All Comments on 'Phosphorus, My Soda Confessions'

by Victoria_Lucas

Sort by:
  • 4 Comments
LeBrozLeBrozabout 16 years ago
██

This poem was mentioned in Wednesday's New Poems Reviews.

----------

bogusbrigbogusbrigabout 16 years ago
*

evanescence, like gossamer is a word better not used in poetry, better to replace it with a concrete image. 'Candour's vapours' is also weak. A very promising poem in need of editing. Not up to your usual standard though.

TzaraTzaraabout 16 years ago
I beg to disagree with my distinguished colleague,

Mr. Brig. I have no problem with the word "evanescent," and in fact rather like it. I find it evocative. I would say, though that "soft evanescence" is pushing it a little. I don't think the qualifier adds anything to the word--in fact, probably muddles it up a bit. The phosphorous and soda connection is good on multiple levels, and "candor's vapors burst" (sorry, Am spelling) I think works especially well, given the soda metaphor. "Paint thinner" seems a little vague, though. Perhaps "turpentine"? This needs a little tuning, but good.

twelveoonetwelveooneabout 16 years ago
*

whoa, I agree with TZ, whole - heart tedly

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous