Twins in the Dark Ch. 02

Morning rose slowly over Tory and Eve. Despite the closeness they had rediscovered yesterday, they spent most of their day apart. Tory spent most of hers away from home, doing laundry and shopping, preparing for Justin's return. And of course, *thinking* about him and all that could happen tomorrow night. He didn't exactly live with Eve and her, but as he and her sister got along fine, he usually spent three or four nights a week with her. His place was far away and very small, so in addition to living with two gorgeous sisters he was closer to the College where he studied. So Tory, eager to see him again although he'd be sleeping with Eve tonight, bought a new skirts, tops, bras and panties that she was sure he'd like.

On the other hand, Eve spent most of her day in Tory's bed, living up to her private nickname and masturbating as if her life depended on it. She just couldn't believe that tomorrow night she'd feel a live cock inside her. Since her hymen had been broken by Tory last night, she finally could use some of her sister's dildos and vibrators. It felt good, really good. But now that she knew that she was going to get a real cock soon, the dildos teased her more than anything else...

In a moment of intense pleasure, very close to one of her climaxes, she accidentally pushed two inches of one large dildo in her asshole. Her hands, as well as her pussy and asshole, were covered with lubricant and the long black doing had slipped from her hand. Pain and pleasure lanced outwards, but Eve didn't pull it out immediately. Feeling the tight pain at such an intimate place felt really, really naughty. She pulled it out slowly until only the tip remained inside her.

And then, purring with pleasure, she pushed it back in. Slowly. Slowly but much deeper. She gasped and cried out when she felt the warm length pushing her insides apart, driving up another virgin alley. She had slid her index finger in her ass once, well lubricated, when she had been in the throes of another intense orgasm. But she hadn't particularly liked the experience. But now, feeling the thick rubber cock inside her, it was completely different!

Just as she was exploring the depths to which she could safely go with the long dildo, she heard Tory coming back from her shopping. She pulled the dildo out completely, her heart beating fast and her orgasm fading away, as she didn't want her sister to surprise her. Had it simply been inside her pussy, Eve would have slowed down and waited for her sister to arrive. But she was not sure about what she had been doing, and was even less sure about Tory's potential reaction. They had talked about a lot of things together, but never about anal sex. In fact, Eve didn't even know if Tory had ever tried it before. She didn't think so.

So she quickly closed the bottle of lube and hastily cleaned the dildo and vibrator. Luckily Tory didn't come to her room right away. When she did come, Eve faked light sleep and groggily opened her eyes when Tory opened the door. The fact that she was naked under the light blankets didn't arouse Tory's suspicions. Instead Eve got treated to a modeling session, with Tory showing her than putting on every article of clothing she had bought.

When Tory got naked and began putting on lingerie only to take it off a minute later, Eve slipped her hand back to her pussy. She was still dripping wet and the sight of her sister getting in and out of new lingerie was enough to bring her climax back to life. At one point she moaned and covered it with a "Wow" at what her sister was wearing, but the following moan couldn't be hidden.

Tory turned around her eyes wide and saw that Eve wasn't even trying to hide herself anymore. Her eyes were closed, her breasts accidentally bared by her movements, and a third and fourth moan soon followed. Tory, wearing light green panties and bra, knelt beside her twin and cupped one of her breasts. Hard. She placed her other hand behind her head and pulled her face up for a tongue fight. She was laughing a few seconds later as she felt Eve exploding all over her. Eve's tongue was a whirlwind, her passion an explosion.

Eve laughed with her sister as her climax receded, then drew her against her breasts for a more affectionate hug. The twins cooked themselves a nice dinner, but were already thinking about tomorrow's dinner, Eve's last meal as a true virgin. They spent a quiet evening and went to bed early. They slept together but Eve merely caressed Tory while Tory masturbated: she was now sore and didn't want to be tomorrow night. They slept deeply and got up at eleven o'clock on the fateful Thursday.

They took a quick breakfast naked in bed, before Tory pulled Eve up and lead her to the bathroom. When she pulled out a razor, Eve looked surprised.

"Come on Eve, " Tory said, "Justin knows my pussy like the back of his palm... If he feels your mound he'll know right away that something's wrong..."

"Oh. But is it impossible that it could grow in two weeks?"

"Not that long... Come on, are you shy?"

"Of course not... But I've never shaved my mound before."

"Well, I'm not completely shaved, so you don't have to go completely bald. "

"But you could have, as a surprise for him..."

"I suppose, yes."

"Ok then, let's shave it all off!"

Tory was surprised at her sister's reaction, but was glad to see that Eve wasn't shy after all. They hopped in the shower and laughed and giggled their way through the ordeal of shaving Eve. Tory even asked her to turn around and shave the few light hairs below her pussy. After having pushed a dildo up her ass yesterday, Eve really enjoyed her sister's fingers on her ass. Tory noticed.

"Hmmm, enjoying this aren't we?"

"No no, that's just the water..."

"Oh yeah?" Tory pushed a finger inside Eve's pussy. When she moaned, the women laughed together.

"Ok ok, I admit... I'm really looking forward to tonight, even though I'm really scared as well.

"I know Eve, " Tory said as they were getting out of the shower. "But don't worry about it, everything's going to be alright."

They left the bathroom, dry but still naked, and sat down next to each other in the living room couch.

"Ok listen Eve. Here's what's likely to happen. Justin's going to come in the room and find you asleep under a blanket. You'll be wearing some of my lingerie. At first he won't make a sound and he'll pull the blanket off to look at you. After a while he'll start feeling you up all over: your thighs, calves, belly, pussy, breasts..."

"What do I have to do in this little game?"

"Not much... Remember that you're the innocent little virgin."

"Oh yes... I'm a virgin alright, but I don't know about innocent!"

"Indeed! But you'll have to play along and not jump on him as soon as you see his cock. OK. After a while you fake waking up and play the frightened girl. At one point after he keeps touching you, you tell him in a little voice that you're ready. He'll then undress you and crawl between your legs and then, after a while, fuck you."

"Hmmm, I really like *that* part!" they laughed again.

"But remember, don't grab his cock, don't try to lick or suck him... You're supposed to be a timid and submissive girl.

"Ok. And then once we're done I get up to wash myself and I'll find you in my bed, waiting. "

"Yes, and probably masturbating while listening to you two fuck."

Eve looked at her sister for a few seconds. "You're really looking forward to this? Aren't you afraid of having Justin fucking someone else?"

"Not if it's you my love. And as I told you, I really think that he'd like to fuck you anyway. Who knows where this special night could lead the three of us?"

Eve leaned forward and kissed her sister, thanking her for this incredible gift. The rest of the day went by slowly, painfully slowly for Eve. They went rollerblading, watched 2 movies, took a shared shower again and finally prepared for the night. At eleven and a half, Tory picked lingerie, dressed Eve and kissed her, before tucking her into bed. After that went back to Eve's room and tried to sleep before Justin got back.

Neither sister slept before Justin opened the door silently. Their hearts started beating faster at the same time, and anticipation grew with each of his steps towards their bedroom. Had Justin known how nervous both women were at that moment, we would have been mystified. He, of course, had no idea of what was happening. All he knew was that he was coming home, well not home yet, but it could become home soon, to a loving girlfriend.

A loving girlfriend who was playing the virgin maiden for him tonight. Before the call Tuesday he had had many other ideas about his first night with Tory, most of them including sex a lot more intense than what he was going to have with his shy virgin. In fact, Justin had though about Tory every night during two weeks, dreaming about ravishing her and fucking her brains out. On the other hand, that particular role-play was his favorite and when he heard Tory speaking with her little voice, he knew that he couldn't tell her no. She had seemed really, really eager on the phone, had even given him an erection, and he was now only second away from her.

The room was completely dark, no candles or small lamp. As expected. Tory didn't say a word and appeared to be sleeping. Also as expected. Looking down at her motionless form, he nonetheless saw that she was breathing too quickly for someone sleep. "Good!" he thought. "She's as excited as I am! This is going to be great!" Justin undressed silently, staring at the barely lit woman in his bed, not for a second doubting that this was not his girlfriend.

He was already hard and twice he had to lick his lips because he was salivating too much. He was now naked, looking into his virgin's face, loving how gorgeous she looked and realizing how lucky he was. With his cock obviously hard in the darkness, he looked at her. He had fallen in love with an incredibly beautiful women, truly loved her and knowing she loved him back. What more could one man ask for? A twin sister? Justin grinned at the thought but dismissed it, careful not to laugh audibly.

He bent down and slowly removed the blanket, uncovering his love's body. "Hmmm, she chose my favorite dark red lingerie... this is going to be a night to remember!" he thought, not knowing just how true that was. He sat down beside her and began caressing her belly. Soft, a very fine down of hair below her navel, and just as feminine as it gets. Justin was not a man that cared for the Heidi Klums of the world. No. Justin liked his women to be real, fully loaded where it counted, with breasts and hips that could turn eyes and harden cocks.

He let his hand wander down to his maiden's hip and thigh, enjoying the smooth skin, the hot skin. He smiled in the darkness: she was really hot. With the back of his fingers he grazed her mound and pussy, feeling even more heat. The maiden moaned slightly in her sleep but didn't wake up. After that his hand kept moving up and found one of the big breasts he so loved. He cupped one in his hand and squeezed slowly as to not wake her up. Her breasts felt and looked as if God had spent twice as much time on them than any other. Or had given Tory and Eve twice as much breasts as they were supposed to have. Heidi Klum could cower in shame before anyone of the twins.

Justin knew that he now should wake her by feeling her harder. But instead he straddled her legs and began pulling the panties down. "Will she play along?" he wondered. Apparently she did. Of course, anyone really asleep would have waken up by now, feeling the panties being forced down. But his virgin maiden was sleeping hard! And then, even in the darkness, he saw that her mound was bared, completely shaven, as bald as it hasn't been for over 12 years. Oh my God it was beautiful.

Slowly, letting the virgin know that he didn't want her to wake up, her moved upwards and unsnapped the bra. The front hook gave way easily and he cursed the darkness as two gorgeous breasts were revealed. Pure flesh, pure youth, pure liveliness. They were exceptionally firm, with no tan lines or stretch marks whatsoever. He gently cupped them both in his hands, squeezing them softly. Then, taking another turn away from the usual game, Justin proceeded to turn his maiden over. He *needed* to see her ass.

When he did, all curves and smooth flesh, he couldn't help but stare. A large ass, a phat ass some of his friends would say, that seemed to beg to be spanked. But not tonight. That was *another* role-playing game. Right now he was above the perfect ass of the perfect virgin maiden. Too late to do anything about it, Justin realized that he had been drooling again and heard two drops of spit falling on his maiden's ass. Two soft plops. The virgin didn't bulge. He saw, mesmerized, the merging drops of spit sliding down between the buttocks, flow across her asshole and disappearing into her pussy.

The woman he thought was Tory was breathing faster now but to his delight she kept playing at being asleep. He was still looking at her flawless skin, the two short lines that defined her thighs from her ass, and the bold arch of her ass. And then, seeing the slightly gleaming trail of spit, he had an idea that was going to change the carefully calculated night for everyone: he was going to take his maiden while she slept. It shouldn't matter much, he thought, as she was already willing. On the other hand, even though she must be excited, she'd probably not be wet enough. And knowing that she'd wake up for sure if he caressed her until she was really wet, he had another plan.

He straddled her thighs again and looked once again at her glorious ass. And he spat a big glob of spit directly between her cheeks. Then, with his thumb her spread it over her asshole and pussy. He had never explored anal sex with her, but he'd let his thumb do some exploring for him. He could ask Tory about what she thought about it tomorrow. After a while he spat again and spread it around. He did that three other times until he couldn't spit anymore. He had teased her ass quite a lot more than he had intended, but each time he went further, his maiden only sighed contentedly. After making sure that she was as lubricated as she could be without any penetration, Justin leaned over the bed and pulled the lubricant bottle from the drawer. He lubed his length up and down, putting lube from the root to the crown of his cock, careful to pull his foreskin back and lube below the head as well. He had no idea he was about to surprise both himself and the lucky maiden below.

Eve had nearly opened her eyes in surprise when Justin had begun pulling her panties down. But seeing how he was careful to be gentle, she understood that he wanted her to keep sleeping. Eve was overexcited and eager to have a cock inside her, but she was getting more nervous now that Justin was changing the plan. She enjoyed having him feel her up, especially her breasts, but once more was surprised when he slowly turned her over.

This wasn't the plan Tory had told her about. Either she was too thrilled to remember correctly or Justin was changing the plan as he went along. She never would have remained asleep while being turned around, but seeing how gentle he was, she guessed correctly that he wanted her too. She nearly felt him staring at her ass and loose long hair, but definitely felt the drop of spit falling on her ass. What was that about? Eve had no idea that it had happened by mistake, but as she felt it creep down her crack and over her asshole, she smiled against the pillow.

The he straddled her and spat again, only to begin massaging that spit into her asshole and pussy. It took all of Eve's willpower not to turn her head back and ask him to fuck right there. Never before had she been more turned on than right now, having her wet asshole teased by her sister's boyfriend. When she felt him reaching for the lube, she nearly gasped aloud, knowing that he was going to fuck her in a few seconds. She was still faking to be asleep, but knew that she was doing a very bad job of it. Well, it was the intention that counted!

She though that he would push his cock against her pussy and push in while still straddling her thighs. Instead Justin leaned forward and lied down over her very slowly. Right into her ear he whispered, extremely faintly so that a really sleeping woman wouldn't have heard: "Oh baby I'm going to fuck that pussy of yours like there was no tomorrow..." Eve began breathing too loud for anyone sleeping, but she didn't reply. All she wanted was his cock inside her.

He began pushing his cock up between her asscheeks, making the underside of his cock slide across her pussy and asshole. He slowly moved downwards as he humped her, pushing his cock closer to her wet pussy every second. He was breathing a lot harder now, his movements becoming faster and faster. He began moaning and speaking louder until he said something that made Eve's eyes open wide. "Oh yes baby, forget about that role-playing, I'm going to fuck you so bad..." Eve panicked for a second or two, not knowing what to do. Then he spoke again, all the while humping her ass harder and harder. "Raise your ass Tory, let me fuck—" And then he stopped suddenly, shocked himself, as Eve took a sharp intake of breath.

By the time Eve had pulled her ass upwards to help him get the right angle, Justin was so excited that he just kept pushing and thrusting against her. One or two thrusts before he could have sheathed his cock all the way inside her pussy, his lubed cock met her lubed ass and his cock drove at least three inches inside her before he stopped. They had both realized what had happened; Eve, painfully.

"Oh I'm sorry baby, I'm sorry—" Justin said.

"Shhh." Eve replied. "Just don't move." She whispered, fearing that if she spoke aloud he'd recognize her.

"What? Don't you want me to pull out?"

"No, not yet. Just give me a second."

Eve's mind was on fire. She was not getting her first cock up her pussy, completing the plan Tory had put in motion two days ago, but she was getting something almost as good: she was getting her very first assfucking. Before she could think it all through, she whispered: "Push in slowly..." and he did. He was raised on his arms and pulled his body upwards. It was painful for Eve, more so than with the dildo, but at the same time it was so much better! She was breathing hard and fast, trying to comprehend and appreciate everything her body was feeling.

Justin, above, was barely believing what was happening. He had been toying with the idea of anal sex for a while, but was far from certain that Tory would be interested. the few times he had teased her asshole with his fingers she hadn't responded at all. But now, feeling his cock being squeezed in his girlfriend's vise-like ass, Justin was grinning like a fool. Inch after inch until nearly all of his length was buried into the virgin abyss. He had come into the room expecting a role-playing virgin, had dropped the game as he was too restless, and suddenly he was finding a real virgin. His woman, the ass virgin. Well, no longer!

Eve, underneath, was throbbing all over. It was really painful, having Justin so deep inside her, but at the same time it was so incredibly delightful that she could nearly forget about the pain. "Put more lube Justin, pull out and put more lube..." He felt him reaching for the bottle and pulling out. When he pushed back in slowly but definitely more lubricated, Eve's mouth smiled open in pleasure. The pain was fading away, leaving nothing but the anal thrill she had begun to explore this afternoon.

And soon, seeing that everything was sliding in and out more easily, Justin picked up the speed. He couldn't believe how tight and wonderful a virgin ass could feel, and he was elated by the sight of his girlfriend shaking in pre-orgasmic bliss. Tory was moaning under him, pushing her ass up and against his thrusts. Firmly grasping the bed sheets Justin pulled himself upward even faster, driving his cock harder into Tory's ass. The bed was beginning to creak, Tory was beginning to groan and he knew that he'd be coming soon.