All Comments on 'Another Time, Place'

by James Kirkland

Sort by:
  • 7 Comments
jd4georgejd4georgeover 19 years ago
This has great possibilities!

I like what's happening here, but find I wanted a little more transition between the "old house on Glenwood" and the memory. The way it feels now, it's like two different pieces. Perhaps a little reference back at the end, or even restructuring to have the "old house" section at the end.

The poem's converstational section conjured up images of WWI, (or even WWII), perhaps because of the names. Then there's that burning bamboo reference.

annaswirlsannaswirlsover 19 years ago
encore!

more than possibility, this is already there for me. I had to read it twice, and I will read it again. Musical word combinantions- I like the way your mind works around words like impromptu dance partners. Masterful.

AnonymousAnonymousover 19 years ago
Full metal jacket power

Those last two stanzas are stunning! Frightening in their power. JD4G is right about the disconnect with no. 1, though. Edit: "helmet"

AnonymousAnonymousover 19 years ago
A tough write

I'm sure, but nevertheless, it was written superbly.

I respectfully disagree with the previous note about this piece being choppy in the transition. I think it reads like a flash back that two soldiers talk about and relive every day (Terrible mind-jobs?flash backs can be).

Thank you and great work.

BooMerengueBooMerengueover 19 years ago
!

James! Don't change a dot. This is so powerful just as it is. I wrote one once about a grandfather lyin in a hammock watching his g'kids play w/ a puppy while bullets zinged and mortars whistled- just out of sight but really there. Its so hard to get that idea across that the battles and the moments NEVER leave your head. You did superb! (superbly?)

Thanks

LeBrozLeBrozover 17 years ago
~~

Old soldiers' recollections;

Could not have been handled any better

Between the here and now

And the grit of what once was.

duddle146duddle146about 17 years ago
Lovely

One can feel the poignancy and the endearing affection from the first line of this heartfelt rendering.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous