I'm watching each of them as they are 'test-driving' my girl, well, it'd generate this desire, a thrill, an excitement deep inside me that's when it's my turn I'd meet the challenge and reclaim my girl showing everyone involved just who my girl belongs to!

"'Yes I'll be able to cope with it and if things get hot and heavy, you just let loose—enjoy the moment without any fears or second thoughts!'

"Jimmy and I looked into each other's eyes and I whispered, 'Hon, I only belong to you and no one else! You don't have anything to prove!'

"We smiled at each other before we said 'good night,' we whispered, 'I love you,' in each other's ears and then locked lips with one of the most soulful, knock your socks off sexy French kisses we'd ever given each other!

"We pressed our lips hard against each other, opened our mouths and swirled our tongues in a circular motion around each other's mouth, like licking a Popsicle, running our tongues along the roof of each other's mouth for maybe three minutes before finally nibbling, sucking on each other's lower lips as we broke our goodnight kiss!"

Cathy didn't waver one bit and looked Donna straight in the eye, "Donna, tonight after losing to the Irish, I doubt the Horseshoe will be hopping all that much. So, don't be surprised if Jimmy and me bid you and Billy an early goodnight and sneak out to the lake with Ryder and Andy!

"Remember what I said to Jimmy in the dining hall if he'd do my laundry? 'If you'll be a sweetheart and do my laundry maybe, just maybe, you'll get a little poontang.' Well, I'm pretty sure Jimmy has relayed the message to Ryder and Andy!"

123456...9