You Were Wonderful Tonight

Story Info
Fucking the Youth Leader is high risk, high reward.
2.1k words
3.88
36.3k
14
0
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

I've never been a big church guy.

Despite growing up in a All-American religion loving family, I just didn't enjoy it. I found it a waste of time and a general bother.

But that all changed when I learned how to play guitar and joined the worship band.

Have you ever been naturally good at something without trying? That's how guitar was for me. I was gifted, for sure, with big hands. Standing a strong 6'1" at 19 years old with jet black hair and light brown eyes, I felt at ease on stage. Before I knew it, I had put in half a decade at this little church in my little town, moving my way up to lead guitarist and music director.

One day, in the middle of the hottest summer on record, we had a new family join the church. A Mexican father, hairy like a bear but balding like an eagle, introduced his wife and children to me.

"Nice to meet you, Sean. I'm Rosie," his wife said, in a very faint Latino accent.

She was average height, with curly dirty blonde hair, clearly dyed. Inspecting her further, I could tell she had been quite the looker in her prime, with a decent b-cup chest and a wide hips that accented a large ass. She couldn't have been a day over 40. As she moved to introduce her children, I could see through the thin material of her cloth dress that she wasn't shy about wearing sexy lingerie, as a dark red thong was clearly visible.

She turned back around and smiled at me.

"These, are my children, Julia, Ramona and Victor."

Julia, 18, was by far the prettiest of the two girls. She was her mom's height, maybe a bit shorter, but much more petite. Her gorgeous dark brown doe eyes, wavy black hair and dimples were her selling points, and I thought as much as I wondered how many boys had fallen under their spell thus far.

Next to her was Ramona, her drastically obese 22 year old sister. I could tell she had inherited a lot of her mom's natural beauty, but as I learned later, she had become an alcoholic following a rough breakup with her high school sweetheart. Despite this, she had an absolutely amazing personality that brightened up the room.

Finally, there was Victor. Rosie's son was about my height, but built like a Marine. With broad-shoulders and a traditional military haircut, I guess he could pass for one. However, he actually worked at a engineering company down the road where he met his wife.

Now, up to this point, his wife had been sitting back and I hadn't noticed her. But when I did, my jaw just about hit the floor.

Naomi was half Mexican and half Native American. She was 24 and 5'5", with shoulder length chestnut brown hair. The girl had a pear body shape, with an small A-cup rack that juxtaposed her wide set hips and thick thighs.

But her ass was what had me going. It was wide and fat, clearly a product of her carrying a extra 10lbs on her otherwise healthy body.

More cushion for the pushing, eh?

As amazing as her body was, her face was great too. She had chocolate brown bedroom eyes that screamed "Fuck me!" while her dick sucking lips seemed to do the same. Seeing her smile with her gums slightly showing sent a bolt of lightning through my body.

I decided then. I had to have this woman.

***

A few years passed and Naomi became a close friend of mine. She worked her way up to the position of Youth Leader and, after we lost one of our singers, I asked her to join the worship team as well.

I would purposely ask her to stand right in front of me so I could watch her ass bounce while she was dancing during worship. She would wear the tightest skirts, and sometimes I wondered if she wore those things to the club as well.

Working with Naomi was great. I had finally found someone who was serious about succeeding as me. Still, I found myself undeniably attracted to her. And, despite the fact that she was married, she was clearly aware of this and flirted with me endlessly.

One time I had gotten to the church early to setup (as usual) when she walked in about a hour before church started.

"Need any help, boss?" she said with a devilish wink.

I smiled back at her.

"Just cleaning the storage room. You down?"

"Yeah, let's do it!"

As she led the way to the storage room, I couldn't help but notice her perfume. I didn't remember her wearing anything this strong before. Sniffing at the air again, the fragrance resembled French vanilla with a hint of cinnamon.

"Here we are!" she announced proudly over my internal monologue.

"So we are," I noted while grabbing a broomstick and handing her one. "You get that corner and I'll get this one, OK?"

"Sounds good."

I had been cleaning for only over a minute when I heard a scream from behind me.

"Sean! Something bit me!"

I turned around and ran to her.

"What was it!"

"I don't know, I think it's still in my dress! I have to take it off!"

Without another word, she pulled down her cloth dress, revealing her thick thighs and tummy, which had just a little pudge on it. On her waist, she had a very sexy, presumably very expensive, thong which accented her hips.

"Oooh, right here, Sean! On my thigh! I think it was a black widow!"

Not thinking, I grabbed her thigh with one hand and her waist with the other, looking for a bite mark. It didn't take long. There it was, about four inches above her knee cap. Clearly a spider, but no telltale signs of it being a black widow.

It was at that moment I spotted the little bugger. A common house spider, running across the ground. I squished it with my shoe before it made a run for it.

"Got him. Just a house spider, Naomi."

"Oh..."

We both then become aware what the situation would look like to anyone walking in.

Her, bottomless with her dress on the floor. Me, with one hand on her thigh and the other just inches away from her ass.

I looked away from her eyes before mumbling, "Uh..maybe you should get dressed before someone comes."

"Yeah, that's a good idea."

She turned around and pulled her dress back on. I couldn't resist looking at the last second, when her ass struggled to fit into the dress.

Absolute perfection.

***

Naomi's husband usually picked her up from band practice, but on this particular night, he couldn't make it.

She meekly came up to me as I was wrapping up cables and wires.

"Hey Sean, can you give me a ride home? My husband is out of town on a job site, and he won't be home until tomorrow morning."

I panicked a little bit inside. This was my chance.

"Uh...yeah, no problem. Let me just finish up here."

She smiled thankfully, "Awesome! I'll be sitting over here on my phone if you need me!" and she walked away.

I internally debated whether having sex with my youth leader and a married woman was wrong, but my dick made no mistakes, it wanted some ass.

I made up my mind. I was going to make the first move and if she wasn't interested, I would apologize and move on.

I grabbed my keys to lock the church and playfully punched Naomi on the arm as I walked out the door.

"Come on, dork. Let's go, I'm done."

From behind me I heard laughter.

"Oww! That hurt, you jerk! I'm going to get you back!"

***

We arrived at Naomi's house around 10PM, as I parked my Honda Civic in the driveway. Her husband's car sat next to mine, I guess he had taken a rental.

"Mind checking the house before you go?" Naomi asked me, "I don't really feel safe without Victor here."

I nodded, "Yeah. No problem."

As I got out of my car, I noticed how nice the house was. It was a off-white, two stories with probably four or five rooms. It had a definite Spanish feel to it.

"Your house is beautiful, Naomi. I can't wait to see the inside."

Unlocking the door for us, she said, "Watch your step, though. It's dark and the lights are across the hall."

She was right. As I stepped in after her, I couldn't see shit. Feeling for the light switch on the wall, I soon got lost in what felt like a long hall as the front door shut.

"Uh...Naomi?"

Suddenly, I felt fingers on my chest.

"Titty twister!" Naomi screamed at the top of her lungs!

"Oooh shit! Stop, haha, stop it hurts!" I said in between bouts of laughter.

Stumbling to find my step in the dark, I tripped over something (which I later learned was a ottoman) and fell, taking Naomi with me.

Laying on my back on the floor, I first became aware of her breath. It had quickened and she had her hands were on my chest, while mines were around her waist.

This is it, I thought.

"Naomi...I don't know how to put this, but-"

I was interrupted by a quick kiss on the lips. Before I could react, a second kiss came, this time overpowering. I let go of my inhibitions and just reacted.

I flipped her over and we made out on the floor in the dark until we were both out of breath.

"The lights...behind you!" she managed to get out.

I turned on the lights and in one quick move, picked her up off the floor and pinned her against the wall.

Her makeup was smeared and her hair was a mess. But she still looked absolutely ravishing.

Her eyes caught mine and without hesitation, she said, "I need you right now, will you be there for me?"

I looked deep in her eyes, and could tell she was serious.

"I need you too."

***

I grabbed Naomi off the wall while she wrapped her legs around my waist. I felt so strong in this moment, like I was unstoppable.

I walked up the stairs with her in my arms, found her bedroom without much trouble and dropped her gently on the bed.

In this moment, I realized what I was doing. I was breaking a marriage, and I was probably changing a relationship with my friend forever. But like I said, my dick was ready to go, and I was so deep in this, there was no turning back.

Pinning her on the bed, I pulled off her blouse and her dress. The smell of her clothes was amazing. I could smell that perfume again, and it took me back to that moment in the storage closet.

She looked so beautiful laying there on the bed in her black bra and black thong. I kissed her from head to toe and could tell she loved it when I kissed sensitive spots, so I flipped her over quickly and started kissing the back of her neck.

"Ooh, Sean, don't stop."

I pulled off her thong and saw her ass in it's full glory for the first time. It was amazing, very firm but with enough bounce to drive any man mad.

She took her bra off as I flipped her over once more. Her boobs were as they appeared, quite small, even more so when she was on her back. However, her nipples were already hard at the thought of getting fucked. I could have spent hours kissing them, but I was already ready to go, so a minute had to suffice.

Seeing her wet set me off even more.

"I need you now, Sean."

That's all I needed. I slowly inserted my tip into her while she quietly moaned, which increased in volume as I went deeper inside her, feeling her small petite boobs as I did. Pretty soon she was screaming, "Harder! Harder!" while I did my best to satisfy her.

Putting her on her stomach, I took another look at that gorgeous ass as I fucked her doggy style. She was ready to orgasm within minutes, just in time too, cause I couldn't have lasted much longer.

"Cum inside me!"

I panicked, "Are you sure?!"

"Just do it, I'm on the pill!"

My body seized up. I felt the hot juice from my penis shoot inside her and she started shaking from the intensity of her orgasm.

In seconds, it was over. I crawled next to her in bed and covered her as I whispered softly in her ear.

"You were wonderful tonight."

Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
Share this Story

Similar Stories

Comforting My Neighbor's Daughter I fuck my innocent neighbor when she comes to me for comfort.in Mature
Ms. Walker's Class Ch. 01 She helps him with a BIG problem.in Mature
The Busty Babysitter John has it bad for his top heavy young babysitter.in NonConsent/Reluctance
Babysitting Perks Snowstorm leaves sitter stuck at her client's house.in Mature
The Son-in-law Ch. 01 A visiting son in law ravishes his wife's mother.in NonConsent/Reluctance
More Stories