I will have given a 10 it it was possible. Great story,Well written!!
by
Anonymous07/22/06
30 pages!
try breaking it up. gets fucking boring
by
Anonymous07/23/06
too much pissing
I guess it would be okay for the one's liking the peeing bit, but I am not into that at all. The story is interesting but something is wrong, but I can't put my finger on it.
by
Anonymous07/24/06
Well written but a bit long
The story was good and the writing was good but the water sports could have been toned down. over all a good story.
by
Anonymous04/11/08
Too Much Of A Good Thing
Too long, too much fucking, too much pissing, too short of an ending/epilogue (ie, too rushed and not enough details, hence too many loose ends), and a bit too disjointed. It would be worth the while rewriting. Even so, blew the entire afternoon reading it, it was that gripping.
by
Anonymous02/15/10
two things
i didn't bother to read this due to two things 1) as soon as i saw your list of charicters i could tell it was going to be confusing and probably involve either a lot of group sex or a lot of sex with different people neither of which i am fond of
2)before reading a story i always check to see how long it is when i saw 30 pages there was no way i was going to read that 3 pages yes 6 maybe 30 never if i wanted a story that long i would have gone to the novels area which is where this should have been put you would have smart to break this up into 6-10 chapters the way it is not to many people are going to take the time to read it all
I am surprised that I enjoyed it as much as I did because I am not a great fan of either watersports or intergenerational incest. However, that was overridden by the quality of the story and the way it was written.
Yes, 30 pages is the longest chapter that I have read and it might have been more acceptable to some if it had been broken into separate chapters (maybe along the lines of the days as you did with headings). However, that is a minor point and I actually preferred it this way. In terms of length, I much prefer a longer story that allows the essence to be fully developed rather than a one page wonder that either tells us very little or leaves all sorts of loose ends. I notice that one other commenter accusing you of leaving loose ends and I think that is unfair. The epilogue was quite brief but it did cover all the main salient points and, after all, the story was really about the 2 week holiday.
The idea of listing the characters at the start was a good one although the rate at which you brought the characters into the story made it unnecessary. Other people may not agree but I applaud your hard work in producing a great story. 5* from me despite not being particularly enthused with the watersports.
30 pages?
Enough said.
Awesome!!!!
I will have given a 10 it it was possible. Great story,Well written!!
30 pages!
try breaking it up. gets fucking boring
too much pissing
I guess it would be okay for the one's liking the peeing bit, but I am not into that at all. The story is interesting but something is wrong, but I can't put my finger on it.
Well written but a bit long
The story was good and the writing was good but the water sports could have been toned down. over all a good story.
Too Much Of A Good Thing
Too long, too much fucking, too much pissing, too short of an ending/epilogue (ie, too rushed and not enough details, hence too many loose ends), and a bit too disjointed. It would be worth the while rewriting. Even so, blew the entire afternoon reading it, it was that gripping.
two things
i didn't bother to read this due to two things 1) as soon as i saw your list of charicters i could tell it was going to be confusing and probably involve either a lot of group sex or a lot of sex with different people neither of which i am fond of
2)before reading a story i always check to see how long it is when i saw 30 pages there was no way i was going to read that 3 pages yes 6 maybe 30 never if i wanted a story that long i would have gone to the novels area which is where this should have been put you would have smart to break this up into 6-10 chapters the way it is not to many people are going to take the time to read it all
OMG!!!! WOW!!!!! LOVED IT!!!
This is the best story ever!
amazing story
Great story - well done
I am surprised that I enjoyed it as much as I did because I am not a great fan of either watersports or intergenerational incest. However, that was overridden by the quality of the story and the way it was written.
Yes, 30 pages is the longest chapter that I have read and it might have been more acceptable to some if it had been broken into separate chapters (maybe along the lines of the days as you did with headings). However, that is a minor point and I actually preferred it this way. In terms of length, I much prefer a longer story that allows the essence to be fully developed rather than a one page wonder that either tells us very little or leaves all sorts of loose ends. I notice that one other commenter accusing you of leaving loose ends and I think that is unfair. The epilogue was quite brief but it did cover all the main salient points and, after all, the story was really about the 2 week holiday.
The idea of listing the characters at the start was a good one although the rate at which you brought the characters into the story made it unnecessary. Other people may not agree but I applaud your hard work in producing a great story. 5* from me despite not being particularly enthused with the watersports.
Continuation
A Great Story and I hope that there would be a continuation.
Click here to leave your own comment on this submission! or
Back to The Holiday or
More submissions by OVERLAND.