Paige's Way

Story Info
Pete struggles to understand his new wife's intentions.
10.8k words
2.68
28.1k
37

Part 1 of the 2 part series

Updated 05/31/2024
Created 05/25/2024
Share this Story

Font Size

Default Font Size

Font Spacing

Default Font Spacing

Font Face

Default Font Face

Reading Theme

Default Theme (White)
You need to Log In or Sign Up to have your customization saved in your Literotica profile.
PUBLIC BETA

Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.

You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.

Click here

"Ok, Pete, I'm off," Paige said, giving him a half-hearted peck on the cheek. 

She stopped in front of the mirror in their foyer and examined herself closely to ensure she had not smudged her perfectly applied lipstick.  Pete watched as she tugged at her tennis skirt, making it just a little shorter, revealing not just more thigh but almost the bottom of her ass cheeks. 

If not for the tennis outfit,  you might think she was on her way to an expensive restaurant for a special occasion. Her hair and makeup looked as if they'd been professionally done, her hands manicured perfectly.  She looked stunning, just as she always did, which made Pete anxious knowing she would be spending the afternoon with her handsome young tennis instructor, Gavin. 

He walked up behind her and began to wrap his arms around her waist but she immediately shrugged him off.

"Pete, stop," she said, sounding more than a little annoyed. "You know Gavin's waiting for me."

Her words cut through him like a knife, turning his momentary lust into stinging jealousy. She caught his gaze and sighed, before carefully running her fingers through her long hair.

"I may be a little later today," Paige continued, reaching out and tracing Pete's jawline with an index finger. "Gavin said I may need some additional coaching."

She gave him a sly, seductive smile before turning around and grabbing her tennis racket from the nearby table.  She strutted to the door, and her ass in that tiny skirt brought Pete's thoughts to something far from tennis.

Just as she was about to leave, she turned around, a wicked glint in her eyes.

"If you're a good boy, maybe I'll let you watch next time I... " Paige paused for effect. "train... with Gavin."

She bit her lip and batted her eyelashes one last time before heading out the door, leaving Pete to his swirling thoughts and the all-too-visible bulge in his pants.

He watched as her car pulled out of the driveway, sitting down heavily on the off-white sofa.  Her insinuations had left him frustrated and confused, not knowing if she was just teasing him or was actually planning on messing around with her instructor and felt no shame in flaunting it in front of him.

He found the mind-games were escalating with every passing week, leaving him feeling tormented and confused.  And yet in spite of his agony, he was as usual, very hard as he sat there imagining her athletic figure in motion, wet from the exertion, maybe even from Gavin's touch.  The images in his brain left him in a miserable mix of jealousy and arousal.

There are moments in life that every man wishes he could take back.  Something said or done that may not seem overly consequential at the time but ends up changing the entire trajectory of one's future.

Pete certainly had a couple of such moments, both of which he wished to god he could go back in time and change.

The first was with his first wife, Stephanie.  They'd been married for just over 10 years when one random evening after several drinks, and a lot of teasing and prodding from his wife, he shared a fantasy that he'd kept secret since they'd been together: how he'd fantasized about her being with another man.  

She was shocked at first but it eventually led to some exciting role playing and dirty talk in the bedroom and a few months later, with increasingly relentless persuasion by Pete himself, finally evolved into her actually going through with it.  With Pete's blessing, she left to meet some guy at a hotel.   And a month after that she filed for divorce and left him for her co-worker that she'd had the fling with.  It was mind boggling how badly he'd fucked up, looking back on it. 

Pete had been devastated.  In the year that followed the divorce, he'd buried himself in his work, rarely socializing with his friends, never dating.  And what was most baffling to him in that year is that he was still constantly aroused when he thought about her fling with the other man.  He imagined it often and in great detail when he masturbated on the many lonely nights that followed.  Each time, the moment his climax ended, he would feel disgusted and heartbroken all over again.

And then he met Paige. 

He had been at a work function, an awards banquet for the law firm he worked for.  As he leaned against the bar and ordered his third martini to help him get through the boring event, she'd bumped against him almost causing him to spill it all over himself.

He was immediately taken by her beauty and raw sex appeal. She was much younger than he was, just 27 years old to his 42 years.  But she flirted with him and he felt flattered.  He was hooked immediately. 

She said she'd just finished her Master's Degree in Psychology and had actually done some work on a case for his firm involving the use of sex through cyberbullying.  Pete only heard half of what she said, as he found himself trying not to stare at the front of her deep V low cut dress that showed off her magnificent breasts.

Unfortunately, 10 minutes into their conversation, she admitted she was actually there on a date with a young intern at Pete's firm, someone Pete couldn't stand to begin with, but from that moment, hated him even more.  

The intern, Darren, interrupted their conversation shortly after, clearly inebriated and drug her away from Pete like a caveman.  She turned and winked at him as she left and as ridiculous as it sounded, Pete thought he may be in love.

Two weeks later, she came by the office to surprise Darren with lunch but he'd left with a female co-worker (whom  Pete was sure he'd been sleeping with) so Paige asked Pete if he wanted to grab lunch with her.  

They ended up at a little bistro down the street and talked for the next two hours.  She shared that she came from a wealthy family, that her father wanted her to become a doctor but she was fascinated with sexology and how it drove human behavior. For now, she was freelancing while she determined her exact path, which meant sometimes being called on by firms like Pete's as expert witnesses or helping with background research.

What Pete found most refreshing, if not a bit shocking, was just how open she was in talking about sex. She shared that she enjoyed being both submissive and dominant, depending on the situation and the guy. That she wasn't 100% sold on traditional marriages. And as casually as explaining her favorite food, confessed that she had, in her words, 'dated a LOT of guys because she just loved having sex'.  Pete almost choked on his drink at her candidness which made her giggle in a way that made his heart swoon.

To his surprise, in spite of their age difference, she agreed to a formal date shortly thereafter and in just two whirlwind months, he was on one knee asking her to marry him.  She was out of his league and he was honestly skeptical if she would say yes, but she did and just 4 months ago they were married on a beach in Barcelona.

Since that time there'd been many nights when Pete had laid in bed staring at her as she slept beside him and questioned how the hell he'd gotten so lucky?  How could someone as young and gorgeous as this woman have ended up with him?  It wasn't that he was ugly, in fact he considered himself handsome, was in decent shape for someone his age, and he made a good living, although he had paid half of his life savings to his ex-wife during the divorce for some ridiculous reason.  Even for a lawyer, the laws often made no sense. 

But Paige was in an entirely different league, there was no question.  When she walked into a room, heads turned, and she could have picked any man she wanted to. Saying she was beautiful didn't do her justice, because it wasn't just a natural beauty kind of thing. It was a raw sexual magnetism, a combination of her stunning looks and her care-free attitude toward all things sex.

And when he thought about all of their dates and times together that led up to him proposing to her, there was one specific evening that stood out for him, when he saw some spark of electricity in her eyes at something he'd said that he felt was the turning point, that he suddenly became much more intriguing to her.

And that became the second event in Pete's life that he wished he could go back and change. The conversation, or confession rather, that would change his future in ways he couldn't have imagined.

They'd been on a dinner date, had a wonderful meal and were sharing an expensive bottle of wine.  Paige had asked him about his first wife and specifically, why they'd gotten divorced.  Pete had tried to skirt around the details but she was having none of it and continued to probe until he finally told her the truth.

What he wished that he'd not been so specific on was WHY she had slept with another man.  That it had been Pete who had encouraged her to do so because he had fantasized about it.

He'd seen Paige's eyes appear to light up when he told her about this fantasy, how she leaned forward, eager to hear every detail.  And he'd thought at the time it was simply curiousity and and being fascinated that someone could be so twisted as to imagine his wife with another man.  He'd been so embarrassed about sharing such a revelation, but she'd taken it in stride, and afterwards he was happy that he'd been up front with her. Frankly, he was thankful that she didn't go running from the restaurant screaming for him to lose her number.

But now he suspected it was something else entirely that he'd seen in her expression that night.  He didn't want to be overly Machiavelian about it but looking back, he wondered if she saw some weakness or vulnerability in him, something she could perhaps fix or worse yet, exploit.  The moment he'd shared all of this with her it was like she became more interested in him. 

Perhaps she just sensed an opportunity for a relationship more unique and exciting than she'd first imagined with Pete.  Or maybe she just thought he was more emotionally complex than other guys and that excited her.  Pete didn't know, and thought he was probably overthinking it all.

And it wasn't long before things began to change, beginning with their wedding day.  It had been a perfect day, just a small ceremony on the beach, a small group of friends from her side and from his, no family.  Just the way they'd both wanted it.  

Late that evening, as they'd laughed, danced and drank the night away, Pete had excused himself to the bathroom and when he returned, there was no sign of his new bride.  He checked their hotel room, but it was empty, so he returned downstairs and searched the grounds. Just as he was about to give up and go check their room again, he caught a glimpse of two silhouettes coming up the pathway from the beach.  He watched as Paige and his friend Chris made their way to where he stood.

"Paige, where have you been?" he demanded, his voice laced with concern and irritation. She gave him a mischievous grin, her deep blue eyes gleaming with excitement.

"Just getting to know your friend a bit better," she said coyly, wrapping her arm around Chris's waist.  

Pete looked at Chris, who looked back at him nervously.

"We just went for a walk, man.  Paige said she needed to get some air." Chris explained, his voice strained.

Pete looked at the two of them suspiciously, noting Paige's hair was a tousled mess and Chris couldn't seem to stop fidgeting, glancing back and forth between them nervously.

"Let's go upstairs," Paige said, as she took Pete's hand and led him up to their hotel room.

The atmosphere in the room was tense as they entered, Pete feeling overcome with jealousy, wondering if his friend had done something with his new bride. He watched as she sauntered towards him, her body swaying hypnotically, her eyes never leaving his.

"What's wrong, baby?" she asked him, as she ran her finger slowly down the front of his chest before hooking into his belt.

"Paige, what were you guys..." Pete began, but couldn't bring himself to say the words.

"What were your big strong friend and I doing? All alone on the beach, while you weren't around?" she whispered, her breath hot against his ear.  "What do you think we were doing, sweetie?"

Pete felt her fingers brush against his erection through his pants, and he gasped.

"Ooohh," she purred. "Why are you so hard, baby?  Are you imagining your friend's big strong hands all over your new bride's tight little body?" Paige murmured, as her fingers deftly worked to unfasten his belt. 

Her lips found his ear, and she nipped at the lobe gently. Pete groaned, his mind reeling with visions of his beautiful young wife in the arms of his friend. He was angry and filled with jealousy, but he could also feel himself growing harder by the second.

"I-I don't...," he stammered, his mouth dry.

"Mmmmm," she continued, as his pants dropped to the ground and she reached into the front of his boxers. "Does that make you hard, thinking about your bride fucking your friend on our wedding night?  Stretching me out before you even get to put your little penis in me?"

And that's when Pete came.  Came harder than he'd ever cum before, filling his boxers as Paige pulled her hand away and stepped back, a shocked smile spreading across her face as she watched his body twitch and convulse.  Pete grabbed his erection and almost doubled over as his orgasm overtook him.

"Unggg, fuck," he grunted, his legs shaking as he tried to maintain his balance. "Jesus Christ, Paige!"  

Pete stroked himself a few times, trying to extend the pleasure even as his mind registered how ridiculous and pathetic he must look, spasming uncontrollably in front of his wife.

"Did that feel good, baby?" she giggled, her laughter ringing in his ears as he struggled to catch his breath.

Pete barely managed a nod as he fought to regain his composure. He couldn't believe what had just happened, couldn't fathom the depth of his arousal at the thought of his wife with another man mixed with the humiliation of cumming so quickly and so ungracefully in front of her.

But Paige wasn't done yet. She leaned in, her lips brushing against his in a gentle kiss.

"Come here," she whispered, taking his hand and leading him towards the bed.

Pete's mind was still reeling, his body still trembling with the aftershocks of his orgasm.  But his wife's eyes were filled with a different kind of hunger, and he knew she wasn't done with him yet.

"Take off your clothes," she commanded, her voice low and serious. "Now."

Pete complied, his fingers fumbling with the buttons on his shirt. He was still struggling to catch his breath, but the desire in Paige's eyes made his cock stir once again.

Once he was naked, he stood before her, feeling vulnerable and exposed. She looked him up and down, her gaze lingering on his semi-hard cock.

"Much better," she murmured, before pushing him back onto the bed.  "Now, stay right there."

She stood before him, fully clothed while he lay there naked, his erect cock throbbing for attention. She ran her fingers over the lace of her panties, teasing him with the promise of what was to come.

"Do you want to see me, Pete?" she asked, her voice soft and sultry. "Do you want to watch me ride you while I close my eyes and think about your friend Chris?"

Pete winced at the thought but couldn't help but nod eagerly, his eyes glued to her hands as she slowly slid her panties down her legs. He watched as she kicked them off to the side, revealing her smooth, bare sex. She crawled onto the bed, straddling his hips.

"Mmmm, feel how wet I am, Pete," she whispered, lowering herself onto his cock.

He gasped as he entered her, feeling her slick heat envelop him. She began to ride him, slowly at first, her eyes closed as she lost herself in the pleasure.

"Tell me you like watching me, Pete," she said breathlessly, her hands braced on his chest.

Pete nodded, unable to take his eyes off her bouncing breasts. He could feel her wetness coating his shaft, slick and hot. She was so fucking tight, so fucking perfect.

"Do you want me to go harder?" she asked.

Pete nodded again, his fingers digging into the sheets as she picked up her pace. She rocked her hips, grinding down on him with each thrust.

"I'm gonna cum, Paige," he groaned, his eyes clenched shut as he felt his climax approaching.

"Ah, ah, ah. Not yet," she said, stopping abruptly.

 She leaned forward, her nipples hard as they grazed his chest. She took his face in her hands and kissed him deeply, their tongues dancing as their bodies moved in perfect harmony.

"Do you like that, Pete?" she whispered against his lips. "Do you like imagining me with Chris on our wedding night?  Watching us and stroking your dick like a pervert, while he fucks your wife so good?"

Pete couldn't believe the words that were coming out of his new bride's mouth, but they were only fueling his desire for her even more. He could feel a second climax building inside of him, his balls tightening as she slowly rocked her hips against his.

"Paige, I'm really gonna cum," he warned frantically, his fingers digging into her hips as he bucked up against her.

"Not yet, baby," she whispered, leaning down to nip his earlobe. "I'm not finished with you yet."

"Please," he pleaded, trying to thrust harder up inside of her.

"I want you to say it," she purred.

Pete looked up at her, puzzled.

"Tell me, Pete.  Tell me what you imagined I was doing with Chris.  Tell me what made you cum so hard," she ordered. "What's making you want so badly to cum again."

Pete's face grew hot as he realized what she was asking of him.

"Nothing," he lied, still trying to push deeper inside of her as she held him down.

He felt her lift off of him, his shaft making a wet smacking sound as it bounced free against his stomach.  He let out a loud groan as Paige looked down at him with a pout.

"That's disappointing, Pete," she said, shaking her head.  "That you would lie to me, and on our wedding night no less.  Are we going to start our life together with lies, Pete?"

"OK, ok.  I thought - I thought about you and Chris," he admitted, his voice barely above a whisper. "About you two kissing on the beach, him touching you, you letting him take your clothes off..."

As he spoke, she slid down onto his cock once again and Pete let out a low moan. She leaned forward, rolled her shoulders slowly from side to side, causing her full breasts to sway above his face.

"Tell me more," she demanded hungrily, her eyes sparkling. "What did you picture him doing to me next?"

Pete hesitated for a moment, unsure of how much more he could admit to, his humility growing commensurate to his arousal.  But there was no stopping the words that came out next, his lusty confessions fueling his desperate need to cum.

"You were sucking his cock," he blurted out, his body shuddering at the thought.

"That's right, baby," she moaned, grinding down on him even harder. "You want to watch your friend stick his big, dirty cock in my mouth on our wedding night. Watch me lick it and suck it until he cums all over my pretty face."

Pete groaned, his hips bucking up to meet hers. He could feel the pressure building inside of him once again, his orgasm about to explode.

"I think you'd like that, wouldn't you?" she asked, her voice husky. "You'd love your wife on her knees for another man."

"OHHH, FUCCCKKKK!" Pete shouted, his climax ripping through him like a tsunami. His young wife's wet pussy clenched tightly around his shaft as he unloaded his hot offering deep inside of her.

"Dirty little pervert," she giggled, leaning down over him to kiss him deeply, their tongues twisting together, his orgasm still pulsing through his body.

And that seemed to have set the stage for things to come in their marriage.  Paige reveling in her power to push Pete's buttons, to manipulate his emotions and desires to achieve any answer or outcome she wished for.