All Comments on '…first impressions'

by Man Ray

Sort by:
  • 17 Comments
IrishBayouIrishBayouover 17 years ago
Imperial Choice!

Nice take on Hans Christian Andersen’s morality play. It jostles us to see/speak truths as would an innocent child rather than succumb to peer pressure. Good illustration! It dresses the poem in myriad ways; the fluidity of man’s potence or lack thereof being one. IB

LeBrozLeBrozover 17 years ago
~~

Much easier to read, this go round

Though on comparing first impressions

The earlier photo was better;

At least here it's clear with no need for zoom.

Nevertheless, your words still remind me of a time long ago

Coming to her place at 3 in the a.m.

First stop at the pool

Then air-dried on up to her apt.

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
Well done! Truthfully beautiful.

Every man should be so loved. Truly touching. I don't know what the 'other' image was. This does it for me!

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
Delightful and charming!

You’ve rebutted the old adage "You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink." With an open-palmed hand, a woman can lead a man to divest him of those things he is willing to shed. Remarkable illustration and poem in ode to HCA’s fable!

Veronica

LiarLiarover 17 years ago
Well done!

I must say, one of your better efforts. A tastefully eloquent tale. (and an only slightly suggestive pic)

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
~

long winded to understand this you need to be in aworld of your own

My Erotic TrailMy Erotic Trailover 17 years ago
first impression...

Awe, the illustrations as well as the poetry seem to get better with each poem that surfaces, I hope to see more of this poets artistic literary art (~_~)

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
...posted by Liar in New Poem Reviews

Dunno who does the reviwing today but I'm gonna barge in an point y'all towards Man Ray's illustrated ...first impressions anyway. I usually shy away from rhyming couplets, but here it's presented in style wthout ever feeling forced or trite. Give it a look-see.

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
loving it

I have now read everything wrote by manray and must say I have enjoyed them all, each poem is different to the last and every picture compliments it wonderfully

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
My first impression: nothing special

Nice picture, though the relationship between it and the text is unclear to me, and the poem is inexplicably verbose. There are contradictions that undermine the poem's impact, e.g. to "prosecute" someone does NOT imply "gentle" treatment, and language errors that simply confuse readers ("divested idealistic imputations"-- huh?)

I'm a little puzzled by the accolades this poem has garnered, but we each have our own tastes. I hope the author welcomes opinions that may differ from his own.

A very nice picture.

Fly

My Erotic TrailMy Erotic Trailover 17 years ago
mention

mentioned on the thread 'New Poem Reviews'

thanks for the literary journey (~_~)

ChagrinedChagrinedover 17 years ago
Pretty inane actually

Swimmers by definition swim. Did you need to remind the reader what swimmers do? Speedos are now vestments?! And since when do swimmers wear vestments? Could it be you don't know that vestments are "official" apparel? A judge wears them as do ministers and priests.

No images or emotions are evoked here. This seems to be just a cacophony of really poorly chosen words.

Frost, Browning, Ginsberg have nothing to worry about here.

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
~~~

Callin' on ya Ya-Ya Sisters. Ya tongue tied? Hogtied? Bound and gagged? No comments! Tsk Tsk girls! @--->--->--ya gotta admit this is good!

Jen

KOLKOREKOLKOREover 17 years ago
There are no happy loves

My personal groove is at its peak when I’m being hit by equal amounts of visual and text; but that’s just my bias, not this poem’s fault. After all, I would not ask any of the poems in the ‘non illustrative’ category to please show up in 24 hours with an appropriate accompanying visual or else, would I? I’ll confess that my visual imagination dept. seemed to have gone on a strike, and therefore no concrete resolution re. the image. Unless I am totally blinded to an obvious depiction, it seems like this poem does not ask for more than highlighting, (dare I say – Illustrating?) the mood it creates by the power of the words.

What I missed in the dialog with the visual I regained in the quirky dialog between imageries within the poem. On one hand the Mythical/fairy tale imagery, on the other the imagery of the court. There is nothing like the power of a poem to bring different worlds together! Here it allows for a lighter, even ironic take on themes which otherwise could have been too familiar. The ocean and the shore; disrobing and getting into the ocean as indicators of different stages in the erotic encounter have been identified as such by numerous poets; films; even by this poet. But take the same dive after a not so hidden parody of both a fairy tale and a trial (every king deserves a trial before his punishment) and that is a different dip altogether.

Don’t take my suggestion for ironic reading too far though. Without risking an over psychologizing read into this poem, its seems pretty clear that the serious romantic core is there. Only it is covered by multiple layers which serve the purpose of distancing us and the narrator from that core. That’s why a poem about love seems more like a poem about a story (or a myth or a fable) about love. And the suggested treatment of this love? Almost like you would treat a suspected criminal - with suspicion of course, then investigate and shed all the layers of untruthfulness and pretence. No one is born with those attitudes, so we can all think back, each about our own legacies of being hurtful or being hurt in our personal histories of failed loves. Yes, somewhere at the end there is a happy end, but I am mostly impressed by all the measures taken to first distance that object, so that I am left with a sense of: yes, there are loves, but they belong in the songs. As the great Guru of love songs Georges Brassens bemoaned in his poem: “Il n'y a pas d'amour heureux” (There are no happy loves), the title gives you the message.

Man RayMan Rayover 17 years agoAuthor
“never explain, never defend”…

an adage I subscribe to though break from when needed. Many have commented on the image: befitting/unfitting/ relevance. I’ll give it my best shot though how one sees/ explains and/or interprets art I haven’t a clue.

I created a dripping phallic image to connote manhood. The well-known fable has always amused me and was the ‘seed’ of the poem. The image spoke/mirrored to me (and I had hoped the poem) in myriad ways. I believe KOLKORE’s comments specific to the poem itself covers the rest.

Thank you everyone for your comments. Special thank yous to Liar and My Erotic Trail for the “New Poems Reviews”!

Man Ray

duddle146duddle146over 17 years ago
meeting

A swimmer meets an Emperor ~ proceeds to straighen him out on things ~ as we leave them they're drifting hand in hand in the soft forgiving sand. Interesting illustration.

tazz317tazz317about 12 years ago
CLOTHES DO NOT MAKE A MAN OR WOMAN

grace and poise take affect. TK U MLJ LV NV

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous