All Comments on 'Suspicion: Healing'

by fdkman262

Sort by:
  • 156 Comments
AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Romantic and touching

I've noticed that this was very similar to some of the other versions of Suspicion in that Senor Karl was an old high school flame of Kathy's. Seems to be a common plot twist with the cheating wife's storylines where an otherwise happily married woman decides to "play" with a man she hasn't seen in 10-20 years but knew in high school. Be nice to see a change, but it did fit the story.

And this was well written overall. The husband came across as believable and you ended up hoping he'd get a happy ending, but I think most would agree that you wanted it to be without Kathy. I'll admit that part of me wanted Kathy's second marriage to fall apart since it was not exactly an honest or honorable marriage (since it was formed through 6 months of cheating on Paul.)

Good dialogue, and no major grammar errors

one note is that the plot does start to drag after about the third page. The steps leading up to the divorce go quickly, but then the life after seemed to almost be a second story where the plot was a bit less uncertain. The overall good writing and basic plot redeemed it, but it could be better.

Hope to see more from fkdman in the future.

Mr. Long Poster

(without a username since 3/29/06. :P )

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Living well

They say the best revenge is to live well, that's what you showed us in this story. Still, for some reason this story leaves me unsettled. I can't understand a woman that could leave her husband of so many years and her children without a thought. Fantasy is just that, a fantasy. I'm sure the reality wasn't as pretty. She had a good thing and let it go. I wanted to see the consequences of her actions. You didn't give me that.

Harryin VAHarryin VAabout 18 years ago
ok but NO pain & hurt for the whore wife

Good story well written ansd much better than what the pathetic walking douche bag MORON the CELT wrote.

still kathy got no pain... and never realized what seh lost. She suffered NOTHING

sherlock40sherlock40about 18 years ago
An excellent ending to the story.

I really don't like those cheating spouse stories where the husband becomes a hermit, never interacting with or moving on after the break-up. I hope that this story will influence other writers to let their husbands or wives continue with their lives after the divorce.

ChagrinedChagrinedabout 18 years ago
An excellent ending!

Yes, I too like to see where folks are able to move on. This was a well written ending. I agree that I would have liked to see a little more reality from the wife's predicament (sic). I have found that reality is VERY rarely better than the fantasy we concock (sic) for ourselves.

Also, it has been my experience that kids won't be as easy to forgive the cheating parent as you indicate in the story. She (or in some stories he) didn't just cheat on a spouse. In a real sense people are being unfaithful to the entire family. Kids do understand this even we want to lie to ourselves that they don't. Kids are far less forgiving. And they should be. A primary component of love is to protect your loved ones from harm and to see to it that they have a stable environment. That was very much glossed over here.

Looking for more submissions.

Regards,

C

gizzmo301gizzmo301about 18 years ago
good

A happy ever after story... to bad real life dosn't turn out that well

peggytwittypeggytwittyabout 18 years ago
Very well done

I won't compare your ending to others as I think yours was very good and you picked your story line for what interested you. More on the ex-wife’s life would have been welcome to maybe make it a more complete story. Your sex scenes were terrific and real like to me. Each person is different in what they like while making love.

Very good writing and story

Thank you

Blue88Blue88about 18 years ago
Well Done

I liked it. The trauma was overcome and Paul did go on to find happiness. Good job, well written.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Good

I thought that Paul ended up better with Heidi than Kathy. Your last words of him reflecting on Kathy not loving him enough was true. I do think the kids would have had problems with Kathy and cut her out of their lives, which should have been shown here. I did read other's version of chapter 2 and did like their take on Kathy getting the wakeup of what she lost. I would have liked to see more of that here, but even without it I found this was excellent. Thanks

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
mature, intelligent way to end it and start afresh

as Paul said, since he's a one-woman-man, once he chose someone, he loves her deeply,,,, and that included Kathy the cheating former wife,,, but as he said, loving someone deeply in your heart does not mean you will carry a torch for them forever,,,

a decent, trustworthy, good man like the character Paul here deserves --- as even Kathy agrees --- to be happy and Heidi is a person with character integrity that would make him possible for both Paul and her to be happy,,, judging from how Heidi raised her kid alone for 10 years without child support, working two jobs,,, raising a smart, upstanding son all by herself,,,

since Paul is such a decent character, he truly, as he observed at the end, wished Kathy a good, long happy life with her "greatest love",,, Paul KNOWS he IS again deeply happy, having found an anchor as solid as Heidi,,,

We don't really care much about Kathy, as this is not her story,,, her story ended when she made a decision to leave two teens and her husband behind to live out her life with her "greatest love",,, Even if her life's told, it would not make it too interesting, because PAUL IS SUCH a nice person, a person we rather root for:

"I left a very decent man, who loved and cherished me deeply, and left my two teenager --- all very hard to do but a life I could not have gone on with --- to marry my to marry my present husband," etc. just doesn't get people to root for you, however happy you may be with this person you cheated your husband with,,,

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
7 pages

you could have done it in 3

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Excellent take

I like your ending of this story as well as Thecelts. Whiteone's story left some tantalizing threads to pick up and it is fun to read everyone's take on it. You did this very well, and I enjoyed the story. I hope to see more of your work on this site.

Again, nice job.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
This story was veryw ell done and seeme dto be

as it would in real life. The only thing missing to me was what happened to the frist wife. I would have liked to have seen her get a little more pain and hurt. She sure destoryed the husband for a while. But Otherwise great story.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Tidying Up Loose Ends - Is Appreciated

And while doing so, doing it not only in a entertaining well written fashion but realatively true to life as most of us know it.

The majic wand injecting manly respect back into him for his spouses failing just isn't a normal lifelike reaction that can be sold in every circumstance.

So, each of your efforts thus far have been tidying up marital consequence themes that you felt passionate about. It is satisfing writing with passion isn't it. Well, there is lots of fodder here for you to consider alternate endings to and I hope to see you considering others or one of your own.

Author - you are appreciated in this theme above all others as a measure of balance to the absurdities that offend human sensibilities.

Again thanks - With Very High Regard

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Thanks loads...

This is the first 100 I've given any writer. Your story flowed and meshed so well that I was kept interested throughout. I appreciated how you so tastefully handled the entire course of events in his life after his divorce, and the absence of bitterness on his part was a nice take. If he had done or said more toward his ex... I would have objected to that. I'm NOT a reconcilliation person 90% of the time, so I'm glad he moved on without looking back. it showed strength of character on his part, which is something sorely lacking in most of the men on this web site.

I've said over and over that "Loving Wives" on Literotica is a misnomer. They are slut wives, pure and simple, for the most part and the men are the ones who come crawling back to the women who betray them. How unrealistic. Having sex outside the marriage circle is not what most husbands consider "loving," and most recoil vehemently to that sort of betrayal. Thanks for bearing that out in your story.

Et Ceteraman

vetter350vetter350about 18 years ago
Very good

I thought this was an excellent ending to this story. It would be hard to make a choice between this ending and thecelts. I cannot understand though why the one poster felt it necessary to badmouth thecelt like he did.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Very Good

Your ending was better than the original author's. Whether it was better than the Celt's ending is a matter of personal preference. I wish you had dealt with what happened to the first wife after the break up.

Boyd

gatorhermitgatorhermitabout 18 years ago
Good ending

Living well is the best revenge. Well done.

andy1hardyandy1hardyabout 18 years ago
ENJOYED THE STORY

Thank you ...good read.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
I too am torn

between your ending and thecelt's. One reader chided you because you made the story too long in his/her estimation. I personally think you did it exactly right, taking your time to develop a full and complete story in it's own right. Well done. Thank You. Ronnie W.

MinigalesMinigalesabout 18 years ago
Excellent Story

Very well written. I hope to see more of you in the future.

Thanks.

RicticRicticabout 18 years ago
Very Good

A very good read. I hope to see more stories from you in the future.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Actually, more Romance than Loving wives

This was very nicely done with a light touch.

The length of the story was needed. I takes time for a man in this situation to be ready to move on and then it takes more time for a new relationship to mature.

Nice positive ending!

Regards, DJ (Dynamite Jack)

Orion623Orion623about 18 years ago
Great!

Very well done. I had no problems with the length of the story as it allowed the author to develope the characters fully.

This was a well a well thought out conclusion and a very realistic one. The husband waited two years to find a woman. The woman he found had waited ten years to meet a man to spend her years with. This is much closer to real life than all the forced reconciliations we read about.

Both of your submissions have been way above all others.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
I Agree with Anonymous in Et Ceteraville ..

and I am changing my rating practice. I had given a 100 for a well written story especially if the author was new despite the ending. You have clearly demonstrated that you can write a well thought out ending consistent with the beginning premises of the story.

For example, many stories on this site in this category start with the husband being the perfect husband, father and citizen with a good job. Then his wife cheats on him and his family for some excuse or reason. After the nashing of teeth and tearing of cloth associated with disclosure of the affair we get either an unrealistic reconciliation (the so-called happy ending) or the husband spend the rest of life moping for his cheating wife or failed marriage.

What I loved about your story (and it was not too long) is that it walked through Paul's healing process which was very realistic given that one day he had a happy marriage and the next day his wife leaves him for a fantasy lover.

I am also glad that you stayed away from some stupid revenge scenario which would have impacted the kids as well.

Once again, thanks for a mature and realistic story.

SleeplessinMD

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Impausible outcome

I agree with the commentator that indicated that this story was too long. The entire sequence of events with Heidi could have been presented in half the pages.

The biggest problem I had was that the Heidi relationship took so long that the Kathy relationship was completely ignored. These two adulterers should not get to just walk off into the sunset; they should not get the happily ever-after treatment. At bare minimum, Karl should have had an accident for injecting himself in another man’s family, but notice that Karl is not even a character in this story!

Our hero goes sulking for a couple years until he finds the right woman. Then our hero finds it in his heart to accept the presence of his cheating ex with such good graces that I wondered why he had not extended her an invitation to the wedding. This story should have been entitled: A wimp’s Saga.

Average-JoeAverage-Joeabout 18 years ago
Very good ending

Paul finds real love and lives happily ever after. Just the type of outcome I usually hope for in fiction.

Although I didnt care much for Kathy, I thought that not mentioning her hardly at all was a great way to go. Having Paul happy is better than having her suffer (or worse yet, having him take her back when her fantasy didnt pan out). By not writing much about the ex it seemed that Paul was truely over her. If he had kept mentioning that she wasnt happy or that reality didnt measure up to the fantasy, it would have seemed like he still cared about her too much (hate is a type of caring). By not knowing or caring what she did, it showed that he was really over her and ready to embrace his new, better, marriage without wondering what might have been.

Im not sure if I could have been as big about it as he was though since I really did dislike Kathy. If she had just dumped him for Karl I could have at least had some respect for her but the way she wanted it all was really annoying.Pauls reaction in this story was better than mine would have been but thats a good thing. I like happy endings (which arent always the same as reconciliations no matter what some authors on this site seem to think) and I like the characters to be better than rl.

Paul seemed like a genuine good guy and I was happy that things ended well for him. For me, ending things well for the good guy is usually more important than seeing the bad guy miserable (not that a little revenge and some 'what goes around comes around' is bad as long as the good guy doesnt let that his/her biterness eat away at them).

Thanks very much for writing.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 18 years ago
Strong Ending

I have read the other endings and liked this very much. As I said in my comment on whiteone_redone's original, Paul is a strong character. Fdkman262 has vividly illustated his efforts to reclaim his life. I do not feel the absence of Kathy dilutes this viewpoint. I think this is an excellent tale, well written, and reflecting a more real-life outcome. Mind you, I'd still torch the bitch!

louguy35louguy35about 18 years ago
Wonderfully Done!

This is one of the best amalgamations of several chapters or versions of a story that I have read on Lit.com. It is so good, in fact, that it is hard to decide where to begin with my comments.

First of all, the story is NOT too long. The theme of the story was the healing of a good man violated by a self-absorbed slut. The length was essential to adequately convey the healing process and Paul's movement from victim to victor (he won a true love). The character development was compelling and complete.

Secondly, the author did not rush the relationship between Paul and Heidi, as they moved from one level of affection to another. That is likely what would happen in real life, and stories are believable only if they bear some resemblance to real life.

Lastly, the ending was WELL CONSTRUCTED, and made sense in the context of the story. I thought the appearance of Kathie at the reception was gratuitous since, as a reader,I did not give a shit what happened to her. But the author, by having her show up at the end of the story, probably completed the circle and closed the book on the narcissistic bitch. Not a bad element in the ending.

All-in-all, the author melded all of the ingrediants of the prior versions and composed a Lit.com near-masterpiece.

Cheers!

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 18 years ago
First class ending

Great story with a much better ending than the original tale. Hope for more stories from you in the future.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 18 years ago
Great alternate ending, great stuff

This is by far, BY FAR, the best ending to Paul's story; & like many of the other commentators, very well written, with good, believable character development. I was somewhat disappointed that Karl & Kathy were able to get off "scot free", but hey, that's just me. I would have liked for Kathy to come to her senses, just about the time that Paul & Heidi got married, too late to reclaim Paul - even if he wanted her back - but just in time to see that Paul was very happy, with a woman who loved him for what he was, and just not settling for second best. Keep up the good work!

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
Better than original

This ending was noy as nearly wimpy as original. (zed)

ddpmanddpmanover 17 years ago
Good Followup

Your is one ofthe better endings. I was sorry you didn't bring Todd and Lucile into the tale to tie things together.

Enjoyed your tales Thanks

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
Long Winded comment..... (appologies) lol

It was good.

I don't see any problems or big shortcommings.

A lot of your harder critics seemed to contradict even themselves. "A man with such good graces cannot invite her to the wedding....wimps saga"

He's not perfect, and not in the best of graces, which is exactally why she wasn't givn any invitation. That's what I love, Paul has depth to him as a character. There is much realism. Guys CAN be like the stereo-typical "victim of a cheating spouse". It's not always a woman. In fact, its 50/50. Gender has nothing to do with it. Paul CAN be nice...and be a jerk. He needs to find a balanced comfort between caring enough not to destroy and ruin Kathy, and wimping out and allowing her to beat down his pride. He won't tolerate some actions, but he will use his heart and his brain to try to give the marriage one more try.

Moral of the story: "Soul Mates are a joke".

Marriage and love....those are commitments between two people who trust, care, empathize with one another. Granted, betrayal has the effect of feeling like a soul mate is lost, but love is easily attainable again. And if a spouse will leave to re-kindle his/her old sould mate match, she/he is deluded, and just chose them over you.

Im glad karl wasn't mentioned...a good author knows when NOT to play certain words, or when a mucisian purposely avoids certain notes. Why do we need to have Kathy punished, or watch her character unfold. Realiy just bites....whether she's happy with Karl....(who left her ages ago....seems she loves him more than he does her) she definately isn't the focal point.

She chose to be taken out of the story when she neglected her relations with Paul. The story is about their relationship and how Paul copes. Do you HAVE to follow your heart? No...its obvious Kathy will never be happy with whatever she chooses. Thank God Paul allows her to abandon the family, and still worked towards having the family comfort her (she didn't deserve it.....but why should people need to help reality bite even more?)

Reality is that she had a choice, made it.....and she did it without much empathy....which shows in Paul's less than perfect attitude towards her. But she lives with it, and it does affect others. We have bonds, making them is great, breaking them sucks. Reality bites, sucks, and blows. But still.....you move on and make life work for you. We all have the natural right to be happy....

All of us, from the skank Kathy.....to the overly compassionate Paul. Even if its not YOUR hapy ending. It's still good to try and find one that'll make you happy. ^-^

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
* sniff *

I almost cried. You have a great talent for writing likable characters, making the reader want to see them happy. You also did very well in making us believe that they are indeed happy.

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
i read some where that writers on this site

try to hard to make you understand the feeling of the female spouse who cheat.this woman was a selfish and sick woman.she did leave her kids and her hubby.she wasn't thinking as an adult,she was acting like inmature person trying to live a fanasy.why would you let your daughter be around the whore and her lover.kids are smarter than adult sometime.

AnonymousAnonymousover 17 years ago
ladies and gentlemen there is life after divorce

there is ten women to every man and they are ready and willing to make a good man happy.writers stop making a cheating whore look like she is the only thing that can make him happy.there are women who go thru the newspaper posting of divorces to find men to see.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 17 years ago
A Real Story Written By A Real Man...

His ex got the boot and he got the doll! This IS how life balances out everything. Being a cuckold is a losing situation and no Man ought to play that game!! Have your cake and eat it too! Teach the bitch ex wife a lesson, but take your pound of flesh. No one should ever put up with a real bitching out like our hero had to. And I'd have stepped on the visitation hard in the beginning so as to cause momma a lot of pain; and deservedly so!

AnonymousAnonymousabout 17 years ago
Bravo!

Far,far better ending. Living well

is the best revenge.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 17 years ago
Now And Forever

A life as it should be lived.No wimp here.Husband or wife,cheaters should never win in the end.

Vulcan_in_OhioVulcan_in_Ohioalmost 17 years ago
This was really well done.

This is a well-planned, well-written story. I liked it a lot.

AnonymousAnonymousover 16 years ago
Beautifully written romantic story

I thought this was a beautifully written story that could just as easily be classified as a stand alone romantic story rather than a sequal,but however you clasify it,it's a very well written story.

60 year old George

AnonymousAnonymousabout 16 years ago
REAL

I enjoyed the other conclusions, but felt they were each a stretch. This was beautifully written and far more real. The reader knew the ending could have gone the other way for a sadder ending, but it still would've stayed true to reality. GREAT JOB! - Budd

DSLAYERDSLAYERover 15 years ago
Nope!!!

You have got to be kidding!!!

AnonymousAnonymousabout 15 years ago
A NICE PERSON

Why do these authors allways try to make every one a nice person. She wasn't a nice person she cheated on him for 6 months and then left him and the kids.She was a self-centered selfish person.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 15 years ago
Boring,ridiculous,inane....

...and not particularly well written, at least as far vas the repartee between children and adults.maybe English kids speak like this but not American teens.Or tweens.PG story on erotic story site.Sure.Pistolpackinpete

SELSTIMSELSTIMover 14 years ago
Well Written Story

It was a little long and I lost interest about half way through. I continued reading, to see if there was any regret on Kathy's part and to see what type of emotional effects the divorce had on Paul. Paul's character was a bit of a stretch. I suppose there are some really strong people out there that when faced with such a traumatic experience don't really have any long lasting emotional effects. I've seen people remarry after emotional divorces but still seem to have commitment issues. That is, they are more detached in the second marriage. Kind of an unconscious self protection mechanism. I realize he was hurt and didn't feel like dating for a couple years but emotional wounds such as these are often character changing events where the character never reverts to the previous personality. Not without counseling, anyway. It was a nice story with very nice characters (especially the kids) in a very nice settings. Even the characters that committed adultery for six months are forgiven and portrayed as nice people but just a little anticlimatic for me. Especially, with such an emotionally traumatic event that this story had derived from. Thank you

peteinchicagopeteinchicagoabout 14 years ago
Very Good Story

I think this is my favorite ending to this story, I think I've read 4 now. I would have enjoyed it more if the 1st wife had suffered a little more, I wouldn't have been as warm to her when she crashed the wedding party. I can't believe that the kids would have been as forgiving, and believe that it would have been a good touch if they had responded with a little more anger to someone who after all cheated them as well as their dad. It also would have been nice if her second marriage didn't work out, as someone said, fantasy doesn't usually work out in the end. Still, he's moved on and has a new wife who is stronger and more loyal than his first. As they say the best revenge is a life well lived. Great job.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 14 years ago
Wonderful!

I really loved this story! I liked it MUCH better that the original by Whiteone Redone. His ending was rather sad. The husband deserved to be happy again after being dumped on by his oh-so-loving wife. The only quibble I have with it is that Kathy did not get what she deserved.

AnonymousAnonymousover 13 years ago

Much better ending than the original. It was nice to see you actually give the man some dignity compared to what whiteone did. His goofy way of speaking with his teenage children was a little awkward to envision, I just can't see teenagers going along with those antics as much as his children did, but I was able to just shrug that off. Overall it was a very nice read with some minor disappointment because of Kathy's callous treatment toward her former family not coming back to bite her in anyway -- but that's life and revenge and karma rarely happen in real life.

huedogghuedoggover 13 years ago
Your ending was better

Your version was better than the whole other story

AnonymousAnonymousover 13 years ago
Ending not satisfying.

Let's see. Kathy cuckolds him, gives up kids for a man willing to destroy a family, and Kathy lives happily ever after. BULLSHIT. Really quite pathetic a tale.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 13 years ago
Still a poor ending.

As commented on, Kathy really broke it off in her family. So, why should she live happily ever after? At a bare minimum there should of been no friendship between him and her (and no contact). He should of found a happier life without ever seeing her again. (And, if Kathy ended up miserable, that would be "gravy" to the story).

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
nice

I liked it that he could wish his ex-wife well.

Hanging on to bitterness just makes unhappiness.

They are all all happier for it.

AnonymousAnonymousover 12 years ago
not nearly enough

humiliation for the wannabe cucks. Graphic creampie eating, sloppy seconds, entire town knows of his cuckhood, then the WBC might be satisfied. They need ample doses of degradation in order to spank.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 12 years ago
Not a proper ending...

Paul should of contacted AIDS from Kathy who got it from a stripper at her bride shower.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 12 years ago
I don't see

the daughter remaining in close contact with her mother, considering what the woman had done. This whole "your mother loves you," business is false, since in the story, the daughter states that the woman left the family for another man. It is wrong.

shuttelpilot

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 12 years ago

I'm glad Paul found love again.

But that bloody whore Kathy? She did not pay for her cheating. She gave up her family for her lover. She did not sacrifice anything in her life yet she got the fairytale happy ending. And to top it off Paul extended an invite for her to attend the celebration? Hell No!!!!!! She got off too easy. She was not accountable for her actions.

AnonymousAnonymousover 11 years ago
How the fuck any idiot author could write this.....

So, little ole cheating slut Kathy lives happily ever after. Bullshit. Best ending possible was to discover (too late) that good ole Paul had AIDs, which she contracted also, and they both die in agony within a month of each other. And, oh, she dies alone since everyone hates her. Fucking wimp author.

AnonymousAnonymousover 11 years ago
this version of

the story is the worst

the wife had never been punished for what she did

and the huisband is the same nice looser like in the other versions

lonewolf3307lonewolf3307about 11 years ago
Well, this is, by far, the best ending to the sad, sordid tale of Paul and Kathy that I've read to date...

... I know the BTB crowd isn't very happy and the romance bunch probably would have liked more information on Kathy's relationship with Karl. As for me, I think the author really found the meat of the story when Paul accepted the fact that Kathy had never really loved him and only married him because she had seemingly lost Karl. Maybe the romantic in me reared it's ugly head but it looked like Paul had found true love for the first time with Heidi. As far as more information about Kathy and Karl goes, who really cares what happened to those two. I know I don't.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 11 years ago
No emotions

wow the story has no emotions no ones sad or upset no one carries a grudge ,What fuck around 6 months expose me to STD's, its okay because im a pussy fuck!. How can your write about betrayal on not get mad these are not men they are pussies the worst kind of male, what rob me steal from me kill me, its okay i deserved it for having a cock. You dont carry the hate day to day but you dont ever forget or forgive they have no remorse,you release the hate but keep the anger at being raped,once more a all is forgiven story, no invite to marriage, no we talking like friends she is and will forever be the enemy of your heart, not hate just no love or affection at all!

AnonymousAnonymousabout 11 years ago
Oh, OK.

Good storyline. Mostly well written, if a bit brusque for its length.

Fuller, more realistic characters with more emotion would make this a 5+, as it is already the best of the alternates by a country mile.

HardFeltHardFeltabout 11 years ago
What?

No consequences, none, zip. Cheating does pay; at least in this story. No VD either. Hum makes a person wonder how come there even is VD .. oh yeah illicit sex. Wow. What a total crock of ...

monkcalmmonkcalmalmost 11 years ago
as good as a text book

math 101= this story well typed, but as feeling as any high school text book, shit for emotions or feeling,do you know what funny and sad are?

FD45FD45over 10 years ago
As monkcalm said

A story is a description but it really requires a conflict as a lynchpin. Jane Austen's was the need for a good husband and the machinations of how to land one. Independence Day had huge scary space aliens.

What little conflict this had was wrapped up in about 2 pages. She cheated, she divorced...and...who cares what comes next.

And frankly, I was desperately disappointed. I had just gotten finished reading or rereading the Hardheads and T & C and both struck me with their clarity of thought and writing. Nice simple prose telling a good story with valid reasoning and never once demanding I suspend my disbelief in unacceptable ways.

So...this was bland. Yes, you had two pages of sex scenes, which is, I suppose, welcome here, but unless there is something wrong, there generally isn't a conflict there. It's SEX.

However, I wish you wrote more.

FullCircle56FullCircle56over 10 years ago
Decent Story, well written

For the most part I enjoyed this. I think I was expecting some type of fireworks with the cheating wife. Glad this was one of those guys who went for divorce. I kind of expected him to get with the sister in law. But that story scenario was already covered somewhere else on the site. Agreed with other commenters. It was a bit bland. For a love story it worked. Thanks for posting. Well written and I hope you continue to write for this site.

bobyroy69bobyroy69over 10 years ago
Stiff & Formal

And this alternate version doesn't relate to the LW Category at all.

Seven pages of nothing...

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 10 years ago
This Paul is a wimp

This is a wimp version of the tail, Paul dont have any pride, another wimp tale.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 10 years ago
Yeah...OK!

Let me get this straight; Kathy doesn't contest the custody arrangement?

You're smoking something whacky there, FDK!

lance_spearmanlance_spearmanalmost 10 years ago
This doesn't do anything to explore the relationship

between Paul and Kathy. Its just an appendage. Could have been any couple from any failed relationships. Or even a couple that had never been married before.

AnonymousAnonymousover 9 years ago
So what the hell happened to the slut and the cuckolding asshole?

Boy, this is a nothing tale.

OneShotOneOneShotOneover 9 years ago
Much better than the original.

Well done.

rightbankrightbankover 9 years ago
really quite bland

nice guy meets nice woman, they date, marry, and live happily ever after.

no resolution with the ex. no mention of the boyfriend. nothing of substance.

the time line is really messed up. isn't it odd that the two sons didn't know each if they were only one year apart, in the same school?

sugnasugnaover 9 years ago
Not Real

First off, there is no way that any normal man who loved his wife would not inflict serious pain on her and her lover for cheating and breaking up his marriage. There is a very real monetary loss suffered in a divorce. That loss has a number attached to it. They made him pay, a self respecting man would make them pay too. Additionally, there is no way the kids would tolerate their mother cheating on THEM. Yes, she cheated on them, humiliated them in their community, and left them alone. All for some cock.The kids would be damaged. They would act out. Drugs for the boy, and sex for the girl - the most common outcome for ignored and rejected children. Cut the crap about her still loving her family - bullshit! Love is in your actions, not your words. Her total lack of respect for her family and even herself was apparent as she dishonored herself and her family. In truth, it is doubtful that she ever loved anyone. Love is the act of caring for another. Her actions showed she did not truly care for her own kids! If you don't love your own kids, who the Hell can you love?! No offense, but this is some stupid, poorly thought out plot here. Reality has the benefit of not tolerating lies for long. People cannot live with them for more than a few minutes before there are consequences.

sdc97230sdc97230about 9 years ago
Yes, real

Certainly, any man who loved his family would WANT to inflict serious hurt on his betraying wife and her wife-stealing asshole lover. But if he was halfway intelligent, he'd know that there's no realistic way that a man who wasn't some magical ex-SEAL or CIA spook could possibly get away with it, and ending up spending years in prison is no way to prevent his kids from succumbing to all the bad impacts of a family breakup. He'd do his best to remain outwardly calm and to not give in to the temptation to trash the kids' mother in front of them - both for the sake of the kids' emotional well-being and because any competent lawyer would advise him that doing otherwise would be a mark against him in any custody dispute - and do his best to keep the home life as calm and supportive as possible.

The kids would naturally resent their mother for abandoning the family, and here they did, the son more so than the daughter, but in the end there is still some mother-child attachment that remains even though both definitely would have sided with Dad when it came down to a choice, which he tried to avoid forcing them have to make. Taking the high road in front of others was the best way to go, because it just made everyone see Kathy for the selfish, faithless cheater she was.

What's maybe a bit unrealistic about this was that he was actually able to pull it off without some aside about him having to see a shrink to do it. I guess Evelyn sort of filled that role for him by being Kathy's sister yet still validating all of his feelings about what Kathy was doing.

sbrooks103sbrooks103almost 9 years ago
Well Done!

“He was my first and greatest love”

“Greatest love”? Does that mean her love for Karl is greater than her love for Paul?

The kids are right! How much can she love them if she could so easily give them up so she could be with Karl?

“as strange as this may seem I wanted her fantasy to come true”

I can understand that, if her fantasy collapses, then all the pain they’ve gone through will have been for nothing.

I’ve never understood this reluctance to kiss a woman after cumming in her mouth. I expect a woman to kiss me after eating her out!

Regarding the jeweler “agreeing” to a ring exchange – as long as the ring isn’t custom, why WOULDN’T a jeweler do an exchange, even without an explicit agreement?

sbrooks103sbrooks103almost 9 years ago
@rightbank

I can't remember for sure, but I could have sworn that the boys did NOT go to the same school.

EddboyEddboyalmost 9 years ago
very good follow up

crazy but i just now found your stories and have been very pleased with the ones ive read so far. I am like you in that i tire of reading RAAC stories, i dont mind reconciliation but make it belivable atleast. One thing with this story you might have added is how Kathys marriage to her new husband turned out bc in the originals it didnt work out so good

AnonymousAnonymousover 8 years ago
one more ending but not the best

A very romantic tale, but I much preferred the endings of other authors where Kathy and Karl suffered some pain as well.

AnonymousAnonymousover 8 years ago
NOT SURE

Along with Statute of Limitations, Wild Card and Was She Ever My Wife, I have always found the original Suspicion story very thought provoking. I often wonder what I would do if my wife and I were in the same situation. I think I would act pretty much like Paul during the period following the blow of the upheaval. However, where I would differ from this author is that I am sure that an intense hatred for my wife and her guy would develop. There would be no chance of inviting her to attend my wedding reception or suggesting that she were a nice person. To do what she did shows a basic disregard for the human feelings of her family. I would never want to speak to her again or acknowledge her existence. I accept that marriages break up through infidelity but there is something particularly unsettling about what this women did, and the brutal type of betrayal involved.

AnonymousAnonymousover 8 years ago

His ex is a dirty cunt . She left her family of 16+ years for a guy she loved as a teenager in a 6 month span. Is she still with him as the years passed. She also said she loved both but the truth was that she didn't love her husband at all , he was just there until the guy she really loved piped back into the picture. It might be childish but I would have made things very difficult for all involved no way would she be able to get off that easy. They would probably have chose to move far enough away to be safe because the humiliation and abuse would've been nonstop just like the shame he had to live with all family and friends knowing she thought he was not good enough to stay married to. That's a real bad feeling about how he must see himself and how he feels others look at him. I also would've kicked her out in a loud and humiliating way or spoke about how great it was to meet someone so good after my lying cheating cunt of a ex left her whole family.

AnonymousAnonymousover 8 years ago
She's a nice person

No Kathy is not a nice person.

You are what you do.

Tearing apart a family and betraying your loved ones isn't what a nice person does.

All it means is that she is nice unless it's hard not to be.

sugnasugnaover 8 years ago
A Few Things

1. His ex was simply a selfish bitch that betrayed her whole family.

2. The I can love two men thing is really about I can USE two men. She can't stop lying to herself and everyone around her - she is a mess.

3. Is she an idiot? What kind of man has an affair with a married woman, worse a married woman with kids? He did not care about her best interests! She should have seen that. It is so obvious that it proves #1.

4. She is a terrible person and a horrible role model therefor she is a shitty and unfit mother. He should have agreed with the kids that they did not need her in their lives.

5. Finally, this guy needs to man up a bit. He thinks and acts more like a woman than a man. Men get hurt, but men suck it up and soldier on. They do not sit around and drink and cry.

6. Her showing up on his wedding day was another selfish move designed to get attention for her. Disgusting, he should have called her on that. He should have treated her like a crazy stalker and told her to leave.

The author had created a saccharine fantasy about a sensitive man and what a good guy he really is. If that works for you, great, you should probably consider transgender surgery

sbrooks103sbrooks103over 8 years ago
Re-Reading

Minor point - He’s met Heidi’s son, why can’t she meet HIS kids?

AnonymousAnonymousover 8 years ago

Always worthy of a-5. I vote in every city I travel to if I read a story I want to rate.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 8 years ago

A wimp story is still a wimp story. -1

AnonymousAnonymousover 7 years ago

Better follow up than what the original author wrote, but I can't get my head around how understanding, benign, benevolent, polite and wise people become in these LW stories after they've been betrayed. The dad telling the kids that their mother loves them after they tell him that they don't want to visit her is an example. I'm not advocating revenge; but he doesn't have to go out of his way to behave in a holier-than-thou manner.

AnonymousAnonymousover 7 years ago
Absolute 7 pages

Of drivel. You actually had the ex show up at the wedding and he was ok with it? I'm not saying you had to burn her to the ground ( even if it was deserved ) but that level of civility is just to soft. At the very least some harsh words ( even in a whisper so he doesn't make a scene ) needed to be said. I'm actually bothered i wasted t hj is much time on that ending.

tazz317tazz317over 7 years ago
SUSPICIOUS MINDS=====SUSPICIOUS ACTIONS

where o where do the end, IF EVER. TK U MLJ LV NV

AnonymousAnonymousover 7 years ago
Meh but

Not a bad story, but the ending. Too easy, too easy.

AnonymousAnonymousover 7 years ago
Story ok at best, ending sucks...

Dialog seemed wooden, doesn't flow like normal speech between people. Very little, if any, emotion. More important to me was the fact that you treated Kathy as if what she did was almost respectable, wrong, but understandable. Almost as if anybody might think having a husband and lover is a normal, everyday occurrence. It's not, regardless of how many cucks so desperately want to make us believe it is. I guess they think they'll feel more like men if they can convince us that it's a good thing.

I'll never understand why so many stories have the husband tearfully telling his kids what good person their cheating slut of a mother is. Why lie to them? Tell them she loves them (hopefully she does), but she did a bad thing and now she'll be living with another man. Trust me when I say that NOT every mother is worthy of raising kids - and leaving the family to run off with some guy she hasn't seen in 20 years is kind of an indicator as to what kind of a mom she'll be for these kids. Let them know what she did was mean, cruel, and disgusting.

Make sure your kids aren't left with the impression that what happened is acceptable or normal. They'll probably never get the truth from mom, so make sure to at least turn this into an object lesson. Kids are much tougher than most people think. Sure, divorce is going to hurt them; it will be a traumatic event in their lives. But if you play down the fact that what mom did was unacceptable, the kids may think that this is something that just happens for no reason and they'll start worrying about whether or not dad will be there much longer. They need to know WHY it occurred, or they'll always wonder if they caused it.

Rc68Rc68over 7 years ago
Good not great...

This was just OK, others have written better endings burning the cheaters.... Your other stories are much better, thanks for your efforts....

swedishreader1swedishreader1about 7 years ago
7 pages

To long.......as in it would have been better not to have written this

EXursusRhereEXursusRhereabout 7 years ago
Reading this is sort of

like getting a double cone of pistachio ice cream and tripping while exiting the shop and the ice cream falls off. Very disappointing.

AnonymousAnonymousabout 7 years ago
Story itself good, but awkward-robotic dialogue?

I really enjoyed the gist of the story, but found that the dialogue between the characters to be awkward/robotic/formal. I can attest to the fact that even highly educated children do not use vocabulary and complex sentences in everyday conversation the way Christi, Jason and James do.

If the dialogue was more organic, real-world, then this story would be 100.

AnonymousAnonymousalmost 7 years ago
Wimp tale

I dont understand this tale, waist of time

SomeOneTwoThreeSomeOneTwoThreealmost 7 years ago
Very nice

Best second part of this story I've read.

Not over the top and not letting

the victim remain a victim.

The ex got as little part as she deserved.

There has been mentioned a song called

"Torn between two lovers".

I remember the song and at least some of

the lyric. In one line says: "Loving both of

them is breaking all the rules". I stand firmly

behind that. (Good song though:))

The only fault I find with this second part,

of a good story, is it's a bit long. And

that's a bit out of character with the

first part.

Well done writer!

LonesomeBoy60LonesomeBoy60almost 7 years ago
Good job!

Jeeze,

I see there is no pleasing your audience. Does any of them have stories "we" could tear apart? I doubt it.

AnonymousAnonymousover 6 years ago
You forgot the lawsuit- now come up with chapter 2 to kill the bad guy

Let's back up a bit. You missed the part about suing for "Alienation of Affection" part against Karl. Bankrupt the son of a bitch, so that they have to live very poorly while the money is sluffed off to the kid's college fund's as part of her "Parenting responsibilities"

12
Anonymous
Our Comments Policy is available in the Lit FAQ
Post as:
Anonymous