All Comments on 'Katie Bradley's Sea-monkey'

by WillowedCabin

Sort by:
  • 8 Comments
tazz317tazz317about 12 years ago
WILL CAGED BIRDS SING

or just be suicidal. TK U MLJ LV NV

AnonymousAnonymousabout 12 years ago
ugh

reads like some crappy imitation of an even crappier annaswirls poem. U R trying way to hard===seppuku slipped just about gagged me

WillowedCabinWillowedCabinabout 12 years agoAuthor
Dearest anon,

If I am even a crappy imitation of annaswirls, I can rest happy.

PS: try some fresh ginger for that over-active gag reflex. Always seems to work for me :)

bronzeagebronzeageabout 12 years ago
reviewed

Reviewed in the New Poetry Recommendation thread, Jan 31, 2012

TzaraTzaraabout 12 years ago
I've read this poem several times

and it has considerable strengths, but I am not sure quite what it's about. I think it is a poem about abortion, more or less from the point of the aborted fetus, but I could be wildly wrong about that. But even assuming I'm correct in that, I'm not sure what the narrator's position is on the subject.

Now the narrator might be conflicted about the subject (if it is abortion, one could hardly fail to be conflicted), but I think (and this is just opinion, of course) that the reader ought to have some sense of what the narrator's opinion is, especially given a controversial subject.

Maybe this is clear to other readers. Maybe (actually, more than likely) I am a complete idiot and the poem is about something else.

Anyway, your poem makes me think, even if wrong-headedly, and thinking is pretty much always good.

DeepGreenEyesDeepGreenEyesabout 12 years ago
Painfully brilliant...

Such rawness treated with such a deft and nimble touch. Terrific.

NachthexeNachthexeabout 12 years ago
all guts/ glory

for me, anyone who mentions seppuku in their poem, even off-handed, wins a special spot. yukio mishima is a patron saint. thanks for sharing this!

buttersbuttersabout 12 years ago
strong write

visceral and unflinching. 'all guts and no glory' was good, but bettered (imo) by 'c-section smile'. a disturbing, uncompromising write. thankyou.

Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous