Top Rated Stories in category:
Page:1
2
First Time
| Rank | Title & Author | Rating (Votes) |
|---|---|---|
| 51. | Claudia’s Neighborly Smokey Service When no rice leads to a smokey handjob. by Bazzle (04/01/24) | 4.09 (44) |
| 52. | Robert meets Duncan on Calton Hill The seduction of a student. by gentletouch1945 (03/24/24) | 4.08 (26) |
| 53. | The Girl On The Train Meeting a girl on a train, with one off encounter. by whistful2 (04/18/24) | 4.04 (81) |
| 54. | How Dory Lost Her Virginity College girl loses her virginity. by TommyBoyinNC (04/19/24) | 4.04 (191) |
| 55. | Me and the Soccer Girl Ch. 01 William gets to fuck the hot blonde in his class. by zanfulcrumsar (04/20/24) | 4.01 (117) |
| 56. | F & N F introduces N to the delights of physical love. by TheCompany (04/19/24) | 4.00 (15) |
| 57. | University Lecturer Pt. 01 Old friends meet up for the weekend. by RupertRude (04/05/24) | 3.97 (34) |
| 58. | Too Tempting Jenn can't understand the reason she is being dumped. by russboy (04/04/24) | 3.96 (83) |
| 59. | You will Always be in My Heart Two lonely middle-aged friends fall in love. by walker68 (03/27/24) | 3.96 (53) |
| 60. | London Suburbs (SW19) How my relationship with a neighbour’s daughter changed. by NorwegianLars (04/03/24) | 3.95 (40) |
| 61. | Meeting Mistress for the First Time First time meeting Mistress. by bic255 (04/02/24) | 3.94 (16) |
| 62. | Ch. 01 - Anticipation An inexperienced freshman curious about her body. by tigerandmouse (04/18/24) | 3.93 (59) |
| 63. | Freshmen Year of College Losing my virginity to my first college girlfriend. by BobMarooga (04/13/24) | 3.92 (171) |
| 64. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 07 A new secret formed, then her second date with Tim. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/12/24) | 3.92 (13) |
| 65. | Beach Crossed Lovers Two lovers never meant to be but for one day. by bobhardcastle (04/15/24) | 3.92 (60) |
| 66. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 02 Abigail deals with customers, has bigger wetter dreams. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/06/24) | 3.89 (37) |
| 67. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 11 Abigail goes on her date with Tim. Is this the climax? by DADDY_LongLegs (04/17/24) | 3.89 (9) |
| 68. | The Lido Sugar Daddies and their Femboys. by Sean943 (03/31/24) | 3.85 (13) |
| 69. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 08 Jack teaches Abigail something new, her ambivalence develops. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/13/24) | 3.83 (12) |
| 70. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 05 Abigail kisses and doesn't tell, goes on a date, and more. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/10/24) | 3.79 (14) |
| 71. | Allen and Sally Closeted gay couple avoid being outed. by TommyBoyinNC (04/21/24) | 3.75 (32) |
| 72. | Papi Ch. 01 An unexpected encounter in the mountains of Spain. by HartMann (04/14/24) | 3.71 (14) |
| 73. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 09 Darla calls Saturday, while the weekend comes and goes. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/14/24) | 3.67 (12) |
| 74. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 01 Chaste Catholic Abigail treasures her virginity. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/05/24) | 3.62 (60) |
| 75. | Fucking Myself for the First Time Journaling my first penetration experience in the shower. by kinkwad69 (03/31/24) | 3.61 (46) |
| 76. | First Hand Experience as a Stag Cuckold. by Stagbestvix (04/23/24) | 3.58 (36) |
| 77. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 10 Abigail takes Jack home, then gets back together with Tim. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/15/24) | 3.58 (12) |
| 78. | Cumming Attractions A nonbinary pansexual couple's first threesome. by Its_reigning_thems (03/24/24) | 3.55 (20) |
| 79. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 06 Abigail sees Tim, Dad's Freudian slip, another wet dream. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/11/24) | 3.54 (13) |
| 80. | Dorm Threesome First Time Threesome in Collge Dorm. by MInneapolisMark (04/05/24) | 3.53 (64) |
| 81. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 03 Coffee with Jack is fun, and her hot dream sheds new light. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/06/24) | 3.50 (28) |
| 82. | Abigail's Awakening Pt. 04 Abigail asks out Tim, has a weird encounter with Dad. by DADDY_LongLegs (04/09/24) | 3.38 (16) |
| 83. | Creampie Experience Gone Wrong I accidentally got a stranger pregnant. by hornebrian40 (04/19/24) | 2.95 (91) |
| 84. | Watching a Couple Fucking Paying to watch. by sapio2sexual (04/07/24) | 2.89 (53) |
First Time Toplist Page
:
1
2
