Two Smiles with the Same Story

'Oh God... Catherine... You're going to make me-'

Before I knew it, I had cummed. The feeling of my orgasm smashed into me, and flooded my entire body.

'Oh my gosh Catherine... I'm so sorry...' I apologized to her.

She kissed back up my stomach.

I twitched as my orgasm still rode through me.

'Don't apologize... That's what I was trying to do to you,' she said, kissing my neck.

Wow... I can't even describe how amazing that was...

My orgasm faded somewhere in my body, and I caught my breath.

'Catherine...'

'Yes Oakleigh?'

'Lay... Lay down...'

Immediately, she lay down.

I had no idea what to do. I don't want her to know that either.

I thought to start off at her breasts. I leaned down, and placed my mouth to her breasts, licking the nipple gently.

'Mmm... That's good...' she said, arching her back.

'Is it?' I asked her, moving to her other breast.

'Mhmm...' she mewed softly.

Kiss down her stomach now?

I slowly made my way down her stomach, and I looked up at her and made eye contact.

Oh gosh... This is so intense... Don't look in her eyes Oakleigh... You're probably making her uncomfortable by doing that...

I placed my fingers to her pants and unbuttoned them, bringing them down her legs.

She tangled her fingers into my hair. Is that her way of telling me to stop?

'Keep going,' she said, looking down.

Never mind.

My nervous self gently kisses up and down her long legs, rubbing them as I did so.

She moaned gently, bucking her hips.

I hope these are pleasure responses...

I kissed her gently through her panties, and she gasped.

'What? What's wrong? I asked her, trying not to panic.

'No, nothing is wrong, trust me,' she told me, holding the back of my head.

I shakily continued, trembling my lips over her panties.

Do I take them off now?

'Take them off,' she said, lifting her hips.

Yep, it's time they come off.

I grabbed them gently, dragging them down her legs.

They hit her ground.

'Tell me what you like,' I told her, kissing her thighs.

She nodded, closing her eyes.

****

I need to feel his tongue, his mouth, his lips.

I bet it will feel so good...

****

I was so nervous.

I could hear my heart pounding. I was afraid that she would be able to hear it too.

Slowly, I brushed my lips up against her, kissing her gently.

'Agh...' she moaned, arching her neck into the pillows.

I slowly inserted my tongue into her, placing her legs on my shoulders.

I swirled my tongue gently inside of her, hoping it felt good.

'Oh... That feels good Oakleigh...' she said, gripping my hair.

I started to get more comfortable. She will tell me what's good for her...

'Go more circular with your tongue, move it up more,' she told me.

I did what she told me, and her moans escalated once I found the spot she wanted.

'Oh... Yes... Right there... Like that..' she moaned, throwing her head back.

Her moans made me feel confident that I could make her feel good.

'Shit Oakleigh...' she moaned, gripping the sheets.

I stopped.

'Yes?' I asked her, thinking she wanted me to stop.

She immediately sat up.

'Why did you stop?' she asked me, out of breath.

'Keep going?' I asked her.

'Yes, yes please keep going,' she said, laying back down.

I continued. I gently wrapped my lips around her clit, trying to suck it.

'You're good Oakleigh, that feels good,' she moaned to me, holding onto a patch of my hair.

I continued to lick and suck her gently, kissing around her once in a while. Soon after, I noticed her breath started to become broken, her hips were in the air, and she was ripping at her sheets.

'Yes... Ugh yes... I'm cumming...' she moaned.

****

It feels amazing...

My orgasm shot through my veins, invading every inch of my body.

Ugh... That was so good...

I tried to catch my breath as he slowly kissed back up my stomach.

'How was that?' he asked, hovering over me.

I held his face.

'Amazing Oakleigh,' I breathed, looking him in the eye.

****

I smiled.

I made her feel good. That makes me feel good too.

I lay down next to her, playing with her hair as she caught her breath.

****

I caught my breath as my orgasm disappeared.

That was so good...

Well... He should go home now...

I turned around to face him.

'Thank you for this...' I told him, smiling.

'Thank you so much Catherine... I hope this will grow between us and build a connection,' he said.

'It will...' I said.

He smiled, looking into my eyes.

Don't look at him like that Catherine... This isn't a relationship... Tell him he has to go now...

'Well we should call it a night. I got to work early,' I told him.

'Oh, right,' he said, getting up and finding his clothes.

I wrapped the bedsheets around me, sitting up.

He became fully dressed again, and I stood up in front of him.

'Come, I'll take you back upstairs,' I said, guiding him back up.

We both stood at the front door. I opened it.

'Thank you Catherine,' he said, stepping out onto the porch.

'Thank you,' I said, leaning up against the door.

He closed his eyes, leaning in and pressing a kiss to my cheek.

I ignored the feeling of guilt that settled into me, and smiled.

'Goodnight Catherine,' he said.

'Goodnight Oakleigh,' I said, closing the door.

I watched him from the window as he started to walk away.

I leaned up against the back of my door.

No feelings... No relationship... Just sex... I can't do this relationship thing... I'm sure he won't want the relationship thing either... This is good, it's great. It doesn't have to be serious, it can be casual.

It's great.

****

Wow...

I walked across the street before the passing car.

That was so beautiful. I hope I can see her again. Maybe I will ask her to dinner. That should also make our relationship stronger.

I arrived back home and grabbed my phone. She had given me her number while we were at the café. I punched her number into my phone, and texted her.

'Thank you so much for an unforgettable night. You are so beautiful and sweet. Thank you,'

****

My phone lit up with an unknown number.

I looked. It's Oakleigh.

I remember him telling me that number.

I opened the text, and read it.

I can't respond to that... Just leave it Catherine... This isn't serious...

I put my phone down, went to the shower and fell asleep shortly after.

************

How was it? Should I continue? xx

Hope you're all well xoxo

'You're beautiful just the way you are,' - Kate xo