You're Not What I Thought You Were

PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here
MTL17
MTL17
2,010 Followers

Maybe it wouldn't. Maybe Paige would make it her mission to make sure that it never did. Bugger Emma every single chance she got to the point that the poor blonde wouldn't even remember what it was like to sit down without excruciating pain. Maybe as well as making sure that Emma's ass hole was always gaping wide open or was at least stuffed with a butt-plug or strap-on Paige would make sure that the other wrestler was pleasing her with her tongue so much that all of Emma's food would taste like pussy or arse. Maybe she'd pimp Emma out, or keep her as her exclusive fuck toy, or maybe she would even make the other girl tattoo Paige's Bitch somewhere on her body so everybody would know who this hot blonde belongs too.

There were many things Paige wanted in that moment, but one above all others, "Suck my dick slut! Mmmmmm, clean it of all your virgin arse juice! You see this cock Emma? You see this girl cock which just took your anal cherry? Mmmmmm, yeah you do, well now I want you to suck it! Suck your cherry of my cock! Ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhh Gooooooooodddddddddd yeeeeeeeessssssssss, mmmmmmmm, suck that cock! Suck the cock which has just been up your virgin arse you beautiful bitch!"

Emma had found herself spreading her own ass cheeks were several minutes. She didn't mind, she knew it was something WWE divas secretly loved to do to each other, and now she was firmly in that position Emma had to admit it felt thrilling. Humiliating, sure, but like the butt fucking before it that was part of the fun. Of course when she got the permission she had been waiting for she didn't hesitate letting go of her cheeks, turning around and crawling in between Paige's legs to wrap her lips around the head of the other girl's cock.

From the way Paige moaned anyone listening might think she had a real dick, which was kind of weird. Then again Paige was still obviously basking in the glory of taking another girl's anal virginity, and Emma could understand that. Sure she had never taken another girl's back door cherry, but having hers taken was a wonderful experience she would never forget, as she did in fact moaned when she took Paige's dick into her mouth, although that was motivated by more than just what had just happened.

After all Emma loved the taste of ass. Whether it was another girl's ass or her own, from the source or something else she always loved it. Not that she could lick her own ass, but she had tasted it a few times on the lips of a girl who had been giving her a rim job. This was like that but so much more perverted, Emma's eyelids fluttering as she revelled in the debauchery of tasting the deepest part of her bowels on this monster cock before relaxing her mouth and then her throat to give it a proper cleaning.

Emma hadn't been with that many men, and had never sucked a strap-on before, but she had practised with a few dildos and a banana or two so she didn't think she did that badly. Her technique was sloppy, and she couldn't deep throat the entire length like most of the girls she had fucked like Alicia Fox and Sasha Banks, but she used her tongue to clean what she couldn't get her mouth on, and not only did Paige not offer any complaint but she continued praising her.

"Yeeeeeessssssss, that's it, suck my dick!" Paige moaned, really getting off at watching Emma blowing her, "Suck it you nasty little cock sucker! Mmmmmm fuck, you look good with a cock in your mouth. Oh yeah, you look good with my cock in your mouth, greedily sucking your own arse cream all up like the dirty little ass to mouth whore you are! Ohhhhhhhh, that's right Emma, you're my ATM whore now. My anal slut, my pussy and arse eating slave, mmmmmmm, my lesbian bitch. You are mine Emma, all mine!"

"All yours." Emma agreed once she took her mouth off the thoroughly cleaned cock.

The two women exchanged a brief smile and then Paige pulled Emma up into her arms and shoved her tongue down her throat. After a few minutes of passionately making out Paige broke the kiss, caressed the pretty face she was now so enamoured with and grinned, "Get dressed. I changed my mind about not wanting a girlfriend, so wear something nice because I'm going to take you out on our first date. Provided of course that you're still willing to put out afterwards and happy with being the bottom of this relationship."

Emma grinned widely back and nodded enthusiastically, both NXT divas quickly throwing on some clothes before leaving together arm in arm for the first of many dates followed by nights of passionate lesbian sex.

MTL17
MTL17
2,010 Followers
Please rate this story
The author would appreciate your feedback.
  • COMMENTS
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous
7 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousover 9 years ago

Awesome work. Hope for one with charlotte and bayley/sasha/or natalya

MTL17MTL17over 9 years agoAuthor

To anonymous 1: I see it as a domination thing. In most of my WWE stories the women are not making love, they're using sex as a way to feel powerful/dominate each other. Sticking to just anal seems like a good way to do that, hot too.

To anonymous 2: While there's nothing wrong with lots of back story it's not always required. For this I didn't feel it was necessary as the back story was simple, and there is something to be said for jumping into the action and explaining as things progress. It's a way of writing I quite enjoy, and combined with narrowing down the activities makes the story less long-winded, which is a complaint I've heard.

AnonymousAnonymousover 9 years ago
Good But Could Have Been Alot Better

Like the title says this story was good however I can't help but think and feel that it could have been alot better.

When I compare this to some of your other stories i find that this story was rather rushed.

In the sense that there was no real build up or backstory it was just like BANG.

If anything I would say that the backstory wasn't even really a backstory it was more like a filler something to write in between writing the erotic stuff or to space out the erotic stuff.

An the build up to what happened in the story wasn't that good either it was just like Emma and Paige see one and other and then BOOM they're at it.

So like i said this was a good story but when you compare it to some of your other stories it is not one of your best

An speaking of your other stories when are you going to do the next chapter of Buffy's Blackmailing Little Sister and when are we going to find out what happened next in Mickie Get's What's Her's?

scott72scott72over 9 years ago
Finally Emma & Paige Together !!

Outstanding, story a little different but it works. Thought maybe there would have been an Paige & AJ Lee, story first. Either way would like to see more between these two women. Emma could be involved with other divas as well.

KMB2476KMB2476over 9 years ago

Damn! Most impressive. And you and Paige just used Emma better than WWE ever has for sure ;)

Show More
Share this Story

Similar Stories

This Is My Ass Now AJ tries to make Paige's ass hers.in Celebrities & Fan Fiction
The Bigger They Are Beth Phoenix gets a taste of her own medicine.in Celebrities & Fan Fiction
Maryse's Love Of Fat Ass Maryse adores Melina's big round bubble butt.in Celebrities & Fan Fiction
Like a Boss Sasha celebrates another win, with mixed results.in Celebrities & Fan Fiction
Candy Holes Candice has her way with Victoria's ass.in Celebrities & Fan Fiction
More Stories