Wrong Can Still Be Right Ch. 01

"NATALIE!" Caitlyn shouted, now wide-awake thanks to Natalie's moaning. "What the fuck are you doing?"

Natalie went from the brink of orgasm to a crashing halt. "Baby," she tried to explain, "it's OK, really!"

"No it fucking is not!" Caitlyn's face was white with shock. "You just caught me doing..." she trailed off.

"Doing your own brother," Natalie finished for her. "And in case you haven't noticed, I think that's about the sexiest thing I've ever seen. I mean, just look at me for a second."

Caitlyn finally saw her. Natalie had been caught with nearly her entire hand inside her cunt while she stared at Caitlyn blowing Nick on screen; it was crystal clear to Caitlyn all at once. "Wait you -- you mean you don't think I'm some horrible fucking pervert?"

"Fuck no!" Natalie yelled. "Are you shitting me? Look at me for fuck's sake. I'm elbow deep in my own snatch and you're still asking how I feel about it?"

Caitlyn burst into relieved laughter. "Thank God. I thought I'd just ruined... what we've got."

"No way," Natalie reassured her. "This is seriously the hottest thing I've ever seen. I counted thirty-seven of these videos. Is that all of it?"

"Not even close. We've been fucking like goddamn rabbits. We've probably recorded a tenth of it; it's something for him to look at once he goes off to college in the Fall. Mister Full Scholarship gets to skip community college unlike the rest of us chumps," Caitlyn explained.

Natalie raised an eyebrow. "So, are you guys, like, in love, or...?"

Caitlyn shook her head. "We're real clear on everything: this is for fun only. I mean, yeah, we're close and love each other but we're not like in love. We're just fucking, pure and simple. And we're going to keep doing it as long as it's fun. And, Natalie," Caitlyn said with a wicked smile, "it's the most fun I've ever had."

Natalie tapped a finger against her chin, thinking. "This has been going on for what, a year?"

"Pretty much right after he turned eighteen," Caitlyn confirmed. She described how everything had happened starting with the seduction, and Natalie's imagined version wasn't far off at all. "Seriously, Nat, you have no idea how great it is," Caitlyn gushed, starry-eyed. "The rush is unbelievable. We're breaking all the rules, but for all the right reasons. Yeah it's incest, but that's half the fun!"

Natalie laughed. "You don't have to sell me, you know. I feel exactly the same way just watching you guys screw."

Caitlyn's grin widened. "You should try it."

Natalie blinked. "What, with Nick?"

"No, with Jake! Although..."

Natalie waved the thought away. "One thing at a time, sweetheart. You seriously think I should fuck my own brother."

"Yes."

"This is ridiculous," Natalie muttered.

"Bullshit, you're just being close-minded. Stop thinking of him as your brother and just look at him for what he is. Smart, good-looking, funny, and he did just save your ass from Dan."

Natalie nodded. "Still though, I'm not so sure I feel that way about him."

"He happens to be related to you, that's all. Then again, you of all people seem to enjoy the kinky incest part, so maybe I should be emphasizing that." Caitlyn looked pensive.

Natalie rolled her blue eyes. "You're enjoying this idea, aren't you. You want me to fuck him."

Caitlyn spread her hands in a helpless gesture. "So?"

"What happened to you having a crush on him?"

Caitlyn chuckled. "I'd share my fantasy boyfriend with you since you're his sister and I've got the hots for you both. That'd totally be worth it."

Natalie sighed. "Look, I'm just not so sure. I'm not saying 'never,' but I am saying 'I'm not so sure.'"

Caitlyn shrugged. "It ain't for everyone, that's for sure. He's got to want you, too."

"And that is by no means certain."

Caitlyn walked over to Natalie and squeezed into the computer chair next to her, taking a smiling, naked Natalie into her arms.

So quietly that Natalie almost didn't hear her, Caitlyn said, "We could make it certain."