Fucking Magic - A Potion Problem Ch. 05

Part 5 - Sunday Morning Seeping of my Cum

I had just enough warning, not that I really needed it besides saving myself from letting out an embarrassing cry. Goosebumps went up all along my forearms, I pulled open the curtain before a soft thump at the door. I didn't think I left the bathroom door unlocked but mom and her sister were there when it opened a half-second later. Both smiling.

"Sunday! No work today." Aunt Allison said, seeing me spying out of the shower curtain.

Neither was interested in getting clean, I was glad I'd brushed my teeth before showering as I was pinned to the tile wall by the sisters, first mom and then Aunt Allison kissing me. Their hands roaming my body, first mom and then Aunt Allison's mouth attaching to my neck. It was fucking amazing, the two of them touching me everywhere while their mouths sucked hard on my flesh, for sure leaving hickeys. I hadn't had one of those in ages, but the sensations had me so hard!

"Did you wash up yet?" Mom asked, but she already had a hold of the soap.

"Not yet." She nodded, then squirted it on her sister before dumping the unnatural blue liquid out onto herself. "Oh fuck yes!"

It was so hot! Both of them sandwiching me between them, using their bodies to scrub me. Mostly their little tits. I turned and turned giving them both ample attention, mom dumping more soap on my cock when I was facing her, Aunt Allison reaching around to grasp me at the same time her sister did. I cursed under my breath as they both jacked me off, four hands up and down the cock that I was still coming to terms with wasn't the one I was supposed to have. That both of them and all the lovers I'd had from Marcy Goldstein (the second time) to my own mother and aunt would have been sorely disappointed instead of... sore.

"We both love you Westley." Mom said the soap and suds were all concentrated on my cock now, like their hands, so mom kissed my freshly cleaned soft skin as she trailed her lips over my shoulder and neck, up on her toe tips, both of them pulling me down into a partial squat.

"Very much." Aunt Allison whispered.

"We really do."

"I love you too, both of you, Aunt Allison, and you mom." They both trembled and made approving noises at hearing my confirmation.

"And you're going to take us? Take us both with you? To Cedar Rapids where we can be yours forever. Your WIVES." Fucking potion was a blessing and a curse.

"But you can't say anything. Do anything, not until I get that job until we're sure."

"We're sure!" My aunt kissing my other shoulder, licking up the other side of my neck. "I hate going back to him. I only want to be with you. I would take you all to myself but I know your mom..." Trailing off as mom made a noise. "I love sharing though."

"Yes! Me first! Then you. I'm his mom AND his favorite, he'll always choose..."

"Ladies! The waters getting cold and... I need to be inside the both of you."

I needed a cure! I needed one bad. I figured the amazing sexual vacation would come to an end, I was a shitty shitty person for enjoying it as much as I was, but it had to happen. Better now before we got busted, then draw it out, upping the chances. This was our hometown, our family would hear about it. (Would believe it if we fled.) We'd never be able to see any of them again. Elaine and her kids! My cousins Aubrey and PJ, I would be making Aunt Allison AND mom give up knowing their kids and grandkids. FOREVER! It wasn't as easy as just being together in secret when they were so bold in public and talked about being my mommy and auntie wife all the more.

We dried off. Well, I got dried off by them, as they took turns kissing me and running a towel over me. I drew in a deep breath as mom slipped to her knees before me, patting the towel over my stomach, thighs, and cock. Clearly just looking for a reason to be on her knees. Using the towel she "dried" my dick, before dropping it, pulling my eight incher down and enveloping it. I groaned, drawing in a deep breath as my aunt was kneeling as well. Both of them pinning me to the wall again, both taking turns licking my balls and dick. Making my entire package wet with their combined saliva after Mom dried it.

Finally, we made it to mom's bedroom. Mom's lube came out, I got pushed back onto the bed and slathered with "Slick Cherry" lubrication. Both of them kneeling beside me, hand over hand tugging me. I could sort of tell they'd done the math too, they wanted to make me happy but knew if they fucked themselves to death on my seemingly always hard dick they wouldn't be who I took to Cedar Rapids.

"Oh fuck!" Even a two lady handie would get boring rather quickly, but one where my hot mother and aunt leaned over and started kissing each other? Probably not ever.

"This is so bad!" Aunt Allison squeaked as her and her sister were forehead to forehead, hands dragging over my length.

"Yeah," Mom agreed before kissing her again, despite her bashfulness the 'dark' version of mom went right into it.

First one hand and then another left me, to touch each other. Mom holding her sister tight for the kiss. My aunt rubbing a generous amount of lube over mom's slightly larger, very pinker and pointier nipples. Which of course soon found mom urging her sibling down until I was cursing again as moans filled the bedroom. Both of the women calling out their pleasure. Mom's a growl while aunt's was happy to serve such pretty titties. I mean fuck! The sight of Aunt Allison slowly letting one of mom's nips slide from her lips would get me hard while I was plunged in icy water.

"God I could do this all day." Allison giggled pulling away from mom's pointers, which were now firetruck red. For somebody who said she could do it all day the dark-haired woman shifted to push hers out, wanting to be tempting to her sister when she asked. "You want to suck mine?"

"Yeah," Mom not just answering bashfully but looking it too, as she stared at them, reaching out for them, Allison leaning towards the hands. Then mom couldn't seem to help herself, giving in to a loud attack on them. Which didn't take long before Aunt Allison was arch backed, pulling on the sheets, overcome with pleasure. "You're so sexy sis. I don't know how that husband of yours can keep his hands off you."

"I don't know how yours ever left you! You should have left him!" Mom agreed while they both settled away from each other, I could tell that maybe it started as a thing for me but they wanted to go at each other, the only thing stopping them was that they knew I had to go at them.

"My turn to try these hot tits," I told them, sitting up, they turned quickly to feed them to me. First mom and then my aunt draping herself over me, arm stretched down they synced up in their hand-job skillfully, while they fought to have me at their nipples. I did like mom's more. Allison's were soft, sexy, and interesting but I kept thinking I was going to pull milk from mom's. Maybe it was some kind of buried memory but I think it was more because her nips were so fat and long. "I could do this all day!"

"You could?" Mom asked with a smirk before climbing onto my lap, holding my artificially long and fat dick with relish and love, sliding her gash up and down the underside. "I think this is what you could do all day."

"Yeah," My voice trembly as Aunt Allison held the back of my head, just barely able to get her brown nipple into my mouth while not blocking my view of mom.

"Mmm, I can't believe I've been missing out on this for eight years. Soncest is the best!" Sliding up and then sitting on it with a moan.

"Incest... Is the best." Aunt Allison whispered, shifting away from me when I tried to reach for her, laying beside me to watch mom work.

"Mmm," Mom nodded, getting going faster, it was nice not to have to divide my attention so much, just watching mom work. Her sexy slim form seemed made for this. Shifting from her hands on my chest to leaning back, rolling her hips as she lifted up, rolling them again after she dropped down. "It really seems to be the case."

I could feel my aunt grow more and more restless with each moan I gave, each time I thrust up into mom, or when I ran my hands over the sexy inevitably more sweaty body. Probably didn't help when mom held my face, levering herself with my grip on her hips. It was insanely intimate, looking right into her eyes as she worked her pelvis along my dick as I had never felt before. During it Aunt Allison was not only forgotten but sort of shoved away as I concentrated on holding mom to allow her to work her pussy the best I'd ever had.

"My turn?"

"Yea... yeah." Mom lifted up and off me, falling to my side laying exactly how Allison had initially, her head on my shoulder, pussy far away.

"Westley, you make your wives so happy!" Aunt Allison said when she was settled onto me.

"So happy," Mom agreed, turning to kiss me. "That's all we want is to make you happy."

"All we want." Aunt Allison curving around her sister while laying on my chest to kiss the other side of my mouth.

"You don't need to fuck any other women." That made me start, wondering if somehow mom was tracking my phone or some shit, but no. I paid my bills and she didn't know my code. "You don't need to meet up with that girl who has been putting things on social media."

"She doesn't love you like we do."

"Won't fuck you like we do."

"Incest is best West, you know it won't be anywhere near as good." I could agree in that moment, with my aunt laying atop me and just rocking her hips to lavish my dick in pleasure, at a speed that was mind-numbingly nice.

"Nowhere near as good Leelee." Mom agreed, kissing her way down her sister's spine before climbing behind her, grabbing her ass. I groaned as mom jerked me off while her sister bobbed her pussy around the tip of my dick, then again when mom started massaging my balls. "We know what you want." Pulling me from her sister she disappeared from sight, but I felt her take me in, literally right from her sister's hole into her mouth! Coming back up with wet lips and chin, jerking me two-handed while her sister found me again with a bouncing probing move. "If you really want, you can bring her over and we'll all have fun together."

"Mom! Aunt... Oh, fuck that feels... Oh, fuck!" Mom helping Aunt Allison up and down on my dick was beyond amazing, my eyes rolling up in pleasure.

"Nobody is going to fuck your big son dick with her sister's pussy, are they?" Mom knew the answer, my hands went overtop mom's all three of us working to break Aunt Allison over my dick.

"You want more? Maybe I'll invite Aubrey in?"

"Or Elaine."

"No! Shit! Mom! Aunt Allison! She's... just a friend."

"We can be your friends, tell us..." Mom's words being drowned out as her sister grabbed my face, staring into my eyes as she came. I leaned up to kiss her, those kisses extra wet as she couldn't keep her mouth closed from the moaning. I took over, thrusting up at her sexy MILF body. We gave her a bit to bask in her orgasm, then mom and I tipped her off me at the same time. "We'll be more! We'll do whatever it is to make you happy." Mom climbing on, laying across me like her sister, if only to speak right to me. "You want a girl with a boyfriend? I'll fuck the boyfriend so you can fuck her. I love you! Leelee!" Grabbing her ass I slammed up into her, holding her so she hovered at just the right place. "Leelee! Leelee! Leelee! Marry me! Leelee! Marry MOMMY! Love MOMMY!"

"I do! I fucking love you more than ever!" I growled rubbing at her asshole with a finger while smashing up into her, going faster and faster as she nodded, her fingernails digging into my chest.

We were both gone for a few seconds. All it was was two bodies creating more pleasure in each other than ever before. Her beautiful face hung over me, the shock in her eyes that she could be feeling so much pleasure fueled me to go on, go faster. She let out a loud cry, shoving herself down all the way on my dick, wanting me to erupt in her, ALL the way. She cried out my name, her body stiffening as if hit by lightning as she came while feeling me cum inside her. I pumped and pumped and pumped and pumped. Four, I imaged that big measuring cup worth of cum now inside her, she wiggled down for more.

But Aunt Allison was there, pushing her sister, grabbing my dick and getting it inside her. She screamed out my name too, jet of cum had gotten free, ran from her chin to her navel. Sitting side saddle she bounced on it, nodding and moaning her relief at being included in the creampie. She was wracked out and done but she smiled as mom gave her a shove, staring me in the eyes as she took my dick in her mouth. Stroking me hard and fast, lips sealed around my tip. She let out a shocked noise when I filled her mouth. Allison was there both of them catching a blast of seed across the face before it got transferred to the dark-haired woman's mouth.

"Ahhh! Oh, fuck yes!" I groaned as my aunt filled her mouth too, my near-empty dick got slapped against the dark nipples and then the pink pointers until I was totally drained. For the moment.

Here was another thing that I was sure they had coordinated. Both of them sitting down to either side of me, in a reclined sort of position with their legs up and out. Fingers went down and splayed their well-fucked cunts apart. I may have gone deep this time but they both had been filled so much all it took was that to start the white stuff coming out. As if by some unheard command they both opened their mouths, my cum and some of their spit rushed out. Down their chins and splattering to where smears of the stuff had already been left on their pretty titties.

"God look at you two." Which was what I was doing, they were positively seeping of my cum.

"See! See Leelee, this is what we can do that nobody else can." As mom spoke more of my semen ran out over her bottom lip.

"Your wives just want to make you happy." Aunt Allison did the same. "Say the word and we'll do it! Anything! Want me to call in for all of next week? Tell Perry to go to hell?" There was a flicker of something there, hesitation I thought. More eagerly she went on with the crazy. "I work with a slut who loves anal, I'll invite her over and we'll learn how to do it on your dick."

"Anything for you Leelee!"

"No! Not until we're sure, we got to be cool about this. Please! Then... I'm trying to make this all better, okay? Can you trust me? I promise I'm thinking about our futures." They both nodded that they could, meant it, wanting nothing but to please me. "And you can be cool? And act like nothing is going on between us, when we aren't together?" More nods, Aunt Allison's just a hint hesitant. "Good." I let my hands run up from their dripping cunts, over their glazed tummies, and cupped their cummy chins. "How could a guy want more than you two?"

"A normal guy shouldn't but... You aren't a normal guy." Mom said, happily eating the cum that I pushed up her chin and bottom lip into her mouth.

"You're not a normal guy Westley, you're our perfect guy." Aunt Allison nuzzling into my hand for some attention.

Both of them were sweaty wrecks but I was literally thinking of going for another jog. I have them a smile stepping away a foot before they both reacted.

"I love you." Aunt Allison cried.

"I love you." Mom hurriedly added both looking like I was holding up a plane ticket for one to Sexsylvania.

"I'm just going to the bathroom, Jesus." But it was in an amused way.

In the mirror above the sink after using the bathroom, I stared at myself. I looked at the ring, thought about whatever spell or potion Jessica had slipped me to give me a big dick and a celebrity face. I needed the potion cured. I loved them and I wanted them but... I didn't... I didn't want it like this. Not knowing that they would seemingly do anything to make me happy, forgive anything. Then at the same time be jealous of a girl for posting stuff about being unable to wait to hang out on Sunday. Okay, maybe they should be a little jealous of her but it was one hang-out, not a tenth date. Even though I told myself they wouldn't, the worst was worrying over if they would tell anybody. Unable to hold back their "love" any longer, or just to stake their claim. It would ruin our lives but who else would touch me after my mom and aunt admitted we were all in love? That we were all fucking like rabbits?

I was sure that there was a certain part of the population who would call me a fool. Who would never try and cure mom or Aunt Allison. I thought it sometimes, I mean how great would it be to have them in my place at Cedar Rapids. Throwing themselves at my dick as soon as I got home. Bathing their beautiful bodies in my cum on the daily. Only eventually Elaine, Martin, Aubrey, or PJ would start to suspect. We'd delay it if we got a three-bedroom place. But could we afford it? Even with mom and Allison there helping to pay bills? A good clean three bedroom? In Cedar Rapids pretty much last minute. Because if any of them came over and we had only one bed between the three of us? They would proverbially burn us at the stake.

I needed to cure the potion and if that meant fucking my way through chubby possibly even bitchier than ever Jessica, well I was just the 'not a normal guy' to do it.