Top Rated Stories in category:
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | My Freaky Senior Prom Just turned 18 and woke up in someone else's body. Perfect. by somethingfar (03/04/24) | 4.91 (998) |
| 2. | Harp Un-strung How can they ever fall in love? by Sammael Bard (08/24/15) | 4.90 (8425) |
| 3. | Last Few Days of Summer Free-spirited woman gives shy guy his own ‘Summer of 42'. by Trionyx (08/19/22) | 4.89 (2004) |
| 4. | Save World Get Girl She's ready for player two. by MsCherylTerra (05/25/21) | 4.89 (1845) |
| 5. | You are Definitely Going to Hell Ch. 05 Rob doesn't see this twist coming. by Bamo68 (02/15/23) | 4.89 (609) |
| 6. | Word of Mouth Not the usual, run-of-the-mill first-time story. by miwoodsman (11/01/13) | 4.88 (16396) |
| 7. | Imperfections Sometimes flawless is not the ideal. by Michael_Butterfield (02/07/21) | 4.88 (3361) |
| 8. | Alistaire Ch. 01: Carrie Croenke A shy virgin wallflower comes back to his old town. by Publius68 (05/07/22) | 4.88 (2633) |
| 9. | Alistaire Ch. 06: Bridget Yeah, you knew it was coming. But did you really? by Publius68 (05/13/22) | 4.88 (1747) |
| 10. | Inverted Intimacy How long can naked friends resist becoming lovers? by darrenr (07/02/21) | 4.87 (3806) |
| 11. | Runaway Pt. 04 Lacey and Noah's quest to find her brother comes to an end. by MsCherylTerra (03/20/20) | 4.87 (1667) |
| 12. | The Super Brain is Super Sexy Two high-achievers discover each other, and themselves. by Antonio_y_Cleopatra (11/08/19) | 4.87 (1613) |
| 13. | Teenage Fantasy Ch. 01 A cliche romance between a nerd and her football player. by SunflowerThorns (11/29/22) | 4.87 (1258) |
| 14. | One Way to Graduate Disabled girl finds something new at an aftergrad party. by cafterhomme (01/21/22) | 4.87 (874) |
| 15. | The Gift Sometimes daydreams do come true. by Member389 (10/20/23) | 4.87 (729) |
| 16. | California Dreamin' Pt. 02 Jack and Sloane take things up a notch. by somethingfar (12/31/23) | 4.87 (324) |
| 17. | The Wingman Always the wingman, never the stud, changes. by Frankenstein1962 (04/23/21) | 4.86 (2622) |
| 18. | The Summer of '77 A young man discovers the joys of adulthood. by HawkeyeTen (03/07/22) | 4.86 (879) |
| 19. | You are Definitely Going to Hell Ch. 03 The trials and tribulations of Rob continues. by Bamo68 (08/12/22) | 4.86 (796) |
| 20. | Tales from Old Shanghai 01 Never Ending Love (不了情) by ChloeTzang (02/07/19) | 4.86 (601) |
| 21. | The Girl from the Ouachita Ch. 10 Covid sucks, but Jo and her Cowboy persevere - the Finale. by Texican1830 (05/15/22) | 4.86 (576) |
| 22. | Michael or Mac Ep. 04 Mac continues to get closer to Emma. by Bamo68 (12/03/21) | 4.86 (524) |
| 23. | The Twelve Zenati Pt. 09 I do. by xelliebabex (11/21/18) | 4.86 (522) |
| 24. | Nothing in Common An unexpected romance. by SilverFoxMullet (11/01/23) | 4.86 (500) |
| 25. | California Dreamin' Pt. 01 High school ruined by COVID sends a young man to California. by somethingfar (12/27/23) | 4.86 (409) |
| 26. | Sophomore Year Pt. 01 Pat Sullivan returns to university. by Quinn_McMullen (12/01/22) | 4.86 (395) |
| 27. | One Night in Xanadu A Princess of the Xiongnu and the Old Way. by ChloeTzang (04/23/19) | 4.86 (332) |
| 28. | Three Boys, One Crush Pt. 01 3 best bros need to tame and claim their girl before prom... by PhilippaMaQuente (04/21/22) | 4.86 (222) |
| 29. | Androshorts: The Village Witch Strangely attracted to the strange woman. by Androgynousother (03/17/18) | 4.85 (1489) |
| 30. | Runaway Pt. 03 Gentle romance, rough passion, and a surprising reunion. by MsCherylTerra (03/19/20) | 4.85 (1311) |
| 31. | You are Definitely Going to Hell Ch. 02 Life sometimes doesn't go how it should. by Bamo68 (03/06/22) | 4.85 (1078) |
| 32. | Tucker's Studio Ch. 04 The Christian Boy. by riverboy (01/04/16) | 4.85 (967) |
| 33. | First and Last A chance meeting at the rec center lets friends reconnect. by NoTalentHack (08/18/23) | 4.85 (943) |
| 34. | It Started with a Unicorn A good deed launches a friendship - and so much more. by TarnishedPenny (10/20/21) | 4.85 (889) |
| 35. | Love Lessons He teaches her math; she teaches him sex; they learn to love. by davepepperbury (06/22/22) | 4.85 (830) |
| 36. | The Girl from the Ouachita Ch. 03 Sweet Country Girl, I'd give the world. by Texican1830 (02/19/22) | 4.85 (828) |
| 37. | Twice Ten Point Zero (10.0) US prof visits China, encounters female translator in need. by XXscribbler (02/14/18) | 4.85 (607) |
| 38. | The Marine Bk. 02 Ch. 08 Nate continues to enjoy the pleasures of Brazil. by UltimateSin (10/04/22) | 4.85 (526) |
| 39. | Teenage Fantasy Ch. 03 A cliche romance between a nerd and a football player. by SunflowerThorns (03/29/23) | 4.85 (498) |
| 40. | Between the Vines She's got her eye on the younger brother. by SpindleTop (09/01/22) | 4.85 (385) |
| 41. | Erin's Wild Week Pt. 01 Amanda helps Erin break out of her shell. by emelle78 (06/14/23) | 4.85 (329) |
| 42. | Love is Being Stupid Together Ch. 01 Science nerd and computer geek explore sex. by RicknCenFl (01/22/24) | 4.85 (303) |
| 43. | Huginn's Yule ...or, How the Jólfaðr Came Calling on Yuletide Eve. by ChloeTzang (11/20/19) | 4.85 (234) |
| 44. | Zeb's First Time Experiences Ch. 02 Zeb's new sexual experiences continue. by silverfern (06/24/21) | 4.85 (226) |
| 45. | I Married a Heptapod A Sweet Young Girl and a battle-hardened Space Marine by ChloeTzang (05/25/20) | 4.85 (203) |
| 46. | Becoming Who We Are Ch. 09 Luke hits rock bottom; a hopeful future beckons. by vanmyers86 (07/18/21) | 4.85 (183) |
| 47. | Suzie's Twenty-Five Acts Shy Suzie breaks free in twenty-five easy steps. by WittyUserName (11/21/23) | 4.85 (182) |
| 48. | Steel Hearts - Patchwork Princess Ch. 02 The stalker steps up the game. by xelliebabex (12/14/22) | 4.85 (179) |
| 49. | Tom and Teresa... Will They? Will this young couple get together? by Westman99 (12/01/22) | 4.85 (120) |
| 50. | Holiday #195 Celebrating their 195th consecutive holiday tests friends. by WatchingCloud (06/22/17) | 4.84 (2390) |
