All Comments on 'Lighting Preference Request'

I'll go with Request #2

Definitely 2.

Setting 1 looks like indoor light, like from a light bulb or candle, or like the light given off of the moon when the moon is full on a clear night. Setting 2 is intense and reminds me of being outside around 8:00 a.m. when the sun is just above the horizon. Personally, I prefer moonlight. Setting 1 for me.

I like #2, more dramatic and artistic so chances are it will be more versatile too.

As a photographer I prefer #2. The face has much more detail and and expression. Breasts are so realistic.

If not too hard, use both in different shots & different story parts.

Second one looks more realistic but it also has a warrior/wanton look to it. Like she ready for action - willing to be taken. Hot