Tom & Sue & John & Debbie Ch. 21

Chapter 21

SUE CLEANS OUT HER CLOSET FROM PROM NIGHT

Thank you for reading the serial novel, 'Tom & Sue & John & Debbie.' If you haven't read the previous chapters please do so otherwise you'll be missing out on all the details of the story as it was told to me.

Mary Ann and Sue resume their drive to the Tri Delt house. Sue is in processing of cleaning out the skeleton hidden in her closet from prom night, and reveals to Mary Ann the nitty-gritty at what took place at the after party.

DISCLAIMER: All characters appearing in the series, 'Tom & Sue John & Debbie', are fictitious, as they do not exist. Any resemblance to a real person, living or dead, is purely coincidental, and should not be construed to associate a real person, living or dead, with the scenes or events described within the series 'Tom & Sue John & Debbie.' Reverse Cowgirl

***

I sat in the passenger seat and was thinking about what Mary Ann and I had been chatty about since we left the Maroon & White, when suddenly the driver's door opened, Mary Ann got behind the Mustang's wheel and said, "Buckle up, we've got a lot to talk about before we reach the Tri Delt house."

Mary Ann pulled her Mustang back onto University Avenue and asked, "Now where were we before I had to pull into the 7-11 to make sure Hubby had enough milk for his Wheaties tomorrow morning?"

I answered Mary Ann, "I'd just given you a quick synopsis of what took place prom night and was about to tell you the nitty gritty about how it played into the mix of me, Tom, and Jimmy's relationships.

"Like I was saying before you interrupted me, I guess John sort of apologized for what had just happened while we were skinny dipping, but Jimmy was sincere, and asked forgiveness for coming within a whisker of inadvertently giving me a cum bath.

"I smiled at Jimmy and said, 'No harm done little brother.' And within seconds, we were all fooling around again. Jimmy with me, Tom with Sis, and John with Cathy. It was after a couple of minutes of casually fooling around that the six of us agreed it was time to return to our sleeping bags with our significant others for another round, so we headed toward the lake's beach.

"I guess when we were skinny dipping a switch turned on in Cathy's head for what happened last night when she and Jimmy..."

Mary Ann interrupted me, "What happened? Did they break up? Call off their up-coming engagement? I mean..."

I answered before Mary Ann could complete her sentence, "No, Jimmy and Cathy are still together, but last night Jimmy and two of his wrestling teammates, Ryder and Andy, took Cathy to the lake, and the three of them literally fucked her brains out, one after the other until their balls finally went dry."

Mary Ann was dumbfounded and in an astonished voice replied, "NO! I can't believe it! Jimmy shared Cathy in a foursome? I mean... Cathy Merricer in an M-M-M-F?"

I answered Mary Ann, "Yes Cathy Merricer. It seems that after getting a bird's eye of view of Tom and John's fully aroused man muscles, teasing them with her kitty, and then actually having outercourse sex with both of them, something triggered a fantasy inside her to experience being fucked by cock bigger than what Jimmy had to offer. Jimmy may not have been blessed with a man muscle the size of Tom or John's, but Jimmy's cock is definitely no needle dick by any stretch of the imagination! Jimmy's man muscle is above the average in length, girth, and thickest, and most importantly—he can rock his boat in motion with the ocean all day long and well into the night, like he did with me not only prom night, but on the Monday and Tuesday after prom too.

"Like I just mentioned, Jimmy and I skipped school on Monday and Tuesday after prom and went to the lake.

"It was after spending Monday and Tuesday out at the lake that Jimmy treated me to a couple of movies at the Skyview Drive In to celebrate my approaching nineteenth birthday. Of course, we never went to the Skyview to watch any movies, but rather to pick up where we left off, and finish what we'd started out at the lake.

"Our little brother and big sis friends with benefits hook up finally came to an end shortly before nine Tuesday night, but not before Jimmy had fucked me a baker's dozen."

Mary Ann replied, "Sue I know prom night all of y'all were boozed up on Purple Passion and things got out of control, but the hook ups you had with Jimmy had on Monday and Tuesday...well, didn't you consider those to be cheating?"

I let out a deep sigh and answered, "Not really. I'll explain in more detail just a bit later.

"Anyway, it was after Jimmy and Cathy put their rings on layaway during the summer that Cathy started hinting in a roundabout way, how she had this once-in-a-lifetime fantasy to experience a Devil's threesome.

"Jimmy more or less just blew it off until finally Cathy took the bull by the horns, and told Jimmy point-blank, 'Hon, it's nothing against you. I love you with all my heart and always will. Your cock hits my G-spot every time, and in certain positions will set my A-spot on fire, sending me into the 'Big O' galaxy more times than I can remember, but Hon, there are other spots deep inside me, which you're not physically able to reach that are yearning, longing, and thirsting to be touched so badly that it hurts. I'd never cheat on you, but just one time, just one time before we get engaged, I'd like to experience the thrill of being fucked in a Devil's threesome by a big strange cock that could hit all those deep spots that are longing to be touched. Of course Hon, I'd never do it unless you agreed to it, and you'd have to take an active part in my once-in-a-lifetime fantasy.'

"Even though Cathy insisted that Jimmy take an active part in the Devil's threesome, he immediately vetoed the idea, but after doing some soul searching, Jimmy agreed to let Cathy experience her once-in-a-lifetime fantasy. After all, Jimmy had already experienced his once-in-a-lifetime fantasy prom night when he fucked me for the first time.

"Once at State, Jimmy and Cathy narrowed their choice down to either Ryder or Andy as the guest who would satisfy Cathy's itch before they got officially engaged at Christmas. And, from what Cathy described to us, Ryder and Andy were packing some serious fuck muscles! Ryder's cock something more than an eight incher, and bigger around than a baby's arm, while Andy's cock was a dead ringer for John's.

"Anyway, the Devil's threesome became a foursome, whenever Cathy and Jimmy couldn't pick between Ryder and Andy, and the once-in-a-lifetime fantasy was to take place Homecoming night, the night of Cathy's nineteenth birthday, but last night the four of them had what Jimmy called, 'a scaled down trial run,' and before it all came to an end, Cathy looked like she had been put through the wringer when I saw her and Jimmy in the dorm's parking lot this morning after I returned from mass.

"I parked my VW next to Jimmy's Chevy and when Jimmy and Cathy got out—Cathy looked like she'd been rode hard and hung out to dry! Her hair was mess—sticking up on end. Her makeup was smeared all over her face, her tank top was on backwards and inside-out, her skimpy Daisy Dukes were still unbuttoned with the zipper pulled only half way up, as she held her panties and sandals in her hands!

"Cathy made no bones about Ryder getting the lion's share of her pussy, and before it all came to an end, fourteen hours after it all started, Ryder had fucked her six times, Andy and Jimmy four times apiece, and there was enough cum inside her ladybox to float a battleship. Cathy's nipples were sore from all the over-enthusiastic sucking, her pussy hurting and swollen from being fucked senseless by the three of them, but their planned foursome for Homecoming night was still on everyone's plate.

"I tried to talk some sense into Cathy and Jimmy, but then who am I to be the one throwing stones...when I live in a glass house?

"Anyway, let me get back to prom night. Once on lake's sandy beach we were about twenty feet or so away from our bonfire, and with our bonfire blazing, the full moon and stars shining brightly, it more of less resembled the early civil twilight instead of the darkness of the early morning hours.

"We were all toweling off when Debbie in her daredevil manner giggled and said, 'Hey y'all look at what we've done! Not a softie among the three of them!'

"Cathy and I were laughing out loud at what Sis had said, when Cathy smiled in Jimmy's direction and said, 'Hon, you're definitely low man on the Totem pole when compared to John and Tom!'

"Everyone giggled at Cathy's remark, and we all more or less examined Tom and John as they stood in their birthday suits side by side. There was no doubt both were built like a couple Greek gods, looks like Hollywood movie stars, and the two possessed more or less the ideal piece of man muscle—John's cock being just a bit longer with a mushroom head while Tom's cock possessed a perfect helmet shaped head, and like we both measured was a true seven by six incher.

"Cathy's eyes were zeroed in on John's seven-and-a-half by a bit more than a six incher that both Sis and Angie had measured. Sis in the meantime was smiling in Tom's direction, no doubt wanting to finish what she and Tom had started not only the night of the Perfect Plan, but in the lake's waist-deep water.

"After a bit I turned my attention to my little brother, and it was big Sis' turn to repay little brother for gawking at my boobs all night, and as I visually checked out Jimmy's male physique, my eyes focused on my little brother's manhood.

"Jimmy noticed his big Sis staring at his cock, more of less like a deer caught in the headlights, turned a bit to his left side, inched a couple feet closer to me, and with a shit eating grin, whispered in my ear, 'Sis, you like what you're gawking at—don't you?'

"Jimmy's left thigh was touching my right thigh, and as he shifted his weight a bit to his right, he spread his legs wider, and gave his big Sis a bird's-eye view of what Cathy had described in our private locker room chats as an 'upward curved six incher with a bit more than a five inch girth that didn't vary an nth from its base to the neck of its spear shaped head.'

"I giggled, smiled at Jimmy and softly spoke, 'So little brother that's what you were rubbing up against my kitty when we were skinny dipping that got all worked up and made a mess? My kitty must have really turned it on—huh?'

"Jimmy was smiling that shit eating grin, and in a low voice replied, 'Sis, I'm not as naive as I once was, and the way you were rubbing your Miss Kitty up against my 'jimmy'—lettin' my jimmy's head slip between Miss Kitty's smooth, wet, inner lips, and then teasing it with those up and down hip movements...well that's what caused me to blow my load! So Sis, when I put two and two together, and get right down to it, there ain't no doubt Sis both you and Miss Kitty want to get to know all of my 'jimmy' a whole lot better—don't you Sis?'

"I smiled a sheepish smile, and mumbled in his ear, 'I plead the fifth little brother!' Jimmy never said another word, but grinned a big ol' Texas type grin, looked me in the eyes, and with a girlish grin I continued to inspect his manhood.

"I thought his cock's head was too rounded and wide to be called a spearhead. It felt more like a bullethead when it slipped inside Miss Kitty's inner lips while we were fooling around in the lake's waist-deep water. And from my perceptive, after giving it a once over, little brother's cock's bullethead would never fit inside the cardboard tube of a standard toilet roll's one-and-a-half inch opening, and his shaft's girth was closer to a five-and-a-half incher—definitely thicker than what Cathy had described as 'a bit more than a five incher'!

"Otherwise, Cathy was right on money in describing Jimmy's cock, and like I alluded to a bit earlier, it was rather of a turn on when I was rubbing my kitty against my little brother's cock's head when we were fooling around in the lake skinning dipping.

"Debbie with a devilish, girly, grin interrupted my thoughts and said, 'I got a great idea y'all, how about if we do some mixing, matching, and fooling around just a bit like we just did skinny dipping, but this time on the beach, it might stir some lustful thoughts in our guys' minds watching us rub our kitties all over another guy's cock—who's in?'

"Tom smiled and said, 'How about it girls? Y'all in the mood for some serious foolin' around?'

"I giggled in Tom's direction, smiled, and said, 'Count me in for some more fooling around, just as long as you know who doesn't get all worked up again, and premature ejaculates all over the place.' I smiled and winked in Jimmy's direction, causing him to turn red as a beet again!

"Tom cut in laughing, 'Jimbo don't let it get you down! If I'd been in your shoes and my future bride rubbed that wet, warm, sweet shaved pussy of hers all over my cock the way she was doing yours...I'd blown a load too.'

"Everyone was laughing and Jimmy's face was getting redder by the second when Cathy said, 'Yeah, count me in too, but just curious how far is everyone willing to go? I mean, are we all just going to let the chips fall where they may—even if it means everyone getting a taste of something a little bit different? Y'all know what I'm talking about...each of us getting some strange tonight.'

"John smiled at Cathy, and while stroking his cock, yelled out, 'OH FUCK YEAH...LET'S ALL HOOKUP AND GET A TASTE OF SOME STRANGE TONIGHT! AIN'T NOBODY EVER GONNA FIND OUT!'

"Cathy smiled one of her straight forward devilish grins, looked John dead in the eyes, and in a rather bold and adventurous voice said, 'Hmm...if that's the case, and no one will ever find out, I'm definitely in the mood for getting some strange tonight! And Hon, remember what I told you, "What's good for the goose is good for the gander!"'

"Tom was still laughing and answered Cathy, 'Naw Cathy let's just fool around a bit more before we hit the sleeping bags, and dance with the one who brung ya.'

"John with a shit eating grin answered Tom, 'I'm with Cathy, we should all get a taste of some strange tonight, like I said, "Ain't nobody ever gonna find out." It'd be sorta like a friends with benefits one-night stand. How about you Jimbo? Seems like you'd like to get some strange off you know who—right?'

"Jimmy winked, smiled at me and answered John, 'Since Cat has made her feelings known, yeah, I'd like nothin' better than to get the opportunity to cure this once-in-a-lifetime fantasy that has been buggin' me not only all night long, but ever since before my junior year at Dragon High. And as much as I'd like to cure this itch, it ain't up to me...Tom controls the shots, and since he isn't for the idea...'

"John interrupted Jimmy, 'I realize we all have strong feelings for our significant others, but experiencing sex with someone else's SO, will actually strengthen everyone's relationships, and if I had my druthers, I'd sure like to accommodate Cathy and get some strange off Jimbo's sexy SO! And even if they won't admit it, Bud and Deb are itching to have a roll in the sack, and we all know what Jimbo has on his mind!'

"John paused just a bit, smiled at me, and said, 'And the way Susie was foolin' around with Jimbo, well, if I was a bettin' man, I'd bet the house that Susie is entertaining thoughts of what'd be like to have a roll in the sack with Jimbo! And, it ain't cheatin' y'all if we all get a taste of some strange tonight since it's all out in the open...and like I just mentioned,"It'd be a friends with benefits one night stand."'

"John was now on a roll, and with the help of Purple Passion he was slowly but surely persuading everyone that a friends with benefits one night stand would be good for everyone's relationships.

"John continued, 'Now, if Bud still don't want no part of it, I guess we could all do the next best thing and hookup with everyone getting a taste of some no holds barred outercourse sex play with someone else's significant other. And, even though I'd hate to stop short of gettin' a taste of some strange off Cathy, or even Susie, if she's calmed down and is agreeable, at the same time none of us need to quit before reachin' that ultimate sexual moment with someone else's SO. Like I said, "A friends with benefits" affair. And there ain't no reason for anyone to feel guilty or ashamed... none of us will be cheatin' on our significant others. Any objections?'

"Tom answered John, 'Well Bud since you put it that way, I'll cast my vote for hooking up and everyone getting a taste of sex with someone else's significant other. How about it girls...any objections?'

"No one objected and within seconds we were all fooling around again. The five Red Solo cups of John's Purple Passion had taken control over of everyone's better judgment. No one was thinking rationally, things were dangerously out of control, and what started as an innocent romantic after prom party that we'd be sharing with the ones we loved, our significant others, Purple Passion had taken control, and since everyone was in that horny tipsy stage, and pretty much turned on from fooling around in the lake's waist-deep water, we were all now flirting with the lustful idea of a having a friends with benefits swinging affair.

"Tom and Debbie never said a word, they didn't have to. Instead Sis just smiled in Tom's direction, and in the blink of an eye, Tom was fondling Debbie's 36D's. Moments later my future fiancé was sucking on Sis' nipples like a hungry new born calf. Sis just wasn't just sitting idly by, like a duck in still water, but was busy swinging her hips upward, rubbing her pussy all over one serious rock hard erection, and in the blink of an eye, Tom was sliding his cock up and down Sis' inner lips.

"John immediately turned his full attention to Cathy, and in a New York minute, he was like the primary male African lion of the pride, kissing, and licking every inch of Cathy's 36C's only seconds before sucking her nipples, squeezing her ass, and rubbing his cock up and down her slit.

"Cathy was beside herself, and in a frenzy. She was rolling her hips like a belly dancer, and after some serious hip action, John's king-sized hard-on slipped between Cathy's wet, slippery inner lips.

"John immediately maneuvered Cathy flat on her back and onto the beach's sandy ground. Cathy raised her legs, rested the bend of her knees over John's shoulders, and crossed ankles. John didn't waste any time at all before he was sliding his cock its full length up and down Cathy's fleshy inner lips.

"John was busy sucking on Cathy's nipples, and while sliding his cock up and down her wet inner lips, he'd pause at times to tease her pussy's opening with the tip of his cock's head, before sliding the underside of his cock's head over her clit.

"Jimmy had slipped in behind me, and was no longer gleefully playing with my 34D's, but was fondling them in all the right ways. My little brother had learned his lessons well, and was no longer the naïve innocent virgin that I once had to tell from A to Z on what he had to do in order to fuck Cathy!

"Jimmy was cupping my breasts, gently running his fingers around my entire boob, tracing his fingers along the curve from my sideboob to underboob, while breathing warm moist air on the back of my neck, kissing the back of my neck, nibbling on my ears, and collarbone. The feelings of Jimmy's lips was lighting up my neck, ears, and collarbone like volts of electricity, sending goosebumps up and down my spine.

"After teasing my boobs from the base to my dark spots, little brother's middle and index fingers were circling my dark spot, lightly stroking, and gently massaging my nipples in a circular motion— causing them to harden like two throbbing twin peaks!