The Sim - Custom Scenarios Pt. 04

After a little prodding and pulling, I think I manage to get the majority of the creampie to land on my cock. I carefully make my way round to Alex's face and present her my messy cock, curious to see her reaction. She doesn't look at me or my dick, just keeps her eyes glued to the screen and game going on but does open her mouth invitingly. I don't think I've ever seen her look more beautiful, it was incredible how good she could look without any makeup or trying.

I slip my cum covered cock into her waiting mouth and down her throat until she gags, I don't want her hacking up cum everywhere so that's where I stop. I got a happy surprise when Alex actually started swirling her tongue around my head and shaft despite the fact it had just been up her ass. It was even better when she wrapped her lips around my cock and sucked off the entire thing, collecting all the cum in her mouth. Making eye contact with me and the camera for the first time, she asks with a slurred voice, "Do you want me to swallow this?"

Grinning cruelly I say, "Yeah."

Alex simply says, "Gross," but swallows the load loudly all the same.

Alex makes a face at the taste, "Dude I can't believe you just made me eat the cum from my ass. What happened to starting off slow. First time I get assfucked, ever, and you make me eat an anal creampie. Ever heard of jumping the shark? How are we supposed to top this? Or am I just supposed to eat the cum from my asshole every time now?"

"Well I mean, that's not a terrible idea. It could be your thing, 'girl that eats anal creampies' or maybe we could bring in another girl and you could eat it out of her."

Alex rolls her eyes at me and says, "You are really milking this for all it's worth aren't you." Alex reaches for a glass on a nearby coffee table, takes a drink and swishes it around her mouth to wash out the taste.

She mutters to herself, "Guess I should try getting used to that taste probably." Then addressing me she says, "You done man or do you wanna keep playing with my asshole some more?"

Alex knew exactly what to say to get me going, but I still needed more time than that to recharge so I told her, "Yeah I am, your gonna have to wait till later for more."

Alex sarcastically replies, "Oh great, I can't wait. Alright, see ya later man."

I start switching off the cameras, and when the last one gets turned off. Alex suddenly leaps up onto her feet and punches me hard in the chest. She angrily says, "You fucking asshole. Ass to mouth? Making me eat the cum from my ass? You fucking kidding me? We never talked about any of that."

I start making excuses, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I got caught up in the moment. And fuck, just because I was filming didn't mean you couldn't just call it quits, it's not like we were live, I thought you were OK with it."

Alex punches me hard again, "You seriously going to blame me? I was acting, dickhead! I've never been fucked in the ass before and you think it's OK to just put it in my mouth? God, you are such an asshole."

Regret was finally starting to hit me, I try to apologize some more, "Sorry. You want to call the whole thing off then? We can just put that one up for sale then, and you're getting anything we make obviously."

Alex still looks pissed and considers it in silence for a few moments before saying, "Maybe. Iunno. I think I wanna put it up for free and paid as well, I mean some cheap dickheads gonna buy it and it's just gonna end up everywhere anyway, might as well do it myself and get some credit for that. But if it ends up getting fuck all traction, then yeah James, I am gonna call it quits."

Disappointment hits me like a brick but I know it's my own fault so I just agree.

Alex grabs some nearby wet wipes to start cleaning herself up while I dress. When she's cleaning her ass, she sucks air in between her teeth and says, "Fuck, that hurt."

"I thought you said you could take it?"

Funnily enough, Alex almost seems offended at this, "And I did, didn't I? I was fine up until you started going ham. That is not how you're supposed to assfuck a virgin dickhead."

"It looked great though, it was really good footage."

"Oh yeah, that's totally why you did it, to get class cinematography. You know, you're lucky I'm not a pussy, otherwise I'd have torn your dick off."

I started to relax now that things started going back to normal between the two of us. I tell Alex, "You were amazing by the way."

"Oh I'm sure I was," she said sarcastically.

"No, I honestly mean it. You couldn't have said anything hotter if you tried. It's like you reached into my head and found everything that turned me on. Trust me when I say that's gonna play well. Fuck, I'm getting a bit of a chub just thinking about what you said right now."

Alex raises a brow, "That good huh?"

"Yes, that good. How'd you know to say stuff like that?"

She shrugs, "You said it was supposed to be a casual, friends with benefits thing fantasy, I just acted like that."

"Well it was perfect, you were perfect."

"Yeah, yeah, keep it in your pants."

Once we're dressed, I transfer the footage onto Alex's laptop and let her watch it, while it's playing, I ask her, "So what do you wanna title it?"

"Huh?"

"The video, gotta have a catchy title right?"

"Oh yeah right. Huh, I hadn't really thought about that. What about, like, teen anal slut?"

I cringe a bit, "Bit unoriginal don't you think? Maybe we should try get it to stand out more."

"What are you, some avante garde director of porn? No one cares about that shit James."

"Come on, humor me."

Alex sighs and relents, "Fine, what do you want to title it then?"

I mull it over before saying, "How about, 'Tomboy friends with benefits lets me fuck her ass any time I want'?"

"Oh and that's supposed to be better? That's a mouthful and a half."

I gesture at my dick with both hands.

Alex groans, "Fine, fine. I don't even care, if it doesn't do well it just means get to keep my asshole safe and sound."

We upload the whole thing as is with only absolutely minimal editing.

~~~

I hang around at Alex's place, constantly refreshing the pages to see where we're at. In less than a day, it's got tens of thousands of views and a few hundred dollars in purchases.

Alex says to me, "Alright fine, it's doing well. Guess we better do some more then."

"What? Now? That soon?"

"I was planning on maybe one a week or something, but it's just I had an idea." Alex doesn't continue and just goes silent, she looks nervous and hesitant to go on but she eventually manages to spit out, "I can't fucking believe I'm the one suggesting this... Alright so I was looking around and saw painal videos seems like a really niche thing that a few creeps really like. I thought we could do a one off painal video. Emphasis on the one off."

The surprise is evident on my face and I only manage to mutter incoherently.

Alex says, "Yeah I know. But my ass was still sore and the idea just hit me. Wanna do it or not?"

"Y-Yeah I'm game."

Alex cocks her head, "Y'know, I was kinda hoping you'd say no. Guess you don't like me much."

That hurt, I sag suddenly and say, "No I do, we shouldn't. It really isn't worth it. We can make enough as is, no need to get all deviant fetish-y."

Seeing the sudden change in my demeanor, Alex quickly says, "Wow, wow, I was just fucking with you. It's my bloody idea and I do wanna go through with it."

"Well too bad, I don't anymore."

Alex seems primed to argue but softens instead, saying, "Look, I know you do like me OK? I was just joking, Jesus. Come on, it'll be fun."

"Not for you."

"True, but I'm a big girl. I didn't mean it OK, we're cool, I'm not angry at you."

I'm still unconvinced, so Alex pulls down her sweats and spreads her ass in my direction, saying, "Come on, you know you wanna tear that ass up. Think about how much fun it'd be to pin me down and ram it up my tight ass."

Again with the dirty talk. I still wanted to say no, to prove I wasn't an awful guy but the raging hard on in my pants made plainly shot that down. So I just give in. Getting together the camera equipment again, we set up a safe word and prepare for a scene on the couch.

Alex takes her pants off this time and is on her side, hugging her knees to her chest, with her head lying on the arm of the couch. She looks at the camera and says, "Well this is Round 2. My asshole is still sore as shit but James wants to buttfuck me again so I guess we're doing this."

I lube her up, take aim and start pressing in. As soon as the head of my cock touches her brown star, she sucks air in through her teeth, saying, "Fuck, this is gonna hurt."

I ignore her and keep pushing in, battering my way past the resistance and slipping into her tender, battered asshole, eliciting a gasp. I slowly sink down to the balls again and start pumping her at a moderate pace. Alex is focusing on her breathing, taking careful, steady breathes in and out to help with tolerating the pain.

Between breaths, Alex says, "This better fucking be worth it, you better be having the time of your life breaking my ass."

"I am, you're too good to me, I don't deserve this."

I start speeding up again. Alex's eyes are screwed shut and she's burying her face in her knees while I'm pumping her ass with deep strokes again. The constant battering is starting to give her the smallest gape when I pull out to get a shot. It looks so good I want to see if I can make it wider, but I clear it with Alex first, "Alex, you're asshole is starting to gape a bit. It looks really, really good, think I can try opening it up wider?"

Alex replies curtly, "Is it gonna make you cum sooner?"

"Yeah I think it will."

"Then fine. OK. If you wanna gape it man, go ahead." Then adding in very unconvincingly for the camera, "I love getting my ass gaped anyway."

I start pulling my cock entirely out before plunging back in suddenly again and again. Each time I use my hands to spread her ass open whenever I pull out. It takes a toll on Alex but it gets the job done, her pretty pink little hole starts to yawn open almost as wide as my cock and stay that way. With my thumbs on the rim of her asshole, I spread it wide as I can as I slowly pull out, admiring the sight of her stretched out hole. When it starts to wink shut, I repeat myself, never letting her fully close. The contrast between that pink, wide open hole and her puffy, juicy, tight looking pussy was erotic in the extreme. I was taken with the idea her asshole was made for fucking and her pussy just a decoration.

I'm so focused on fucking out her asshole, I didn't hear the soft sobbing coming from Alex. With her head buried in her knees, I couldn't see either. But when Alex finally looks at me, I see her face is streaked with some tears which she's fighting to hold back. Alex stares at me with pleading eyes and asks, "Hey James, how often do you think you wanna do this?" then in a desperate tone, she adds, "Is it gonna be every day?"

I keep in mind what she said and reply, "No, I think just once is enough Alex."

She nods once acceptingly and buries her head back in her knees.

That was enough niceness though so I spend the next minutes roughly pounding out Alex's asshole until it was a swollen red mess. She was gaping like a pornstar by the end of it to my satisfaction and would hardly close, I liked seeing what I was responsible for doing to her.

When I cum, I slam inside finally and fill her up again. It's a repeat of the first video, I pull my cock out of her mistreated ass, a thick trail of cum following before I treat her mouth to another round of fucking. At least this time there's little cum on my cock though. Alex almost seems relieved to suck my cock, even if it's just been in her ass, anything's better must be better than being assfucked at this point for her.

While she's busy cleaning me off, I tell her "There's some cum leaking out of your ass, don't let it mess up the couch, eat it up would you?"

Without taking me out of her mouth, she reaches back with her free hand and starts scooping up the cum trailing down her ass, the stationary camera perfectly catching it all. She pulls me out of her mouth, sucks the cum off her fingers and then returns me to her mouth. She does this like a half dozen times before her ass is clean. I'm not done with her yet though and say, "Inside too."

Alex gives me and the camera a tired look before complying. She tries to reach inside her ass but tenses and winces when her fingers brush against her abused hole. It takes her a moment to psyche herself up, but she soldiers through and plunges 3 fingers into her ass to scoop out the cum inside, pain clearly etched across her face as she does.

She quickly and robotically repeats this a few more times until she's satisfied she's cleaned out as she can manage.

"Thanks Alex."

"Any time James, see ya."

I turn off the cameras again. And as I expected, Alex breaks character again, the tears and pained expression on her face instantly cutting off.

"Man I was so hoping you were faking that."

"It wasn't hard to. That really sucked. I'm not gonna sit right for a week after that."

Defensively I say, "Remember it was your idea, you can't be mad at me."

"Yeah, yeah, I know. Jesus Christ I've had a day; started out an anal virgin, ended it having eaten cum out of my ass twice then having my asshole gaped open. You are really using this to turn me into a slut."

I point a finger at her accusingly, "This was all your idea, all of it, I'm innocent I tell you."

Alex groans, "That doesn't mean you have to be so... enthusiastic about things. Jesus, I'm not a pornstar remember."

"Well, you can relax, we definitely aren't doing another one until a week or mores gone by and you're better."

"Real fucking considerate aren't ya."

~~~

As the days go by, we watch in surprise as the view count keeps rising and the purchases alongside it. In a just a week, the videos have got more than a hundred thousand views with several grand in purchases with only a little slowing.

One day Alex finally decided things were doing well enough and tells me, "Well, I guess this is gonna be a regular thing then. Lucky you."

~~~

Our videos keep getting more popular because of the free use type, casual theme and the fact Alex seemed like such an easy anal slut. We easily managed to raise enough money for our holiday across Europe, but even that, we kept up the videos. For one, I assfucked Alex on a chair, she dangled her legs over the arms, giving me open access. We chatted while I pumped her ass with deep strokes; she just sat there and let me drill her ass relentlessly, both of us ignoring her pussy all the while. I eventually filled her ass and she as usual, ate it.

In one popular video, I was taking Alex's ass while she was kneeling on hardwood flooring. It was fine at first but after a while of pounding into her ass, I could tell her knees were hurting being pressed into the floor like that. Alex was too proud or stubborn to admit it hurt though so I just leaned more and more of my weight onto her as I assfucked her harder, trying to see if she'd complain but she never did. When I eventually filled her ass with semen, I had her lean back and push out the anal creampie onto the floor. When I pulled her up and turned her around, she gave the mess on the floor one look and said with an annoyed expression, "You're going to make me eat that aren't you."

"Yup."

"Ugh, gross." Alex shook her hands out to psyche herself up for a moment before she leaned down, pursed her lips and nosily slurped the cum off the floor. She straightened out and opened her mouth for me and the camera to get a good look, even swirling her tongue around and gargling a little before she loudly gulped it all down.

It wasn't something we planned on doing; it was just something I sprung on her again. Alex might get a little annoyed at first but would quickly get over it. In fact, as things continued, I'd noticed she complained less and less about the surprises I gave her and just went along with them.

~

Another popular one had us playing FIFA together while Alex bounced her ass on my cock. She'd have to go ass to mouth every time I scored and could swap to her pussy for a little while if she did, she didn't play too well with all the distraction. I finished in her ass after bending her over upside down. Alex gave me a confused look while I was maneuvering her around but just went along with it like I knew she would.

Once I had her folded over herself, I told her to push the creampie out. Posed like that, she realized what I was aiming for, getting her to push the creampie out into her own mouth and face. We'd gotten to the point where even something this obscene didn't get anything more than a surprised out of her. She played along and pushed, opening her mouth and sticking out her tongue to catch the creampie. Some of it landed in her mouth or on her tongue, but some splattered on her cheeks and lips too. At this point Alex didn't need to be told what to do, she just scooped the cum off her face and into her mouth before gargling a little and swallowing it like usual, after all, eating my cum out of her ass is what friends do.

It was becoming more than just a thing for the videos too. When I visited Alex one day, she was busy with something on her laptop, instead of just ignoring me until she was done, she said, "Hey man, sorry I can't talk and I'm gonna be a while, typing a lot of shit up."

"That's cool," I reply.

After a little while I me just awkwardly hanging around while she silently worked, Alex eventually says, "Dude you don't have to sit there twiddling your thumbs, just iunno, use my asshole while you wait."

"You want to film something?" I ask, confused.

"No just pump my ass if you want to kill some time."

"Are you serious?"

Alex shoots me a confused glance, "Yeah? Why wouldn't I be? You assfuck me all the time anyway, how is this any different?"

The question stumps me for a moment, "It's hard to explain, that feels more business-like? This feels more personal."

"Yuck, stop with the feelings. Dude, you've been in my ass so much, I don't even care anymore. But if you don't want to, then don't."

Shrugging, I take her up on the offer. Somehow, it feels better without the cameras rolling, like she isn't doing it for any reason beyond just letting me fuck her.

"God it feels so good being in your ass Alex, you've got no idea."

"Yeah, well, good for you man, enjoy it."

"The first time it was amazing though, shame it can't be like that all the time."

Alex turned to give me a annoyed look, "Oh gee, I'm sorry my asshole isn't tighter since you've been fucking it all the time. Dickhead."

"Sorry, sorry, I didn't mean it that way. I just meant the first time you brought it up it was like mindblowing, the fantasy and all that, now it's just casual sex. Sorry, I do appreciate this Alex."

"Oh OK. Wait, fantasy? Huh, didn't expect that. Didn't seem like you spent afternoons fantasizing about getting into my pants, bet this must be a real dream come true," she said smugly.

Rolling my eyes I replied, "That's not how it is."

Mockingly Alex says, "Sure, sure, why don't you just get back to my ass and let me finish this up."

~~~

I obviously started buttfucking Alex a lot more after that. And as an added bonus, she still kept up the routine of eating the cum out of her ass too. She got the message pretty soon and any time I came over, her pants would come off and she'd ride me with her ass while we hung out or played games. I was pretty happy with how slutty Alex had become, she wouldn't so much as bat an eye at sucking her ass off my cock anymore, even offering it pretty often.