Two Wrongs DO Make a Right

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

While they talked and giggled Kelly suddenly became aware of a hand on her own thigh, it casually stroked her just as she had done earlier tonight, what shocked her more than anything was that the hand in question belonged to Amy and not Bianca! After putting all her effort into seducing one sister, and almost succeeding, Kelly found herself panicking, she couldn't brush Amy away but, if she had feelings for her, there was no way she could continue trying to get with Bianca. What she wanted originally was to get back at Jennifer, to do the exact thing that Jennifer guarded against! She didn't want to come between the two loving sisters though, after all, they had shown her nothing but kindness since they saw each other in town that day.

It wasn't long until they arrived at the girls' house, and pretty soon they were out of the taxi and hurrying to the front door, eager to get out of the cold night and into the warm house. Amy told Kelly that they had left the central heating system running on a low setting so it should be nice and warm indoors, as they entered the house the wave of heat hit them, making them suddenly feel very hot! In short order they took off their coats and shoes, then Amy turned the kettle on to make some coffee, soon after all three of them were warmed up and sat in the living room, Kelly sat on one end of the little sofa with Bianca beside her, Amy was slumped in a comfy looking chair directly opposite them. Now that it was just the three of them, they didn't worry as much about their clothes as Amy demonstrated when she rested her feet on the chair, bending her knees so they were close to her chest giving both her little sister and Kelly an unobstructed view of her pretty black panties. Bianca also had her feet up on the sofa, her elbow rested on the arm of the sofa which helped her hand support her head, her knees were drawn underneath her and her arse pointed towards Kelly.

As they were sat Kelly could easily see up Bianca's dress and on a few occasions found herself either staring at the thin material that covered the girl's pussy and her firm rear that was fully on show, or staring at the other sisters exposed legs, thighs and underwear, all the while Kelly got more and more excited, enjoying having the young women to stare at. She was certain that either of them could see up her own dress, her knees had drifted apart and her dress had ridden up when she sat down anyway. What a sight they must be! Kelly thought to herself, she was certain that her pussy was moistening, after the sisters left her to the sofa for the night she intended to give herself a little treat before bedtime!

"So, Kelly," said Bianca with a slight nervousness in her tone. "We...well; we have a small confession to make." She sounded worried and when Kelly turned to face her she avoided her glare, looking towards Amy instead.

"It's nothing bad," Amy said quickly. She considered her words carefully before proceeding; she put her feet back on the floor and leant towards Kelly. "We like you, and now Jennifer is out of the picture it means we're free to be...friendly."

"Ok," said Kelly, trying her best to understand exactly what the sisters were getting at.

"Which is great," said Bianca, "I mean being friendly is...good." She, like her sister, had put her feet back on the floor and leant in towards Kelly, making no effort to cover herself up. "The thing is...there was a reason Jennifer was worried about the three of us being friendly, because..."

"Look," Amy said firmly. "I'm just going to tell her, or we'll be here for hours dancing around it, Kelly. Bianca and I aren't just sisters, we are..."

"In love," Bianca finished for her.

"With...each other?" Kelly asked, stunned.

"Yes," Amy confirmed. "Please keep our secret; please don't tell anyone, we don't need that kind of attention from people."

"Does Jennifer know about it?" Kelly asked them, still fully expecting them to start laughing and saying it was all a joke.

"Yeah, she found out, why?" Bianca asked.

"Something she said over the phone when she...dumped me, she said that if you didn't stay away from me she'd do something to spoil your fancy new life," said Kelly, surprised and a little annoyed at the pang of pain that ran through her when she recalled the phone call that ended her first real relationship.

"She said it to us as well, take no notice of her, she can't prove anything, all that matters is; we love each other, it's not just illicit sex or a fling or something. We're serious, do you understand Kelly?" asked Amy, she spoke of her love so emotionally that Kelly could have cried for her.

"I understand, the heart wants what it wants," she said in a 'matter of fact' way. "I don't think it's sick or anything."

"Thank you so much," said Bianca. She moved towards Kelly and sat right beside her, and then she leant forward and hugged Kelly. They held each other for a moment; Kelly breathed in the scent of the young woman and had to restrain herself from kissing her bare neck.

"Is this what you meant earlier? You said you had a confession to make," asked Kelly.

"Well, that was part of it," said Bianca, letting go of her. She laid her left hand on Kelly's knee and stroked her soft skin. "When Amy said we like you, we meant..."

"We really like you," Amy finished. To illustrate her point she got out of her chair and sat on the arm of the sofa. Kelly was in-between both sisters, Bianca was sat close to her on her right side, still gently stroking her leg. Amy was on her left on the raised arm of the sofa; Kelly's head was about level with her breasts. From her raised position, Amy began stroking Kelly's long blonde hair, enjoying the feeling of the beautiful woman. At last, Kelly understood, all night she'd been trying to seduce Bianca, at the same time both Amy and Bianca were attempting to pique her interest, to tempt her to come back to their house where they would reveal their secrets. Now it was they who wanted to seduce her, to share the beautiful woman who had been so cruelly treated by their sister. To comfort her while they, in turn, comforted each other.

Kelly looked up at Amy, the rock chick red hair and blood red lipstick, her face was so beautiful, her lips were pouted and, in this bizarre moment, Kelly desperately wanted those luscious lips pressed against her own. Amy saw the desperation in Kelly's eyes, the blonde was silent but her stare screamed to her without moving a muscle, Kelly was able to convey her need, her lust, with a simple look. Amy slowly lowered her head, the fierce apprehension bolted through her but she resisted the urge to 'dive in.' Amy enjoyed the look of anticipation on Kelly's face, her lips parted and her tongue rose ever so slightly towards Amy's oncoming mouth. For a few agonising seconds, Amy made her wait, she was just out of reach, but then, after what seemed like hours, Amy covered Kelly's open mouth with her own. Their kiss was soft, sensual and erotic all at the same time. Kelly closed her eyes as their tongues danced with each other, neither of the women wanting to come up for air. However, the person who most enjoyed the moment was Bianca; she watched her sister's tongue probe Kelly's mouth and watched their lips kiss as they savoured each others taste. It would be her turn soon, but for now the watching was just fine.

For the last 9 months, while Kelly was seeing Jennifer, she had felt used. She'd felt no more important than an inflatable sex doll, her needs often went unfulfilled and sometimes they were flat out ignored. She had longed to make love, she had never experienced real love making, the erotic and sensual pleasure that two women can give each other. Here and now, Amy was kissing her in a way she had dreamt about, no hard pressure, no violent thrusts or raw fucking! This was gentle, slow, soft, intense, beautiful and sensuous in the most erotic way. On top of all that, there was a beautiful 19 year old girl watching them, it sent a voyeuristic thrill through Kelly, soon she would need to sample the sweet lips of the younger sister.

Amy broke the kiss and moved away, she had been stroking Kelly's hair but now she gentle pushed her head to one side. Kelly realized that Amy was guiding her towards her little sister. Kelly looked dreamily at the sweet and smiling expression on the birthday girl's face, Bianca swung her right leg over Kelly's left leg, placing her knee on the sofa in-between Kelly's bare thighs. After positioning her small body in such a way that she straddled Kelly's left leg, she leant forward and parted her lips, unlike Amy, Bianca didn't tease or make her wait, because she simply wasn't patient enough. She pressed her pale pink lips against Kelly's mouth, relishing the taste of the sexy woman. Kelly noticed the similarity in Bianca's taste; it wasn't exactly the same as kissing Amy, but not far off.

Kelly started to relax and enjoy herself, she went from sister to sister, deeply kissing Amy and then switching to Bianca, and back again. Kelly had moved to the centre of the little sofa so there was room for each sister to sit either side of her, she had one hand on Amy's thigh and one hand on Bianca's and they, in turn, their hands explored her exposed flesh. Then the sisters looked at each other and smiled, they leant in towards each other and, directly in front Kelly, they kissed each other. This was no peck on the cheek, they kissed deeply, stroked each other's hair and closed their eyes, it was one of the most erotic scenes she had ever seen; the gorgeous blonde with hair down to her lower back, and the beautiful red haired girl with plump red lips and long pale legs, both kissing passionately, knowing they were sisters made it feel even sexier to Kelly, maybe because it's taboo...or flat out illegal!

Kelly found herself wondering how long they had been doing this, what a beautiful discovery it must be to realize someone so very close to you already was in fact your soul mate as well as a sister. As she watched the girls kissing she couldn't help feeling a little envious.

"Is this ok with you?" Amy asked cautiously, pulling away from her younger sister's lips, "not too weird?"

"No, it isn't weird, I was just thinking how nice it must be," said Kelly, trying not to be patronising. "I actually feel a bit jealous of you both."

"That's sweet of you," said Amy. "I'm glad it's not putting you off. We've been looking forward to sharing you," she giggled.

"Really?" Kelly asked, surprised that she could be the object of two people's desire.

"Absolutely," Bianca confirmed with a naughty smile, like a schoolgirl admitting she has a crush on someone. "Especially when we saw what you were wearing tonight, very tasty," she continued.

"Jennifer bought it for me," admitted Kelly, "the underwear as well!"

"Oh right," said Bianca, quickly regretting her compliments of the dress.

"She wanted to fuck me with a dildo on the bus," Kelly recalled.

"God," said Amy. "Did you do it?"

"No, of course not," she replied. "I stood up for myself for once."

"Good for you," said Bianca. She and Amy knew how hard it was to say no to her domineering sister, she'd just keep pushing until you gave in.

"After tonight I'll throw it away or tear it up, maybe cut in to little bits with scissors," said Kelly, giggling all the time.

"Can we help?" Bianca asked, grinning in that naughty way again.

"Sure," said Kelly.

"Hmmm, go and get the kitchen scissors Bianca," said Amy, smiling in the same way as her sister.

"Oh, I didn't mean now, I'll have nothing to wear when I go home!" Kelly said, panicking.

"It's ok, I'll lend you something," said Amy as Bianca skipped into the kitchen. A moment later she returned with a large pair of scissors and sat back down where she had been before, sandwiching Kelly between the two sisters.

"Where shall we start?" Bianca asked playfully.

"A little snip to start off and we'll tear it off her," said Amy.

"I thought I was going to take it off first!" Kelly said, surprised.

"More fun this way," said Amy. "Cut here," she said, pointing in between Kelly's breasts. Grinning widely, Bianca angled the scissors downward and snipped a little slit into the top.

"Do I get to tear your clothes off?" Kelly asked.

"You won't need to babe," replied Amy. After another snip, Bianca withdrew the scissors and pulled at the tear, it was tough material and would need both sisters' strength.

"Stand up, Kelly," said Bianca, pulling at her arm. Amy stood as well and took hold of a flap of torn dress. "You ready?" Bianca asked her sister.

"Yeah, on three. One...two...THREE!!!" Both sisters pulled as hard as they could, tearing the little dress open as far down as Kelly's navel. Kelly gasped as, quite suddenly, her upper body was revealed to these two girls. They hadn't finished yet, each of them took hold of the dress further down and, at the count of three again, they tore the pretty dress totally of their beautiful blonde guest. Even as the dress lay ruined at Kelly's feet, the sisters still had more to do. Amy retrieved the large scissors and stoop up in front of Kelly.

"You said our bitch of a sister bought your underwear too?" Amy asked.

"Y...yeah, she did," Kelly stammered, still a little shocked at her state of undress.

"Shhh...it's ok, we're having fun. Remember?" Amy said softly, stroking the older girl's hair gently. Kelly nodded and Amy smiled at her, a big, wide and beautifully seductive smile that made Kelly's heart skip a beat. "Let us take good care of you tonight; you don't have to worry about anything, right Bianca?"

"Yeah, of course," the youngest of the three girls agreed. She was squatted down at Kelly's side with her small hands holding on to her thigh. She lightly kissed her knee at first; and then she moved around behind Kelly and kissed the hollow recess behind her knee. Bianca wanted to enjoy Kelly's entire body, she planted soft kisses up the back of her thigh, then her cute buttocks, and finally she got to the base of Kelly's spine. Kelly shivered as she felt the young woman drag her tongue right up her spine as far as the shorter girl could reach.

"Ready for more?" Amy asked, sliding the cold scissors down Kelly's throat towards her bra.

"I think she is," said Bianca, walking around to stand in front of Kelly again, eager to see more of the stunning woman's body. Despite Amy and Bianca's soft encouragement, Kelly still felt apprehensive about being naked in front of these two girls, however the excitement was too tempting and she gently nodded in agreement. Amy smiled again and positioned the scissors directly between her cute breasts, trapping the middle of her bra between the two sharp blades. Then, after a little snip, Kelly's breasts were out in the open.

"Wow," said Bianca. "They're beautiful." She cleared away the remnants of the broken bra so she and Amy had an unobstructed view of the two sweet mounds. Wasting no time, Bianca cupped Kelly's right breast. She caressed the soft skin and ran her thumb ever so gently across the raised nipple, making Kelly shudder and tingle with pleasure. Amy took a hold of her left breast, caressing it in a similar way to Bianca. When both sisters were massaging her breasts, Kelly sighed and the tingling grew more intense, however, when the sisters simultaneously brushed her erect nipples she couldn't help gasping and sighing loudly. Her pussy tingled in a similar way to her breasts; it was demanding attention and took every last piece of self control she had to keep her hands by her side rather than rubbing the sweet flesh inside her panties.

Bianca and Amy smiled at each other when they heard, and felt, Kelly's reaction to their touch. It had been Amy's idea to coerce Kelly into this, Bianca wasn't sure at first but the more she'd thought about it, the more it piqued her interest. She had then suggested attempting to lure Kelly's friend, Ariel, into their plans but she hadn't arrived at the party. The night before the party they had talked about having both of them, Kelly and Ariel, at the same time, each sister having one of the friends for a while and swapping over. They reworked the plan earlier tonight while they were at the club and decided to simply share Kelly rather than take turns. Amy said it would be fun to explore the beautiful blonde's body together and, so far, all was going to plan.

"You like this, baby?" Amy asked Kelly.

"Mmmmm..." was all she could manage vocally so she just nodded her head in reply.

"Good, good girl..." Amy's voice was soft and full of lust but something caught Kelly's attention. Jennifer had always called her 'baby' when they had sex and, for just a moment, Kelly thought of the woman who had ripped out her heart. Despite her feelings of revulsion at the temptress, a smile crept along her lips; after all she now had Jennifer's two sisters pleasuring her. At this point, Kelly thought to herself, revenge was a dish best served hot and wet!

"Ready for the last part?" Bianca asked, holding the scissors again.

"Let's do it," Amy answered. Kelly didn't say anything, she was shaking again. Embarrassment was part of it, she was fairly sure it would be wet down there, but mainly because only Jennifer had seen her down there and now she was going to be totally naked in front of these two seductive sisters! Amy moved behind Kelly and rested her chin on her shoulder, briefly kissing her neck before sliding her hands around her slim waist. Hugging her from behind, her chest pushing into Kelly's back, Amy dragged her hands along the soft skin of Kelly's abdomen before bringing them up to her bare breasts, caressing them both so gently that it made the blonde's head fall back onto Amy's shoulder. Kelly was so focused on Amy's expert stimulation that she didn't even notice the cold metal on her thigh, and it wasn't until Bianca cut through the thin waistband of her panties which was followed by the feeling of the ruined silky material sliding down her legs and gathering around her feet, that she realized she was naked. Her clothes were ruined and she had no way of covering herself up but Kelly was so turned on that she didn't care about anything other than the amazing sensations the two sisters gave her.

"So," Kelly said breathlessly, "when do I get to see you naked?"

"Well we bought our own clothes so there's no need to ruin them," said Amy, still with her hands on Kelly's bare breasts. Bianca stood in front of them and smiled, clearly excited by what she saw; her beautiful sister fondling the naked blonde's breasts was an extremely erotic scene. Unable to stay away from the action, Bianca walked towards the two women; before she was in touching distance of the naked girl she suddenly stopped herself and stepped back.

"What is it?" Kelly asked.

"You wanna see me naked?" Bianca asked.

"Yeah, of course she does," said Amy, squeezing Kelly's breasts lightly, causing her to moan aloud. Bianca giggled at Kelly's obvious arousal and took another step back; she crouched down first and put her hands up her dress and pulled her panties down before standing up and tossing them aside, still giggling, Bianca slowly pulled the left strap of her dress down over her shoulder and slid her arm out of it, holding the dress in place with her left hand, she repeated the process with her right arm. Kelly silently begged her to drop the dress but Bianca made her wait, enjoying the look of pure lust on Kelly's face, Amy also watched her little sister's performance with growing desire, even though she'd seen her naked many times before. Finally, Bianca released her grip and the little dress tumbled to the floor and gathered around her feet, she stepped back and kicked it away, then stood before Kelly and Amy with her hands on her hips.

1...456789