Senior Year Memories Ch. 16

"I'm sorry, Josie, but this is gonna happen. You have no idea how hot her tight little ass looks right now," I said.

"Oh I know how hot her tight little ass is. Who do you think gave her her first rimjob? Who do you think first fed a monster dildo up there? Who do you think taught her how to take a cock up her ass? Me, that's who!" Josie complained.

"And I'm thankful for that, I truly am. All of that's really going to come in handy right now," Sarah said, getting down on all fours in front of me, her asscheeks spread and showing off her cute, tight little hole to me. She looked over her shoulder at me, smiling that sweet smile.

"You know I'm gonna jill it to this, right?" Josie threatened, though there was definite excitement in her voice.

"It wouldn't be the first time," I said, setting the phone down beside us.

"It wouldn't?" Sarah asked as I crawled up behind her, running my cock between her asscheeks.

"It's kinda how we met," I explained.

"Awww, how sweet!" Sarah said, groaning as I pressed my cockhead against her asshole. Even with the lube this would be a tight fit, but looking down at Sarah, so tiny and sweet, the wing tattoos on her upper back, an angel's on her left, a demon's on her right, she was so hot I could more than take a little tightness.

"I hear groaning, what's going on?" Josie asked, her voice breathy.

"God, his cock's up against my asshole, it's so big! I don't know if it's gonna fit!" Sarah said teasingly.

"Let's find out," I said, pressing forward. There was definite resistance at first, but her experience taking it in the ass showed when I finally popped inside.

"Oh fuck! He's in me, it's so fucking big!" Sarah moaned.

"I know, it's great, right?" Josie moaned.

"Seriously!" Sarah exclaimed as I pressed a few more inches into her tight hole.

"Fuck, she's so tight," I said.

"I know she's tight. She's about as tight as they come. Just remember who the real anal queen you dream about is," Josie challenged.

I pressed a few more inches into Sarah's ass. "Come on, can't I, fuck she's tight, can't I just enjoy this?"

"Fine, enjoy it, take her ass to town, just remember, soon, you and me, you're gonna destroy my ass, alright?" Josie moaned, the sound of her fingerfucking herself audible even over the phone.

"Gladly," I said, bottoming out in Sarah's ass. "God, I'm all the way in."

"That's a, wow, that's a lot of cock," Sarah admitted, wiggling around on me.

"I know what it is, I want to hear you two fuck," Josie said.

"Hey, we're the ones actually doing the fucking here, we'll take it at our own pace," I said.

"Yeah!" Sarah added, before whispering to me, "Though I could really go for some serious assfucking soon."

"Me too," I whispered back. "Just want her to know we're in charge."

"Awww, isn't it great that we're all friends?" Sarah whispered back, amused.

"I'm starting to like it," I returned.

Sarah nodded, giggling. Already we could hear Josie moaning as she fingerfucked herself, and it was probably that we had an audience that got us moving forward. Whether it was because she was familiar with Josie or that Josie just didn't have eyes on her, I couldn't say, but Sarah didn't seem to have a problem with an audience now.

Slowly I started fucking in and out of her ass, enjoying her tightness (and that I'd had the foresight to bring lube) as she got accustomed to my size. She must've had more experience with Josie and the others than I thought, though, because it didn't take long to build up a rhythm where I was fucking her ass hard.

"Yes, yes, yes, god, it's so big, keep fucking my ass, keep fucking my slutty little ass!" she yelled.

"God it's so hot, so tight, fuck, god I love this ass," I grunted.

"Keep fucking her ass, god, you keep doing that, keep fucking her, keep fucking him, keep going, god this is hot, fuck!" Josie exclaimed.

Sarah may not have been the anal queen that Josie was, but she was definitely a student of hers, fucking back against me unmercifully as I pounded her ass. For such a tiny, dainty girl it looked like I'd break just by looking at her, she had a surprising amount of muscle. She may not have had Brooke's attitude, but if Sarah and her were ever to hook up they probably would've shaken the very earth itself.

"God, keep fucking my ass, keep fucking my ass!" Sarah roared, dropping her head to the ground so she could reach up and finger her pussy with both hands.

"You better keep going, keep going, I'm so fucking close, god, you two, just keep it up, keep it up, fuck, so close!" Josie grunted.

"We've got this, we've got this," I said, enjoying the odd threesome and fucking Sarah's ass even harder for Josie's encouragement. I almost felt bad that we hadn't waited, hadn't invited Josie to come over so we could make this a proper anal fuckfest, but I was also glad that we hadn't. After all of my time, all of the thought I'd put into searching for Sam, finally finding her made me a little greedy. I wouldn't have felt bad sharing Sarah with Josie at another time, but for now I was happy that we got this moment to ourselves.

Not that I was complaining when I heard Josie cumming over the phone.

"Oh you motherfuckers! You motherfuckers! I'm cumming, fuck, I'm cumming, I'm CUMMING, FUCK YOU BOTH FUCK FUCK FUCK!!" Josie roared as she came on the other end of the line.

"Lightweight," I taunted, even as I was running out of breath.

"Yeah," Sarah agreed. "You just start touching yourself and you cum, while we've still got fuel in the tank!"

"Yeah, well I'm not freshly fucked like you two," Josie groaned, coming down slowly. "If you'd had the courtesy to just call me first-"

"Yeah, but we didn't," I said. "Now shut up so I can fuck Sarah's ass!"

I said it teasingly, and Josie replied in kind. "Oh you're gonna pay for that."

"I can't wait!" I shot back, grabbing Sarah's hips and pounding her as hard as I could. We were a blur of slapping flesh, grunting and groaning, sweating and moaning. Our hips were a blur as they collided with each other, my cock constantly reappearing and disappearing in her ass. I wanted to wait for her to cum first, but with my balls boiling as they were, it would be close.

Thank god Sarah came when she did, squealing, moaning, even screaming slightly as her fingers and my cock worked their magic. She collapsed under me, pulling me down with her as she shook and shuddered beneath me, still fingering herself even as the orgasm took her and her juices sprayed on my thighs. I fucked her against the ground, a few more swift, heavy pumps, but with one final groan I came hard, filling her ass with cum.

We lay like that for a while, me on top of her, my cock softening inside of her ass, the two of us trying desperately to catch our breath.

"I'll say it first since the two of you aren't exactly in a place for rational thought right now, but the three of us really need to get together and do something sometime," Josie said.

"Agreed," Sarah said.

"Agreed," I added, smiling and kissing Sarah.

***

It took a while, but we both eventually got dressed, Sarah seeing me to the door of the dance studio.

"I'm... I'm glad you came looking for me. I was hoping you wouldn't, at first, but... I'm really glad you did," she said.

"Me too," I said, leaning down to kiss her.

"Josie's gonna be so pissed at both of us," Sarah said.

"Yeah, but so what?" I said.

Sarah agreed, nodding. She may have gotten dressed, but her hair and face still had that ridiculously hot just-been-fucked look, and she was smiling with more confidence than she had when I'd just walked in. It was a good look for her, one I hoped to see again.

I leaned in for another kiss. "We gotta do this again sometime."

"Seriously," she replied. "Maybe invite Josie next time?"

"Maybe," I teased, kissing her one last time and walking up the path toward her gate. I knew she was watching me as I walked away, and it felt great. I'd found Sam, and I'd rocked her world almost as much as she'd rocked mine. I hoped I left a similar impression, and I was looking forward to seeing where we'd go next.

I'd found Sam.

I'd found Sam!

I'd found Sam and the sex was still amazing.

Truth be told, as I walked toward Rachel in her car, waiting to pick me up, I might as well have been walking on air. I was having a great day and it honestly felt like nothing could stop me, and that I could do, or be, anything I wanted.

"So, looks like you had a good time," Rachel said smugly as I sat in the passenger seat.

"Yes. Yes I did," I replied. She was clearly expecting me to give her all the details, and seeing her twist in the wind when she was usually in such control was surprisingly fun. I watched as her face went to expectant to frustrated and about half a dozen other emotions in between as she waited for me to elaborate. For all the teasing she'd given me, it was fun to watch her on the receiving end for a bit.

"That's it?" Rachel asked.

"Maybe," I said.

"So, we're really gonna play it like this?" she said, raising an eyebrow at me. Maybe it was all the flirtation or that I was riding high from finding Sam or the savage sex I'd just had, but Rachel looked good.

Really good.

That may have led me to being a little more impulsive than I might've otherwise been.

"No, we're gonna play it like this," I said, leaning in and kissing her deeply.

Rachel's eyes went wide with surprise, and for a fraction of a second I'd worried that I really fucked up, but when she started kissing me back all worry left me. It didn't matter who we were before this, no, now we were just two horny kids in a car, making out and having a good time. The kisses were passionate and fierce, my hands finding her tits while hers rubbed my cock through my pants. Her nipples responded through her thin t-shirt, hard and needy, unrestrained by a bra and desperate to burst free. Her tits weren't as big as her sister's or mom's, but they still felt fantastic in my hands. Her hands were firm but gentle as they caressed my cock through my pants, almost reaching for my zipper, begging to pull my hardening cock out.

It felt good.

Too good.

Thankfully, sense found Rachel first as she gently pushed me away.

"We... we should stop. This is a bad idea," she said.

Realizing much the same thing at the same time, I said, "Yeah. Yeah it is. Sorry."

"Don't be sorry. Just..." she trailed off.

"Yeah. We shouldn't do that again," I said.

"No, we shouldn't," she replied, starting up her car and pulling away from the curb. "You taste like pussy. I've got gum in the console."

"Thanks," I said, taking the offered stick of minty gum and chewing on it, because chewing on it gave me something to do that wasn't sitting awkwardly and quietly in the car with my best friend's sister who I'd just made out with for a few seconds.

As she drove, I sometimes looked at her and she sometimes looked at me, our faces sharing much the same awkward embarrassment. We both got caught up in the moment, I knew this, she knew this, and it was one of those fleeting moments that come and go in life. It was easy for both of us to realize the mistake we made, and that it was one that we shouldn't make again.

If only I'd remembered that long enough to make it to Thanksgiving, then a whole lot of things would've gone differently.

***

(Author's Note 2: To the reader who sent me anonymous feedback under the name "Natalie R.", I'll be more than happy to discuss the matters of your message further. Please send me another feedback with your e-mail address so I can respond to you and I'll be glad to discuss those story ideas and suggestions with you.)