All Comments on 'It's About TIME'

by Teechurgye

Sort by:
  • 4 Comments
ReiDeBastosReiDeBastosalmost 11 years ago
Sorry, but I hate

...I hate, Hate, HATE stories where the other person is referred to as "You", as though that character is supposed to be me.

Being a 55-year-old, gray-bearded MAN, it is difficult for me to read a story where a female character, or even a younger male character, is referred to as "You".

Referring to a character as "you" is always going to be thus jarring to around 50% of your potential readership, so why do it?

I didn't get past the first sentence because of this, sorry.

-Rei

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 11 years ago
mixing tenses

This is intended to be constructive, since this is your first post. Please avoid mixing present and past tense in your writing unless there is a reason to do so. Most stories should be written exclusively in past tense.

TeechurgyeTeechurgyealmost 11 years agoAuthor
Thanks

Thank you for the constructive criticism! I used first person to appeal to a more global audience (no names), but I see the alternative perspective as well. Thanks.

As for the verb tense shifts... I definitely should know better. Hardest to edit your own work! :-)

ReiDeBastosReiDeBastosalmost 11 years ago
Snarkiness

Though it was somewhat snarky & harsh in tone, my previous comment was meant to be constructive. Had I noticed this was your first story, I would likely have toned the harshness back a notch or two - sorry.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous